Welcome to the Second Life Forums Archive

These forums are CLOSED. Please visit the new forums HERE

Ageplay

Nolan Nash
Frischer Frosch
Join date: 15 May 2003
Posts: 7,141
03-26-2006 20:58
From: Csven Concord
Got my vote. Only I want to run the Inquisition. It's a guy thing.

_____________________
“Time's fun when you're having flies.” ~Kermit
bella Ophelia
Registered User
Join date: 22 Mar 2006
Posts: 152
03-26-2006 21:17
From: Susie Boffin
I understand your concern but there is no evidence to suggest that child molestation is something one learns from the internet. It is a disorder developed at an early age and engaging in child play in second life has nothing to do with it. A person just doesn't engage in child play in second life and all of a sudden decide to be a child molester in first life.



I love how there is NO EVIDENCE to suggest child molestation is blah blah blah... yet you are so sure Second Life has nothing to do with it... where is that evidence?
Starax Statosky
Unregistered User
Join date: 23 Dec 2003
Posts: 1,099
03-26-2006 21:20
From: Nolan Nash


Q is creepy! He wants to molest Picard's head like it's a young boy.


Hey, ever wondered who would win in a fight between Picard and Kirk? My money is on Kirk! I reckon he'd crack Picard's egglike head open with a rock.
Allana Dion
Registered User
Join date: 12 Jul 2005
Posts: 1,230
03-26-2006 21:20
From: bella Ophelia
before seeking help, I would have ignored the problem and maybe even defended a person's right to be a pretend child rapist like some of these people are...

after years of dealing with it, I know that children being victimized is not a game and not a free speech issue.

btw, it is so clear to see men parading as women in these posts because any real woman wouldn't attack another woman for being concerned about children... and no real woman would trivialize sexual abuse in any way shape or form unless she was unusually anti-female.



Well you do seem hell bent on believing that everyone who challenges your position is personally attacking you.... unfortunately it detracts from the real subject and makes others not want to hear what you have to say.

For the record, child abuse in any form is sick and wrong and all actual abusers should spend eternity in hell and most likely will.

That said, I'm gathering that your position is that ANY roleplaying as child avatars should be eliminated in SL to prevent some of them from indulging in sexual activity. (please correct me if i'm wrong here)

I have several problems with that kind of censorship. First of all, I've seen child avs all over the place and frankly the sexual activity you are describing I simply haven't witnessed. I haven't even met a child av with a sexually provacative profile, I've never even seen one being hit on. I'm sure there are the occasional instances of this but I'm also sure they are few and far between in relation to how many child avs are out there. What prohibiting them from their roleplay would do would be simply punishing the innocent to avoid the possibility that a few of them may be guilty.\

Secondly that kind of censorship can lead us down a very ugly road. Next we'll ban any and all BDSM activity because SOME Masters/Mistresses may possibly abuse some slaves. Then we'll have to ban all furry avatars because some of them may indulge in beastiality roleplay and thats illegal in most places. Then of course .... well robot sex eewwwww! Think of all the oil spills.

Bottom line, while there are plenty of things out there that make the majority of the people shudder and run away to more pleasant scenes ... It simply isn't ok to punish the innocent as a way to prevent the possibility of guilt. And unless an activity is blatantly illegal and or directly harming another it is not ok to force others to conform to one person or one group's idea of right and wrong.

I would worry, I would worry very much, about the mental health and potential RL threat of someone who looks at a child av and thinks of sexual fantasies or the person who dresses in a child av and lives them out.... however I honestly do not believe that applies to 99% of the people running around SL wearing jammies and carrying teddybears. I truly believe most of them manage to get through a day in SL without ever finding themselves in a sexual situation. How? Because they avoid them. Simple. Don't want to see it? Don't go looking for it.
bella Ophelia
Registered User
Join date: 22 Mar 2006
Posts: 152
03-26-2006 21:20
From: Elspeth Withnail
Your multiple, explicit, and egregious postings about your own abuse did more to trivialize child molestation than anything I've seen posted in response to you. Not because it shouldn't be talked about, not because it shouldn't be prevented, but for one simple reason: You used your own claimed history of abuse, presented in a graphic manner, to 'shout down' people who disagreed with you. You played the 'It happened to me, you can't possibly know better than me!' card, and fell flat on your face.

