Welcome to the Second Life Forums Archive

These forums are CLOSED. Please visit the new forums HERE

Age verification enters Grid-wide beta

Alicia Sautereau
if (!social) hide;
Join date: 20 Feb 2007
Posts: 3,125
12-05-2007 18:03
as i posted in the blog and ofcourse waiting moderation...

From: Ali
unless this time Linden Lab clearly states what is mature content or not, i think it would be wise to NOT enable it or half the grid will be unaccessable

random enforcing on nudity, pictures people have in their house/store/hangout/what ever, furries, tinies or what ever idiots will find “offensive” will be reported and in cases it is “according” to some vague rules, the random enforcing will start as with everything so far

still a good move as it will restrict our wallets without our intervention who simply do not want to verify with some dodgy company
if we should take your (linden lab) word on trust with some corperate privacy statement, santa is real
_____________________
Tatiana Heckroth
Registered User
Join date: 13 Jun 2007
Posts: 36
12-05-2007 18:11
Passport Number: No Go
Last 4 SSN : No Go
Driver's License: No Go.
Picture of me with today's newspaper : No go.


AGE VERIFICATION FAILED.
Bittersweet Lime
Registered User
Join date: 23 Aug 2006
Posts: 29
12-05-2007 18:11
An address from 2003?- hell then I would have to put in a UK address and as well I had another identity card at that time. Will I have to put in the data like it was official recorded in England then?

Did my old identity card, I had at that time, have the same number like my current one then?- I am german living in germany now again - not to tell, that I cant use my real name as LL is not accepting german letters. And how to write the street names, there are lots of ways to write them?

Like always LL is providing crap work - like with the billing system as well, which is not able to use my paypal - and guess by what reason?- paypal tells me LL never asks for money, so paypal never can pay. Anyway, this is crap and i wonder if LL will give any hints how to verify in these cases before putting this shit live.
spinster Voom
Registered User
Join date: 14 Jun 2007
Posts: 1,069
12-05-2007 18:12
From the blog post:

http://blog.secondlife.com/2007/09/18/identity-verification-and-flagging-parcels-for-restricted-content/

From: someone
We strongly encourage estate owners and parcel owners to flag any restricted content



but on the knowledge base today (info for parcel and estate owners):


From: someone
Note: If land has content that is particularly sensitive or adult in nature, it is incumbent on the landowners to expressly ban adults who have not verified their ages.
Laura Lobo
Registered User
Join date: 8 Sep 2006
Posts: 79
12-05-2007 18:13
Used last 4 on the SS and went through just fine. The idea is good and should have been done from the start. No sure their current way of going about it is good or not. Oh well.
Rita Hainsworth
Registered User
Join date: 29 Jul 2006
Posts: 93
12-05-2007 18:14
as long as im verified as younger its ok
_____________________
mysocalled2ndlife.com
Danielle Harrop
Jus' lil ole me
Join date: 2 Mar 2007
Posts: 410
12-05-2007 18:19
Gave them my current address and Driver's License number. Same info on every check I write, and probably on my credit report (which anyone can access for a fee) . Not much you can do with a Driver's License number, and they can get your address (US) from the City Directory published by R.L Polk and Co. Most if not all larger cities/metropolitan areas have one, and it's updated annually.


That's all the info they're getting out of me though. They have that, and my payment info. that's all they need.

Funny thing is I dont hang out where there's a lot of "adult themed material", but I have shops in malls that are adult themed, so I figured it would benefit me in the long run to verify. Quick, painless, and took me all of a few minutes if that.

But I have to admit, on the verge of 42, it was nice to be carded again. ;)
_____________________
Dani's Fine Fashions
http://slurl.com/secondlife/Dubya%20City/135/99/24

http://danisfinefashions.wordpress.com/
-
The equine mammal requires no further flogging as posthumus assaults serve no greater purpose...or any purpose at all, so please cease and desist.
Amity Slade
Registered User
Join date: 14 Feb 2007
Posts: 2,183
12-05-2007 18:21
If you need give only a very little bit of information to have your age verified, that does not mean that the verification system is shoddy. What that means is that you would be shocked at how much information exists on you in various databases that sell your information, and that because all that information already exists on you, a service may only need one or two little pieces of information to locate a ton of data on you.

Having used skip-tracing databases before, I was amazed at how easy it was for me to find a lot of information on a particular person by just starting with an incomplete name and one other piece of information, like an old address that hasn't been used in 20 years.

