Gender stereotypes in SL: "Real" women
|
Oryx Tempel
Registered User
Join date: 8 Nov 2006
Posts: 7,663
|
05-26-2009 11:17
From: Seven Okelli I look at it this way: innocent until proven guilty. When I meet people in SL I assume they are normal, polite, well-meaning people. I treat them as if they are until they go out of their way to prove me wrong. I have met male avatars who told me they were women and female avatars who told me they were men. And I always said the same thing when they told me: "Okay" (and sometimes I added, "Do you want to dance?" I mean, what does it hurt me? Oh, you know what it's like? It's like wondering in real life who is gay. Some people put a lot of time into figuring out who they know is actually a closeted gay. What is the point? I figure it doesn't matter unless you want to hook up with that person. I *hate* it when people tell me that they think that someone is not what they appear, because it's hard to shake off doubt. If you start out suspicious, it will poison your relationships. . What a lovely post.  Thanks, Seven.
|
Lewis Luminos
Ginger
Join date: 13 Aug 2008
Posts: 218
|
05-26-2009 11:20
Given my own ambiguous gender situation (in RL) I am equally a contradiction of gender stereotypes.
On the one hand, I like art and culture, I can't script to save my life, I'm not interested in pixel-bumping and dirty talk but I do like the erotic/sensual/romantic side of SL sex. I don't do voice (though that's not for lack of trying). I've no interest in guns or combat roleplay, or any kind of computer game. I'm not attracted to the skinny female avatar with enormous boobs and booty. And I know what that torture-looking device is that Oryx posted a pic of (although I've never used one in RL), but I have absolutely NO clue what goes on underneath the hood of a car.
On the other hand, I love sport, especially watching it live. My favourite genre of movies is the action movie. My favourite place to spend the evening is my local pub, where I drink real ale in pints. I love military aircraft and one of my favourite summer pastimes is visiting airshows. I hate shopping, I especially hate shopping with other people. I am a hopeless cook, and I try to avoid domestic chores if I can possibly get away with it. I hate soap operas, chick flicks and "reality" TV, and I don't even pretend to begin to understand the concept of "gossip".
I also cannot abide grammar-nazis.
_____________________
http://luminosity2l.wordpress.com/
|
Marianne Little
A hopeless fool
Join date: 14 Aug 2007
Posts: 645
|
05-26-2009 11:25
From: Lolita Pro ................... If you *really* want to spot the RL men playing as SL females .... look at the hands.  Do you mean they have big hands? I disagree with that. A lot of avatars who I'm very sure of are RL females, care a lot about their avatars look. Some of them want RL proportions. A hand should be roughly the same length of the face. Very many avatars has small hands, but if their avatar has a more proportional look, it doesn't mean they are male RL. I also start to dislike my size zero feet more and more, especially in ballet flats. I want feet that look like they can hold my body up. So I have some shoes that I can change size on, and if I have medium feet and size 22 hands... I am male RL? *shrug* Doesn't matter much to me. I have male friends who have the most sexy, adorable and stylish female avatar. Prim lashes, elegant dressed, changes clothes all the time. I talk to "her" as a woman all the time when the female avatar is on. When the male avatar is on, I am more flirty, in a teasing way. I know both are played by the same, but I react a bit different. But I don't look for a RL partner/love so I am much more relaxed about it. I'm not going to meet them in RL, so I treat them as they appear in SL. I even think about them as their SL gender.
|
Melita Magic
On my own terms.
Join date: 5 Jun 2008
Posts: 2,253
|
05-26-2009 11:33
I've a serious bone to pick with someone here, and I don't care who knows it.
I've become addicted to ferret photos.
Argent, would you kindly find and post some that are a lot less cute?
Ah thankyew kindly.
|
Argent Stonecutter
Emergency Mustelid
Join date: 20 Sep 2005
Posts: 20,263
|
05-26-2009 11:39
From: Melita Magic I've a serious bone to pick with someone here, and I don't care who knows it.
I've become addicted to ferret photos.
