Welcome to the Second Life Forums Archive

These forums are CLOSED. Please visit the new forums HERE

Upcoming Changes for Adult Content: Answers to Questions

Cal Kondo
Low impact
Join date: 7 Oct 2006
Posts: 143
04-24-2009 04:14
Many PG mainland owners have commented that they feel they will need to relocate to Mature land. Many Mature land owners intend to move to Adult land (assited or not). All these potential movements are likely to create imbalances in the land supply which will drive disparities in land pricing across different maturity ratings. Fortunately unlike real land LL has complete control over the availability and therefore the price of virtual land. New sims can be released in under supplied land and surplus land can be withheld from auction in over supplied land.

Will LL commit to maintaining similar land prices in all 3 maturity ratings?

A positive answer to this question would ease the concerns of your customers that they will be out of pocket as they attempt to comply with the changes.

It would also be fair because without some commitment your customers take a financial risk that this policy change will work.

Most of all it would be a strong signal that LL are confident that this is indeed what customers want because if it is, land supply would be more likely to be balanced.
Qie Niangao
Coin-operated
Join date: 24 May 2006
Posts: 7,138
04-24-2009 04:28
From: Cal Kondo
Will LL commit to maintaining similar land prices in all 3 maturity ratings?
Good question! LL has a mechanism (if it chooses to use it) to control the collapse of Mature Mainland prices when residents are forced to Ursula in the land-swap: just delay bringing the swapped parcels to auction. But if significant numbers of PG landowners flee to Mature without a land-swap those owners will have no choice but to dump the PG land into the market for whatever they can get.

It might help if PG landowners could swap for the M land that gets abandoned en route to Ursula. [Edit: (in case it's not obvious) and then the swapped-out PG land could be kept from auction until prices stabilize for that land rating.]
_____________________
Archived for Your Protection
Valerius Constantine
*I* am adult content!
Join date: 5 Jun 2008
Posts: 777
04-24-2009 04:42
From: Argent Stonecutter
Speaking of which...

One of the longest running and best behaved PG communities in SL is worried about the change.

Blondin: Any comments on this?



This might sound like I'm being sarcastic, but I'm not- Luskwood should move to Ursula if these changes go through as planned. they can keep all the community standards they like, and be safer from griefers at the same time.

Course, there's the NPIOF thing to worry about, but nothing is perfect, right?

-V-
Tanya Spinotti
Registered User
Join date: 8 Jan 2007
Posts: 4
04-24-2009 04:45
From: Blondin Linden
Flagging will have to be done by region and not by parcel. Since it sounds like you have a mix, it may be easier to flag the region as Adult.


Thanks Blondin and all those who replied. It's probably worth including this in the FAQ and/or the Estate Managers Guide, as I'm sure others will misinterpret this in the same way that I did (or it could just be me, of course lol).
Cal Kondo
Low impact
Join date: 7 Oct 2006
Posts: 143
04-24-2009 04:58
From: Qie Niangao
But if significant numbers of PG landowners flee to Mature without a land-swap those owners will have no choice but to dump the PG land into the market for whatever they can get.

It might help if PG landowners could swap for the M land that gets abandoned en route to Ursula. [Edit: (in case it's not obvious) and then the swapped-out PG land could be kept from auction until prices stabilize for that land rating.]


Yes but, if the mysterious majority that want this change come forward and buy the PG then everything will be balanced. That is why if LL are confident that they have it right they should have no problem committing to balanced land prices.

If they have it wrong I suppose they would have to buy back their own PG to support prices.

They should put their money on the line not their customers.
Couldbe Yue
one unhappy customer
Join date: 30 Mar 2008
Posts: 1,532
The snowfields of Ursula
04-24-2009 05:01
They've used that crappy ice terrain texture, which is the equivalent of that damn rock on Corsica. tell them to use the proper snow terrain like they used originally around Koss. You can at least *try* not to be so grudging about this.
_____________________
Satiated Desires: Toys for Grown Ups.
Inworld: http://slurl.com/secondlife/Norf%20Haven/186/132/55
XSL: https://www.xstreetsl.com/modules.php?name=Marketplace&MerchantID=77743&&sort=age&dir=asc
Blog: http://satiateddesires.wordpress.com/
Thorn Witrial
Registered User
Join date: 28 Jun 2008
Posts: 237
04-24-2009 05:06
From: Couldbe Yue
They've used that crappy ice terrain texture, which is the equivalent of that damn rock on Corsica. tell them to use the proper snow terrain like they used originally around Koss. You can at least *try* not to be so grudging about this.



