Upcoming Changes for Adult Content: Answers to Questions
|
Brieanne Bomazi
Don't forget the *E*
Join date: 29 Jan 2005
Posts: 383
|
04-23-2009 10:08
From: Carl Temin Greetings
I am not happy. I run an animation business connected to a large market. Dis assembling and moving my business would be a good deal of hard work, take a lot of time and time is money. My region is Mature, the other businesses on my region are mature ( sex industry mainly ). I don't want anything to do with this moving at all. As far as I am concerned the prudish minority should be given their own 'continent' and the majority should be left in peace. That's the first thing. The second thing is that....why do we physically have to move at all. LL should just be able to move the region server over to this mystical new continent. Where is it by the way?
No, I don't want to troll through 300 to 600 forum posts to find the information I need.
Lindens move my whole region to the new adult continent seamlessly and leave me be!
Too, as I don't spend all my time in SL these days I might not be able to move my 3500 + prims and 16K+m2 somewhere else, am I going to return one day and find my business gone? Will I be given new land? Where? And whilst I have payment info used on file etc...there is no way you are having my drivers license or passport number.
I expect the following as a customer of SL
Protection of my interests Detailed information on what you intend to do with my parcels server and when How it will effect me How I will be compensated for any loss Ok?
Just move the whole region and its contents to this new SL continent without it effecting me or my business at all.
Kind regards
Carl Temin New Continent is Ursula. They will not pick up and move your sim, nor will they help you. This is your problem. This is what they have told the rest of us, and saving you wading thru the mess, let me sum it up for you. LL has decided. At some future point, they are saying June, you will have to file a ticket stating you are adult content, how much land you own, and that you wish to move. IF they deem you worthy, they will give you further instructions. You get X number of days to own both lots, then LL reclaims your mainland, and your stuck on the new parcel, and revenue lost, time lost ect, is all your problem. If they deem you not worthy, you have to get your shit cleaned up. cause first time someone files an AR on you for adult things in M rating, you risk losing everything. Sorry to be the bring you the bad news.. and you can ask, wait for and get pissed when a Linden doesn't respond, or you can feel free to wade thru the 3K+ posts before this and find out i have said nothing but the truth as they have given it to us already. ~Brie
|
Snickers Snook
Odd Princess - Trout 7.3
Join date: 17 Apr 2007
Posts: 746
|
04-23-2009 10:09
Has anyone thought of emailing LL's PR firm??
[email]secondlifeus@lewispr.com[/email]
It's a public address connected to that incredibly dense and stealth media release about Adult content.
_____________________
 Buh-bye forums, it's been good ta know ya.
|
Kalderi Tomsen
Nomad Extraordinaire!
Join date: 10 May 2007
Posts: 888
|
04-23-2009 10:14
From: Paisley Dawes A partner and I are in the process of building a private region, and on that sim, in a skybox, we would like to have an area of a more adult nature. This space would not be advertised in any way, and would be for the sole use of our residents and close friends. A place to go, hang out and...whatever.
What rating would that fall under??? Based on what Blondin has said on here (well, said one way then corrected), you would be rated Mature.
_____________________
Kalderi, General Manager, Hosoi Ichiba and Hosoi Design
- - - Hosoi Ichiba - High Quality Classically-styled Asian buildings, furniture and home decorations in an old-fashioned Japanese market garden on Japan Kanto. http://hosoi-ichiba.blogspot.com/
Hosoi Design - High Quality prefabs and furnishings, plus commercial buildings.
|
Brenda Connolly
Un United Avatar
Join date: 10 Jan 2007
Posts: 25,000
|
04-23-2009 10:14
From: samatha Congrejo Ok now at 250 and counting,
and survey says not one of those 250 Adult content providers has been contacted, consulted, or even talked to about these changes.
So exactly who of "those most effected by these changes" did they consult with??
Anyone reading these forums who has adult content and WAS actually consulted, please please speak up, I would love to know at least someone was consulted in the adult content field.
How about muti sim owners? Any one of you Consulted??
How about Major mainland land owners with adult content? Any of you consulted?? Paging Lord Sullivan......