The test of the system is not in how easy it is for the system to come up with the correct answer. The test is in how easy it is to fool the system.
Alicia Sautereau
if (!social) hide;
Join date: 20 Feb 2007
Posts: 3,125
12-05-2007 18:30
From: Amity Slade
If you need give only a very little bit of information to have your age verified, that does not mean that the verification system is shoddy. What that means is that you would be shocked at how much information exists on you in various databases that sell your information, and that because all that information already exists on you, a service may only need one or two little pieces of information to locate a ton of data on you.

Having used skip-tracing databases before, I was amazed at how easy it was for me to find a lot of information on a particular person by just starting with an incomplete name and one other piece of information, like an old address that hasn't been used in 20 years.

The test of the system is not in how easy it is for the system to come up with the correct answer. The test is in how easy it is to fool the system.

so as it`s "out there" nway, we should just submit it to a proven company wich sells personal details to the highest bidder?

using old/innacurate info is as said by incompitence&co for supplying false information as easilly obtained from other sources of info like signup, cc etc, beating the system and you get fried totally in the end

symphaties to who will endup with shops in restricted sims/parcels but as my fav shops are in area`s that will be shutdown for unverified, they will loose my money wich is mostly impulse buy it "empty"
_____________________
Kitty Barnett
Registered User
Join date: 10 May 2006
Posts: 5,586
12-05-2007 18:37
Interestingly:
From: (From Massively - the old Second Life Insider)
Age Verification isn't so much about verifying your age/identity. The company that is operating the service (Aristotle/Integrity) provides a number of identity-related services, but in this case, it appears that the function they're providing is professional insurance against lawsuits. The verification step appears to simply be one of the prerequisites to that insurance. Fundamentally, probably nobody at the business end cares if your information is true or false or belongs to you. Once you enter it, asses are covered.
And on a lighter note, all the people saying that minors would just use their parents' actually gave me a good idea. If I can't get Aristotle/Integrity to acknowledge I exist, I'll ask my mom if she'll try her details the next time I'm over and see if that'll do it :p.
Ceera Murakami
Texture Artist / Builder
Join date: 9 Sep 2005
Posts: 7,750
12-05-2007 18:43
Verified my main and all but one of my alts with no trouble at all, using my real info and last 4 of my SSN. Kept one alt unverified to test access permissions, for now.

However, when viewed with the new RC viewer, all the accounts, the ones I verified and the one I did not, they all say ", Not" after the payment info in their profiles. So apparently it takes a while to get the age verification data in-world? Like more than 3 hours? And despite what the FAQ says, you CAN see someone else's age verification status in an individual's Profile.
_____________________
Sorry, LL won't let me tell you where I sell my textures and where I offer my services as a sim builder. Ask me in-world.
Adz Childs
Artificial Boy
Join date: 6 Apr 2006
Posts: 865
12-05-2007 18:44
Here and in the blog comments i've seen several stories about having to enter in information from years ago. Has it occurred to anyone else that this might be a data mining technique? Think about it... Apparently they have your address from 4 years ago... suppose that cost a certain amount for them to acquire that data, But now, with LL's blessing, and due to your persistent attempts to verify, this company now has on record every place you've lived for the past 4 years. for free. voluntarily.

"rejected" does not mean "discarded."
_____________________
http://slnamewatch.com — Second Life Last Name Tracking — Email Alerts — Famous People Lookup — http://adz.secondlifekid.com/ — Artificial Boy — Personal Blog
From: Tofu Linden
Hmm, there's nothing really helpful there, but thanks for pasting.
Sindy Tsure
Will script for shoes
Join date: 18 Sep 2006
Posts: 4,103
12-05-2007 18:51
From: Ceera Murakami
...when viewed with the new RC viewer, all the accounts, the ones I verified and the one I did not, they all say ", Not" after the payment info in their profiles..

I saw that too and wondered if LL has been watching too much Wayne's World. "Payment info used, Not"!

I've also seen an un-verified move onto a verified-only parcel.. I didn't see them mention it in the blog but I guess nothing's being enforced yet??
Cherry Czervik
Came To Her Senses
Join date: 18 Feb 2006
Posts: 3,680
12-05-2007 19:02
From: Ciaran Laval
Age verification is a good idea, this is a very poor system.

I verified quite early on. I asked the UK Passport office how on earth Integrity Aristotle have got the authority to verify my passport number and the UK passport office told me that they don't have the authority to verify my passport number, that they aren't a partner in any way, shape or form.

They did however say that companies can buy passport checkers that try to check for authority of the document, such as is the number in the right format etc. but as that's a physical check, that's not happening here.

Not that the passport number was an issue anyway, I left that field blank and it happily verified me. So I verified with less information than is required to get payment info used status.

After verifying I received nothing. No email, no letter, nada.

