Feedback on Ad Farm post
|
Kara Spengler
Pink Cat
Join date: 11 Jun 2007
Posts: 1,227
|
09-06-2008 07:56
From: Drongle McMahon There have been a few suggestions that licensed advertising should be located on existing protected road land. My neighbours, and to some extent myself, have expended a great deal of effort and money to recover the roadside from the cutters and to keep it from them thereafter. I am sure this is true for thousands of other (groups of) residents. Placing advertisements in the road despite these efforts would be a grave disservice to all of them. I plead most vehemently against this suggestion. Same here. My big lot (which a needlessly laggy ad forced me to sell) was across the road from an ad farm in a sim corner. Now I live on the remnants of that farm and am spending a lot of resources to clean it up.
|
Yumi Murakami
DoIt!AttachTheEarOfACat!
Join date: 27 Sep 2005
Posts: 6,860
|
09-06-2008 07:58
From: Talarus Luan What are you talking about? Instead of buying an area of land, you buy a certain number of prims. You can choose freely the arrangement of the land on which they fit (prims correspond to server resources, but land size doesn't - it's just a coordinate range - so this is perfectly possible). Then, you choose your neighbours by specifying links to their parcels - just like you would with a normal website. The client can connect to the appropriate region servers to render the "chain" of linked parcels next to each other.
|
Kara Spengler
Pink Cat
Join date: 11 Jun 2007
Posts: 1,227
|
09-06-2008 08:06
From: Dora Gustafson One bare 16m2 parcel is on sale for 999999L$, is that extortion? Yes! From: someone One bare 16m2 parcel next to it is not on sale, is that extortion?
Again yes, you need to grovel to whoever owns the bare parcel and they will probably say the parcel is vital to them and put a high price on it (in actuallity it is part of the scam to sell the other parcel). From: someone I stand up for the right parcel owners on the mainland have: to set their land for sale at any price; NOBODY can force ANYBODY to buy Shall we play the "whose alt is this" game? First guesses anyone? Remember to not use actual names somehow.
|
Toy LaFollette
I eat paintchips
Join date: 11 Feb 2004
Posts: 2,359
|
09-06-2008 08:13
From: Yumi Murakami Instead of buying an area of land, you buy a certain number of prims. You can choose freely the arrangement of the land on which they fit (prims correspond to server resources, but land size doesn't - it's just a coordinate range - so this is perfectly possible). Then, you choose your neighbours by specifying links to their parcels - just like you would with a normal website. The client can connect to the appropriate region servers to render the "chain" of linked parcels next to each other. This basically sounds pre version 1.2 when they changed from that because of prim hording, there was also a huge revolt about it I believe in 2003
_____________________
"So you see, my loyalty lies with Second Life, not with Linden Lab. Where I perceive the actions of Linden Lab to be in conflict with the best interests of Second Life, I side with Second Life."-Jacek
|
Kara Spengler
Pink Cat
Join date: 11 Jun 2007
Posts: 1,227
|
09-06-2008 08:14
From: Joannah Benelli Just build a region called "Advertising Island", give access only to ad farmers and build a huge banline around it. So those guys can play their game and leave use ordinary people alone. Oh, you can forego the banline. Then the advertisers can see how many people go out of their way to see the ads. 
|
Teresa Graziadei
Registered User
Join date: 8 Jul 2006
Posts: 2
|
09-06-2008 08:47
Wow, this is really great, at last some real action to salvage the mainland! Congratulations!
And 32 pages of posts, I can't read all that so I don't know how much talk there has been about zoning. But it seems to me this is the complicated part, and it seems to me that having two categories, "residential" and "commercial" would only make for a lot of very boring sims.
So I hope some thought will go into this. Also a lot of thought about exactly what kind of advertising will be allowed in each type of zone.
|
Sandor Balczo
SL Resident since 5/30/07
Join date: 5 Jun 2007
Posts: 30
|
09-06-2008 08:47
From: JubJub Forder I for one, am opting out before the date...