Argent, would you kindly find and post some that are a lot less cute? I don't know how to do that!  Maybe I can dilute them.  Does that help?
|
Pserendipity Daniels
Assume sarcasm as default
Join date: 21 Dec 2006
Posts: 8,839
|
05-26-2009 11:43
From: Arcady Yue <snip>I find violent sex activities repugnant, but I've been attacked by women before <snip>  Pep (Sorry, I have taken your quote completely out of context, but I did laugh out loud in rl when I read it and wanted to bring it to the attention of others. Oh, and I thought your post was much too sensible for this forum.)
_____________________
Hypocrite lecteur, — mon semblable, — mon frère!
|
Melita Magic
On my own terms.
Join date: 5 Jun 2008
Posts: 2,253
|
05-26-2009 11:44
From: Argent Stonecutter I don't know how to do that!  Maybe I can dilute them.  Does that help? Ahhhhhgghhh! *goes into rehab*
|
Weston Graves
Werebeagle
Join date: 24 Mar 2007
Posts: 2,059
|
05-26-2009 12:29
From: Marianne Little A hand should be roughly the same size of the face. I just want to clarify this a bit. A hand should be roughly the length of the face (assuming you want normal human proportions, but that's a whole 'nother thread). But it takes two hands to cover the width of the face. I didn't want people to start making their hands huge all of a sudden.
|
Melita Magic
On my own terms.
Join date: 5 Jun 2008
Posts: 2,253
|
05-26-2009 12:39
Actually (IRL) my hand just about covers whether the width or the height of my own face. I do have long slender fingers...but I don't know if that is true of everyone, that there is one measurement.
I go by eye but that's one reason if people don't have the eye for it they should buy their shape. At least in SL you *can*.
Oh and if I see big hands I think "someone bought a demo shape and was too cheap to pop for the real one."
I had hands on my av that were a bit big until one day I noticed it. Then I changed it. (I prefer to make my own shape. And it's cheaper.) Generally, for an av around 6' tall I'd say under 20 hands for a female. But it depends.
Y'know what is worse in a way are those teeeeny tiny hands. Again, it takes an eye.
|
Marianne Little
A hopeless fool
Join date: 14 Aug 2007
Posts: 645
|
05-26-2009 12:41
Thank you for clarifying. I will edit my post  .
|
Melita Magic
On my own terms.
Join date: 5 Jun 2008
Posts: 2,253
|
05-26-2009 12:43
Are you guys talking about RL or SL? And are you counting fingers or just the palm? Cos that's one wide face if it's two hand lengths wide!
|
Marianne Little
A hopeless fool
Join date: 14 Aug 2007
Posts: 645
|
05-26-2009 12:43
From: Melita Magic Oh and if I see big hands I think "someone bought a demo shape and was too cheap to pop for the real one."
Demo hands can't be mistaken. They are so big! 
|
Melita Magic
On my own terms.
Join date: 5 Jun 2008
Posts: 2,253
|
05-26-2009 12:44
Yes - it's amazing how the wearer doesn't notice, when they are THAT big! (The feet too!)
|
Lewis Luminos
Ginger
Join date: 13 Aug 2008
Posts: 218
|
05-26-2009 12:48
From: Melita Magic I had hands on my av that were a bit big until one day I noticed it. Then I changed it. (I prefer to make my own shape. And it's cheaper.) Generally, for an av around 6' tall I'd say under 20 hands for a female. But it depends.
Y'know what is worse in a way are those teeeeny tiny hands. Again, it takes an eye. My hands are size 50 and they're about right for my face, but then again my head's size 70, and that's accurately in proportion with the rest of my body (total height = 8 heads high). And I'm only 6'4" which is pretty short for a guy, so I dunno how people hope to get everything in proportion when they crank their height up to 100. I guess that's why there are so many muscle-bound, pin-headed men in SL.
