Welcome to the Second Life Forums Archive

These forums are CLOSED. Please visit the new forums HERE

Upcoming Changes for Adult Content: Answers to Questions

Snickers Snook
Odd Princess - Trout 7.3
Join date: 17 Apr 2007
Posts: 746
04-27-2009 22:24
What if everyone changes their land description to just a list of bad keywords? I wanna move mommy!!!

From: someone
For Second Life users as a whole, Kend Linden said, "the community to its credit... has enough invested in this platform that they follow the rules."


That is a mind boggling "up yours" quote. It basically says, our customers have put so much time, effort and money into SL that they won't leave no matter how badly we treat them.
_____________________

Buh-bye forums, it's been good ta know ya.
Valerius Constantine
*I* am adult content!
Join date: 5 Jun 2008
Posts: 777
04-27-2009 22:28
From: Kalderi Tomsen
QFT.

People have been speculating as to why there hasn't been a vocal support for the Adult policy - well, maybe now you are seeing it. They get bullied and picked-upon by those that don't like it.

And you wonder why they don't post?

Then everyone needs to stop wondering why this is one big happy party of people who don't agree with it - answer: you bully anyone who doesn't agree with you.


Define "bully", please. Because if by "bully" you mean "disagree with", or "Ask for proof of certain statements".

I don't think that word mans what you think it means.


If by "bully" you mean "hold accountable for snide, crass, and hostile comments".

I don't think that word means what you think it means.


If by "bully" you mean "get disappointed that everyone doesn't either flock to your banner, or shut up."

I don't think that word means what you think it means.


Freedom of speech is a two-edged sword, you know. Everyone has the perfect right to express their opinions. However, Everyone also has the perfect right to express *their* opinion about *your* opinion.

You can't yell "Freedom of speech!" and get a "Get away without hearing anything that disagrees with me, free" card.

people have every right to say why the agree with this policy- but if they do, they then have to deal with the fact that someone might not agree with them. and might have extremely *good* reasons for doing so.

That *still* shouldn't stop people from expressing their opinion- however, nowadays, people think that they have a *right* never to be offended, or be exposed to something they don't like or don't want to know.

Here in the US, the right to free speech has somehow morphed into "the right to wear blinders" and "the right to have everyone respect your views and never question them"

There *ain't no such right*. not in the public sector *or* the private.

In practice, any freedom has responsibilities and consequences that one must be willing to accept if one wants to use them.

I'll admit I was a bit harsh with the Dictatorshop people, but it was because of their *tone*, not their *opinion*. and that's what you will find here 90+% of the time.

At least that's *my* opinion from having read every one of these damn posts, both here and in a previous thread on definitions.


-V-
Valerius Constantine
*I* am adult content!
Join date: 5 Jun 2008
Posts: 777
04-27-2009 22:48
From: Blondin Linden
I just checked our tools and you 1) look verified to me and 2) have your maturity setting set to Adult.

You're good to go.


Except she *wasn't* "good to go"- People are complaining that *despite* showing up as verified, and the maturity setting set to adult, they *still* can't TP to places that are set to look for AVS.

-V-
Valerius Constantine
*I* am adult content!
Join date: 5 Jun 2008
Posts: 777
04-27-2009 22:50
From: Paw Pawpaw
More censorship -always- leads to a safer world.

Since we're making things up as we go along, as it sounds like we're doing, lets just have a camp for all of the "unclean" so those who might get offended never will.


Hehe, a little irony is good for the blood, they say... :)


-V-
Valerius Constantine
*I* am adult content!
Join date: 5 Jun 2008
Posts: 777
04-27-2009 22:53
From: Bez Violet
People keep talking about beating the filter... I don't think that's the point.

Do you really think Xcite wants kids in their Sim, and the potential lawsuits that come with it?

I think most places won't mind the filter, actually I think the opposite might be the problem. I know if I had a PG Sim, I'd find a way to make it just mature enough not to show up in the search, because I wouldn't want a lot of idiot kids running around in it. They're a pain.


