Upcoming Changes for Adult Content: Answers to Questions
|
Couldbe Yue
one unhappy customer
Join date: 30 Mar 2008
Posts: 1,532
|
04-27-2009 13:53
From: Argent Stonecutter Which is why you need something that will reach the people who don't understand but can be educated, and frankly the "I am adult content" and other campaigns I've seen won't do that. They'll alienate the people they need to reach, just like those ads you see in stores in SL talking about intellectual property. There's no "hook".
You get people's attention by showing how it'll effect them, not by talking about abstractions or downtrodden outgroups they likely think ought to be downtrodden.
Don't ask me for examples, I'm ambiclumsy when it comes to Photoshop. yes and at the moment the only hook i can see is for LL to exercise some corporate goodwill and make this change as easy as possible. at the moment they have no intention of doing that. but first of all what is needed is clear policy from LL. Until then all of this is really speculation and will just upset people
_____________________
Satiated Desires: Toys for Grown Ups. Inworld: http://slurl.com/secondlife/Norf%20Haven/186/132/55 XSL: https://www.xstreetsl.com/modules.php?name=Marketplace&MerchantID=77743&&sort=age&dir=asc Blog: http://satiateddesires.wordpress.com/
|
Argent Stonecutter
Emergency Mustelid
Join date: 20 Sep 2005
Posts: 20,263
|
04-27-2009 13:54
From: Kalderi Tomsen They asked us for advice on how best to go about doing it. It seems like 90% of the answers were "don't do it", and then those answering like this have been surprised that LL didn't listen to them. I've been giving them suggestions based on the assumption that the move will take place, and so have many others. I have received responses from Blondin Linden that indicate that he at least is listening. I was reasonably content with the progress... until KB 6010 was reposted and contained NO indication that anything that they were listening to were going to be acted upon: the definitions of PG and Mature were actually more restrictive than the "mistaken" ones in the original document. In addition: * Blondin has said that the definition of PG will be reverted. * Blondin has said that transcripts of the Borwn Bags would be made available. We're still waiting for these. Listening is fine. Blondin seems to be doing a pretty good job of listening. But is that going to lead to any action?
|
Brenda Connolly
Un United Avatar
Join date: 10 Jan 2007
Posts: 25,000
|
04-27-2009 13:56
From: Ilana Debevec The proper term is Pornsylvania.. just to the north of SqueakyLand And the capital is Pornodelphia. *Beams proudly as her meme takes hold.
_____________________
Don't you ever try to look behind my eyes. You don't want to know what they have seen.
http://brenda-connolly.blogspot.com
|
Talarus Luan
Ancient Archaean Dragon
Join date: 18 Mar 2006
Posts: 4,831
|
04-27-2009 13:56
From: Alexander Harbrough And the complete stranger would know how? The kid is smart enough to steal mommy's credit card or DL number and get it back without her noticing, but not able to do the same with a friend's or stranger's? One major reason: availability. Mommy's credit cards / ID are right *there* where they can go get them. A friend's or stranger's cards/ID are not. From: someone And I bet they never shoplift or do anything else wrong either, cause 'that would be wrong or dangerous?' Kids justify things completely differently than adults, simply because they don't have the experience to know better. They know that their stuff is theirs, and often (mistakenly, sure) think mommy/daddy's/sister's/brother's stuff is also theirs, all until they learn differently. It is quite different from "mine/mommy's/daddy's/brother's/sister's stuff" to "stranger's stuff", since they often learn that lesson much earlier in life. From: someone And they would probably feel they could get away with it if they were caught too, cause they are 'just kids.' When it comes to pre-teens, they probably don't think or feel anything about it. They see a need, and unless their upbringing has proscribed fulfilling that need in a particular way, they most likely won't even think about it. Teens, on the other hand, start realizing the world doesn't revolve around them, and start understanding and respecting morals and ethics by association, even without previous specific proscription. However, the flip side of that is that they understand what being devious and committing wrong is about, and they tend to be willing to "push the limits" of what they can get away with in that vein specifically. They are a lot more capable of weighing the risks vs the benefits (though that doesn't imply they weigh them correctly, just that the issue of premeditation becomes more prominent in their thinking), and are probably a lot more likely to sneak mommy's or daddy's credit card / DL info for "verification" purposes on the supposed justification of "it's not going to hurt anybody".
