Upcoming Changes for Adult Content: Answers to Questions
|
Argent Stonecutter
Emergency Mustelid
Join date: 20 Sep 2005
Posts: 20,263
|
04-06-2009 06:48
From: Andiez Smythe I can't find it at this time but I'm pretty much certain that it has been stated that if you point to it on the parcel then that determines that parcel's classification. That seems to me to include such things as signs, teleporters and indeed search terms. If you have a big sign that says "SEX R US" or you've listed it as "BDSM SEX BRING UR OWN PRIM DONG" then you're probably going to be seen as an adult business. That's not the same as saying that if you have it listed as "Andiez Smythe's Beautiful Home" and have it listed in Search under "residences" you're going to be tossed over the big wall. Then there's the people who have "Joe's Flower Shop" at ground level and their house 3km in the air. I've been waiting for a Linden word on *that* for almost a week.
|
Lord Sullivan
DTC at all times :)
Join date: 15 Dec 2005
Posts: 2,870
|
04-06-2009 06:49
From: Argent Stonecutter Cite please. I've seen several OTHER people saying that's what the policy SHOULD be, but I haven't seen Blondin come out and say that just listing in search is a litmus test. Post #130 Blondin Linden From: someone 2) Some Linden's have suggested that only locations intended for "public" use with "adult" content need to move to the adult continent. Is this the case? If so what is meant by "public"? ANSWER: Public would mean a build on the mainland that is intended to draw and host Resident traffic in such a way as to make it more of a venue than a residence designed for individual enjoyment. That said, mainland locations that have adult content on them may wish to consider a move to the adult continent, because that is where the adults will be. Residents who are interested in adult content will be looking there. Adult content can not be advertised on non-Adult land, so if you want your content found, it needs to be on adult land. Post #605 Morganna Was a question from Morganna where she specifically asked From: someone Specific case related to the above quote which I hope will receive a specific response:
I own 1/4 Mature mainland sim which is my home and my Haven. I enjoy opening my gardens to vistors (much like great houses in Europe) so my land was listed in Search and once a month I hosted a Blood Ball which was advertised in the Events. I had also planned to hold a monthly BDSM munch which is social meet 'n greet event.
As I am a Vampyre Domme my gardens have all the expected Gothic ambiance with a dance floor, loaded Intan balls, sex coffins, blood pools with sex animations and quality BDSM toys among the black roses, trees, gazebos and shadows...on the ground. I do NOT do skyboxes <shudders>.
I have 40m walls bordering the 2 external sides of the sim but not the internal sides as this is not necessary as our extended RW "family" of approximately 25 people owns the entire sim. We purposely bought a full sim so that everyone in the Evoco family could do their own "thing" which currently involves a punk grunge club, an otaku hangout, a sandbox and The Insane Asylum which is the home base for the "homeless" members to change clothes, open boxes and so on...
This WAS my home and my INDIVIDUAL ENJOYMENT came from sharing it with like minded avatars in the SL community. At no time was it intended, used or viewed as a VENUE. I like decorating it, landscaping it and knowing that when I'm not there that others are strolling in the moonlight, playing in the graveyard or wasting time with the Lament Trivia cube. I was looking forward to adding a 7Seas fishing area with a rickety docks and sharks...
All of that came to a screeching halt when this pronouncment was posted on the blog and remains on hold until I have a clear answer to my two questions...
1. Will I be allowed to reopen my gardens, list it in Search under Mature and host Mature events once or twice a month as before?
2. If the answer is No then am I still "allowed" to have my sex gen items and BDSM toys in my gardens for my own use? Not everyone enjoys sex indoors, in a skybox or in a dungeon setting. I personally find most dungeons, RL and SL, to be claustrophobic, constraining and generic in decor/amostphere. I think that based on what Blondin said then she would be under the move as she advertises events albeit once or twice a month and has the place open to the public access with toys available, if not i need to re arrange our sim so that we are not included as well as clearly there is a way round the new rules as they stand 
_____________________
Independent Shopping for Second Life residents from established and new merchants. http://slapt.me  slapt.me - In-World HQ http://slurl.com/secondlife/Bastet/123/118/26
|
Lindal Kidd
Dances With Noobs
Join date: 26 Jun 2007
Posts: 8,371
|
04-06-2009 06:52
From: Alexander Harbrough ...In theory, a main purpose of this thread was to discuss what the definition of adult should be and why, but the majority of discussion has been people digging up any arguement they can think of, no matter how far fetched, to say why this should not be done at all.