From the song "The man that got away": "Good riddance, goodbye, every trick of his you're on to, but fools will be fools and where's he gone to?" LOL Sandor 
|
Rubee Adelaide
Registered User
Join date: 2 Oct 2006
Posts: 15
|
Hooray!
09-06-2008 08:49
I'm really happy about this plan. I hope it works!
My suggestion: After ads/ad farms are under control, please implement a plan to start re-joining all those tiny 16m plots to larger plots. The mainland is too carved up. Only ad farmers are interested in buying those little plots.
Here are some ideas:
* Preference for buying tiny plots should go first to the owners of adjacent plots, then to land owners in the same sim, and then to the general public. Give the neighbors a few days to buy them so they don't have to race against the land bots. This will encourage people to rejoin the land.
* When a tiny plot is in Governor Linden's custody, don't immediately put it up for auction. Wait (a few days or a week?) to see if it can be joined to nearby plots.
* This is extreme, but you could consider putting a price cap on tiny plots (at least temporarily - until the land isn't so broken up)
|
Esther Merryman
Registered User
Join date: 21 Nov 2007
Posts: 152
|
Extortion?
09-06-2008 09:00
From: Dora Gustafson One bare 16m2 parcel is on sale for 999999L$, is that extortion? One bare 16m2 parcel next to it is not on sale, is that extortion? I stand up for the right parcel owners on the mainland have: to set their land for sale at any price; NOBODY can force ANYBODY to buy
Note: a bare parcel is what you get when the ad farmer removes the ad from the parcel. I see your point here Dora. So this is my comment if a person with premium account paying land tier on a single 16sqm plot who owned this particular plot only and chose to put it up for sale at 999999L or whatever price. then this is merely stating that the plot is not for sale as this is clearly a absolutely stupid figure as soon as they buy any other plots or place anything on that plot or edit the terrain to cause disturbance then they are HARASSING their neighbors. When that person buys 100's or 1000's of plots for no genuine realistic purpose but to place them on sale for 1495L in the case of one extortionist or 9999L in the case of another then it becomes an extortion racket. Many other groups in world hold high numbers of small parcels for running scripts etc. and as such these parcels have a purpose and are not for sale obviously in these circumstances extortion is not the case, and most of these groups will move their parcels for you when asked and do not wish to make your life unpleasant.
|
Raudf Fox
(ra-ow-th)
Join date: 25 Feb 2005
Posts: 5,119
|
09-06-2008 09:17
*blinks* While I am very glad to see this step forward, I do have one concern... From: Blog There are lots of positive forms of advertising already inworld that are no problem at all, from the signs you place above your own stores to the club owner that will place your ad on the wall behind the bar for a fee. Does this mean our own shop signs will count as ads?
_____________________
DiamonX Studios, the place of the Victorian Times series of gowns and dresses - Located at http://slurl.com/secondlife/Fushida/224/176
Want more attachment points for your avatar's wearing pleasure? Then please vote for
https://jira.secondlife.com/browse/VWR-1065?
|
Kara Spengler
Pink Cat
Join date: 11 Jun 2007
Posts: 1,227
|
09-06-2008 09:24
From: Esther Merryman So this is my comment if a person with premium account paying land tier on a single 16sqm plot who owned this particular plot only and chose to put it up for sale at 999999L or whatever price. then this is merely stating that the plot is not for sale as this is clearly a absolutely stupid figure as soon as they buy any other plots or place anything on that plot or edit the terrain to cause disturbance then they are HARASSING their neighbors..
Yes, landscaping affects the landscaping of adjoining plots. Putting up ban lines also does, as the lines appear over your neighbor's property (I had to move my house when lines appeared in my living room). Of course, setting to an unrealistic selling point is clearly extortion hoping someone will accidentally buy it. Plots do not have to be set for sale.
|
Ciaran Laval
Mostly Harmless
Join date: 11 Mar 2007
Posts: 7,951
|
09-06-2008 09:35
From: Raudf Fox *blinks* While I am very glad to see this step forward, I do have one concern...