|
Blondin Linden
Linden Lab Employee
Join date: 2 Jun 2008
Posts: 381
|
04-27-2009 13:57
From: Sasha Nurmi I tryed to search..... 300+ pages of post... you gotta miss something... I don't belive in alts and all that... but one thing of curiosity... If I ever got a socalled "alt".... lets call the alt for "alt alterson"  and vertifyed "alt alterson"with the same RL info I gave my normal/main account. would SL residents be able to know that Im allso "alt alterson"? in a way I dont care, but Im shure some don't want others to know who theyr alt/alts are please reply if you can, and send a IM with the answer... I belive I will loose track of forums fast... I dont like forums  thanks No, SL residents would not be able to tell that your main account and Alt Alterson were related 
|
Phoenix Welles
Multiple Avatar Disorder
Join date: 6 Jan 2007
Posts: 111
|
04-27-2009 13:57
From: Darien Caldwell Why I Support the Adult Changes an essay by Darien Caldwell For those that do not know me, I run Dari's Haus, Odds, ends, and Stuff, a Second Life business I started back in Feburary of 2007. My first item was a blindfold-gag, which launched my business into the stratosphere. I've been a proponent of the D/S community and freedom of speech in SL for a long time now. But I support what LL is doing, and here is why. You've heard the spiel more than once, Second Life is a diverse place with a lot of people doing a lot of things. Some come here for adult reasons, some don't. And that clash is the cause of a lot of issues. We as adults have a right to do what interests us, as long as it doesn't run afoul of the jurisdictional law this service operates under. And this is universal, to everyone here, not just those interested in D/S, Sex, or what have you. Not everyone's world-view is open enough to accept the same things as others, we all have our taboos, and dislikes, but some things transcend the personal into the realm of the societal. Sex is definitely one of those things. Sex is a wonderful and beautiful thing, but it's also a private, intimate thing. It is understandable some are not comfortable with it being 'in their face' when out and about. As well, there are many good reasons why people of young age should not be exposed to them. "But SL is for adults, no kids are supposed to be here!" you will say, and that's true. But saying and doing are two things, and that is where LL's efforts begin. Only with some kind of verification can they make a good-faith effort to ensure there are no kids here. Is it perfect? No. But it is necessary an effort be made. As to the point of the segregation, I feel LL is making their best compromise under the circumstances. If LL wanted Adult Content gone, they could do it, quite easily, as they did with gambling, and banks, and other things which came before. They could have implemented Age Verifying in it's most flawed state, so nobody could verify as adult, and that would have done the job too. But they have obviously been working very hard to ensure they not only have a system that works, but a system that is as all-encompassing as possible. Again, it's not perfect. But what in SL is?  Respect is a two way street. We as Adults demand our lifestyles and viewpoints be respected, but we must do the same for those who's viewpoints are different from ours. We must respect their desire to not be inundated with what to them is uncomfortable or even immoral. Only through mutual respect can a kind of understanding ever hope to be achieved. I do believe LL has some major holes in their plan which still need to be overcome, but they are not insurmountable. I only hope they can do so in a way that satisfies (and note I didn't say pleases) everyone. So in closing I say I support this because I want it to work. Everyone deserves a better SL, the lascivious Adults, and the buttoned down Adults; the Teacher Adults, and the Subbie Adults; and every Adult in between. One of my favorite authors, Robert A. Heinlein said it best: "A society that gets rid of all its troublemakers goes downhill." I believe LL is doing it's best not to make that mistake. Worthy of being re-read and thus reposted 
|
Ilana Debevec
Registered User
Join date: 25 May 2007
Posts: 130
|
04-27-2009 13:57
From: Brenda Connolly And the capital is Pornodelphia.