And then people wonder why threads like this get shut down.
Not everyone has been like that.. there has been some constructive discussion and some legitimate criticism, but it gets buried amidst all the naysaying. Well, look. If somebody came to you and said, "I have this plan to drive to the Moon in my Honda Civic. Do you have a roadmap I can borrow?" you wouldn't haul out your atlas and start comparing alternate routes. No, you'd say, "That's crazy talk. You can't get to the Moon that way." LL's GOAL to achieve a more "predictable, enjoyable Second Life experience for everyone" is a good one, and we'd be happy to discuss it. Their PLAN is as flawed as trying to use a car for a spaceship. It will NOT achieve the stated goal. So...either the real goal is a very different one (hence all the conspiracy theories and speculation), or we should be talking about how to build a spaceship instead of how to fold the map.
_____________________
It's still My World and My Imagination! So there. Lindal Kidd
|
Argent Stonecutter
Emergency Mustelid
Join date: 20 Sep 2005
Posts: 20,263
|
04-06-2009 06:57
From: Alexander Harbrough (And no offense to any actual weasels listening  ) Thanks for that!  http://animals.nationalgeographic.com/staticfiles/NGS/Shared/StaticFiles/animals/images/primary/black-footed-ferret.jpg[/img]
|
Alexander Harbrough
Registered User
Join date: 22 Feb 2009
Posts: 601
|
04-06-2009 06:58
From: Lord Sullivan LOL i will be interested to see if you do get get a move there, as that will prove just how open to abuse this whole situation is for the genuine adult venues that have no option but to move or not as the case my be  Actually if they did not offer the move to all existing land owners regardless of current content it may be seen as a legal issue. In other words, require people to move based on content, but give those who do not have adult content the option of moving. That possibility is pure speculation on my part, though.
|
Ceera Murakami
Texture Artist / Builder
Join date: 9 Sep 2005
Posts: 7,750
|
04-06-2009 06:58
From: Alexander Harbrough If you are having BDSM events at your home that you publicly advertize, that is not exactly a white pages listing, is it? The thing is, it could be ANY sort of advertized event or activity or place at your home that could be a problem, not just a kinky orgy. A business office. An art gallery display that is strictly PG... Anything. Example: My home is a beautiful castle, and well-landscaped lands, on 1/4 of a private island sim. My sim building and terraforming business has an office in the ground floor of that castle. There also happen to be sex beds in several rooms of the castle, and a dungeon in the basement, and a neighbor has an outdoor sex-themed area. If I have a client over to look at the examples of my building and terraforming skills, I am not going to be inviting them to make use of the sex toys there, any more than a merchant on main street USA who lives in an apartment over their grocery store is going to be asking a customer to "come upstairs for a Quickie" when they buy a quart of milk. Yet based on LL's currently vague rulings, I can't advertize my terraforming business with an ad that refers to any place on my quarter-sim parcel, because there happens to be maybe 5% of that area that is a "sex themed area". Even if I set up access controls and security orbs to prevent a guest from entering ANY of the sex themed areas without explicit permission, my whole sim would have to flag as Adult if I had even a single ad that mentioned my business office! As it happens, I don't choose to advertize that way. I get enough business on word-of-mouth referrals from happy clients and on repeat business from past clients that I don't NEED to advertize my business. But my example still shows a critical flaw in how LL is talking about categorizing mixed-use parcels that have any adult content in them.