Does this mean our own shop signs will count as ads? Yes, but those sort of ads aren't being banned.
|
MarkEdward Harvey
Registered User
Join date: 25 Feb 2007
Posts: 5
|
Public Service Messages
09-06-2008 09:53
I have been posting Christian messages on billboards in SL for over 2 years.I have invested thousands of hours and thousands of dollars without any financial return. I feel this issue will be a perfect test legal case in RL for discrimination and would welcome contact from folks interesting in joining a law suit against SL, which I want to make it abundantly clear I will pursue if I suffer any form of financial loss or extortion or discrimination.
|
Talarus Luan
Ancient Archaean Dragon
Join date: 18 Mar 2006
Posts: 4,831
|
09-06-2008 10:07
From: MarkEdward Harvey I have been posting Christian messages on billboards in SL for over 2 years.I have invested thousands of hours and thousands of dollars without any financial return. I feel this issue will be a perfect test legal case in RL for discrimination and would welcome contact from folks interesting in joining a law suit against SL, which I want to make it abundantly clear I will pursue if I suffer any form of financial loss or extortion or discrimination. Good luck with that...  Since they aren't singling out your billboards specifically, it's not discrimination. Since they aren't asking for money to let you continue spamming people, it isn't extortion. As for financial loss, nothing in the ToS you agreed to guarantees you any kind of remuneration if they change the ToS in such a way that causes you financial loss. It sucks, but that's part and parcel of being in a virtual world where literally ANYthing can and WILL change at a moment's notice.
|
Esther Merryman
Registered User
Join date: 21 Nov 2007
Posts: 152
|
09-06-2008 10:12
From: JubJub Forder I admit it... i have ad plots... i abide by the rules as expressly laid out by Lindens "Current policy allows adverts...." (blog:Tuesday, August 5th, 2008 at 11:02 AM by: Jack Linden)... in return for abiding by the rules... i have been harassed, griefed, abused, threatened, lied about, slandered and more. You should certainly not be harassed or abused but the fact remains that by placing huge orange blocks in the sky you are being very inconsiderate, this was pointed out to you by me in the previous mainland forum last month From: JubJub Forder My ads advertise legitimate businesses - my own (visit and you'll see i make some great products)... and i get good results - click rates as high as 7-9% per day depending on the ad. My most frequently clicked ad is for my large art gallery promoting RL artists in SL. Ask any friends or customers and you will find i provide great, prompt, and friendly service.
This is just the sort of thing advertising has a genuine use for but I do think in this case the search would be better utilized to look for an art gallery etc. as how many people just happen to fly around and look for ads to find something they want I would think the numbers are more or less non existent. From: JubJub Forder Where people have approached me reasonably i have swapped or sold parcels for less than $400LD (about a $1.50 for all the time it takes to find, buy, setup, then reset for sale AND none are set for sale, I prefer not to sell cause it's usually not worth my time for the pittance i get offered). Where people are rude or trying to bully - i simply dont sell. I do not extort. I do not bully. I am not in the business of selling land for profit. I ONLY buy land on mature rated, uncovenanted, Mainland. I do not advertise sex or any sex related items. And i am against extortion via high land prices, ban lines etc.
The time it takes you to place one of your 3prim ads is seconds and purchase of plots through the land search engine also very quick so time is not really a factor here, Surely good will is more likely to make potential customers remember you and use your gallery. From: JubJub Forder I see in these forums a lot of people spewing hatred and name calling... basically it seems cause they cannot get their own way..and making any argument to justify it.