*Beams proudly as her meme takes hold. Which gives a whole new meaning to Pittsburg /rimshot
|
Kara Spengler
Pink Cat
Join date: 11 Jun 2007
Posts: 1,227
|
04-27-2009 13:58
From: Talarus Luan Day ain't over yet.. ponders what would complete the trifecta .... 
|
Couldbe Yue
one unhappy customer
Join date: 30 Mar 2008
Posts: 1,532
|
04-27-2009 14:00
From: Talarus Luan Dude, it's not just a "particular species", it is a "family" of species. I'm not much of a bird watcher myself, but they are common targets for those that are.
So, yeah, for those who are interested in detailed representations of birds, there should very well be a strong market for them and, thus, putting them in advertising is quite warranted.
As for the other part, it is irrelevant, because the filter won't filter on context but on the words themselves. As such, his business will be impacted negatively from the overzealous (and ineffectual) use of filtering. and chickens.. chickens are *really* popular inworld at the moment.. my mind boggles
_____________________
Satiated Desires: Toys for Grown Ups. Inworld: http://slurl.com/secondlife/Norf%20Haven/186/132/55 XSL: https://www.xstreetsl.com/modules.php?name=Marketplace&MerchantID=77743&&sort=age&dir=asc Blog: http://satiateddesires.wordpress.com/
|
Ann Otoole
Registered User
Join date: 22 May 2007
Posts: 867
|
04-27-2009 14:00
Rofl @ Darien - You know i luvs you Darien. But fact of the matter most do not see is that LL allowed us to get away with behavior explicitly banned for years. Now Linden Lab is reversing the global ban on adult content and it structuring it as best they can in a puritan controlled country on the verge of economic collapse.
Go with the flow. I am going to get burned in this deal. Maybe I will survive maybe not.
Personally I am more worried about the founder of the EFF on the SL Board of directors since my work (intellectual property) may be at risk simply due to his beliefs and presence (some relevant content erased).
|
Shockwave Yareach
Registered User
Join date: 4 Oct 2006
Posts: 370
|
04-27-2009 14:00
From: Viciously Llewellyn I can keep it short.  I work as an artist for a "sin tax" business, in this instance a large import beer company. There is no way that unregulated, uncontrolled and unzoned hard core pornography can be a continued going concern, as Second Life grows and finds itself in the public eye. Its a walk on a train track, waiting for the speeding light to run you over. I dislike the way they are handling it. There probably isn't a user's manual at Barnes and Noble. Their wanting to create a better PR view of SL and have a seperate continent so people don't have to see sex/violence/alcohol/smoking/whips/chains/dental hardware is not at issue. Their forcing ALL of mainland people with certain keywords in their advertising to uproot and move to one small landmass - that is the problem. And in the end, people walking around mainland will still see people humping away in their houses or on unadvertised poseball stores here and there. So honestly, this accomplishes nothing with a huge amount of effort on everyone's part. We've said over and over that if they'd make Ursula a rated G land for all new members, educators, corporations and the teens, then NOTHING naughty can be seen there. ANY Xrated item is ARable in the G-rated continent. And the only way the new SL members can leave Ursula and go to the rest of the world is to verify, as inaccurate and pointless as that is. This then would create a VR world even your Sunday School teacher could enjoy while not destroying thousands of people's creations over half a decade of building. But LL doesn't seem to be listening to us. It's not the seperation we object to - it's who is being segregated, by what means, and what words we can and can't say in Mark's Brave New World V2.0.
|
Akira Luminos
*I* Am Adult Content
Join date: 19 Mar 2009
Posts: 41
|
04-27-2009 14:00
From: Brenda Connolly And the capital is Pornodelphia.
