Upcoming Changes for Adult Content: Main Forum Thread
|
Argent Stonecutter
Emergency Mustelid
Join date: 20 Sep 2005
Posts: 20,263
|
03-20-2009 14:11
From: Da5id Weatherwax Option 1: Sims flagged higher than your current view level simply appear offline to you. You cant cam in or enter them. Those sims show on the map but are redflagged with no info about their contents visible.
That's the option I was referring to. The obvious fix is: Option 3: SERVER only sends terrain and linden plants for sims with a higher rating level, viewer displays "Mature Mature Mature" or "Adult Adult Adult" warning lines when you get close to the boundary. No need to add stupid easily-hackable client side restrictions.
|
Ian Undercroft
Registered User
Join date: 3 Nov 2007
Posts: 86
|
03-20-2009 14:14
From: Argent Stonecutter That's the option I was referring to.
The obvious fix is:
Option 3: server only sends terrain and linden plants for sims with a higher rating level, viewer displays "Mature Mature Mature" or "Adult Adult Adult" warning lines when you get close to the boundary. No need to add stupid easily-hackable client side restrictions. Surely the whole adult SIM has to appear offline to those with a PG viewer. Invariably it is the actions of avies on a SIM that will be explicit. Does it make any difference that they appear to exchaging pixels whilst floating in mid air rather than lying on a couch?
|
Rene Erlanger
Scuderia Shapes & Skins G
Join date: 28 Sep 2006
Posts: 2,008
|
03-20-2009 14:21
From: Neptune Shelman Because they already said adult related items such as furniture will be able to remain in the mature areas, skins would be able to remain in the mature areas. So the choice is left get adult varified and go get yourself an escort, visit a porn video rental site or free sex club if you wish otherwise stay in the mature mainland and get a sex bed and nip home with your latest squeeze. Dildos,penises,basically anything that Xcite sells,porno movie streams,ball chains,sexual orientated pictures & paintings,sex toys, ball & chain gags etc etc. I'm not talking about furniture or skins....I do read the thread comphrensively you know!
|
Da5id Weatherwax
Registered User
Join date: 17 Dec 2007
Posts: 90
|
03-20-2009 14:22
From: Argent Stonecutter That's the option I was referring to.
The obvious fix is:
Option 3: SERVER only sends terrain and linden plants for sims with a higher rating level, viewer displays "Mature Mature Mature" or "Adult Adult Adult" warning lines when you get close to the boundary. No need to add stupid easily-hackable client side restrictions. The ONLY advantage of doing it viewer-side and authenticating the official viewer builds as I described is that by using a 3rd party viewer (or even altering the channel reported by the official one) folks who cant/wont verify can accept that they proceed at their own risk, thus covering LLs rear from any legal exposure and can continue to access whatever they want. Of course in the process they would give up the right to AR anything they saw for obscenity too because they chose to be exposed to it. Server-side-only restrictions would still expose businesses and mixed-use locations to the same "what about the ones that wont verify?" issues that have been raised repeatedly here. The combined solution is the only one I've been able to come up with that seems to give both LL and the vast majority of residents what they want.
|
Argent Stonecutter
Emergency Mustelid
Join date: 20 Sep 2005
Posts: 20,263
|
03-20-2009 14:25
From: Ian Undercroft Surely the whole adult SIM has to appear offline to those with a PG viewer. Invariably it is the actions of avies on a SIM that will be explicit. Does it make any difference that they appear to exchaging pixels whilst floating in mid air rather than lying on a couch? If the server only sends terrain and linden plants for sims with a higher rating level you won't see any avatars in them, will you?
|
Ian Undercroft
Registered User
Join date: 3 Nov 2007
Posts: 86
|
03-20-2009 14:29
I get you now. You mean seeing open land rather than linden ocean?
|
Argent Stonecutter
Emergency Mustelid
Join date: 20 Sep 2005
Posts: 20,263
|
03-20-2009 14:29
From: Da5id Weatherwax Server-side-only restrictions would still expose businesses and mixed-use locations to the same "what about the ones that wont verify?" Huh? How are they at less liability if there's an easier way for people who won't verify to bypass the restrictions? It will make them MORE liable because they are less able to argue that people shouldn't have access don't have access.