If the filter *worked*, Bez, I think everyone would be behind it. I know *I* would. However, what blondin has been telling us has *sounded* like "most people with a lot of sex and violence on their land could get by on Mature land by changing a few words in their ads and parcel descriptions."

That naturally leads to the question "which ones should we change?"
and the LL answer "We can't tell you- that would make it too easy to "game" the system".

So, we're figuring it out on our own. :)

-V-
Valerius Constantine
*I* am adult content!
Join date: 5 Jun 2008
Posts: 777
04-27-2009 23:02
From: Viciously Llewellyn
In a discussion with a friend this weekend, that has a pretty thriving adult business, I was amazed to hear her say that she supports these measures, but wishes they would have limited it to age verified only and not PIOF.

She also indicated that several vendors she knows, along with her, have been heavily lobbying the Lindens for quite some time about offering more protection from children accessing their merchandise and clubs.

I guess they weren't blowing smoke when they said that some adult vendors were asking for this.



I'd be willing to guess that what *they* were talking about was getting rid of unverified freebie accounts- something LL won't do because it lets them present *really* inflated membership numbers to potential advertisers.

I'm reasonably certain that *no* adult content vendor *on the mainland* said

"Hey, could you maybe or maybe not uproot my business and force move me to a new continent, giving me only 9 days to move before you take back my mature parcel, and then make me play "guess the search terms", and let people use credit cards as age proof, and then change the content rules in such a way as to confuse the hell out of everything, while at the same time, leaving in place everything that residents are complaining about?"


-V-
Valerius Constantine
*I* am adult content!
Join date: 5 Jun 2008
Posts: 777
04-27-2009 23:04
From: Meade Paravane
I think I'm confused.. Damn Mondays..

Are we agreeing that the proposed adult content project isn't going to prevent RL kids from getting into SL and being 'verified'?


Well, *I* agree with that statement! :)

-V-
Ian Nider
Seeds
Join date: 20 Mar 2009
Posts: 1,011
04-27-2009 23:09
From: Wynochee LeShelle
Your World. Your Imagination.

I would not ask. Just do it! ;-)

Think on Woodstock;-)

http://img.stern.de/_content/52/83/528328/Woodstock18_600.jpg?

Hehe, yeh, I have a nude sky sandbox kind of, I live in the best spot on main and one neighbor is kind of a bit straight, but also a nice guy, I am trying to find a medium line. The sandbox is the scarlet A prim 300mtrs up . Ground level is trees and a small hut.

People are landing nude and I whilst I want that, (I hate clothes r/l) I also don't want to trash the experience for others.

I am trying to retain my right to nudity and also be repsectful. I think I will get left in mature as I have no business of any worth to ok me for an exchange to Ursula...
Valerius Constantine
*I* am adult content!
Join date: 5 Jun 2008
Posts: 777
04-27-2009 23:14
From: Sling Trebuchet
The changes are aimed purely at sanitising the currently existing Grid so that people who want "predictable" can generally have it.
A problem for this search for predictability is that the people looking for it will be confined to the most unpredictable part of the grid, where they share space with unlimited numbers of unverified throw-away accounts.
The Ursula thing gives LL some measure of plausible deniability when granny gets attacked by a bling penis. That's all.


Plausible deniability, yes.

But if the changes are aimed at increasing "predictability", then LL missed. BY a country *mile*

-V-
Ian Nider
Seeds
Join date: 20 Mar 2009
Posts: 1,011
04-27-2009 23:23
My other concern is kids having access to adult skins etc... For people who are refused the move to Ursula will need protection from kids sneaking into their adult lifestyles.
Valerius Constantine
*I* am adult content!
Join date: 5 Jun 2008
Posts: 777
04-27-2009 23:27
From: Meade Paravane
That would certainly be a step in the right direction!