*Beams proudly as her meme takes hold. Yeah. But the housing is cheaper in Smutsville and Spankton, just south of the river. 
|
Ilana Debevec
Registered User
Join date: 25 May 2007
Posts: 130
|
04-27-2009 14:02
From: Kara Spengler ponders what would complete the trifecta ....  LL announces that they really HAVE been bought by Disney
|
Lord Sullivan
DTC at all times :)
Join date: 15 Dec 2005
Posts: 2,870
|
04-27-2009 14:02
From: Viciously Llewellyn I can keep it short.  I work as an artist for a "sin tax" business, in this instance a large import beer company. There is no way that unregulated, uncontrolled and unzoned hard core pornography can be a continued going concern, as Second Life grows and finds itself in the public eye. Its a walk on a train track, waiting for the speeding light to run you over. I dislike the way they are handling it. There probably isn't a user's manual at Barnes and Noble. Agreed  Just wish LL would go about it in a better way than the way it is being handled now and i think thats the crux of the matter  PS: do you get free beer?
_____________________
Independent Shopping for Second Life residents from established and new merchants. http://slapt.me  slapt.me - In-World HQ http://slurl.com/secondlife/Bastet/123/118/26
|
Shockwave Yareach
Registered User
Join date: 4 Oct 2006
Posts: 370
|
04-27-2009 14:04
From: Ilana Debevec LL announces that they really HAVE been bought by Disney I will abandon everything and quit that very day! I've done a job for Disney before. Never a more crooked, scheming group have I seen - not even LL (which isn't scheming, just stupid).
|
Meade Paravane
Hedgehog
Join date: 21 Nov 2006
Posts: 4,845
|
04-27-2009 14:04
From: Darien Caldwell ...Only with some kind of verification can they make a good-faith effort to ensure there are no kids here. Is it perfect? No. But it is necessary an effort be made. There are, I think, 3 numbers that come out of age verification: the number of RL kids the process will keep out; the number of RL adults that will be unfairly rejected; the number of RL adults that will decline to verify because of privacy or some other such issue. You call the current plan imperfect but I think it's just horrible - I can't see how it will keep any kids out but it will keep plenty of adults out, either by their choice or not. I would rather they didn't do this plan if it's not going to accomplish a goal. Saying "well, they HAVE TO do something" doesn't cut it - the current plan causes more harm than good and gives people a false sense that kids are being kept safe when they're really not. Then there's the bit where they're treating somebody with PIOF as being verified, something that credit card companies say that LL is not allowed to do.. From: Darien Caldwell ...As to the point of the segregation, I feel LL is making their best compromise under the circumstances. If LL wanted Adult Content gone, they could do it, quite easily, as they did with gambling, and banks, and other things which came before. They could have implemented Age Verifying in it's most flawed state, so nobody could verify as adult, and that would have done the job too. But they have obviously been working very hard to ensure they not only have a system that works, but a system that is as all-encompassing as possible. Again, it's not perfect. But what in SL is?  /me points Darien to the LL answer about land speculation. They ARE shutting down the growth of the adult industry!! Maybe not the same as "shutting down the adult industry" but a great first step! From: Darien Caldwell Respect is a two way street. We as Adults demand our lifestyles and viewpoints be respected, but we must do the same for those who's viewpoints are different from ours. We must respect their desire to not be inundated with what to them is uncomfortable or even immoral. Only through mutual respect can a kind of understanding ever hope to be achieved. Agreed but how is this plan going to do that? Shops that sell adult stuff aren't necessarily going to have to move. Land on mature regions that isn't set to show in search doesn't have to relocate - they can still do anything they want. Welcome areas are getting changed to be mature regions - can you think of ANY good reason for them to do that? From: Darien Caldwell I do believe LL has some major holes in their plan which still need to be overcome, but they are not insurmountable. I only hope they can do so in a way that satisfies (and note I didn't say pleases) everyone. I think we all do. The difference is that I'd rather not see them implement such painful things if they're not actually going to accomplish the goals. Doing stuff for the sake of doing stuff is bad, IMO!!! From: Darien Caldwell So in closing I say I support this because I want it to work. Everyone deserves a better SL, the lascivious Adults, and the buttoned down Adults; the Teacher Adults, and the Subbie Adults; and every Adult in between. There are sooooooooo many things LL could be doing to make SL better. I've been following all these threads pretty closely and I don't see this project doing anything productive. Nothing at all. I'm sad that I've now gotten to the point of believing that their only goal here is "make people think we care." From: Darien Caldwell One of my favorite authors, Robert A. Heinlein said it best: "A society that gets rid of all its troublemakers goes downhill." I believe LL is doing it's best not to make that mistake. No.. If this was really about choice or keeping most of the people happy most of the time, there would ALSO be a new PG continent coming. THAT would actually accomplish some of their goals. /me hopes she is not discouraging you from posting. I strongly disagree with you but you're one of the few rational ones arguing for this plan.. Please keep it up! 
