Yeah, and that takes away from making SL all about Y O U. Damn us! How could we?!
Where do my posts say "it's all about me?"
These forums are CLOSED. Please visit the new forums HERE
As You Like It - Men Becoming Women |
|
Avawyn Muircastle
Registered User
Join date: 24 Jul 2008
Posts: 528
|
11-22-2008 05:17
Yeah, and that takes away from making SL all about Y O U. Damn us! How could we?! Where do my posts say "it's all about me?" |
Gabriele Graves
Always and Forever, FULL
![]() Join date: 23 Apr 2007
Posts: 6,205
|
11-22-2008 05:18
Yeah, and that takes away from making SL all about Y O U. Damn us! How could we?! ![]() |
4318723350112047 String
Registered User
Join date: 5 Sep 2008
Posts: 147
|
11-22-2008 05:20
Yeah, and that takes away from making SL all about Y O U. Damn us! How could we?! But we're not sitting around hoping to entrap the next gullible noob who happens to think we're somebody we're not. |
Daros Jewell
Lolcat ov teh day
Join date: 26 Jun 2007
Posts: 126
|
11-22-2008 05:22
But we're not sitting around hoping to entrap the next gullible noob who happens to think we're somebody we're not. Don't lookit me, I'm taken. _____________________
I r in lurv
|
Avawyn Muircastle
Registered User
Join date: 24 Jul 2008
Posts: 528
|
11-22-2008 05:22
1 user found this very funny ![]() Yes because you keep missing the point. And, I also gather you get a kick out of hurting others if you have no consideration for other's feelings? Is that funny to you too, that you got your jollies off at the expense of another? |
4318723350112047 String
Registered User
Join date: 5 Sep 2008
Posts: 147
|
11-22-2008 05:22
Things people do and say only affect you if you let them, the responsibility is still yours. You have mute and the ability to tp anywhere, the effect of the fantasy of others is very much diminished, unless of course you allow yourself to be suspecible to dramas, for that there is little cure (taking about the general "you" here and not you personally, I don't know anything about you and would not care to presume). I don't believe anything you just said. It's probably just roleplay. |
Daros Jewell
Lolcat ov teh day
Join date: 26 Jun 2007
Posts: 126
|
11-22-2008 05:23
Where do my posts say "it's all about me?" *Smiles and pats you on the head* Sometimes it takes a little while to sink in. _____________________
I r in lurv
|
4318723350112047 String
Registered User
Join date: 5 Sep 2008
Posts: 147
|
11-22-2008 05:23
Don't lookit me, I'm taken. by a poor gullible noob? |
Avawyn Muircastle
Registered User
Join date: 24 Jul 2008
Posts: 528
|
11-22-2008 05:25
*Smiles and pats you on the head* Sometimes it takes a little while to sink in. That's what I'm trying to express to you. Hope some of what I said sinks in. |
Avawyn Muircastle
Registered User
Join date: 24 Jul 2008
Posts: 528
|
11-22-2008 05:34
Oh honey, that last quote is staggering on very thin ice over here. I hope you didn't intend it the way it came across, because how I read it, it had an additional rider of, "...that way they rest of us normal people don't have to concern ourselves with them." 1. "Turn on your mic; I want to make sure you're not a man pretending to be a woman before I talk to you or let you in my club." 2. "Turn on your mic; I want to make sure you're not a woman pretending to be a man before I talk to you or let you in my club." 3. "Turn on your webcam; I want to make sure you're not black and pretending to be white before I talk to you or let you in my club." Spot the offensive statement. I circled 1, 2 and 3. Not quite sure how you would verify if someone is gay or not. Voice is no guarantee, nor is webcam. We look and sound just like real, normal people, Avawyn. Just like you, in fact. Gay people are quite normal. We love people just the same as straight people do. We just don't love the 'correct' gender, in some peoples' eyes. That's all. Doesn't mean we throw it in their faces, and it doesn't mean we should be segregated to our own little spaces so that 'normal' people don't have to look at us. And as I was previewing my post, I spotted this further