_____________________
Don't you ever try to look behind my eyes. You don't want to know what they have seen.
http://brenda-connolly.blogspot.com
|
Ryanna Enfield
Registered User
Join date: 26 Dec 2005
Posts: 225
|
04-23-2009 10:21
I'm not too sure why LL is so focused on appealing to Educators. Honestly there are already very viable competitors out there such as ReactionGrid, which is already a completely PG environment and accepting of all ages. In addition the costs are much more minimal. Schools don't usually have a lot of extra cash floating around to spend on side projects. I can't really see why an in world economy would be super important to a school using it as a learning platform, so again... Why is LL trying to attract Educators? This is the same LL that was going to shaft Educators by removing their Education discounts. I'm not sure what happened with that, but I recall that being an issue during the Open Space debacle.
_____________________
~*Ryanna Enfield*~
|
Brenda Connolly
Un United Avatar
Join date: 10 Jan 2007
Posts: 25,000
|
04-23-2009 10:30
From: Ryanna Enfield I'm not too sure why LL is so focused on appealing to Educators. Honestly there are already very viable competitors out there such as ReactionGrid, which is already a completely PG environment and accepting of all ages. In addition the costs are much more minimal. Schools don't usually have a lot of extra cash floating around to spend on side projects. I can't really see why an in world economy would be super important to a school using it as a learning platform, so again... Why is LL trying to attract Educators? This is the same LL that was going to shaft Educators by removing their Education discounts. I'm not sure what happened with that, but I recall that being an issue during the Open Space debacle. They want to be "Legitimate". They are the Joseph Kennedy of the age.
_____________________
Don't you ever try to look behind my eyes. You don't want to know what they have seen.
http://brenda-connolly.blogspot.com
|
Yumi Murakami
DoIt!AttachTheEarOfACat!
Join date: 27 Sep 2005
Posts: 6,860
|
04-23-2009 10:30
From: Ryanna Enfield I'm not too sure why LL is so focused on appealing to Educators. Honestly there are already very viable competitors out there such as ReactionGrid, which is already a completely PG environment and accepting of all ages. In addition the costs are much more minimal. Schools don't usually have a lot of extra cash floating around to spend on side projects. I can't really see why an in world economy would be super important to a school using it as a learning platform, so again... Why is LL trying to attract Educators? This is the same LL that was going to shaft Educators by removing their Education discounts. I'm not sure what happened with that, but I recall that being an issue during the Open Space debacle. My guess: they're going to allow true-PG regions to be mirrored onto the Teen Grid. Not actually connecting the two grids, but having the same build duplicated on both exactly, thus solving the "we can't market to everyone" complaint by external companies. (Yes, educators would need this, because University recruitment targets under-18s.)
|
Waterstar Eilde
Registered User
Join date: 12 May 2007
Posts: 404
|
04-23-2009 10:35
From: Snickers Snook Has anyone thought of emailing LL's PR firm??
[email]secondlifeus@lewispr.com[/email]
It's a public address connected to that incredibly dense and stealth media release about Adult content. Now there's an idea... [/me starts thinking one step to the side about putting out our own press release...or at least, a letter to the editor...]
|
samatha Congrejo
Registered User
Join date: 10 Apr 2007
Posts: 188
|
04-23-2009 10:38
From: Brenda Connolly Paging Lord Sullivan...... Hi Brenda I know about Lord, but he does not sell content on sl and i beleive owns one or two sims only.
|
Meade Paravane
Hedgehog
Join date: 21 Nov 2006
Posts: 4,845
|
04-23-2009 10:39
From: Snickers Snook Has anyone thought of emailing LL's PR firm?? Since LL probably pays them a fair amount of money, I think they'd care even less than LL does. Unless LL started paying them to care. You'd probably gave better luck contacting Visa and asking them if it's ok that LL is going to be blocking adult content based on if people have payment info (and the answer, according to Visa.com, is "no. absolutely not." 