_____________________
Tired of shouting clubs and lucky chairs? Vote for llParcelSay!!! - Go here: http://jira.secondlife.com/browse/SVC-1224- If you see "if you were logged in.." on the left, click it and log in - Click the "Vote for it" link on the left
|
Milla Janick
Empress Of The Universe
Join date: 2 Jan 2008
Posts: 3,075
|
04-27-2009 14:04
From: Blondin Linden That is correct. Ursula will not be the name of the Adult Content mainland. So Pornsylvania is still in the running? Huzzah!
|
Mosley Sperber
Registered User
Join date: 11 Jun 2007
Posts: 87
|
04-27-2009 14:06
From: Alexander Harbrough That kind of thinking explains why so many use bots (note, not saying you do, just lamenting your response)... I fail to see with what train of thought you're bringing bots into this, but well, you already alleged that I make tits only for the "cute joke", so ... From: Alexander Harbrough You would not have to put 'I am not telling you which ones' in a search any more than a clothing vendor needs to specify their list of clothing in search is not all inclusive. No clothing vendor has their classified saying nothing but "Clothes." If I were to search for birds, I would certainly pass over classifieds that do not list what birds they have, as I would assume that their birds either are not realistic representations of RL bird species, or that birds aren't their main product. From: Alexander Harbrough Is there really that much competition for specific species of songbirds that you need your ads to be that specific as well? Even though it means your ads would come up in searches completely irrelevant to your product other than perhaps as a marketing gimmick? Again: Currently more than half of my birds are tits, as tits make up the majority of songbirds where I live. And yes, I have had customers (yes, more than one) tell me that they were happy to find blue tits, and that they had searched for them specifically, and making people come to my store to find out which birds I sell as opposed to telling them right in my classified or in my parcel description is a disservice to the potential customer. Just to be sure that I don't misunderstand you: You think that instead of lamenting obviously too broad word filters (as lists such as the previously posted word list will have false positives) I should simply not list a good part of my products in search, not mention them in my classified, nor in my parcel description, lest my store might be misclassified as adult? You're really saying that I cannot call a tit a tit, that it's "too bad, but your own fault for making songbirds and naming them by their correct name"? Really? (For the record, since I'm posting anyway, and because previous postings stated that it might be of interest: My main store is on PG mainland. I chose PG mainland because I, personally, do not want to see "adult content" on every corner. "On every corner of mature mainland" would have been perfectly fine with me though ... all I ever wanted was for LL to properly enforce the old PG/Mature definitions, which they apparently never did.)
|
Lord Sullivan
DTC at all times :)
Join date: 15 Dec 2005
Posts: 2,870
|
04-27-2009 14:07
From: Brenda Connolly And the capital is Pornodelphia.
*Beams proudly as her meme takes hold. and you shall be its Mayoress
_____________________
Independent Shopping for Second Life residents from established and new merchants. http://slapt.me  slapt.me - In-World HQ http://slurl.com/secondlife/Bastet/123/118/26
|
Shockwave Yareach
Registered User
Join date: 4 Oct 2006
Posts: 370
|
04-27-2009 14:07
From: Milla Janick So Pornsylvania is still in the running?