reply from you:Rider: "...but don't bring your nasty, icky, not-normal self anywhere near us, please." I am so out of this thread. Oh and you completely jumped to the WRONG CONCLUSION about my point of bringing up gay and transgender clubs. I brought that up because if a male is in a female avatar but hiding their sex they could try one of those clubs because maybe they are afraid of being who they are in other clubs. However, ALL of SL I visit excepts heterosexual and homosexual couples equally the same. My points are about those hiding their real sex in an opposite sex avatar and how their hiding could effect others. |
Gabriele Graves
Always and Forever, FULL
![]() Join date: 23 Apr 2007
Posts: 6,205
|
11-22-2008 05:35
Yes because you keep missing the point. And, I also gather you get a kick out of hurting others if you have no consideration for other's feelings? Is that funny to you too, that you got your jollies off at the expense of another? Nope simply I found what they said funny, anything else you read is your own problem. |
Gabriele Graves
Always and Forever, FULL
![]() Join date: 23 Apr 2007
Posts: 6,205
|
11-22-2008 05:38
I don't believe anything you just said. It's probably just roleplay. |
4318723350112047 String
Registered User
Join date: 5 Sep 2008
Posts: 147
|
11-22-2008 05:40
If you think that causes me any problem whatsoever then you are mistaken, take it as roleplay if that is your preference. Nah, I was being silly. I've just had enough of the discussion.. ..for now. ![]() |
Avawyn Muircastle
Registered User
Join date: 24 Jul 2008
Posts: 528
|
11-22-2008 05:43
ahh and the witch hunting begins...you know nothing about me, stop projecting. Nope simply I found what they said funny, anything else you read is your own problem. I'm sorry Gabriele but I don't hear any consideration of others in your posts. This is what is hear: It's about ME and my fantasies. Who cares about what anyone else might feel because of it. Or what outcome may come of it cuz it's all about ME and me fulfilling MY fantasies and MY roleplay is all about ME and MY fun. If I'm not hearing you correctly, send me an IM any time. Peace, out. |
Gabriele Graves
Always and Forever, FULL
![]() Join date: 23 Apr 2007
Posts: 6,205
|
11-22-2008 05:51
I'm sorry Gabriele but I don't hear any consideration of others in your posts. I don't see much consideration of that coming from you. I believe that all should respect all, but again you seem to be saying that is a one way street only. You do not seem to be respecting an individual's decision to use SL the way they want without adding conditions to it. Why should another individual respect and consider the wants of another when they are not showing the same consideration? |
Daros Jewell
Lolcat ov teh day
Join date: 26 Jun 2007
Posts: 126
|
11-22-2008 05:51
by a poor gullible noob? /me suggests you and Avawyn get together on MEMEME! Island and find out. _____________________
I r in lurv
|
Daros Jewell
Lolcat ov teh day
Join date: 26 Jun 2007
Posts: 126
|
11-22-2008 06:06
That's what I'm trying to express to you. Hope some of what I said sinks in. /me sighs and tries a last time: Listen, you say you want only men who are Really REALLY In Real Life men chatting you up in Second Life. Fine. That's your right. You're being perfectly reasonable to insist that those who enter into some kind of intimate association with you in SL be who they say they are IRL. That's settled. You following so far? Now, where you start to go wrong is when you demand that everyone in SL take up your SL model and apply it to themselves. Those that don't, you suggest they can use a "special" area far away from the mainstream where there won't be any chance of your fantasies being contaminated by, you know, THEIR fantasies. That's where you're steppin' wrong, girl, and no amount of crying the poor wounded and deceived victim is going to make that right. Your experiences with a few jerks are not justification for wanting to introduce segregation of those who, although guiltless of doing you personally any harm, you find useless to your purposes. Are we clear? _____________________