_____________________
http://luminosity2l.wordpress.com/
|
Marianne Little
A hopeless fool
Join date: 14 Aug 2007
Posts: 645
|
05-26-2009 12:51
From: Melita Magic Are you guys talking about RL or SL? And are you counting fingers or just the palm? Cos that's one wide face if it's two hand lengths wide! I wonder if I just mess up here and should tiptoe out. I quoted Lolita who meant she could see if a female avatar was played by a man RL, on the size of the hands. Did she mean that men who play females in SL has too big hands on their avatars? http://www.ehow.com/how_2213390_keep-face-hand-proportions-realistic.html"Keep the fingers roughly the same size as the palm of the hand. When sketching the hand, bend the fingers at the knuckles for a more natural look. Check that the hand is roughly the same size as the face. The hands and face should be close in size if they are correctly proportioned. The length of the face is the same as the length to the longest point of the hand."
|
Melita Magic
On my own terms.
Join date: 5 Jun 2008
Posts: 2,253
|
05-26-2009 12:57
Lewis: those sound like really big hands. I've had an av with a close to 70 head before (I just like big heads, I have to work against that) and 33 or so hands. But that was female. Maybe on males it's different? But I don't recall your hands seeming outsized in the pic you posted of your av, so maybe it depends on overall musculature as well, whether they 'appear' big or not. I don't know that going by exact human proportions is ideal for an avatar in Second Life. Despite the vaunted '3d' it's still on a 2d screen, etc. People perceive toons differently than they would a real-life person, and there is some creative license. Marianne: No that quote sounds right. It was two hand lengths being the same as the face's WIDTH that I wondered about. FWIW, I interpreted Lolita's post about big hands on an av that way too. Btw about hands; it's supposedly something a lot of people have trouble drawing but I always loved drawing hands. Maybe it's one thing that it was always easy to find a model for! Plus they're so telling, and often so graceful.  Maybe in future versions virtual worlds will have more refined hands/feet, while we're on the topic. 
|
Seven Okelli
last days of pompeii
Join date: 4 Dec 2008
Posts: 2,300
|
05-26-2009 12:58
Wasn't the hand-size comment a joke?
.
_____________________
: : I met most of the people I know in Second Life through these forums. : I learned most of what I know of Second Life through these forums. : When I couldn't get inworld, these forums were the next best thing. : And sometimes these forums WERE the best thing. :
|
Melita Magic
On my own terms.
Join date: 5 Jun 2008
Posts: 2,253
|
05-26-2009 13:00
Only the person who wrote it can say. I took it as a joke based on a hint of truth...or hint of opinion.
And then others took the conversation from it - as often happens. People think of something and the conversation takes a turn.
|
Weston Graves
Werebeagle
Join date: 24 Mar 2007
Posts: 2,059
|
05-26-2009 13:02
From: Melita Magic Are you guys talking about RL or SL? And are you counting fingers or just the palm? Cos that's one wide face if it's two hand lengths wide! LOL! Okay now it's time to clarify MY post. The face is one hand length long, two hand widths wide -- more or less. Incidentally, I really appreciated Marianne's smiley face. She must have understood I wasn't trying to be a grammar Nazi. I'm just a geeky old illustrator who is finding this thread very interesting.
|
Melita Magic
On my own terms.
Join date: 5 Jun 2008
Posts: 2,253
|
05-26-2009 13:07
Never said or thought anyone was correcting grammar. I was trying to understand what was being said, that is all. Two hand widths = one face width seems to bear out in my own home test. Lol. Thanks.  (Assume smiley face by default!)
|
Marianne Little
A hopeless fool
Join date: 14 Aug 2007
Posts: 645
|
05-26-2009 13:19
From: Weston Graves LOL! Okay now it's time to clarify MY post. The face is one hand length long, two hand widths wide -- more or less.
Incidentally, I really appreciated Marianne's smiley face. She must have understood I wasn't trying to be a grammar Nazi. I'm just a geeky old illustrator who is finding this thread very interesting. Could NEVER think that about you! The more I think about it, it was probably a joke that started it. I took it damned serious, the "hand size" thing.
|
Lewis Luminos
Ginger
Join date: 13 Aug 2008
Posts: 218
|
05-26-2009 14:15
From: Weston Graves LOL! Okay now it's time to clarify MY post. The face is one hand length long, two hand widths wide -- more or less.