Here we seem to be getting our way, Jack Linden seems to be willing to make the mainland a nice place to spend time, wants to clean up the advertising that is currently downright ugly and produce guidelines for people who if they were a little more considerate of others should have made this step unnecessary. From: JubJub Forder "that ****** extortionist won't sell me the land i want at what i think is a reasonable price" or "i don't like that 'thing' in my view therefore the person is ruining my experience" The facts remain; mainland is uncovenanted, advertising a business is a fact of life, and there are problems with extortion for high land prices.
If adverts were thought about then people would not be so dismayed by them, use mainland is uncovenanted because LL trusted all users to have a little respect for each other and use common sense, unfortunately people have proved to LL they cannot be trusted to act responsibly in many cases. From: JubJub Forder This new policy does nothing to cure the actual problem - extortion. Extortion via ban lines Extortion via high prices Extortion via blocking/walling in Extortion via high color, bright flashing rotating pseudo ads for non-businesses.
This policy is not intended to stop extortion, Jack has made that clear in his post on page 11. This policy will license people to advertise responsibly following set out guidelines nothing more, if these guidelines are not followed the LL will remove the license. The Lindens also intend to act as Estate Managers to prevent other forms of abuse such as extortion, this hopefully means they will actually look at the actions of an individual or group and see if they are trying to cheat extort or abuse in anyway and when convinced this is the case they will put a stop to it. Not through a particular policy but more in the same way a private estate manager would by using common sense to make their own conclusions and decisions. From: JubJub Forder This policy will not satisfy the vehement name callers - it'll be ban the 'for sale' signs next - then "make that person sell to me", then "i don't like his colored wall". This policy will not stop advertising. And it will not stop extortion. And it won't stop land cutters.
You are right some will not be satisfied, however as Estate managers hopefully the Lindens will also stop inconsiderate placement of for sale signs, colored walls etc. From: JubJub Forder What it will do is stop some advertisers - probably the least of the actual problem. And it will stop legitimate advertisers like me (yes - i hear the chorus of yays) 'cause i ain't gonna pay Lindens more money for an advertising network - even if it is a license to make money (which it is) - it is simply not part of my business plan.
It will not stop people advertising if that is their real intention, and that is not a snipe at you. From: JubJub Forder I realise it's a starting point but feel it simply won't work - witness the Marxs etc adjusting already. Only two solutions i can see - add a visual mute function so people can avoid what they simply don't want to see.... or disallow any price above $xx per square metre to make land cutting and resale simply uneconomic. I for one, am opting out before the date... but one final word... Jack has asked for suggestions on policy...those of you in here name calling and multiple posting to argue your points - where are you gonna direct your anger after?
It is a great starting point and personally I feel the Lindens are declaring an intention to do far better things for the mainland, combating extortion amongst a few. As far as someone with surname MARX and other such friends are concerned I believe that Jack and the other Lindens are more than clever enough to see what is happening and will act appropriately. And as for future anger well the Lindens are always going to pull the short straw on that one, its one of the problems with being in control  But right now they have made this Lady very happy, along with many others.
|
Joshua Philgarlic
SLinside.com
Join date: 29 Jan 2007
Posts: 143
|
09-06-2008 10:13
From: MarkEdward Harvey I have been posting Christian messages on billboards in SL for over 2 years.I have invested thousands of hours and thousands of dollars without any financial return. I feel this issue will be a perfect test legal case in RL for discrimination and would welcome contact from folks interesting in joining a law suit against SL, which I want to make it abundantly clear I will pursue if I suffer any form of financial loss or extortion or discrimination. Why are you so greedy? I'm sure The Lord will recognize your effords anyway.
|
Kathy Morellet
Registered User
Join date: 26 Jul 2006
Posts: 809
|
09-06-2008 10:16
From: MarkEdward Harvey I have been posting Christian messages on billboards in SL for over 2 years.I have invested thousands of hours and thousands of dollars without any financial return. I feel this issue will be a perfect test legal case in RL for discrimination and would welcome contact from folks interesting in joining a law suit against SL, which I want to make it abundantly clear I will pursue if I suffer any form of financial loss or extortion or discrimination. Oh, goodie, another litigation happy resident. You did agree to the Terms of Service when you joined, did you not? From: Terms of Service 5.3 All data on Linden Lab's servers are subject to deletion, alteration or transfer.