Ice fields? Really? Criminy. Nothing says hot adult action like goosebumps, chapped feet and e-peen0rs turtling for warmth.
Storyof Oh
Registered User
Join date: 14 Apr 2007
Posts: 139
04-24-2009 05:07
listening to the definitions meeting the first few minutes were a couple of people wondering who else was coming, if they were there and not even sure....
someone gave their version of the definitions and it seemed by seniority no one dared debate them...after a long while a couple of female gamers raised some questions to which no clear answer was given...

Cyn (possibly) did a piece on why this was happening for the great and good and that an art gallery may well be adult................etc ..oh and that a woman in ropes however arty is adult...
A lot of silences...NO MALE gamer questions (to my ear)

If this was indeed a brown bag to cover the basic core of this change i.e. what the heck IS Adult...the room should of been abuzz with 'order order'..'one at a time'...set at a time slot to reflect the global nature of SL (therefore impossible)

As it was i got the feeling the Lindens left the meeting congratulating themselves on a job well done, a definition sheet pretty much black inked having heard the views of ..hmmm...er maybe 3 out of millions of SL logons.....
Couldbe Yue
one unhappy customer
Join date: 30 Mar 2008
Posts: 1,532
04-24-2009 05:19
From: Thorn Witrial
Ice fields? Really? Criminy. Nothing says hot adult action like goosebumps, chapped feet and e-peen0rs turtling for warmth.



hey, I'm going to turn my house into the first snow bunnies free sex room and diner on the mainland to make sure my snowplot goes over.. So I want decent snow :)

edit: and you'll have to turn Ursula around.. I currently have an uninterrupted sunset view.. none of this facing north or east thanks.
_____________________
Satiated Desires: Toys for Grown Ups.
Inworld: http://slurl.com/secondlife/Norf%20Haven/186/132/55
XSL: https://www.xstreetsl.com/modules.php?name=Marketplace&MerchantID=77743&&sort=age&dir=asc
Blog: http://satiateddesires.wordpress.com/
Ryanna Enfield
Registered User
Join date: 26 Dec 2005
Posts: 225
04-24-2009 05:40
From: Storyof Oh
listening to the definitions meeting the first few minutes were a couple of people wondering who else was coming, if they were there and not even sure....
someone gave their version of the definitions and it seemed by seniority no one dared debate them...after a long while a couple of female gamers raised some questions to which no clear answer was given...

Cyn (possibly) did a piece on why this was happening for the great and good and that an art gallery may well be adult................etc ..oh and that a woman in ropes however arty is adult...
A lot of silences...NO MALE gamer questions (to my ear)

If this was indeed a brown bag to cover the basic core of this change i.e. what the heck IS Adult...the room should of been abuzz with 'order order'..'one at a time'...set at a time slot to reflect the global nature of SL (therefore impossible)

As it was i got the feeling the Lindens left the meeting congratulating themselves on a job well done, a definition sheet pretty much black inked having heard the views of ..hmmm...er maybe 3 out of millions of SL logons.....


I'm currently listening to the definitions brown bag as well. On one hand they say they don't want to be as black and white with definitions because they saw what happened with Amazon when they were over zealous with a policy change. But then you have them say at the end that simulated drug use is Adult. But this is something you see on T.V. just like the blood splatter issue that was also mentioned. You guys need to be consistent. If you are gonna look at this as what is available on T.V. during prime time, then you need to make that consistent throughout all of the categories, not just well blood is mature because I can see it on T.V. but drugs are Adult. There are lots of forensic file type programs on TV that show drugs, sex, violence, and murder. If you don't like that kind of thing, you change the channel. CSI New York was popular in SL and had their own Sim. Would that be an Adult venue under these new definitions?