_____________________
Tired of shouting clubs and lucky chairs? Vote for llParcelSay!!! - Go here: http://jira.secondlife.com/browse/SVC-1224- If you see "if you were logged in.." on the left, click it and log in - Click the "Vote for it" link on the left
|
samatha Congrejo
Registered User
Join date: 10 Apr 2007
Posts: 188
|
04-23-2009 10:43
From: Ciaran Laval Minx Eisenheart I think it is, she was at one of the brown bags and I believe Stroker was at one of them, might have been the same one but maybe Minx will see this and confirm. Ok thanks hun, i just checked and she owns a clothign store i believe. Not sure whatehr sales are like, but wonderign if they come close to the figures for meor the others i have asked that only get what is posted here and never see a linden.
|
Angelia Rees
ROMA Estate Manager
Join date: 6 Oct 2006
Posts: 20
|
Having read the new guidelines, things are still clear as mud
04-23-2009 10:44
Dear Lindens, Thank you so much for the publishing of the new guidelines on the Knowledge Base ( https://support.secondlife.com/ics/support/default.asp?deptID=4417&task=knowledge&questionID=6010) but I hate to tell you, they are still too vague to know where one stands. I have two major concerns and several minor ones regarding the new rules and region designations. Let's start with the 1st major one: I am the Estate Manager for a group of 4 non-mainland sims - on these sims, we allow *non-sexual* toplessness and nudity, for both women and men (including non-erect prim "bits" for men). How does this fall under the new guidelines - adult or mature? Your guidelines state no "Photo-realistic nudity". Does this also apply to realistically drawn skins? (E.g. skins with realistically detailed *drawn* nipples and "kitties"?) If so, then you might as well say nudity is "Adult", and not allowed in Mature areas, since I cannot judge what sort of skins our visitors might choose to wear. And what about prim gentialia attachments? Is it still "Adult" if our sim rules do not allow them to be in an erect state? What about the activities naked avatars are engaged in? If a group of avatars is dancing naked in a field, but not engaging in sexual acts, is *that* "Adult"? Where is the line drawn? Another concern regarding our sim and it's activities is this: while we allow non-sexual nudity in "public" (nothing in SL is really private anyway, but we define public as anywhere one should not normally expect sexual activity - shops, taverns, the street, the main square, etc.) we do have an underground region equipt with sex-gen beds for those who wish to engage in such activities in "private". Your new guidelines state - "Dance clubs that feature "burlesque" acts can also generally reside in Mature Regions so long as they don't promote sexual conduct such as through pose balls (whether in "backrooms" or more visible spaces)." While our underground private rooms are not a dance club, this would still seem to apply to them in that they "promote sexual conduct such as through pose balls (whether in "backrooms" or more visible spaces)". We have taken great care to keep all sexual activity out of the eyes of those who might not wish to see it, while still allowing those who wish to engage in it the freedom to do so. But it seems that under your new guidelines, this would brand our sim "Adult", rather than Mature. Why are we being penalised for being *responsible* folk? If I am mistaken, and this does *not* define our sim as "Adult", please explain why it isn't and whether or not as an Estate Manager I will have to worry about fraudulant ARs from the small minority that might be offended anyway. For me, as a manager, that would be a *major* concern, because often, ARs are handled in haste and repaired after the fact. I cannot afford to be banned for "running adult activities in a mature sim", even if it were rectified later. I am part of the law and order in our sim, and need to be availible to maintain that order, as well as all my other duties as a manager. Which brings us to our sims rental residents. Will they be forced to remove any sex-gen or similar items from their homes because of this "promote sexual conduct such as through pose balls (whether in "backrooms" or more visible spaces)" clause? Will they have to remove nude art (including artistic nude photographs, since these are certainly "photo-realistic"  ? How far does this "no sex poseballs in public" thing go? We will lose a *lot* of rental residents if they are forced to remove all things of a sexual nature from their homes. And before you suggest "Well then, just re-zone your sim Adult", I will explain to you why we do not want to do this: We do not consider ourselves an "Adult" sim. We do not want to be re-zoned "Adult", and then have to argue with visitors who come in about not sex-scening in the street or removing erect attachments. We do not want to be ARed because we banned them from our land after they would not comply, having them tell us "This is an Adult region and I can do that here!" Even if the AR was not enforced, it makes more work for us, and we do not have a huge management staff. We also do not want to attract the sorts of visitors an Adult rating *would* attract - not because of their interests/desires/behaviours - but because they will come in assuming we offer entertainments we do not actually allow. This will hurt our reputation in the manner of "false advertising". (EDIT: Resulting in further arguements, ARs, and general ill-will between visitors and management) Not to mention the severe downturn of traffic we will see since only the age verified will be able to enter. (And would also result in banning some of our rental residents from their land, as they are Europeans who are having difficulty verifying.) These new guidelines were obviously *not* meant to work with people who try hard to maintain a balance on their sims between sexual freedom and orgiastic licentiousness. You seem to have a assumed that if we allow any adult activity, then we are by definition an "Adult" sim, which is not always the case. Please clarify for me how these new rules will affect those of us who allow certain adult behaviours in a *controlled* and private manner. It seems as if these new rules, if implemented as I fear they will be, will end up punishing those of us who are trying to maintain a balance that will please almost everyone. Please correct me if I'm wrong.