Huzzah! At least it would show LL isn't completely overrun by mindless Ogres who resort to MBA manuals to solve problems.
|
Viciously Llewellyn
Not Really Vicious ;-)
Join date: 27 Sep 2007
Posts: 332
|
04-27-2009 14:08
From: Shockwave Yareach Their wanting to create a better PR view of SL and have a seperate continent so people who don't wish to see sex/violence/alcohol/smoking/whips/chains/dental hardware is not at issue. Their forcing ALL of mainland people with certain keywords in their advertising to uproot and move to one small landmass - that is the problem. And in the end, people walking around mainland will still see people humping away in their houses or on unadvertised poseball stores here and there. So honestly, this accomplishes nothing with a huge amount of effort on everyone's part.
We've said over and over that if they'd make Ursula a rated G land for all new members, educators, corporations and the teens, then NOTHING naughty can be seen there. ANY Xrated item is ARable in the G-rated continent. And the only way the new SL members can leave Ursula and go to the rest of the world is to verify, as inaccurate and pointless as that is. This then would create a VR world even your Sunday School teacher could enjoy while not destroying thousands of people's creations over half a decade of building.
But LL doesn't seem to be listening to us. It's not the seperation we object to - it's who is being segregated, by what means, and what words we can and can't say in Mark's Brave New World V2.0. So buy the company, so you can tell them what to do! Honestly, this just can't be this difficult. I don't really like it either, but It's their company, their investment, their risk. They do have the right to have the best public relations image then can present. There is a huge difference between: This is our wonderful world, and for those that want it, we keep our porn here! ... and ... This is our wonderful porn world, but we have a place that you can be safe!
|
Tcko Cazalet
Less Freedom=Exodus
Join date: 16 May 2007
Posts: 163
|
More to it than just moving
04-27-2009 14:08
My first land was in Oppeano....I worked hard there acquiring land..eventually ad farmers got to be too much so I started searching for the ideal land I wanted. I found Longfin....I bought my first parcel and then started selling off land in Oppeano and then bought more in Longfin...two long hard years, terra forming and buying out land as it became for sale...you get attached to places....and I have a little of everything on my 55000+ sqm.
Yes I am adult and I do fit in the extreme catagory.....I know without a doubt I will not get the same land....as well as lost income....I feel I am losing a lot more than that...something I was proud of that can't be replaced.....then I'm told it's first come first served no matter how much land I own or how much I pay SL in tiers. Sad...it takes a lot out of the heart. I read somewhere we make three choices for land then SL decides if we get our choices if at all.
Something's just not right...so I guess I'll just sit back and watch it all unfold (as if I have any choice )....then make my decision from there MHO
|
Mosley Sperber
Registered User
Join date: 11 Jun 2007
Posts: 87
|
04-27-2009 14:09
From: Persephone Loon Dear Mosley, please pay attention to the following with respect to that avatar:
~~ does Professor Quirrel imitation ~~
TROLL! TROLL IN THE DUNGEONS!
Thought you should know.
You may be right .... I just can't keep up with this thread (I skipped at least some 100 posts in the middle). If I've been replying to an obvious troll, then I apologise ... in any case, I think I've said all I wanted to say anyway, and will now return to lurking 
|
Shockwave Yareach
Registered User
Join date: 4 Oct 2006
Posts: 370
|
04-27-2009 14:10
From: Viciously Llewellyn This is our wonderful world, and for those that want it, we keep our porn here! ... and ... This is our wonderful porn world, but we have a place that you can be safe!
You are thinking too small, see. You can have both at the same time!! But not the way they are doing this now, though.
|
Blondin Linden
Linden Lab Employee
Join date: 2 Jun 2008
Posts: 381
|
04-27-2009 14:11
From: Leanne Karas I would like to know how this affects the huge Star Wars Roleplay community in SL? Does a RP sim have to be labelled as "adult" due to roleplayed depictions of death if someone comes along and decides to have a battle? As combat is only a small part of roleplay in these sims labelling as "adult" would detract from the main purpose... I might have already missed a similar question in pages and pages of posts about this subject, sorry, but I would really like to know where I stand on this... I run my mainstore and dance club business in the same sim and this would obviously impact on them too  Depends what Princes Leia does with that golden bikini. I don't see this impacting the Star Wars rp community at all.
|