It bothered me when one Linden started talking about how they wouldn't want their 12 year old to see nude art. Again, SL is a service for Adults. If you wouldn't take your child to a museum for fear they might see nude art, then you should not be letting them look over your shoulder at SL, which is an Adult Service. I have to question why this was the mind-set.

Also, I don't understand the comments about "People should know what they should and shouldn't do when they are not in private." Considering that SL is not RL and there is no real privacy or even consequences, how does "what you can and can't do in private" apply here in SL? How do you define privacy in SL? Does it even exist? It was mentioned that Advertisement of services/content was the way to define it in SL. So then if my house is a forest on mainland without walls and I'm gettin it own with my partner and an audience gathers round, am I now advertising?
_____________________
~*Ryanna Enfield*~
Anabella Spark
Registered User
Join date: 2 Nov 2006
Posts: 418
04-24-2009 05:46
The best consensus in this situation would be:

- proceed with all changes related to new adult policy except one: instead of mandatory age verification/payment info, just issue the pop up window with warning of adult content before accessing adult continent. This way a lot of people here will at least not worry about majority of sl residents who will not be able to access certain areas in SL

- allow at least 3 months for people to move (yes give them some time to prepare), you can 'encourage' people to move faster by giving them free tier offers. Those who will move faster will receive : during first 9 days - 3 months free tier, during 30 days - 2 months tier, 60 days - 1 month free tier.

- or create seperate SL client called Adult SL client and let people choose the client during registration

I think it's fair and it's real consensus. Since there is adult content all over internet and nobody is requesting credit card number before accessing this kind of content over the internet, so why SL would be different? it just doesn't make sense. nobody will bother to age verify if they can see adult content on the web without any problem. Under age people who want to access adult content don't go to SL, since they can see real boobs over the net. lol and nobody is suing web pages for displaying things like BDSM, real escort agency.
Blondin Linden
Linden Lab Employee
Join date: 2 Jun 2008
Posts: 381
04-24-2009 06:08
From: Jannae Karas
Some will be AR'd by enemies, zealots and opportunists, but most won't. If you are truly paranoid, build high in the sky and become the needle in the haystack. For myself, I will continue to use my "mature" beach to sunbathe sans clothing, skinny dip in my river, and tub naked under the stars whenever I damn well please. I paid top dollar for the privelage to "own" mature mainland, and have no intention of relocating. There are damned few parcels in SL (as is) that can equal the bit of mainland that I live on. Not likerly to get a far swap in Ursala.[/QUOTE


Nothing you described above would be considered adult.
Shuggy Miles
Registered User
Join date: 22 May 2007
Posts: 4
04-24-2009 06:14
How about leaving us all alone and moving those that want a "G" experience to some kind of SL family friendly theme park. You could set up some G continents for the exclusive use of those want a more "predictable" (whatever that means) experience. This is all just getting to be too much, too expensive and not worth the headache of owning land. It seems like unless you are a commercial operator of some sort you are screwed. however, my tiers are as payed with RL money just the same. If I cant use my land for its intended Adult ( however commercial free) purpose, why should I have the inconvenience and expense of moving it ?
Shockwave Yareach
Registered User
Join date: 4 Oct 2006
Posts: 370
04-24-2009 06:21
From: Blondin Linden
Many of the forum posters were in fact invited and attended the land and definition brown bags.


I was not. And I saw NO SUCH INVITATION in any of the threads. If you can point to the open invitation, I would like to see it.
MystressAnna Lovenkraft
Registered User
Join date: 24 Oct 2007
Posts: 28
*I* Am Adult Content
04-24-2009 06:23
From: Blondin Linden
1) Strip Club would be Mature.
2) Strip Clubs that use adult key words in listings and in search would be considered Adult. 3) Strip Clubs with sex balls and back room sex areas would be Adult.



Ok so Strip Club are Only Mature ..