Even better would be to have a new PG continent and a new adult continent and not force anybody to move. Doing that and losing the foolish 'verification' stuff that everybody knows won't keep RL kids off the grid would almost make this project tolerable.



Better yet would to simply designate Ursula as a "G" rated protected area that you couldn't visit without being verified, and require verification on all *new* accounts from now on. Allow anyone who wants to move there a free swap, and then enforce the content rules there like Torquemada with a hangover.

*fix* search, so that it actually *works* and scans for parcel descriptors more than once a decade,

Put some sort of affirmative opt-in thingie on *all* mature parcels

Leave everything else the hell *alone*-

-V-
Valerius Constantine
*I* am adult content!
Join date: 5 Jun 2008
Posts: 777
04-27-2009 23:29
From: Kalderi Tomsen
Careful not to name her - the crowd here will be calling for another public lynching.... (oops, boycott, sorry)... ;)



If her post was as snide as some we've seen here- probably. You'll notice though that Nobody talk about boycotting LS, and he was in favor of the changes until the details came along. He likes the *idea*, it's the execution that bothers him, right LS?

-V-
Valerius Constantine
*I* am adult content!
Join date: 5 Jun 2008
Posts: 777
04-27-2009 23:32
From: Ciaran Laval
How is this word filter going to work? If someone has a store on mature land selling Gorean silks and Gorean clothing will an advert be rejected?

nope, but only verified accounts will be able to see it, and it will be considered "adult content" so will "slave silks" and probably a buch of other words as well.

-V-
Wynochee LeShelle
Polykontexturalist
Join date: 3 Feb 2007
Posts: 658
Ah, nature - such a subversive nature
04-27-2009 23:33
http://www.pilzepilze.de/piga/pics/phallus_impudicus_gm1.jpg

http://brainlessworld.files.wordpress.com/2007/10/when_plants_go_bad8.jpg

http://brainlessworld.files.wordpress.com/2007/10/when_plants_go_bad11.jpg

http://www.biology-blog.com/images/blogs/8-2006/nature-is-sexy-844772.jpg

http://www.emailjokes.co.za/resize2/49291.jpg

http://data54.sevenload.com/slcom/gm/gk/gfflic/ggrtjgjllf.jpg~/Pink-Orchid.jpg

http://www.shakewellbeforeuse.com/images/oyster.jpg

http://farm3.static.flickr.com/2280/2389071167_0e7aef0c98.jpg
Valerius Constantine
*I* am adult content!
Join date: 5 Jun 2008
Posts: 777
04-27-2009 23:39
From: Argent Stonecutter
I cared, I cared enough to suggest restrictions on OpenSpace that might have headed off the disaster, and got spammed for it.


I cared because I rented one of the damned things, used it as directed, and then got hit with an untenable price increase because LL didn't do their homework.


Kinda like *now*

-V-
Valerius Constantine
*I* am adult content!
Join date: 5 Jun 2008
Posts: 777
04-27-2009 23:41
From: Kara Spengler
evil idea ....

What if people replaced the verboten words with words LL would not *dare* ban and then circulated the substitutions to everyone else?

M: "Why is Linden suddenly on the naughty word list?"



Aw *man*! :)


"I wanna stick your Linden in my Linden. LInden service- discreet, professional, limits- no Linden, Linden, Linden, Linden or Linden-play".


-V-
Taly Fluffy
Registered User
Join date: 26 Feb 2006
Posts: 32
04-27-2009 23:50
From: Jamie David
But there is sex in Star Wars just as there is sex in Gor and in Pony play but oddly not in Furry according to the list.


Dear Blondin,

Jamie's point is excellent.

Many subcultures and sexual orientations are sex-related for, oh, only 15 minutes out of 24 hours in the day :)
The Lindens are acknowledging that they know this, because we see they are not blocking the following words (subcultures) from Unverified Search:
gay, furry, star wars...