|
Phoenix Welles
Multiple Avatar Disorder
Join date: 6 Jan 2007
Posts: 111
|
04-23-2009 10:49
From: samatha Congrejo Ok now at 250 and counting,
and survey says not one of those 250 Adult content providers has been contacted, consulted, or even talked to about these changes.
So exactly who of "those most effected by these changes" did they consult with??
Anyone reading these forums who has adult content and WAS actually consulted, please please speak up, I would love to know at least someone was consulted in the adult content field.
How about muti sim owners? Any one of you Consulted??
How about Major mainland land owners with adult content? Any of you consulted?? I think I might have been the token 'little' party at the landowners and for the second half of the definitions brownbags. But as the little guy I tried to aim my concerns for what those of us smaller players are facing.
|
Couldbe Yue
one unhappy customer
Join date: 30 Mar 2008
Posts: 1,532
|
04-23-2009 10:54
From: Angelia Rees
And before you suggest "Well then, just re-zone your sim Adult", I will explain to you why we do not want to do this: We do not consider ourselves an "Adult" sim. We do not want to be re-zoned "Adult", and then have to argue with visitors who come in about not sex-scening in the street or removing erect attachments. We do not want to be ARed because we banned them from our land after they would not comply, having them tell us "This is an Adult region and I can do that here!" Even if the AR was not enforced, it makes more work for us, and we do not have a huge management staff. We also do not want the sorts of visitors an Adult rating would attract - not because of their interests/desires/behaviours - but because they will come in assuming we offer entertainments we do not actually allow. This we hurt our reputation in the manner of "false advertising". Not to mention the severe downturn of traffic we will see since only the age verified will be able to enter. (And would also result in banning some of our rental residents from their land, as they are Europeans who are having difficulty verifying.)
These new guidelines were obviously *not* meant to work with people who try hard to maintain a balance on their sims between sexual freedom and orgiastic licentiousness. You seem to have a assumed that if we allow any adult activity, then we are by definition an "Adult" sim, which is not always the case. Please clarify for me how these new rules will affect those of us who allow certain adult behaviours in a *controlled* and private manner. It seems as if these new rules, if implemented as I fear they will be, will end up punishing those of us who are trying to maintain a balance that will please almost everyone.
here we are, someone who doesn't mind the flashing of the titties and the "kitties" thinks we're unwholesome and doesn't want to be associated with us. welcome to the new reality..
_____________________
Satiated Desires: Toys for Grown Ups. Inworld: http://slurl.com/secondlife/Norf%20Haven/186/132/55 XSL: https://www.xstreetsl.com/modules.php?name=Marketplace&MerchantID=77743&&sort=age&dir=asc Blog: http://satiateddesires.wordpress.com/
|
Argent Stonecutter
Emergency Mustelid
Join date: 20 Sep 2005
Posts: 20,263
|
04-23-2009 10:57
From: Angelia Rees I am the Estate Manager for a group of 4 non-mainland sims - on these sims, we allow *non-sexual* toplessness and nudity, for both women and men (including non-erect prim "bits" for men). How does this fall under the new guidelines - adult or mature?