_____________________
Sorry, LL won't let me tell you where I sell my textures and where I offer my services as a sim builder. Ask me in-world.
|
Lindal Kidd
Dances With Noobs
Join date: 26 Jun 2007
Posts: 8,371
|
04-06-2009 06:59
From: Qie Niangao Okay, so I've pr0n'd-up some parcels on three different sims, scummified their descriptions, IDV-restricted their access, and listed them in Search. Now I'm waiting. I don't know nor particularly care to learn just now how to make money on Adult Content, so they're not even paying back their parcel listing fees--to say nothing of tier--from commission sales on a few sleazy affiliate vendors and one slightly racy product of my own. So I'm eager that they hurry up and qualify for the move to Ursula.
Any word on when the list of to-be-migrated parcels will get established? Can I hire you to nasty up my land? I thought about doing just that, but I quickly realized 1) I don't have low enough imagination 2) I don't have the necessary Really Racy Stuff in my inventory 3) I'm too fond of my own build to scuzz it up myself. I need a Professional!  And I can't afford Ceera. 
_____________________
It's still My World and My Imagination! So there. Lindal Kidd
|
Argent Stonecutter
Emergency Mustelid
Join date: 20 Sep 2005
Posts: 20,263
|
04-06-2009 07:03
From: Lord Sullivan I think that based on what Blondin said then she would be under the move as she advertises events albeit once or twice a month and has the place open to the public access with toys available, if not i need to re arrange our sim so that we are not included as well as clearly there is a way round the new rules as they stand  I'm familiar with both texts you quoted. Be that as it may, "listing your land as a place to have sex" is not the same as "listing your land in search and having a sex bed on it".
|
Argent Stonecutter
Emergency Mustelid
Join date: 20 Sep 2005
Posts: 20,263
|
04-06-2009 07:06
From: Lindal Kidd Well, look. If somebody came to you and said, "I have this plan to drive to the Moon in my Honda Civic. Do you have a roadmap I can borrow?" you wouldn't haul out your atlas and start comparing alternate routes. No, you'd say, "That's crazy talk. You can't get to the Moon that way." 
|
Alexander Harbrough
Registered User
Join date: 22 Feb 2009
Posts: 601
|
04-06-2009 07:07
From: Ceera Murakami I agree that there should be a way in Preferences to explicitly opt OUT of accidentally accessing the XXX Extreme sims. Likewise there should be a way to lock out access to combat sims and damage-enabled areas. Two separate flags. Or three, if you also want an "I only want access to PG-rated sims and parcels" option.
Or a warning with a 'do you want to continue' whenever porting from a non-ursula im to an ursula sim, with an option to turn those warnings off. I do not know of any combat or damage enabled sims that do not have safe landing areas that automaticly offer you a notecard warning you what you are in for if you step out of the landing area though, so I do not think they need a separate flag. The main point to age verification is not to keep those who voluntarily wish to screen themselves out.. those people can do so on their own without having to verify anything. It is to reduce access to the underaged.
|
Ceera Murakami
Texture Artist / Builder
Join date: 9 Sep 2005
Posts: 7,750
|
04-06-2009 07:09
From: Lindal Kidd Can I hire you to nasty up my land? I thought about doing just that, but I quickly realized 1) I don't have low enough imagination 2) I don't have the necessary Really Racy Stuff in my inventory 3) I'm too fond of my own build to scuzz it up myself. I need a Professional!  And I can't afford Ceera.  Lindal, dear, for you I am sure I could work out a very affordable rate. 
_____________________
Sorry, LL won't let me tell you where I sell my textures and where I offer my services as a sim builder. Ask me in-world.
|
Waterstar Eilde
Registered User
Join date: 12 May 2007
Posts: 404
|
04-06-2009 07:09
From: Lindal Kidd Well, look. If somebody came to you and said, "I have this plan to drive to the Moon in my Honda Civic. Do you have a roadmap I can borrow?" you wouldn't haul out your atlas and start comparing alternate routes. No, you'd say, "That's crazy talk. You can't get to the Moon that way."
LL's GOAL to achieve a more "predictable, enjoyable Second Life experience for everyone" is a good one, and we'd be happy to discuss it. Their PLAN is as flawed as trying to use a car for a spaceship.