What about BDSM Club where there is No place for Sex

I thinking an area with only kneeling pose and a few racks and some cages ..
but without any poseballs to have sex with??
Anabella Spark
Registered User
Join date: 2 Nov 2006
Posts: 418
04-24-2009 06:24
From: someone
From: Jannae Karas
Some will be AR'd by enemies, zealots and opportunists, but most won't. If you are truly paranoid, build high in the sky and become the needle in the haystack. For myself, I will continue to use my "mature" beach to sunbathe sans clothing, skinny dip in my river, and tub naked under the stars whenever I damn well please. I paid top dollar for the privelage to "own" mature mainland, and have no intention of relocating. There are damned few parcels in SL (as is) that can equal the bit of mainland that I live on. Not likerly to get a far swap in Ursala.[/QUOTE


i have been reported last week because I banned the griefer from my sim. he sent AR because he felt offended that I sent his name to other sim owners to ban him. thats funny isnt it?
Anabella Spark
Registered User
Join date: 2 Nov 2006
Posts: 418
04-24-2009 06:25
From: MystressAnna Lovenkraft
Ok so Strip Club are Only Mature ..

What about BDSM Club where there is No place for Sex

I thinking an area with only kneeling pose and a few racks and some cages ..
but without any poseballs to have sex with??


strip clubs expose nude dancers (STRIP CLUB means strippers inside lol) so how come it's now mature not adult?
Signey Gustafson
Registered User
Join date: 16 Apr 2007
Posts: 2
04-24-2009 06:26
From: Blondin Linden
From: Jannae Karas
Some will be AR'd by enemies, zealots and opportunists, but most won't. If you are truly paranoid, build high in the sky and become the needle in the haystack. For myself, I will continue to use my "mature" beach to sunbathe sans clothing, skinny dip in my river, and tub naked under the stars whenever I damn well please. I paid top dollar for the privelage to "own" mature mainland, and have no intention of relocating. There are damned few parcels in SL (as is) that can equal the bit of mainland that I live on. Not likerly to get a far swap in Ursala.[/QUOTE


Nothing you described above would be considered adult.



I'm in the same boat as Jannae Karas, I have a great piece of land in a mature sim that is second to none and took years to find at a rate I could afford. I will continue to use it as it was meant to be for me. My residential land, for my private enjoyment. Nude sunbathing and hottubing and full use of all my poseballs, including the hot tub and the bed in my home.
MystressAnna Lovenkraft
Registered User
Join date: 24 Oct 2007
Posts: 28
*I* Am Adult Content
04-24-2009 06:32
From: Originally Posted by Blondin Linden
1) Strip Club would be Mature.
2) Strip Clubs that use adult key words in listings and in search would be considered Adult. 3) Strip Clubs with sex balls and back room sex areas would be Adult.[/QUOTE



From: Anabella Spark
strip clubs expose nude dancers (STRIP CLUB means strippers inside lol) so how come it's now mature not adult?



Simple, I think it is because they are not providing sex or an area to have sex
Anabella Spark
Registered User
Join date: 2 Nov 2006
Posts: 418
04-24-2009 06:36
From: MystressAnna Lovenkraft
Simple, I think it is because they are not providing sex or an area to have sex


could you give us landmarks to some strip clubs. I would like to see one.
Thorn Witrial
Registered User
Join date: 28 Jun 2008
Posts: 237
04-24-2009 06:36
From: MystressAnna Lovenkraft
Simple, I think it is because they are not providing sex or an area to have sex


Every strip club I have seen has people eventually naked and emoting explicitly what they are doing to their own bodies or to the bodies of their customers.

For example: Stripper smiles suggestively as her fingers dip in pleasuring her...making her shiver as she stares hotly at Big Tipper.

And that's mild, imo.

Personally, I don't have any problem with anything people say, but know a lot of people do, or we wouldn't be in this mess.
Balthazar Almendros
Registered User
Join date: 22 Jan 2008
Posts: 4
04-24-2009 06:43
I don't see a point to these changes. When you talk to regular users or read the comments made by most residents on this subject it's overwhelmingly obvious that there is extreme opposition to this move.

These changes are unnecessary. If you don't want to see overtly adult content you can easily not see it i've traversed the grid since late 2006 and i have never come across any of the extremes of adult content that is on the grid that is widely heard about. You can't accidentally find the content you need to deliberately seek it out. I have never walked a sim and had extreme adult content thrown in my face.

You are more likely to be hit by the same griefer 10 times on random sims than stumble across a sim that simulates extreme adult content.