I have no objection to verification but LL have been told plenty of times of the flaws in this system, I expect to see an increase in minors on the grid, who will be verified. It's an easier status to achieve than payment info used and therein lies the biggest flaw of all in this system.

So as a system, this process is hugely flawed in terms of verifying the person going through the process and yet all it needed was a little bit of tweaking, a letter sent to me or a small transaction on my credit card so I have a paper trail.


We've had to use a passport checker at work. It just verifies that the document is genuine, no more no less. I've just tried to verify, no luck.
Qie Niangao
Coin-operated
Join date: 24 May 2006
Posts: 7,138
12-05-2007 19:05
From: Sindy Tsure
I've also seen an un-verified move onto a verified-only parcel.. I didn't see them mention it in the blog but I guess nothing's being enforced yet??
I'd like to know that too: I also couldn't find it in the blog or KB articles. It was the first thing I tried with my unverified alt. But I realized it wasn't a great test because he has an "Owner" role in the group to which the land is deeded. I'm running out of alts to test all the combinations!
Dancien Graves
Not Nice
Join date: 12 Sep 2007
Posts: 111
12-05-2007 19:08
The sky, it falls. RUN RUN!!!


That being said I verified. I have bad credit, please steal my identity and improve it.
Amity Slade
Registered User
Join date: 14 Feb 2007
Posts: 2,183
12-05-2007 19:20
From: Adz Childs
Here and in the blog comments i've seen several stories about having to enter in information from years ago. Has it occurred to anyone else that this might be a data mining technique? Think about it... Apparently they have your address from 4 years ago... suppose that cost a certain amount for them to acquire that data, But now, with LL's blessing, and due to your persistent attempts to verify, this company now has on record every place you've lived for the past 4 years. for free. voluntarily.

"rejected" does not mean "discarded."


I was about to reply that Linden Labs would not do this, but before I did, I checked the TOS.

To paraphrase section 6.1 of the TOS, Linden Labs will not give your personal information to third parties, unless Linden Labs wants to give your personal information to third parties.

I doubt that the process is a disguise for such data collection. But the TOS does not guarantee that Linden Labs will not give information back to the company doing the age verification. That seems to fall under, "reasonably necessary to fulfill your service request, to third- party fulfillment houses, customer support, billing and credit verification services, and the like."

I bet the age verification company would provide a discount to Linden Labs in return for information to add to its databases.

Edit: The FAQ on Age Verification says that the information provided for age verification is not retained by Linden Labs or the company doing the age verification. So I would assume that Linden Labs is being honest here.
Johan Durant
Registered User
Join date: 7 Aug 2006
Posts: 1,657
12-05-2007 19:30
From: Sling Trebuchet

From the Blog:
"Removed the ability to *ban* access to Residents who have provided payment info or who have used payment info. We continue to support the ability to *allow* access to only those who have provided payment info."

Assuming that text is a verbatim copy/paste from the blog, you are reading it wrong. Note that the first part refers to banning residents who HAVE provided payment info. Thus, this isn't a semantic game surrounding one issue, it's two different things talked about in the same sentence.
_____________________
(Aelin 184,194,22)

The Motion Merchant - an animation store specializing in two-person interactions
Vittorio Beerbaum
Sexy.Builder Hot.Scripter
Join date: 16 May 2007
Posts: 516
12-05-2007 19:38
Reading the 50% of replies here i figured that none (of those 50%) really got why this has been introduced. It's not to prevent minors to access to the main grid (as you continue to say: i may get the driver license from my parents.. bla bla bla) but it's to move the rensposability away from LL and land owners whenever a minor is exposed to adult contents.

Without a age verification: LL is on risky, because doesn't have in place a concrete way to identify the age of a person. In lawsuit where a minor may be involved, LL may be condamned because it doesn't have (had) an efficient way to prevent a minor to join the main grid in seconds. On the other side, the land owners, may be on risky as well because the fact that minors aren't allowed on the main grid, isn't enough to be "covered" and assumption: they aren't authorized, so no minors can be be here isn't right for the current law (at least not in USA, were about 2 months ago a guy has been condamned because he meet a girl on a "adult only" network.. when she wasn't (adult)).

With a "strong" age verification (providing a ID): LL and land owners does have no rensponsability if a minor joins the main grid, because they adopted all the methods provided by the law to verify his identity... so the "guilty" would be the person/minor that is "falsificated" a ID (federal crime) or the parents that has no control on their childs (got their ID's "stolen";).

Then again, this is not to prevent childs on SL... this is just to be "safe" when someone gets in: i've asked for his ID / i've flagged my land where only persons that provided a valid ID can join. It's a kind like sell alchool to minors: if you don't ask for a document, you are wrong; if you ask for a document, but it is false, it's not your problem anymore. In both cases the child will buy that bottle of wiskey, but in the first one the shopper would be "outlaw", in the second case the minor is!