Yet the Lindens have decided that other words (subcultures) are so "sexy" (Adult) that they must be totally blocked from Unverifieds being able to use Search to find them:
BDSM, Gorean, Ladyboy, Shemale...

So the gay community and furry community can be located in Second Life, but the BDSMers and Goreans are so "sexy" (or offensive?) that the Lindens feel that Unverifieds should not be able to locate their fellows?

I hope, Blondin, that you can explain to us why some of these large subcultures are being hidden, while others are being given respect as legitimate lifestyles.

From: Jamie David
Where is the hard core definitions of what is PG vs mature vs Adult? Too damn hard isn't it? Where mature and PG were hard enough to define now there is the 3rd for a supposed Adult community.
Is not violence Adult? So battles, weapons and killing are Adult and that is what Star Wars is about? Or has lindenlab definition of Adult found that killing is ok yet sex and tits are not?


Jamie, I think you stated this very well.
Phoenix Welles
Multiple Avatar Disorder
Join date: 6 Jan 2007
Posts: 111
04-28-2009 00:01
From: Alexander Harbrough
And people accuse me of trolling... how many non-english speakers are going to be looking specificly for a bird known as a 'tit' regardless of which variety?


ummm... as a bird person I can tell you that anybody who wants a particular bird will search for THAT BIRD. I'm not a songbird person myself, I'm the parrot type, but if I were looking in world I wouldn't be looking for 'parrot' I would look for cockatoo, or eclectus, or hyacinth macaw. There are plenty of people who might want a 'songbird' and they'll find our bird man, but then there are people who want a particular bird and they'll use the proper name. So if the bird they want is a tit, then they'll search for tit.

From: Alexander Harbrough
I still stand by my opinion that the filtering is causing you more indigation than any actual damage to you. 'Songbirds' leads to you in a much cleaner fashion.


Songbird only leads to him if the buyer is willing to take just any songbird. In the meanwhile it is a disservice to him and his customers of a purely PG product that he cannot effectively advertise and properly represent a portion of his product.

Any dog lover would scream if they were told to advertise as having dogs, but were told as well that they could advertise shepherds but not retrievers. And effectively that is what is happening here.

Not only that, but this is just one instance of a pg creator being hit by this, there will be more because several of the now bad words have purely PG meanings as well. This is what we've been trying to get across and why people keep calling you a troll. You've latched onto this one creator and not looked at the bigger picture of how words can have multiple meanings and many many words on the filtered list will have this exact same issue.

/rant
Mars Lake
Registered User
Join date: 13 Jul 2006
Posts: 10
04-28-2009 00:10
From: someone
Originally Posted by KT Syakumi
I own an art gallery. The nude is a popular artistic expression. I'm sure some nudes would be acceptable, but where do you draw the line? And isn't that censorship of the arts?


From: Blondin Linden
Nudity itself will not be considered ADULT. As to drawing a line - we know there will be many different types of edge cases and will be prepared to evaluate them on a case by case basis.


As an artist and gallery owner, I find that answer unsatisfying. There are plenty of artists famous and otherwise who have done works that would appear to fall within the adult content restrictions as currently stated. There shouldn't be a line or edge cases with subjective case by case evaluations for art.

Art displayed as art should be exempt from adult content classification and censorship. Can we get that clearly stated? Or does every gallery that might someday display an edgy or controversial work according to the new SL standards of adult vs mature need to relocate to the adult flagged lands?
Valerius Constantine
*I* am adult content!
Join date: 5 Jun 2008
Posts: 777
04-28-2009 00:21
From: Ann Otoole
there is no dangling meat.

there won't be any "dangling meat" until flexi sculpts are rolled out. and flaccid members will be the first to hit the street like the member flags when flexis hit the street.