This is obvious pandering to the complaints of a very small minority of residents who bare striking resembelance to people who write to newspapers expressing their negative opinions on every aspect of daily life. People who live under rocks in between complaints. This is merely pandering to the media after a small amount of negative publicity the reality is you get good publicity and you get negative publicity it's the nature of the beast known as public relations you take the good with the bad and move on there is no need to change direction to bring a minority of people or a viewpoint back to viewing sl in a positive light, let those lost causes go and maintain the previous direction this new direction is not where sl should be heading.

SL is a great concept and still has alot of potential but moving to hamper the openness of sl for the majority of people is only going to limit any future potential.

The majority of residents oppose this move it is not going to destroy sl to listen to them

But it will destroy sl not to.
Blondin Linden
Linden Lab Employee
Join date: 2 Jun 2008
Posts: 381
04-24-2009 06:52
From: Photon Tokyoska

My sim has been my most significant financial investment in SL. LL has received a few thousand dollars of revenue from me over the last year and a bit. Blondin/LL I am still small enough to represent a typical resident, but also big enough to represent business - both landlord and retail. So lend me you ears.......


You got it :-)

From: Photon Tokyoska
I do not sell anything sexually related, however my houses are used as private homes and clubs, which become areas for meeting, coupling and whatever a person over 18 might get up to. So in a direct way I provide the covers that keep the sex and other fun stuff hidden from publics eyes. So I am directly, and indirectly, part of the 'Adult Sex Industry". My houses make Adult scenes Mature...... think about that for a moment. Does that make me adult - no - but I support the adult industry.


People can do as they wish in a private residence. The club however, would need a bit more explanation. Is it advertising sex? If it is, which is fine, then it would have to be on Adult land.

From: Photon Tokyoska
Secondly, as has been mentioned many times, no mater how well defined the Adult/Mature boundary is, there will be many subjective rulings and people will also want full freedom within SL (One reason why I put my rentals on Mature Land in the first place). These things combined will see the bulk of mainland residents want to move to ADULT rated lands. This will totally ruin mainland property values destroying my investment in SL. I will be forced to move to protect my investment. (And I don't want to move as I have spent hundreds of hours making a lovely place for my tenants to live and play)


If the club you mentioned above, is a run of the mill, SL nightclub - then there is no reason that you would have to move. If you decide that it would be in your best interest to move then you will be given that opportunity.


From: Photon Tokyoska
Thirdly: I cannot, and will not, police the activities of my tenants, or see if they are advertising ADULT events on my Mature land - this very aspect alone means that I must move to an Adult area. (Not to mention any potential AR's that may result in my being charged along with the offending tenant(s)).
Oh just on that - every one of my rental houses has a TV that shows music video's plus a selection of ADULT movies - omg sex... and more, further putting me/my renters at risk of being AR'd.


We won't expect you to police their activities. But if you decide to stay on Mature land, you'll need to tell them that advertising and hosting public adult content won't be allowed.
Glimmer Rhiadra
Registered User
Join date: 22 Oct 2008
Posts: 2
Brown Bag where??
04-24-2009 06:53
Same here Shockwave. I did however hear about the damn things AFTER the fact. So far, I'm not impressed with this LL insanity. If the G/PG community is so wound up, maybe THEY should move, not the adults/adult communities. This nonsense has made me rethink buying an island. Can't see giving people who refuse to hear any of us, truly HEAR us, that much money each month especially as they intend to treat us as unwanted cattle being herded into pens.

A note on the AV: I will NEVER AV with Aristotle! From what I've read and researched, it seems both they and LL have lied about the retention of information. See, Aristotle was found to be holding data for as long as 5 years without the owner's consent, according to the official reports.

If LL has CC info (and my use of it) on file (which they do as I bought $L with it!) I see no need to further expose my privacy. Should further demands be made, I'll take my money and my online pursuits to another game site.
Jannik Pikajuna
Registered User
Join date: 25 Dec 2006
Posts: 1
Where and When???
04-24-2009 06:57
I'm landowner on Mainland and I'm not a millimeter in doubt that the entire business setup on my land will be considered as Adult.
I have no time to read page up and page down in forum threads, + plus hidden places on Blog and Jira etc. This is really a impediment on my creativity, energy and enterprise !!! Therefor.: I exactly need to know where and most of all When can i opt in for that Land-Swap.