As far as men parading as women, and your ability to detect real women based upon whether or not they agree with you... frankly, bella, I'm not sure you'rea woman, or a survivor of child sexual abuse, or a psychologist. I am certain that you really like stirring up a hornet's nest, though. Have fun.



I understand your concern sir. And I'm sorry if reality is so painful to read that you feel a need to attack the victim to justify your position and ease your discomfort.
Ravenelle Zugzwang
zugzugz.com
Join date: 23 Jul 2004
Posts: 267
03-26-2006 21:22
Kim Anubis
The Magician
Join date: 3 Jun 2004
Posts: 921
03-26-2006 21:24
_____________________
http://www.TheMagicians.us
Susie Boffin
Certified Nutcase
Join date: 15 Sep 2004
Posts: 2,151
03-26-2006 21:24
From: bella Ophelia
I love how there is NO EVIDENCE to suggest child molestation is blah blah blah... yet you are so sure Second Life has nothing to do with it... where is that evidence?


Yes I am sure. Show me your evidence that second life causes child abuse please.

As my father used to say "poop or get off the pot."

I am not the one who started this thread. All I am doing is trying to add some logic to it.
_____________________
"If you see a man approaching you with the obvious intent of doing you good, you should run for your life." - Henry David Thoreau
Kendra Bancroft
Rhine Maiden
Join date: 17 Jun 2004
Posts: 5,813
03-26-2006 21:24
From: Vivianne Draper
I disagree with Kendra as well when she said we should be more tolerant. No, we should never be tolerant with witch hunts. Not if the witches are age play roleplayers and not if they are witches and not if they are any thing which said hunter happens to have an issue with at the moment.



I never said be tolerant of the witch hunt. If you read my posts you'ld see what I have to say about witch hunts. I said be more respectful of bella's pain and try not to deliberately antagonize a woman who is obviously exeriencing a re-trauma of a painful event in her life.

My own personal feelings on this fall along the lines of pixel bumping isn't real and I could care less if an AV wants to shape themselves as a child or a sea turtle for that matter.
_____________________
Zepp Zaftig
Unregistered Abuser
Join date: 20 Mar 2005
Posts: 470
03-26-2006 21:26
Help protect the children in SL. Now available, Child Protection Kit - Security Plus, just attach to your avatar for instant protection. Only 1000 L$.

_____________________
:cool: :p ;) :D
Ravenelle Zugzwang
zugzugz.com
Join date: 23 Jul 2004
Posts: 267
03-26-2006 21:26
From: Kim Anubis


Thank you.
Elspeth Withnail
Completely Trustworthy
Join date: 24 Jan 2005
Posts: 317
03-26-2006 21:26
From: bella Ophelia
I understand your concern sir. And I'm sorry if reality is so painful to read that you feel a need to attack the victim to justify your position and ease your discomfort.


'I'm right because I was abused' doesn't work on me, bella. That club you say you belong to isn't an exclusive one, and some people don't let bad things that happened to them warp their perception of reality. Get help.
Elspeth Withnail
Completely Trustworthy
Join date: 24 Jan 2005
Posts: 317
03-26-2006 21:28
From: Ravenelle Zugzwang


Best. Post. Ever.
Allana Dion
Registered User
Join date: 12 Jul 2005
Posts: 1,230
03-26-2006 21:28
From: bella Ophelia
before seeking help, I would have ignored the problem and maybe even defended a person's right to be a pretend child rapist like some of these people are...

after years of dealing with it, I know that children being victimized is not a game and not a free speech issue.

btw, it is so clear to see men parading as women in these posts because any real woman wouldn't attack another woman for being concerned about children... and no real woman would trivialize sexual abuse in any way shape or form unless she was unusually anti-female.