|
Phoenix Welles
Multiple Avatar Disorder
Join date: 6 Jan 2007
Posts: 111
|
03-20-2009 14:30
From: Shockwave Yareach At the same point all the demons and vampires do. Shall we all start singing the Necrophilia Shuffle in the key of D? rofl I'm in a weird mindset, that leads to odd questions lol. if I recall we're s'posed to helping with definitions in this thread as well. But I'm fairly liberal, so I don't know at what point other people get offended by toon furries and toon humans being seen together. and that could affect large communities of players if the bar is set low. I agree that the nekos, furries, dragons, vampires, lycans, demons, faeries, etc (the list really goes on and on), are not offensive, and I'd hate to see them treated different because they choose to play an avatar who is not human. Heck, I hang out with a good number of different SL 'Species' and I consider my SL experience all the better for it. But if we're dealing with any puritanical mindsets in the definitions of what is mature and adult then we really need to think very carefully to make sure that these groups, just as with the other groups that are worried, won't be singled out and have tighter restrictions. That was my point. I have a neko alt I play sometimes when I don't want to deal with tons of group chatter or just not want to be showing as online for my businesses. And I'll cuddle with human av friends. I've had people irl look over my shoulder, see the ears and tail and tell me that my av should be somewhere other than public, even though she is fully clothed and not doing anything explicit. That is the point I'm trying to make, if we're dealing with people's sensitivities, how do we not discriminate? To one person it's innocent, to another that particular act of cuddling a friend is extreme because of ears and a tail.
|
Da5id Weatherwax
Registered User
Join date: 17 Dec 2007
Posts: 90
|
03-20-2009 14:38
From: Argent Stonecutter Huh? How are they at less liability if there's an easier way for people who won't verify to bypass the restrictions? It will make them MORE liable because they are less able to argue that people shouldn't have access don't have access. Because as part of the login process if the server cannot authenticate the viewer as an official build that honors the restriction, the user has to agree to continue at their own risk and acknowledge that they might be exposed to content they find objectionable. In fact, to make the inconvenience of having to agree to this every time go away, you might even see the folks who are on the fence about verifying do so in greater numbers. Click-through for acknowledging you know what you are getting info and saying that yes, you are of age to see anything you want in your jurisdiction covers most other online businesses, theres no reason for LL to worry any more than they do.
|
Lynni Aeon
Registered User
Join date: 4 Dec 2007
Posts: 25
|
Underage "Verified" Possible
03-20-2009 14:39
From: Blondin Linden
Payment info will be valid even if the credit card has expired after the account has been verified. The adult flag won't be removed unless there is a reason to suspect/believe that a verified account may be underage.
I thought the point of verification was to assure that there would be no underage lurkers! Thus, no need to suspect! Very disturbing
|
Ian Undercroft
Registered User
Join date: 3 Nov 2007
Posts: 86
|
03-20-2009 14:46
Awww, come on now, Lynni, play fair. You must suspend your disbelief for the purpose of participating in this forum. Otherwise, no point you raise will receive an answer.
|
Lord Sullivan
DTC at all times :)
Join date: 15 Dec 2005
Posts: 2,870
|
Adult changes in the Press
03-20-2009 14:48
Have a read on a post in RA makes interesting reading /327/d5/312818/1.html
_____________________
Independent Shopping for Second Life residents from established and new merchants. http://slapt.me  slapt.me - In-World HQ http://slurl.com/secondlife/Bastet/123/118/26
|
Rene Erlanger
Scuderia Shapes & Skins G
Join date: 28 Sep 2006
Posts: 2,008
|
03-20-2009 14:53
From: Lord Sullivan Many of us said when they removed the need to verify and make freebie accounts that this would come back and bite LL in the arse and it looks like thats happening now eh? Yes we are lucky to have SL as a platform for our members of our RL business and i agree many don't have the luxury of being VAT registered and able to write of SL expenses as advertising costs. But i have also stated several times that i respect the views and opinions of others here during this discussion, i just get fed up with all the whining and whinging and the fact that so many don't even bother to read past posts before they post. But i am direct and will never beat about the bush But i have to agree that yes some will fight on principle or belief, dam i spent 2 years in the Middle East where people were doing just that, but here LL has the final say in all matters and some just forget that it seems. Peace For the record i was "Payment on file" practically from the 1st day when i joined back in Sept 06. I think i bought my 1st piece of land after day 10. I also had to age verify as LL sent me an email last year for being an Estateowner...so was kind of forced to go through that process too. So aside to asking 7 vendors (adult content displayed) to leave my Fetish Mall.....this whole process doesn't really effect me the person too much.....possibly it could have an impact on all my non-Adult related businesses, but let's discount them for now! Like i thought the bait & switch tactics of the Open Space sim tier hikes was so wrong...again i was not directly effected.....i feel these latest LL proposals are so wrong too. I'm not arguing as someone being hugely effected.....i'm arguing on "principles" sake. At the end of the day its not about "how this effects me".....its how it effects of the SL community as a whole and every aspect related to "your world, Your imagination" philosophy.
|
Neptune Shelman
Registered User
Join date: 1 Aug 2008
Posts: 329
|
03-20-2009 14:56
From: Ian Undercroft I think you place too much faith in this suggested "private home" exception, Neptune. The justification for such an exception bears no close scrutiny.