I r in lurv
|
Gabriele Graves
Always and Forever, FULL
![]() Join date: 23 Apr 2007
Posts: 6,205
|
11-22-2008 06:07
/me sighs and tries a last time: Listen, you say you want only men who are Really REALLY In Real Life men chatting you up in Second Life. Fine. That's your right. You're being perfectly reasonable to insist that those who enter into some kind of intimate association with you in SL be who they say they are IRL. That's settled. You following so far? Now, where you start to go wrong is when you demand that everyone in SL take up your SL model and apply it to themselves. Those that don't, you suggest they can use a "special" area far away from the mainstream where there won't be any chance of your fantasies being contaminated by, you know, THEIR fantasies. That's where you're steppin' wrong, girl, and no amount of crying the poor wounded and deceived victim is going to make that right. Your experiences with a few jerks are not justification for wanting to introduce segregation of those who, although guiltless of doing you personally any harm, you find useless to your purposes. Are we clear? ![]() |
Daros Jewell
Lolcat ov teh day
Join date: 26 Jun 2007
Posts: 126
|
11-22-2008 06:11
I endorse this post, very well put Daros ![]() /me smiles and bounces. "Cake time!" _____________________
I r in lurv
|
Kelli May
karmakanic
![]() Join date: 7 Oct 2006
Posts: 1,135
|
11-22-2008 06:24
Transsexuals may well hide their status for a number of reasons. It is commonly known as 'stealth' (I think FD mentioned it earlier in the thread). Sometimes appalling prejudice and violence is directed towards trans-people. People are still killed or driven to suicide by this. Stealth is often taken to extreme levels... severing ties with family and friends, obtaining forged identity documents and setting up an entirely new life. By comparison, hiding their ID on SL is a fairly minor thing.
Don't misunderstand me here. I find anyone playing the opposite sex on SL with the intention of hurting others totally reprehensible. In small ways, I've been a victim of it myself. I'm a trans-woman and I usually adopt a don't ask/don't tell policy. I don't state it outright on my profile, but there is a RL photo on my First Life tab. If anyone asks, I tell them. If a relationship looks like it's moving beyond casual flirting, I let them know. I've had all sorts of responses: "So what?", "Me too!" and "I know" being the most common. I've had the odd polite and not-so-polite refusal, too. The reason I don't have it plastered across my profile and group title is because it attracts the wrong kind of attention. Here, and in RL, trans-women have an exotic sexual status to some minds. There's a great deal of shemale & ladyboy exploitation (who is being exploited is a matter for another debate; I'm aware that some trans-women are happy to present themselves in this way and make a living at it). I'd rather not been seen in that way, but unfortunately that's how trans-women are perceived by many. As an aside, anyone who thinks voice, photos, cam or pretty much any other means of determining ID can reveal someone as male or female are deluding themselves. Post-op trans-women can often pass basic medical examination without being read. Even genetic tests (and gods help us if it ever goes so far) are not 100% foolproof. Apart from the real possibility of cheating the sampling procedure, there are people with XY (male) chromosomes who appear female from birth http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Androgen_insensitivity_syndrome. _____________________
Do worried sheep have nervous ticks?
Karmakanix@Sin-Labs http://slurl.com/secondlife/Circe/170/197/504 Karmakanix on SLX http://www.slexchange.com/modules.php?name=Marketplace&MerchantID=61062 |
Aeslyn Dae
over and out
Join date: 12 Jul 2007
Posts: 453
|
11-22-2008 06:36
I have a feeling that Gabrielle and Avawyn are talking at cross purposes here. Both have valid points but seem to be discussing two different angles of the roleplaying and fantasy aspects of SL.