When using the Service, you may accumulate Content, Currency, objects, items, scripts, equipment, or other value or status indicators that reside as data on Linden Lab's servers. THESE DATA, AND ANY OTHER DATA, ACCOUNT HISTORY AND ACCOUNT NAMES RESIDING ON LINDEN LAB'S SERVERS, MAY BE DELETED, ALTERED, MOVED OR TRANSFERRED AT ANY TIME FOR ANY REASON IN LINDEN LAB'S SOLE DISCRETION.
YOU ACKNOWLEDGE THAT, NOTWITHSTANDING ANY COPYRIGHT OR OTHER RIGHTS YOU MAY HAVE WITH RESPECT TO ITEMS YOU CREATE USING THE SERVICE, AND NOTWITHSTANDING ANY VALUE ATTRIBUTED TO SUCH CONTENT OR OTHER DATA BY YOU OR ANY THIRD PARTY, LINDEN LAB DOES NOT PROVIDE OR GUARANTEE, AND EXPRESSLY DISCLAIMS (SUBJECT TO ANY UNDERLYING INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS IN THE CONTENT), ANY VALUE, CASH OR OTHERWISE, ATTRIBUTED TO ANY DATA RESIDING ON LINDEN LAB'S SERVERS.
YOU UNDERSTAND AND AGREE THAT LINDEN LAB HAS THE RIGHT, BUT NOT THE OBLIGATION, TO REMOVE ANY CONTENT (INCLUDING YOUR CONTENT) IN WHOLE OR IN PART AT ANY TIME FOR ANY REASON OR NO REASON, WITH OR WITHOUT NOTICE AND WITH NO LIABILITY OF ANY KIND.
|
Lias Leandros
mainlander
Join date: 20 Jul 2005
Posts: 3,458
|
09-06-2008 10:20
From: Jack Linden- Aug. 5th Now it *may* be that one day we allow existing regions to opt in to Zoning if all owners there agree, but we shall see how feasible that is as we get closer to new regions being Zoned....And this isn't about encouraging people to misuse Protected land. From: Jack Linden- Sept. 4th In recent months we have had a large amount of feedback about the need to improve the Mainland experience. We have listened and we agree. There will be a number of phases to this work that will include policy changes, land recycling, zoning and urban regeneration programs... just as city planners do in the real world. Well it is good to see that some parts of the new mainland zoning plan WILL effect the old mainland without this 'opt-in' plan leaving older sims out in the cold. I thought it was a major misstep to exclude the existing mainland in this new policy.Hopefully this 'save the mainland' project will keep moving forward and truly make a positive impact that the tier-paying SL residents can enjoy. .Customer Service. Good. .
_____________________
 http://slurl.com/secondlife/Bear/214/199/107 Join in SL open enrollment CLUB JOBS to announce new DJ and Host Jobs for free. And on Avatar's United http://www.avatarsunited.com/groups/club-jobs
|
Alazarin Mondrian
Teh Trippy Hippie Dragon
Join date: 4 Apr 2005
Posts: 1,549
|
09-06-2008 10:21
From: Joannah Benelli Just build a region called "Advertising Island", give access only to ad farmers and build a huge banline around it. So those guys can play their game and leave use ordinary people alone. Yeah... what she said!!!