Sex furniture is inanimate and by and large inoffensive until an avie jumps on it to use it. It is the act of use that offends and little else. No reasonable person could objectively suggest that the balls that appear when you choose the "Hardcore XXX" option on your sex bed do not result in the playing out of an explicit sexual act. I think a group of 70 year old ladies camming around whilst sitting in a coffee shop chatting and catching sight of you and your sl partner exchanging pixels on your home sex bed on one side of that shop and catching sight of naked women pole dancing in an empty sex club on the other side would be astonished to discover that your behaviour was acceptable whereas that of the pole dancers was not.
As for the 2-4% figure that has been quoted by LL. That I suspect is proportion which the prims directly related to sex bear to prims as whole. Sure remove them and you can stay put because without them there will in most cases be no sexual act. LL need to confirm their stance on adult and mature where the line lays, my personal opinion is someone cams into my sl home then their have entered a private place where they have no business to be so if they get a shock then tough titty. I would expect them to be in trouble for invading my privacy not to be in trouble for my actions on a parcel I pay tier for. To remove scripted beds, nakedness in the form of avatar skins from the current mature mainland by forcing sellers of such items to the adult rated areas would be extreme lunacy, LL must already realise that almost all users who have a building like a house in second life use these items, why did they implement voice chat if they don't like the idea of people getting it on together? It doesn't seem to have any other real use. Till LL state what is acceptable on a mature sim precisely, all our ideas are just hearsay, but I really think they are talking of toning down explicit texture content and removing the few public sex clubs to the new adult area, not 80% of the mature mainland, if thats really their idea then obviously they will need to rethink as they have made a huge error in judgement.
|
Argent Stonecutter
Emergency Mustelid
Join date: 20 Sep 2005
Posts: 20,263
|
03-20-2009 15:03
From: Da5id Weatherwax Because as part of the login process if the server cannot authenticate the viewer as an official build that honors the restriction, Which is why having it in the viewer is pointless. The server can NEVER authenticate the viewer so long as its open source. From: someone the user has to agree to continue at their own risk and acknowledge that they might be exposed to content they find objectionable. Who cares about the user? This isn't about the user. If it was about the user there wouldn't be any point to adult verification, you could just have the viewer pop a "yes I agree to see porn" dialog.
|
Dawn Pienaar
Registered User
Join date: 3 Sep 2007
Posts: 3
|
A Nother Mastake By Linden
03-20-2009 15:04
Well Land owners and business men, iam Tired of paying for a service that is suppose to be a free and open world. Then Constantly having a company messing this up. I dont feel these up changes are a good thing. I firmly believe linden is going to put them self's out of business if they carry on in this manner. I hope to see you all on opensim in the near future enough of linden and there games.
|
Neptune Shelman
Registered User
Join date: 1 Aug 2008
Posts: 329
|
03-20-2009 15:13
It sure does, maybe a change in direction will be announced.
|
Da5id Weatherwax
Registered User
Join date: 17 Dec 2007
Posts: 90
|
03-20-2009 15:13
From: Argent Stonecutter Which is why having it in the viewer is pointless. The server can NEVER authenticate the viewer so long as its open source. Sure it can - the authentication info just needs to be supplied from a source not in the source at build time. put a -DBUILDAUTH=key in at build time and suitable ifdefs to incorporate the key. Anyone else can build the code and it will work but unless they have the LL build-specific key they cant make it lie about whether it honors the restrictions or not.
|
Rene Erlanger
Scuderia Shapes & Skins G
Join date: 28 Sep 2006
Posts: 2,008
|
03-20-2009 15:21
From: Neptune Shelman It's crazy to believe LL are dependent on the adult sex business to remain a profitable business. If most of the adult content providers get up and walk away from SL, do you really think new ones will not happily jump into the new adult areas? I understand its not good for your business, or any of those businesses being asked to move or change textures to be less explicit ect. LL will do what they want to, it doesn't make it fair but thats life, or even 2nd life. The short term will mean upheaval, acompanied by loss in profits but in the long term things will even out. You don't get it!!! read my first reply and what i wrote. I'll try saying it simpler form ---->A major source of LL income are the collection of land tiers from ALL its residents From: Rene Erlanger ...... Apart from the inital venture capital to kick start SL, how do you think LL managed growth to a point that it has or owns servers to house 25-30k worth of sims? Where do you think the funds came from? What do you think supports 300+ employees drawing a salary each and every month? Comphrendi?
