Welcome to the Second Life Forums Archive

These forums are CLOSED. Please visit the new forums HERE

Upcoming Changes for Adult Content: Answers to Questions

Wynochee LeShelle
Polykontexturalist
Join date: 3 Feb 2007
Posts: 658
04-23-2009 11:28
From: Deira Llanfair
From my perspective it is as PG as a Tom and Jerry cartoon. They could be considered very violent - but it's a cartoon, not real. I'm in the UK if you really want to know - where we still realise the difference between real guns and animated cartoon ones.


I thought so. Same here in Austria. But since Blondin spoke of legal guns, and guns will be not moved to Ursula, I think, if one makes a nice waterboarding - animation this will go through as legal and PG too. I have heard it is a common freetime pleasure of specific american "services"...to give people a waterboarding treatment 800+ times. Was in medias, prime time, worldwide, the term and how it works and that it will not be prosecuted. Sure PG....
Blondin Linden
Linden Lab Employee
Join date: 2 Jun 2008
Posts: 381
04-23-2009 11:29
From: Amelia Marikh
I have been trying to follow this issue off and on and aside from the problems with verification i have (being a european) i do have one question which may or may not have been answered somewhere already and i appologise if it has.
How will this affect homestead sims? currantly we have one and are slightly in limbo with regards to changing the existing club incase this new "thing" would affect what we do. again sorry if this has been asked before



What kind of club do you have? Homesteads would need to flag their content just like any other region.
Thorn Witrial
Registered User
Join date: 28 Jun 2008
Posts: 237
Dear Blondin
04-23-2009 11:30
I originally posted this on the Xstreet forums, but no Linden has acknowledged it, even though I've seen Meta Linden on at least twice in the last six hours. So, here we go. Second try.

~~~*drops gracefully to his knees*```

SL has taught me the art of pleading without shame. If what it takes for you to listen and understand what someone says is to put aside all pride and beg you, I will do it.

I beg of you to listen. Please. There is an important part of this transition to Adult Orientation that everyone has been trying to express. And after reading 4000+ comments on the Blog, it seems you either can't, or won't, acknowledge or understand it.


This move is going to hurt. A lot. It seems to us that you don't care about what we are saying because, when direct questions are asked in simple language on the blogs, they either are not answered, or are only answered by repeating the exact language of the official release regardless of the fact that people are asking for clarification of that exact same language. This is giving the impression of willful obfuscation, regardless of what you may really mean. Please understand that. Even if you don't mean to come across as steamrolling over people, you still are coming across that way.

It appears as if the 'discussion' is designed to entangle people long enough to pull this off and that people will just settle back down like they did after the casinos were removed. However, I think this time we are really screwed.

I think the sweeping changes made before in SL's history (casino removal, age play crackdowns) didn't affect the guts of SL like this will, but the lesson you seem to have learned is that Linden Labs can do anything if you are willing to wade through the backlash.

That nothing seriously different will happen to our world, however, in this instance, so many residents are going to lose so much time and money that I think they'll just leave. Linden Labs appears to not be paying attention to the fact that all the other major changes to SL occurred when people though the macro world economy was humming along fine. In this global recession/depression, people are feeling desperate and worried and angry and broke. They will not take this.

Again, I beg you to please please PLEASE listen to what we are telling you. Listen to the alternatives people have proposed and debate the pros and cons sensibly and clearly. LET US HELP YOU HELP US.

TRUST US.

If we do this, SL will not survive but thrive and we will all be the richer for it.
Shockwave Yareach
Registered User
Join date: 4 Oct 2006
Posts: 370
I will not cooperate
04-23-2009 11:33
I will continue to operate in my home as I always have. It's not a business, and it's not anyone elses business what I do in my private parcel so long as it's not visible from a road.

I will not move to Adultville, simply because I have a sexbed and ocassional guests. Period. Not voluntarily, and not forcifully either. If you DO choose to press the issue with me or my friends and neighbors, then you choose to lose us as customers. You will choose to lose our thousands of dollars monthly income because you (of all people) cannot tell the difference between reality and a cartoon. And then, you can all pay the electric bill and your salaries by having bake sales and raffling off M's Porsche.