And considering the "compensation" fixations of most SL users- "Hit the street" is an apt phrase :)


-V-
Wynochee LeShelle
Polykontexturalist
Join date: 3 Feb 2007
Posts: 658
04-28-2009 00:22
From: Phoenix Welles
ummm... as a bird person I can tell you that anybody who wants a particular bird will search for THAT BIRD. I'm not a songbird person myself, I'm the parrot type, but if I were looking in world I wouldn't be looking for 'parrot' I would look for cockatoo, or eclectus, or hyacinth macaw. There are plenty of people who might want a 'songbird' and they'll find our bird man, but then there are people who want a particular bird and they'll use the proper name. So if the bird they want is a tit, then they'll search for tit.



Songbird only leads to him if the buyer is willing to take just any songbird. In the meanwhile it is a disservice to him and his customers of a purely PG product that he cannot effectively advertise and properly represent a portion of his product.

Any dog lover would scream if they were told to advertise as having dogs, but were told as well that they could advertise shepherds but not retrievers. And effectively that is what is happening here.

Not only that, but this is just one instance of a pg creator being hit by this, there will be more because several of the now bad words have purely PG meanings as well. This is what we've been trying to get across and why people keep calling you a troll. You've latched onto this one creator and not looked at the bigger picture of how words can have multiple meanings and many many words on the filtered list will have this exact same issue.

/rant


They gave scat to the no-no list.

In google I found: several companies with the name Scat. Plus: A card-game. A way to sing songs. A way to create school tests and much more.

Scat has around 20 meanings...says Wikipedia, including a sexual variant.

In german, from wich I know the word as: Skat and in english as Scat it is a famous card game - especially very, very popular in Germany. Another meaning of that word I didn't know before.

And since google showed me now that there are some companies around the world, with the Company name Scat, I wonder what LL would do, if one of these companies would like to represent itself in SL?

For example:

http://www.scatenterprises.com/

or a book:

http://www.amazon.com/Scat-Carl-Hiaasen/dp/0375834869

or this:

http://www.scat-europe.com/en/produkte.html
Taly Fluffy
Registered User
Join date: 26 Feb 2006
Posts: 32
04-28-2009 00:26
From: Storyof Oh
LL say they haven't set everything in stone yet but the mortar is quickly drying with little sign of an about face.

We should not have to lie to stay on mainland nor lie to enter 'Ursula'.


Beautifully worded.
Valerius Constantine
*I* am adult content!
Join date: 5 Jun 2008
Posts: 777
04-28-2009 00:30
From: Alexander Harbrough
Nothing, but if they are willing to commit theft, they are probably willing to steal from more than just mom and might even be considered legally adults depending on how criminal they are RL.



Not quite sure where you get this- Lifting mom's driver's license number to access the grownup stuff leads to B&E and Bank robbery? Mugging? Extortion and Racketeering?

you're comparing grapes to watermelons

-V-
Valerius Constantine
*I* am adult content!
Join date: 5 Jun 2008
Posts: 777
04-28-2009 00:34
From: Alexander Harbrough
And you are seriously trying to make the case that there is (a) both a strong enough market for those particular species that they warrant specific advertizing and (b) that there is no intent to use the obvious link to other meanings of 'tit' to bring in customers not looking for birds at all? (Or at least not that interpretation of the word 'bird?).

This is all starting to sound like a Monty Python sketch... ah, well.. if you do not survive, I guess you will go 'tits up'... :)


Why would that be unbelievable to you? I supposed you'd suspect him of "trying to get around the rules if he sold "Blue-footed boobies" (sex) and Puffins (drugs) :)


-V-
Valerius Constantine
*I* am adult content!
Join date: 5 Jun 2008
Posts: 777
04-28-2009 00:36
From: Alexander Harbrough
Identity theft is identity theft. If they are willing to 'borrow' mom's credit card or driver's licence, why would they be reluctant to 'borrow' those of complete strangers?

And why would they stop at SL instead of buying RL merchandise or trolling/griefing/defrauding others using the stolen ID?



I don't know- maybe because they would have to risk more than a spanking to do so? maybe because they *know* mom and not strangers?

A whole *raft* of reasons :)

-V-