Mature, according to Blondin: 
|
Angelia Rees
ROMA Estate Manager
Join date: 6 Oct 2006
Posts: 20
|
04-23-2009 10:59
From: Couldbe Yue here we are, someone who doesn't mind the flashing of the titties and the "kitties" thinks we're unwholesome and doesn't want to be associated with us.
welcome to the new reality.. I never said you were unwholesome. But we see our sim as a *business* catering to all types. We *can't* favour one group over another. That having been said - I think anyone ought to be able to f***, s***, and charge a buck (so to speak) til their heart's content. But I also believe that the whole neighbourhood doesn't have to see it.
|
Ceera Murakami
Texture Artist / Builder
Join date: 9 Sep 2005
Posts: 7,750
|
RE Brown-bag invitations
04-23-2009 11:00
I am a registered SL Service Provider. My largest business venture in SL is one that builds whole-sim and multi-sim projects for clients, ranging from prestigious Ivy League Universities on one extreme, to private multi-sim playgrounds with extensive XXX facilities on the other.
While I *did* get one e-mail inviting me to one of the Brown Bag sessions, the invitation came far too close to the start time of the session for me to schedule time off during my RL work day to attend. I didn't even see the e-mail until after the event was already over, since I don't monitor the SL Dev mailing list 24 x 7. I was *at work* when the e-mail came in, and had no chance to read the e-mail until I got off duty, well after the session had ended.
And even if I HAD attended, their insistance on using Voice meant I wouldn't have been able to hear a single word of their replies.
So technically I was invited. But they made sure I couldn't attend or benefit from attending!
_____________________
Sorry, LL won't let me tell you where I sell my textures and where I offer my services as a sim builder. Ask me in-world.
|
Blondin Linden
Linden Lab Employee
Join date: 2 Jun 2008
Posts: 381
|
04-23-2009 11:13
From: Darien Caldwell Blondin Linden: Please answer this question. Would a business on a private estate that sells BDSM gear but has no nudity, no sexually explicit content, no poseballs, is not an orgy room or a sex room, is just a store, be considered Mature or Adult?
Please give an answer. From your description above, the store would be Mature. What kind of language does this store use to advertise?
|
Couldbe Yue
one unhappy customer
Join date: 30 Mar 2008
Posts: 1,532
|
04-23-2009 11:13
From: Angelia Rees I never said you were unwholesome. But we see our sim as a *business* catering to all types. We *can't* favour one group over another.
That having been said - I think anyone ought to be able to f***, s***, and charge a buck (so to speak) til their heart's content. But I also believe that the whole neighbourhood doesn't have to see it. The way I read your post is that one of the reasons you don't want to be adult is that it will attract the wrong type of crowd. taking your comments at face value in that first quote, I assume you mean that by labelling adult you'll get all those who have sex on the brain and aren't capable of understanding what kind of sim it is and only want to fuck like rabbits where ever they can (amongst other things).
_____________________
Satiated Desires: Toys for Grown Ups. Inworld: http://slurl.com/secondlife/Norf%20Haven/186/132/55 XSL: https://www.xstreetsl.com/modules.php?name=Marketplace&MerchantID=77743&&sort=age&dir=asc Blog: http://satiateddesires.wordpress.com/
|
Blondin Linden
Linden Lab Employee
Join date: 2 Jun 2008
Posts: 381
|
04-23-2009 11:20
From: Ayla Holt Ok so...............
I'm mainland. I sell poseballs. What happens to my sex poseballs? Do I just delete them? Nothing will happen to your poseballs. From: Ayla Holt What about clothing I make that has sheer items that show the skin underneith? Those items are not Adult. From: Ayla Holt What about search keywords like "sex" ? Certain words will be filtered so that only verified account will be able to search for them. What kind of language does your store use to advertise? From: Ayla Holt What about cuddle balls or kissing balls? Do they have to be 1950's prom style where the pelvis of each avatar don't touch? Cuddle and Kiss poseballs are not considered adult.
|
Brieanne Bomazi
Don't forget the *E*
Join date: 29 Jan 2005
Posts: 383
|
04-23-2009 11:20
From: Couldbe Yue The way I read your post is that one of the reasons you don't want to be adult is that it will attract the wrong type of crowd.