You have set a bad course here, and you've made it much worse by setting standards that will make almost every parcel in SL today an Adult one. You're take a moderately simple problem and making it much, much worse with this solution method. And if you proceed as planned, your losses will make it into management history books for a century to follow. You'll become a textbook example of how to take a profitable enterprise and utterly destroy it by forgetting what, exactly, you are selling.

I implore you -- please stop and take a good hard look at what the goal is, and whether or not this solution is the best one available to you. Every day, you make matters worse, not better, by widening the list of "adult" activities to the point where your 2-4% claim is impossibly naive. When I said it was impossible to clean up Mainland without bulldozing everything, I didn't mean for you to do just that! I meant that what is here is here and your goals are better met by making Ursula the new G rated entry point for new users, businesses, educators and teens. Keeping it clean will be a snap - making the mainland clean, that's not achievable without losing lots and lots of customers.

The customers you lose today will equal ten times that number in future customers lost. If you think we don't blog and we don't tell others what's going on (and in some cases, set corporate policy), you are fooling yourself.

Time is running short, LL. If you turn on your customers like you are planning, then you'll have far fewer customers left.
Blondin Linden
Linden Lab Employee
Join date: 2 Jun 2008
Posts: 381
04-23-2009 11:38
From: Couldbe Yue
if alts are tied to an account will the account verification status of the primary be cascaded to the npoif/non verified alts tied to the account or will all accounts still have to age/account verify separately?



It's something we are working toward, but at this point, it'll be individual.
Thorn Witrial
Registered User
Join date: 28 Jun 2008
Posts: 237
04-23-2009 11:38
From: Shockwave Yareach


I implore you -- please stop and take a good hard look at what the goal is, and whether or not this solution is the best one available to you. Every day, you make matters worse, not better, by widening the list of "adult" activities to the point where your 2-4% claim is impossibly naive. When I said it was impossible to clean up Mainland without bulldozing everything, I didn't mean for you to do just that! I meant that what is here is here and your goals are better met by making Ursula the new G rated entry point for new users, businesses, educators and teens. Keeping it clean will be a snap - making the mainland clean, that's not achievable without losing lots and lots of customers.

The customers you lose today will equal ten times that number in future customers lost. If you think we don't blog and we don't tell others what's going on (and in some cases, set corporate policy), you are fooling yourself.

Time is running short, LL. If you turn on your customers like you are planning, then you'll have far fewer customers left.


After reading each and every comment on this thread, I have come to the conclusion that they don't believe what we are saying.
Couldbe Yue
one unhappy customer
Join date: 30 Mar 2008
Posts: 1,532
04-23-2009 11:40
From: Thorn Witrial
After reading each and every comment on this thread, I have come to the conclusion that they don't believe what we are saying.



I suppose that's fair, we don't believe what they're saying after all ;)
_____________________
Satiated Desires: Toys for Grown Ups.
Inworld: http://slurl.com/secondlife/Norf%20Haven/186/132/55
XSL: https://www.xstreetsl.com/modules.php?name=Marketplace&MerchantID=77743&&sort=age&dir=asc
Blog: http://satiateddesires.wordpress.com/
Blondin Linden
Linden Lab Employee
Join date: 2 Jun 2008
Posts: 381
04-23-2009 11:41
From: Cytherion Revnik


how do you classify "Animation stores" that strictly sell animations and regulate no nudity policy have no nude images in their store, no cuss words or explicit words describing genital contact as adult based on your definition?
Its not a rant but I speak for every animation designer in SL when I say that its needs to be clearly identified if you make animations that lets 2 avatars engage in sex makes you an explicitly sexual region or not. Because going by definition its not "Explicit"

For example a product made by my company is a Kama Sutra MetaBook, Its an animated book for residents who want to learn about Kama Sutra. The book of kama sutra is classified as art and is available even in PG book stores openly.
It has no explicit nudity, its clothed demonstration but yet it allows 2 avatars to engage and try out the Kama Sutra positions in their privacy. You can see my dilemma here, is it PG or do I mark it as "explicitly sexual content"
It doesnt matter to me either ways as I have both PG and MA sims, I just need to know where I move what that is all..


The animation store you described above would not be considered Adult.