_____________________
My stuff on Meta-Life: http://tinyurl.com/ykq7nzt http://www.myspace.com/alazarinmobius http://slurl.com/secondlife/Crescent/72/98/116
|
Sindy Tsure
Will script for shoes
Join date: 18 Sep 2006
Posts: 4,103
|
09-06-2008 10:22
From: MarkEdward Harvey I have been posting Christian messages on billboards in SL for over 2 years.I have invested thousands of hours and thousands of dollars without any financial return. I feel this issue will be a perfect test legal case in RL for discrimination and would welcome contact from folks interesting in joining a law suit against SL, which I want to make it abundantly clear I will pursue if I suffer any form of financial loss or extortion or discrimination. Woohoo!! No thread is truly complete without mention of a class action lawsuit! All we need now is an open letter.
|
MarkEdward Harvey
Registered User
Join date: 25 Feb 2007
Posts: 5
|
Trees planted in front of signs?
09-06-2008 10:25
I'm sure the TOS also allowed all of the "Linden" trees planted in the middle of the roads to purposefully block my signs and messages?
TOS's won't cover deception or fraudulent inducement in a court of law.
|
Alazarin Mondrian
Teh Trippy Hippie Dragon
Join date: 4 Apr 2005
Posts: 1,549
|
09-06-2008 10:28
I'm surprised it's lasted this long without being Godwined..... yet.
_____________________
My stuff on Meta-Life: http://tinyurl.com/ykq7nzt http://www.myspace.com/alazarinmobius http://slurl.com/secondlife/Crescent/72/98/116
|
Lias Leandros
mainlander
Join date: 20 Jul 2005
Posts: 3,458
|
09-06-2008 10:29
From: Kathy Morellet Oh, goodie, another litigation happy resident. You did agree to the Terms of Service when you joined, did you not? Kathy enough Judges have ruled against LL's TOS to make it all completely debatable. If someone wants to spend the money to challenge the TOS - then let them. Even when a judge has not ruled against LL - they have caved rather quickly and cut a deal with the unhappy customer. I guess even LL's attorneys know that the TOS isn't worth the paper it's written on. .
_____________________
 http://slurl.com/secondlife/Bear/214/199/107 Join in SL open enrollment CLUB JOBS to announce new DJ and Host Jobs for free. And on Avatar's United http://www.avatarsunited.com/groups/club-jobs
|
Esther Merryman
Registered User
Join date: 21 Nov 2007
Posts: 152
|
09-06-2008 10:31
From: MarkEdward Harvey I have been posting Christian messages on billboards in SL for over 2 years.I have invested thousands of hours and thousands of dollars without any financial return. I feel this issue will be a perfect test legal case in RL for discrimination and would welcome contact from folks interesting in joining a law suit against SL, which I want to make it abundantly clear I will pursue if I suffer any form of financial loss or extortion or discrimination. I have not seen any of your billboards, and count myself as a Christian to, if your billboards comply with sizing required for a license then they should not be affected. If they are of an overbearing size and disturbing to people in the surrounding area then you are not sending out a good message for Christians as a whole and they should be removed and new ones placed out. Religion is important to many people in Second Life and Real Life, and as such can come under unfair scrutiny, complaints from people with other religious beliefs, atheists etc. so in instances like this I hope LL will use a little discretion and common sense when making decisions. Especially where there is no financial motive and the intention is good and just, sending out a message of PEACE and LOVE. From: Alazarin Mondrian I'm surprised it's lasted this long without being Godwined..... yet.
This sort of response is unhelpful and rude, and I would hope each and every person here should be grown up enough to respect others beliefs.
|
Yumi Murakami
DoIt!AttachTheEarOfACat!
Join date: 27 Sep 2005
Posts: 6,860
|
09-06-2008 10:33
From: Toy LaFollette This basically sounds pre version 1.2 when they changed from that because of prim hording, there was also a huge revolt about it I believe in 2003 I believe that was when you paid ONLY for coordinates, and there was no prim limit on land, so you could indeed "hoard prims". But even then you were still paying for placement. What I'm proposing is that the landowner themselves decides their own placement, at least, as it appears to someone on their parcel.
|