taking your comments at face value in that first quote, I assume you mean that by labelling adult you'll get all those who have sex on the brain and aren't capable of understanding what kind of sim it is and only want to fuck like rabbits where ever they can (amongst other things). I saw the same thing....*smiles*...can only go by whats written.
|
Angelia Rees
ROMA Estate Manager
Join date: 6 Oct 2006
Posts: 20
|
04-23-2009 11:22
From: Couldbe Yue The way I read your post is that one of the reasons you don't want to be adult is that it will attract the wrong type of crowd.
taking your comments at face value in that first quote, I assume you mean that by labelling adult you'll get all those who have sex on the brain and aren't capable of understanding what kind of sim it is and only want to fuck like rabbits where ever they can (amongst other things). I amended my original post for clarity - I was really thinking about those that would show up and become angry because they were not getting what they expected to find. Often, that upsets people even more than not being able to do what they want. An Adult rating would *imply* they could engage in Adult activity anywhere on the sim, and that wouldn't be the case. Hence the "false advertising" I mentioned.
|
Blondin Linden
Linden Lab Employee
Join date: 2 Jun 2008
Posts: 381
|
04-23-2009 11:24
From: Marin Mielziner How would this issue affect live theatrical performances? For instance, in March 2008 a group of talented and dedicated SL writers and actors created and produced the highly successful stage production "In the Pink," to raise funds and awareness for V-Day, the global movement to end violence to women and girls. Our original production was a series of monologues and sketches written and performed by SL residents and the subject was sexuality of women. By certain standards the material could be defined as "adult" in nature with its frank discussion of sexuality, language, and violence towards women. But this was all in a effort to raise awareness. I do not feel that the material should be considered smut, but by applying the rubric description of the 3 proposed areas, our show would be banished to the "adult" continent to reside among some of the same content it was designed to combat. Although we also celebrated the sexuality of women, our awareness and fund raising goals would have been meaningless and we would have had difficulty reaching a broad audience.
Some might say we could go to a private sim. Indeed we could and "In the Pink" was hosted on Ivy Falls, a private sim. However if all artistic endeavors are sent to private sims then the cost of production goes up substantially, thus stifling many new works. Plus would we not have mark our content as "adult"?
I know it's a difficult subject. In RL we get it too. For instance Daddy Warbucks in "Annie" uses the word "damn" and Tinkerbell in "Peter Pan" calls Peter a "ass". Hardly shows that you'd warn the audience about "language". You'd rate it G, right? In both productions I was involved with, you should have heard the complaints. So I know it's hard to please everybody. But please consider the legitimate artistic community of writers, songwriters, and theatre and visual artists.
I am interested in speaking to someone further about this issue. Unless precisely defined, I can see that such censorship will severely hamper the artistic creativity that is now beginning to enfold in SL. There is truly groundbreaking work being created here. Please don't stifle it; I'm sure that working together to further define this issue is needed.
Marin Mielziner Artistic Director Act Up Theatre Company While 'In the Pink' may not be suitable for a PG region, there should be no problem with it, or any of your examples being on Mature land.
|
Thorn Witrial
Registered User
Join date: 28 Jun 2008
Posts: 237
|
04-23-2009 11:26
From: Angelia Rees I amended my original post for clarity - I was really thinking about those that would show up and become angry because they were not getting what they expected to find. Often, that upsets people even more than not being able to do what they want. An Adult rating would *imply* they could engage in Adult activity anywhere on the sim, and that wouldn't be the case. Hence the "false advertising" I mentioned. Okay that is more clear. And I get that. People think they can have something, and when they realize they can't, they get really angry. Gee...Just like people thinking that Mature meant just that and their land would have value and options that they paid for. Hmm...
|
Blondin Linden
Linden Lab Employee
Join date: 2 Jun 2008
Posts: 381
|
04-23-2009 11:27
From: Emilly Orr THANK YOU, this has been killing my brain through the whole process. When AO popped up as a handy contraction, I had that moment of "what do walking animations have to do with adult content?"
I still have to fight to hear "AO" and relate it to "adult content". I know. And this issue had been raised before. I do apologize for the confusion. I've been making a conscious effort not to call it AO.
|