Thorn Witrial
Registered User
Join date: 28 Jun 2008
Posts: 237
04-23-2009 11:41
From: Couldbe Yue
I suppose that's fair, we don't believe what they're saying after all ;)


Then we are at an impasse of Gordian Knot proportions. That was solved by cutting it in half, as I recall. :-(
Blondin Linden
Linden Lab Employee
Join date: 2 Jun 2008
Posts: 381
04-23-2009 11:43
From: Miro Collas
Uhm, what if a private region is a home (or a few homes) and nothing else? No commerce whatsoever, no clubs, just private homes.


Mature would be fine.
Moon Metty
Registered User
Join date: 23 May 2008
Posts: 12
04-23-2009 11:46
From: Argent Stonecutter
Blondin: This contradicts many statements you have made that what would otherwise be adult content in private residences does not need to be in an Adult region.


From: Blondin Linden
No you're right, If it's an advertised venue it would be adult. So for the error.


From: Argent Stonecutter
So if it's not an advertised venue it's not required to be in an Adult region. Thank you.



Blondin, what if the venue is advertised on a website outside of Second Life?
Marcia Moulliez
Registered User
Join date: 21 Nov 2007
Posts: 5
not impressed
04-23-2009 11:47
this will ruin sl for me...

I build generally and my store is on the mainland.

Currently mature as I sell sexually themed furniture/ bondage gear and Sci type vehicles. Most of this have the usual nukes fitted which is pretty damn violent I assume.

I took up this parcel just before the new rules were touted by the Lindens.

We also rent a piece of land which luckily is on a private mature island so LL should not mess with us there but I just see this as totally unrealistic. The levels of what is mature and what is adult will be blurred as always which will kill alot of businesses.

In this case I'd ask if LL will be providing a free swap of land (i.e. my mature mainland parcel) over to the adult land or will only the people who get chosen get a look in.

This sucks and removes the option to be sensible. I thought a nanny state existed in RL, a shame the Lindens are not sensible enough to avoid reflecting the mistakes made in RL in SL.
Blondin Linden
Linden Lab Employee
Join date: 2 Jun 2008
Posts: 381
04-23-2009 11:47
From: Argent Stonecutter
Even if the landowner owns the whole region?
Um.

Think that one through, could ya?

What about Private Homes on Private Regions? Are you saying that the only place you can have a personal sexgen bed in your own home or skybox is on an Adult private region or on the mainland? :eek:


I thought somewhere I had corrected myself for this but I'm not sure. Maybe I dreamed it :-)

Private homes on a private region with no advertising would be mature. If they were hosting adult content open to the public, then it would be adult.
Blondin Linden
Linden Lab Employee
Join date: 2 Jun 2008
Posts: 381
04-23-2009 11:51
From: Ciaran Laval
Female nipples are not mature content. Topless sunbathing is not mature content either.



Female nipples and topless female sunbathing will not be suitable for a PG region.
Blondin Linden
Linden Lab Employee
Join date: 2 Jun 2008
Posts: 381
04-23-2009 11:52
From: Shockwave Yareach
Thus far, it sounds like every sim that has any home with any sexbed in it or picture of Michelangelo's David will have to be Adult.

You are going to have nothing but Adult sims at this rate.


This is absolutely not true. A home with a sex bed will not be considered adult.
Argent Stonecutter
Emergency Mustelid
Join date: 20 Sep 2005
Posts: 20,263
04-23-2009 11:53
From: Blondin Linden
I thought somewhere I had corrected myself for this but I'm not sure. Maybe I dreamed it :-)
I think your correction came after I posted that.
From: someone
Private homes on a private region with no advertising would be mature. If they were hosting adult content open to the public, then it would be adult.
What does "open to the public" mean, does that mean having some sign or description or advertising that it's open to the public?
_____________________
Argent Stonecutter - http://globalcausalityviolation.blogspot.com/

"And now I'm going to show you something really cool."

Skyhook Station - http://xrl.us/skyhook23
Coonspiracy Store - http://xrl.us/coonstore
Blondin Linden
Linden Lab Employee
Join date: 2 Jun 2008
Posts: 381
04-23-2009 11:54
From: Aeneas Beaumont
To Blondin:

It wasn't my question, but this concerns me as well.