It will NOT achieve the stated goal. So...either the real goal is a very different one (hence all the conspiracy theories and speculation), or we should be talking about how to build a spaceship instead of how to fold the map. Great analogy Lindal! 
|
Argent Stonecutter
Emergency Mustelid
Join date: 20 Sep 2005
Posts: 20,263
|
04-06-2009 07:11
From: Ceera Murakami Yet based on LL's currently vague rulings, I can't advertize my terraforming business with an ad that refers to any place on my quarter-sim parcel, because there happens to be maybe 5% of that area that is a "sex themed area". Even if I set up access controls and security orbs to prevent a guest from entering ANY of the sex themed areas without explicit permission, my whole sim would have to flag as Adult if I had even a single ad that mentioned my business office! Based on what Linden Labs is saying, it wouldn't matter whether you advertised your parcel in search or with a sign on the land or in your picks, IF YOU WERE ADVERTISING SEX. He hasn't said anything about advertising that doesn't mention naughtiness. The question of whether any listing in search (or any other indication that there was a business of any kind on the parcel) rules out any kind of explicit sexually oriented material on the parcel is one that has not been answered, even vaguely. And it needs to be.
|
Argent Stonecutter
Emergency Mustelid
Join date: 20 Sep 2005
Posts: 20,263
|
04-06-2009 07:13
From: Alexander Harbrough The main point to age verification is not to keep those who voluntarily wish to screen themselves out.. those people can do so on their own without having to verify anything.
It is to reduce access to the underaged. Then they should be carding everyone. No more NPIOF accounts.
|
Blondin Linden
Linden Lab Employee
Join date: 2 Jun 2008
Posts: 381
|
04-06-2009 07:18
From: Sadako Shikami question 1: when you say "without incurring fees" do you mean that the new swapped adult land will be free of charge to the land owner? (i understand that tier will not be charged twice.) specifically speaking of the case of an owner of a parcel or parcels: will the new swapped land be free of charge, or will the land owner need to purchase the parcels from 1) Linden Labs, or 2) a person who has already purchased the entire sim?
question 2: can i have a Linden personally come to my place of business and check it out with me, and give me advice as to whether i'll *have* to move? i believe my group's parcels belong on Mature land, since any adult content is not easy to reach unless a person is *trying* to get inside. who should i contact for a feedback session on my club?
thank you, i hope for a response to these 2 vital questions. ?1 - The land will be exchanged and you wouldn't be paying any more for an adult continent parcel then you would be on the mainland. ?2 - Sure, send me a notecard and and a LM and Ill pop over.
|
Alexander Harbrough
Registered User
Join date: 22 Feb 2009
Posts: 601
|
04-06-2009 07:18
From: Lindal Kidd Well, look. If somebody came to you and said, "I have this plan to drive to the Moon in my Honda Civic. Do you have a roadmap I can borrow?" you wouldn't haul out your atlas and start comparing alternate routes. No, you'd say, "That's crazy talk. You can't get to the Moon that way."
LL's GOAL to achieve a more "predictable, enjoyable Second Life experience for everyone" is a good one, and we'd be happy to discuss it. Their PLAN is as flawed as trying to use a car for a spaceship.
It will NOT achieve the stated goal. So...either the real goal is a very different one (hence all the conspiracy theories and speculation), or we should be talking about how to build a spaceship instead of how to fold the map. Bad analogy. In this case the moon (adult content online) has been reached. The goal is to limit access to it. What part of this plan is not feasable? And even if you argue that does not achieve a more predictable enjoyable second life experience for everyone' if this results in a more predictable and enjoyable experience for the majority of users now *and in the future* then is it a bad plan? Note that if that is the main intent, then the very goal is impossible. No change will please 'everyone.' That does not mean that change is not good. There are valid reasons to put such limits in place. The fact that you dislike them or that those reasons are not the reason LL states as their primary reason does not change the fact that there are valid reasons to put such limits in place. If they do the right thing for the wrong reasons, they are still doing the right thing.
|
Alexander Harbrough
Registered User
Join date: 22 Feb 2009
Posts: 601
|
04-06-2009 07:20
From: Argent Stonecutter Thanks for that!  http://animals.nationalgeographic.com/staticfiles/NGS/Shared/StaticFiles/animals/images/primary/black-footed-ferret.jpg [/img] <purrs>
|
Ceera Murakami
Texture Artist / Builder
Join date: 9 Sep 2005
Posts: 7,750
|
04-06-2009 07:21
From: Alexander Harbrough Or a warning with a 'do you want to continue' whenever porting from a non-ursula im to an ursula sim, with an option to turn those warnings off.