Soz about my english... im (indeed) not english, it's 4.37am here (italy).. ah, and age verification doesn't work for me (lol) both with identity card and driving license. :)
Susie Boffin
Certified Nutcase
Join date: 15 Sep 2004
Posts: 2,151
12-05-2007 19:41
I won't have anything to do with this publicity stunt scam which is all it is. It looks like I will be having martial relations with my unverified partner fully clothed or out back in the outhouse on our unverified land like our forefathers did.

The fact that we know one another in first life doesn't count since we will both be unverified.

Oh and one more thing I just thought of. My plan is to ban all verified users from my land as I assume the only reason they got verified is 1) they fell for the LL scam or 2) they want to be verified as official purveyors of pornography. Either way I don't want them anyway near me.
_____________________
"If you see a man approaching you with the obvious intent of doing you good, you should run for your life." - Henry David Thoreau
Tarina Sewell
Just Browsing Thank you
Join date: 20 Jul 2007
Posts: 2,180
12-05-2007 19:53
From: Vittorio Beerbaum
Reading the 50% of replies here i figured that none (of those 50%) really got why this has been introduced. It's not to prevent minors to access to the main grid (as you continue to say: i may get the driver license from my parents.. bla bla bla) but it's to move the rensposability away from LL and land owners whenever a minor is exposed to adult contents.

Without a age verification: LL is on risky, because doesn't have in place a concrete way to identify the age of a person. In lawsuit where a minor may be involved, LL may be condamned because it doesn't have (had) an efficient way to prevent a minor to join the main grid in seconds. On the other side, the land owners, may be on risky as well because the fact that minors aren't allowed on the main grid, isn't enough to be "covered" and assumption: they aren't authorized, so no minors can be be here isn't right for the current law (at least not in USA, were about 2 months ago a guy has been condamned because he meet a girl on a "adult only" network.. when she wasn't (adult)).

With a "strong" age verification (providing a ID): LL and land owners does have no rensponsability if a minor joins the main grid, because they adopted all the methods provided by the law to verify his identity... so the "guilty" would be the person/minor that is "falsificated" a ID (federal crime) or the parents that has no control on their childs (got their ID's "stolen";).

Then again, this is not to prevent childs on SL... this is just to be "safe" when someone gets in: i've asked for his ID / i've flagged my land where only persons that provided a valid ID can join. It's a kind like sell alchool to minors: if you don't ask for a document, you are wrong; if you ask for a document, but it is false, it's not your problem anymore. In both cases the child will buy that bottle of wiskey, but in the first one the shopper would be "outlaw", in the second case the minor is!

Soz about my english... im (indeed) not english, it's 4.37am here (italy).. ah, and age verification doesn't work for me (lol) both with identity card and driving license. :)


hmmm...... the seller of the whisky is not off the hook if the minor provides a fake ID.
Tarina Sewell
Just Browsing Thank you
Join date: 20 Jul 2007
Posts: 2,180
12-05-2007 19:59
From: Dancien Graves
The sky, it falls. RUN RUN!!!


That being said I verified. I have bad credit, please steal my identity and improve it.


hmm....
ZeeScarlet Zenovka
Registered User
Join date: 11 Jul 2007
Posts: 26
Wtf!
12-05-2007 20:14
Okay...so I was actually excited about this age verification business.

I went in..first I tried my driver liscence..no good.

Tried the last 4 of my ssn no good.

Kept saying..maybe your address and or name has changed in the last 18 months?

I got married and moved FOUR years ago?..Are you kidding..I don't remember my old address.

Please tell me this is just a beta issue.
Tod69 Talamasca
The Human Tripod ;)
Join date: 20 Sep 2005
Posts: 4,107
12-05-2007 20:29
From: Sunni Jewell
It's only the last 4 numbers, actually. I just verified with no problem, but obviously some people are having a problem with it. Good luck, everyone!


ID Theifs can use those last 4 digits to their hearts content. ;)

I dont trust these methods they're coming up with.

In this day an age of ID Theft, LL really should consider a better alternative.
_____________________
really pissy & mean right now and NOT happy with Life.
Tod69 Talamasca
The Human Tripod ;)
Join date: 20 Sep 2005
Posts: 4,107
12-05-2007 20:32
From: Dancien Graves
The sky, it falls. RUN RUN!!!


That being said I verified. I have bad credit, please steal my identity and improve it.


That or use it to commit terrorist acts in other countries.
_____________________
really pissy & mean right now and NOT happy with Life.
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 ... 13