Incidentally, I really appreciated Marianne's smiley face. She must have understood I wasn't trying to be a grammar Nazi. I'm just a geeky old illustrator who is finding this thread very interesting. Weston, my "grammar-nazi" comment wasn't aimed at you. 
_____________________
http://luminosity2l.wordpress.com/
|
Lewis Luminos
Ginger
Join date: 13 Aug 2008
Posts: 218
|
05-26-2009 14:23
From: Melita Magic Lewis: those sound like really big hands. I've had an av with a close to 70 head before (I just like big heads, I have to work against that) and 33 or so hands. But that was female. Maybe on males it's different? But I don't recall your hands seeming outsized in the pic you posted of your av, so maybe it depends on overall musculature as well, whether they 'appear' big or not. It probably would look weird on a female avatar, and yes my avatar isn't tall but is a bit on the "chunky" side (more thickness and body-fat rather than muscle and shoulder width though). More the soft and cuddly type  From: Melita Magic I don't know that going by exact human proportions is ideal for an avatar in Second Life. Despite the vaunted '3d' it's still on a 2d screen, etc. People perceive toons differently than they would a real-life person, and there is some creative license. Well, I didn't, exactly. The correct human proportion is 7 to 7.5 heads high, but that just made me look too squat, so I went for 8, which is the comic-book standard and actually looks MORE realistic than really-realistic. Go too low in the numbers and you start looking like a child.
_____________________
http://luminosity2l.wordpress.com/
|
Tarina Sewell
Just Browsing Thank you
Join date: 20 Jul 2007
Posts: 2,180
|
05-26-2009 14:29
From: Briana Dawson What sort of gender stereotypes do you ascribe to if any at all? It seems that there is an attitude among certain male posters in this forum that if one "claims" to be female, and yet believes "A, B, or C", then she is clearly male and a poseur. In 2003-2005 this was common in world with certain preconceived ideas like: - Real women cannot build - Real women cannot script - Real women are not furries or neko's - Real women cannot be tech savvy Recently, I have seen people say things like: - Real women do not like "X" sexual activity(ies) - Real women do not seek out sex - Real women do not watch porn - Real women are not attracted to violent sexual activites/RP (in varying degrees) - Real women WILL voice or cam verify - Real women do not carry weapons - Real women are not violent - Real women do not like Anime - Real women do not use Anime emoticons ============================ What do you all think of these sort of stereotypes? Do any of them hold a sliver of truth to them? Do any of them have truth to them in the year 2009? Do you believe in any of these? Or have you once believed in any of these? If so, which one(s) and why? Isn't SL one big giant Anime?
|
Carl Metropolitan
Registered User
Join date: 7 Jul 2005
Posts: 1,031
|
05-26-2009 14:38
From: Nina Stepford one doesnt need to be a guy to see male stereotypes any more than one needs to be a minority to spot racial stereotypes. male sl/rl stereotypes: From: Nina Stepford sl- they rarely change clothes Got me there. Plus I have my famous 2004 vintage mesh hair. From: Nina Stepford sl- favours women with beachball-sized breasts and pencil-legs I like breasts, but the there is too much of a good thing. And what you are describing is it. From: Nina Stepford sl- thinks about cybersex a lot Nope. I don't even own a penis in SL. (The last time I said that in public someone gave me one--but I ended up selling it at the last NCI fundraising auction. "Carl Metropolitan's Sex Life--Barely Used" raised 3500L$.) From: Nina Stepford sl- is willing to cam/voice No cam. I am willing to do voice, but have a strong preference for text. From: Nina Stepford sl/rl- lack taste and/or refinement (unless gay) Not gay. Have taste. Enjoy design. From: Nina Stepford sl/rl- have little appreciation for art or culture (unless gay) In SL I own an art gallery and collect art by SL artists. It looks like if I can just start changing my clothes every day in SL, I can convince people I'm really a woman.
|