|
Lord Sullivan
DTC at all times :)
Join date: 15 Dec 2005
Posts: 2,870
|
03-20-2009 15:21
From: Rene Erlanger For the record i was "Payment on file" practically from the 1st day when i joined back in Sept 06. I think i bought my 1st piece of land after day 10. I also had to age verify as LL sent me an email last year for being an Estateowner...so was kind of forced to go through that process too. So aside to asking 7 vendors (adult content displayed) to leave my Fetish Mall.....this whole process doesn't really effect me the person too much.....possibly it could have an impact on all my non-Adult related businesses, but let's discount them for now! Like i thought the bait & switch tactics of the Open Space sim tier hikes was so wrong...again i was not directly effected.....i feel these latest LL proposals are so wrong too. I'm not arguing as someone being hugely effected.....i'm arguing on "principles" sake. At the end of the day its not about "how this effects me".....its how it effects of the SL community as a whole and every aspect related to "your world, Your imagination" philosophy. Yes this will affect the community as a whole but as always within SL in 12 months time we will remember the great Adult Content upheaval in the same way we will, the OS debate, the ending of gambling, the end of banking and the end of dwell payments they will fade into the archives of SL history as new folks will read about them and wonder what the fuss was all about. I wonder how many shouting now even remember the dwell payments? as it will be in time to come with this move we are facing as the new blood comes in and a lot of the current players move on to other things and the adult content has settled back into a routine and people recovered from their short term losses and its business as usual until the next bombshell. Just my thourghts 
_____________________
Independent Shopping for Second Life residents from established and new merchants. http://slapt.me  slapt.me - In-World HQ http://slurl.com/secondlife/Bastet/123/118/26
|
Kryket Gothly
Registered User
Join date: 8 Oct 2008
Posts: 1
|
03-20-2009 15:23
They are just going way too far over bored with this... if you dont like that sort of stuff they should give you a filter so you auto block going to those zones.. something you set YOURSELF... or that it atleast prompts you letting you know your going there and the option to cancel your teleport. Most of us are adults and should be able to monitor ourselves. if you find adult content bothersome then instead of making it all but unavailable to people or a hassle to be able to view for those that WANT to see it, I would suggest making it a filter. Maybe one thats automaticly on that you have to disable to go to those places. but otherwise leave it to US to make the choice on what we view or see or participate in. This is a game after all and if you dont like something you can always walk away/leave/turn it off.
|
Lord Sullivan
DTC at all times :)
Join date: 15 Dec 2005
Posts: 2,870
|
03-20-2009 15:24
From: Neptune Shelman It sure does, maybe a change in direction will be announced. Well that would be good news for a start as the wife wont have to rebuild everything lol
_____________________
Independent Shopping for Second Life residents from established and new merchants. http://slapt.me  slapt.me - In-World HQ http://slurl.com/secondlife/Bastet/123/118/26
|
Linda Lunt
Registered User
Join date: 17 Dec 2006
Posts: 1
|
I’m for keeping the kids out of harms way
03-20-2009 15:25
Okay. So all "adult" content will be shoved into one continent. Great. I’m for keeping the kids out of harms way. The name of my Store is “Sacred Yoni Jeweler Mall.” I sell intimate prim body wear and have been in the same location, on a mature sim, marked as adult content for an extra 30L$ a week, for over 1 year. That means that over one year of advertisement and landmarks given out will be at a loss when I’m forced to move. I would also like to know who is going to foot the bill for the cost associated to my move? I’m almost certain in order for me to maintain my SL business I will be assigned an unwanted task of selling my 1/2 sim of mainland along with the task of finding & purchasing the same in the "adult continent". Will my tier fees be affected during this transition? My mall vendors will have to find another place to sell there wears and I’ll have to close about 100 rental & commission locations selling my creations that are currently all earring everyone a profit through either through rents received or commissions paid. I help the SL economy by moving L$ around. I also help put this L$ in the Lindens pocket when I sell it for $, tier fees and other Linden costs. Who is going to rebuild what took me months to make? Who is going to take the loss of sales revenue here during this transition? Since SL is majority adult content would it not make more since to move non adult to a non adult continent? You know like the Teen grid?
|
Grey Wasser
Registered User
Join date: 30 Apr 2008
Posts: 4
|
For example ...
03-20-2009 15:34
My land is not one of the standard rectangular sizes. It is divided by a Linden road and a region boundary. In one region it meanders from one corner to the diagonally opposite corner. I use and like these features. How does Linden Lab propose to relocate me?
Most of my build (even sections that were once linked and prefab) are single objects, even single prims. Although there may be no charge to relocate, it would still require considerable time and effort to un-build and re-build. Do you have a way to replicate constructs through your software?
|
Katheryne Helendale
(loading...)
Join date: 5 Jun 2008
Posts: 2,187
|
03-20-2009 15:46
From: Brenda Connolly The only boobs we allow to be seen all the time are in Washington, DC. Damn! I really MUST learn not to try to eat or drink while reading these forums! 
|