From Gabrielle I get: "SL is a fantasy world in which people can, if it appeals, play a role and try out things they otherwise wouldn't get the chance to in RL, e.g. being vampires, furries or just humans of the opposite gender, and that is their right." From Avawyn I get: "Roleplay and gender-bending are perfectly fine explorations of a virtual existence - *up until* it becomes a purposeful conning of another person into believing that this is what you are in RL. Then it's manipulative and wrong." Or as one Granny Weatherwax might put it, treating people as things. I don't actually think these are incompatible views, nor do I think that any putting down of gay/transgendered or any other residents was intended. My 2p ![]() /me retreats to Saturday catching up. -- Aes |
Avawyn Muircastle
Registered User
Join date: 24 Jul 2008
Posts: 528
|
11-22-2008 06:45
/me sighs and tries a last time: Listen, you say you want only men who are Really REALLY In Real Life men chatting you up in Second Life. Fine. That's your right. You're being perfectly reasonable to insist that those who enter into some kind of intimate association with you in SL be who they say they are IRL. That's settled. You following so far? Now, where you start to go wrong is when you demand that everyone in SL take up your SL model and apply it to themselves. Those that don't, you suggest they can use a "special" area far away from the mainstream where there won't be any chance of your fantasies being contaminated by, you know, THEIR fantasies. That's where you're steppin' wrong, girl, and no amount of crying the poor wounded and deceived victim is going to make that right. Your experiences with a few jerks are not justification for wanting to introduce segregation of those who, although guiltless of doing you personally any harm, you find useless to your purposes. End of Daros' post. _____________________________________________________ Avawyn's response: I made a comment that I would put mic only in my profile as I think it might be best for me in the future because I don't like this game you're talking about. I said there ARE, however, currently clubs that will accept mic only females. One who is a real transsexual was not part of this thread. It was/is about males in female avatars. And, you haven't read my posts thoroughly and/or are not understanding what I'm trying to say. I tried to explain I brought up gay or transgender clubs for those who are hiding. Why hide? Hiding could end up hurting you or another in the long and short run. And in SL as in RL, there will always be pockets of a type of segregation. Even in America today we have segregation within integration. Do some research on that. I'm not trying to segregate anyone. I suggested those clubs for people who are hiding so they may begin to feel some freedom. And those clubs are segregated from me and that's cool. Sometimes, for instance, just girls want girl time. Or men want dude time. You are taking way out of proportion what I said regarding the clubs. Again, almost all clubs except hetero and homosexual couples the same way, and those roleplaying are welcomed as well, but ALL need to respect and be in a club within the SL TOS, of course. Meaning, no pushing, shoving, harassment, stabbing, for some examples. However, there are certain clubs that have restrictions and that is their right as that is their money and their land. Some I am excluded from myself and I'm fine with that because that is their money/land, etc. My points have been: Do you have consideration about how another person might feel about this and/or how it might affect them if you don't tell them? |
Daros Jewell
Lolcat ov teh day
Join date: 26 Jun 2007
Posts: 126
|
11-22-2008 07:40
And, you haven't read my posts thoroughly and/or are not understanding what I'm trying to say. I tried to explain I brought up gay or transgender clubs for those who are hiding. Why hide? Hiding could end up hurting you or another in the long and short run. Yes it could, but who are you to decide that for them? Some people prefer the fantasy over reality. You seem to be saying that the ultimate end-point of SL relationships/friendships is that it all eventually become some kind of RL relationship with disclosures and all that. That may be what you want, but most (like FD if I am not mistaken) simply want the fantasy and want to leave it that. I can't begin to count the amount of profiles that have "no real life, please" in them. Why do you think that is? All of them can't be lying about gender. I'm not going to presume, but it seems to me that the ones who get the most angry about gender bending and transgenders in SL are the ones who are expecting a whole lot more crossover from SL to RL. Most people, gay, straight or otherwise, don't want that. _____________________
I r in lurv
|
4318723350112047 String
Registered User
Join date: 5 Sep 2008
Posts: 147
|
11-22-2008 07:59
Yes it could, but who are you to decide that for them? Some people prefer the fantasy over reality. You seem to be saying that the ultimate end-point of SL relationships/friendships is that it all eventually become some kind of RL relationship with disclosures and all that. That may be what you want, but most (like FD if I am not mistaken) simply want the fantasy and want to leave it that. I can't begin to count the amount of profiles that have "no real life, please" in them. Why do you think that is? All of them can't be lying about gender. I'm not going to presume, but it seems to me that the ones who get the most angry about gender bending and transgenders in SL are the ones who are expecting a whole lot more crossover from SL to RL. Most people, gay, straight or otherwise, don't want that. Most? Well I've just done a survey (i asked my m ![]() |
Daros Jewell
Lolcat ov teh day
Join date: 26 Jun 2007
Posts: 126
|
11-22-2008 08:02
Most? Well I've just done a survey (i asked my m ![]() The e-harmony website is that way.... _____________________
I r in lurv
|