Not even going to justify that last paragraph as it's clearly an emotional response and simply used to try to shout people down.

Listen once and for all bella, the majority of people here have NOT attacked you personally (with the exception of a few who may have been a tad insensitive) they are merely challenging your position and you don't like it.

EDIT: You know what, scratch that, I will respond as it does apply in my mind to the topic. I am a woman, yes a real woman, and a mother. I have made it my mission (along with help from i'm sure several guardian angels) to protect my children from the evil that is out there. My daughter is 14 yrs old and has never once been online without me sitting right next to her. I am aware of who her friends are, where she goes, what she does and what she is exposed to. This does not always make me the most popular parent but it has made my child safe so far. (knock on wood and pray to more angels)

Real child abuse is an issue we as a society should NEVER stop talking about and should NEVER stop fighting to put an end to. However, what happens in SL between child avs is not child abuse. It is roleplay between consenting adults and while it might make us want to hurl at the thought, no crime is being committed and no one is being victimized. Thats the bottom line. Its bothersome and it's icky and we dont like it.... but it is not the real problem. The real problem is the real life crime, the real life victim and that is where we as parents and as a society should be focusing.
Torley Linden
Enlightenment!
Join date: 15 Sep 2004
Posts: 16,530
03-26-2006 21:29
From: Ravenelle Zugzwang
Who is the person we call on for cow bell?


Christopher Walken and/or me, who is a self-professed fan of C. Walken, as well as analogue-modelled cowbell. I am also a fan of John De Lancie, but my continued waxing poetic of his portrayal of omnipotence would be off-topic. ;)

Speaking of, unfortunately, this thread is experiencing derailment. Please keep the discussion on-topic.
_____________________
Nolan Nash
Frischer Frosch
Join date: 15 May 2003
Posts: 7,141
03-26-2006 21:29
From: Starax Statosky
Q is creepy! He wants to molest Picard's head like it's a young boy.
Bwahaha!


From: Starax Statosky
Hey, ever wondered who would win in a fight between Picard and Kirk? My money is on Kirk! I reckon he'd crack Picard's egglike head open with a rock.

I don't know. It's a brains versus brawns thing. Maybe if Kirk had that green alien chick around to distract Picard for a second, so he could place a giant nutcracker about his considerable dome, and crush it like a brazil nut, but I'm thinking Uhuru is really a man and that she is playing a female character in SL who is participating in this thread. Makes sense ne?
_____________________
“Time's fun when you're having flies.” ~Kermit
bella Ophelia
Registered User
Join date: 22 Mar 2006
Posts: 152
03-26-2006 21:32
From: Allana Dion
Well you do seem hell bent on believing that everyone who challenges your position is personally attacking you.... unfortunately it detracts from the real subject and makes others not want to hear what you have to say.


Yes, "kill the messenger," it's tried and true.

From: Allana Dion


For the record, child abuse in any form is sick and wrong and all actual abusers should spend eternity in hell and most likely will.


begin innaccurate assumptions as way of qualifying earlier PC statement.

From: Allana Dion


That said, I'm gathering that your position is that ANY roleplaying as child avatars should be eliminated in SL to prevent some of them from indulging in sexual activity. (please correct me if i'm wrong here)



Let's see... I've only said it several times before but all I suggested was an official police by the Lindens that child avatars not be used as sexual objects or for sexual means.

But what you said demonizes me better so go ahead and promote that that is what I suggested.

From: Allana Dion


I have several problems with that kind of censorship. First of all, I've seen child avs all over the place and frankly the sexual activity you are describing I simply haven't witnessed. I haven't even met a child av with a sexually provacative profile, I've never even seen one being hit on. I'm sure there are the occasional instances of this but I'm also sure they are few and far between in relation to how many child avs are out there. What prohibiting them from their roleplay would do would be simply punishing the innocent to avoid the possibility that a few of them may be guilty.\



Yes, well, I've been in SL for 2 weeks and walked up on it because I wanted to dance and meet people. But I'm sure you are somehow living a more valid life so your experience should be considered and mine ignored.