If I have a home, on an estate now flagged as 'mature', and:

- it has a full range of BDSM stuff,
- it has a very nice sexgen bed,
- it has pictures depicting sexual acts,
- there is nothing for sale (barring some stuff that is for sale because of jumbled settings by the creator - happens every now and then)
- it is not advertised
- but it is accessible for everyone because I hate banlines and banlists

what does it mean then? It's private, but usable by everyone.

Is it still mature or is it adult?


This would be Mature.
Ilana Debevec
Registered User
Join date: 25 May 2007
Posts: 130
04-23-2009 11:54
From: Blondin Linden
From your description above, the store would be Mature. What kind of language does this store use to advertise?


OK, please MAKE UP YOUR MIND. First time we discussed this (in private) BDSM was 'mature' even if some of the devices have 'potential sexual use' and when I mentioned that I could disable those on the demos, that seemed to be fine. Then BDSM was going to be inherently 'sexual' and all of it was ADULT. Now we swing back the other way, if there is no nudity. You only made ONE comment our out advertising and that was a company name (CumOn) ... is it what's in the store or the ADVERTISING.

I even offered SPECIFICALLY to work with the group on setting the standards to see what was/wasn't 'adult' and what could be done to adjust things to 'fit in' and was IGNORED!

FOR GHODS SAKE, MAKE UP YOUR MIND LINDEN LAB!
Shockwave Yareach
Registered User
Join date: 4 Oct 2006
Posts: 370
04-23-2009 11:55
From: Argent Stonecutter
Your correction came after I posted that.
What does "open to the public" mean, does that mean having some sign or description or advertising that it's open to the public?


Whereas all of SL should now be Adult, since we are all being bent over a barrel and getting f***** by the Lindens.
Blondin Linden
Linden Lab Employee
Join date: 2 Jun 2008
Posts: 381
04-23-2009 11:55
From: Milla Janick
Field trip to the Xcite store during your office hours today?

Are Lindens still doing surveys of potential adult material in world? Would it be possible for you to announce it here so residents could tag along and get a handle on what's going to fall on which side of the line?



I'd be willing to do something like this next week for my OH.
Milla Janick
Empress Of The Universe
Join date: 2 Jan 2008
Posts: 3,075
04-23-2009 11:56
From: Blondin Linden
I thought somewhere I had corrected myself for this but I'm not sure. Maybe I dreamed it :-)

Private homes on a private region with no advertising would be mature. If they were hosting adult content open to the public, then it would be adult.

Open to the public, or advertised?

Would "open to the public" mean residents in mature regions would have to stop allowing public access to their land via the about land option if they wanted to get their digital freak on?
_____________________


http://www.avatarsunited.com/avatars/milla-janick
All those moments will be lost in time... like tears in rain...
Lord Sullivan
DTC at all times :)
Join date: 15 Dec 2005
Posts: 2,870
04-23-2009 11:56
From: Ciaran Laval
Minx Eisenheart I think it is, she was at one of the brown bags and I believe Stroker was at one of them, might have been the same one but maybe Minx will see this and confirm.


I was at one, yes stroker was, Matthew, Melody, Toy, Marianne and others as i didn't keep a list of who was at mine.
_____________________
Independent Shopping for Second Life residents from established and new merchants.

http://slapt.me



slapt.me - In-World HQ http://slurl.com/secondlife/Bastet/123/118/26
Wynochee LeShelle
Polykontexturalist
Join date: 3 Feb 2007
Posts: 658
04-23-2009 11:58
From: Blondin Linden
Female nipples and topless female sunbathing will not be suitable for a PG region.


And male nipples?
Blondin Linden
Linden Lab Employee
Join date: 2 Jun 2008
Posts: 381
04-23-2009 11:58
From: Matthew Dowd
According to the definitions a PG region does not permit "any content that is suggestive of any (even mildly) sexual or violent themes, or references to social drug or alcohol usage"

yet you will find more than just suggestions of violence, sex, alcohol, even rape in Shakespeare!

Matthew



There will always be edge cases and in the context of education, these things would be acceptable.
Shockwave Yareach
Registered User
Join date: 4 Oct 2006
Posts: 370
tick tock tick tock
04-23-2009 11:58
Time is rapidly running out, Lindens. If I were you, I'd leave the details of what you did at LL off of your resumes'.

And any former LL resume' I see with the exception of Soft's goes right to the shredder.