From: Allana Dion



Secondly that kind of censorship can lead us down a very ugly road. Next we'll ban any and all BDSM activity because SOME Masters/Mistresses may possibly abuse some slaves. Then we'll have to ban all furry avatars because some of them may indulge in beastiality roleplay and thats illegal in most places. Then of course .... well robot sex eewwwww! Think of all the oil spills.

Bottom line, while there are plenty of things out there that make the majority of the people shudder and run away to more pleasant scenes ... It simply isn't ok to punish the innocent as a way to prevent the possibility of guilt. And unless an activity is blatantly illegal and or directly harming another it is not ok to force others to conform to one person or one group's idea of right and wrong.

I would worry, I would worry very much, about the mental health and potential RL threat of someone who looks at a child av and thinks of sexual fantasies or the person who dresses in a child av and lives them out.... however I honestly do not believe that applies to 99% of the people running around SL wearing jammies and carrying teddybears. I truly believe most of them manage to get through a day in SL without ever finding themselves in a sexual situation. How? Because they avoid them. Simple. Don't want to see it? Don't go looking for it.


Beautifully put. If you don't want to see crime, hide. 99% are normal, only 1% are going to rape your child tomorrow, don't worry...

worry after your child is raped and his/her life is changed forever. 99% okay... let's see... that is 1 person in 100... how many people do I think a child meets in the course of being a child... okay, well, maybe if they cross their fingers they won't come upon one of these unusual specimens.
Starax Statosky
Unregistered User
Join date: 23 Dec 2003
Posts: 1,099
03-26-2006 21:32
Cowbell from a fly's point of view. Doesn't it make you wish that you was a fly too? :(

Elspeth Withnail
Completely Trustworthy
Join date: 24 Jan 2005
Posts: 317
03-26-2006 21:33
From: Nolan Nash
Bwahaha!



I don't know. It's a brains versus brawns thing. Maybe if Kirk had that green alien chick around to distract Picard for a second, so he could place a giant nutcracker about his considerable dome, and crush it like a brazil nut, but I'm thinking Uhuru is really a man and that she is playing a female character in SL who is participating in this thread. Makes sense ne?


... does this mean bella thinks I'm Nichelle Nichols? I'm really more of a Janice Rand.
Starax Statosky
Unregistered User
Join date: 23 Dec 2003
Posts: 1,099
03-26-2006 21:33
Starax Statosky
Unregistered User
Join date: 23 Dec 2003
Posts: 1,099
03-26-2006 21:35


.
Elspeth Withnail
Completely Trustworthy
Join date: 24 Jan 2005
Posts: 317
03-26-2006 21:35
From: Starax Statosky
Cowbell from a fly's point of view. Doesn't it make you wish that you was a fly too? :(



Flies see multiple images, but not in much detail... so there'd be lots of cowbell, but far blurrier cowbell. I prefer quality over quantity, in my cowbell.
Starax Statosky
Unregistered User
Join date: 23 Dec 2003
Posts: 1,099
03-26-2006 21:36

,
Ravenelle Zugzwang
zugzugz.com
Join date: 23 Jul 2004
Posts: 267
03-26-2006 21:36
From: Starax Statosky


:eek: I don't want to be a fly, I think that might make me dizzy.
Kiari LeFay
Lemon Flavored Fish Treat
Join date: 27 Jan 2003
Posts: 223
03-26-2006 21:36
From: someone
btw, it is so clear to see men parading as women in these posts because any real woman wouldn't attack another woman for being concerned about children... and no real woman would trivialize sexual abuse in any way shape or form unless she was unusually anti-female.


It's so clear to me that this is really a way for you to project your issues onto other people.

Next thing you know, you'll be telling us that it's better to be molested than to be spanked by a parent.
1 ... 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11