I do not know of any combat or damage enabled sims that do not have safe landing areas that automaticly offer you a notecard warning you what you are in for if you step out of the landing area though, so I do not think they need a separate flag. Yes, precisely. If you haven't explicitly opted in or out, then trying to TP to Ursula or to any Adults Only flagged sim should trigger a dialog asking if you are willing to be exposed to XXX content. Saying Yes prevents future pop-ups, saying No denies the TP, and you stay where you are, and there should also be an option for "Yes, one-time-only", so you can look without changing your default. The popup would happen again at every sim crossing and every attempt to TP to an Adult sim until you chose either Yes or No. Naturally, if you don't meet the age verification or payment requirement, saying "Yes" would direct you to information on how to get approved for access. As for damage areas, The LL-owned combat sims, Jessie and Rausch, have no "safe zones", to my knowledge. We used to see lots of complaints from people doing a TP to either sim and getting shot/killed/TP'ed home before the sim had even fully rezzed for them. And I have lost track of how many times I have tried to TP to a store I wasn't familiar with, or was flying across an open expanse of land, and suddenly noticed the damage-enabled indicator popping up on my screen. (At which point I immediately TP home, and mark that location mentally as one never to return to.)
_____________________
Sorry, LL won't let me tell you where I sell my textures and where I offer my services as a sim builder. Ask me in-world.
|
Blondin Linden
Linden Lab Employee
Join date: 2 Jun 2008
Posts: 381
|
04-06-2009 07:21
From: Sindy Tsure Blondin, will LL be sending our payment info to the age/identity verification service? You mean if you already have it on file? I THINK that if we already have that info, then we don't have to do anything and you are good to go.
|
Alexander Harbrough
Registered User
Join date: 22 Feb 2009
Posts: 601
|
04-06-2009 07:26
From: Ceera Murakami The thing is, it could be ANY sort of advertized event or activity or place at your home that could be a problem, not just a kinky orgy. A business office. An art gallery display that is strictly PG... Anything. From: someone
Pardon, but how would 'BDSM' get into your listing or event ad unless you put it there?
As for the rest of it, that should not be actionable and should not be considered non-residential since you have taken reasonable precautions to limit the view and otherwise keep people out of the private areas.
That is one of the reasons that I prefer RL definitions over trying to come up with a list... too many situations like that where a list can catch false positives.
It is also a good reason for 3 linden tribunals deciding these things rather than individual lindens.. you get better consistancy in the results.
|
Waterstar Eilde
Registered User
Join date: 12 May 2007
Posts: 404
|
04-06-2009 07:29
From: Blondin Linden You mean if you already have it on file? I THINK that if we already have that info, then we don't have to do anything and you are good to go. Poor Blondin - they put you in charge of answering our questions, but don't even give YOU definitive information to pass on??? That's a bit rough - I hope you have a good sense of humour! Thanks at least for being game to have a go 
|
Alexander Harbrough
Registered User
Join date: 22 Feb 2009
Posts: 601
|
04-06-2009 07:29
From: Argent Stonecutter Then they should be carding everyone. No more NPIOF accounts. I agree. May teens these days have their own credit cards and a lot of disposable income (you do not need a great job when living at home with negligible expenses).
|
Argent Stonecutter
Emergency Mustelid
Join date: 20 Sep 2005
Posts: 20,263
|
04-06-2009 07:32
From: Alexander Harbrough As for the rest of it, that should not be actionable and should not be considered non-residential since you have taken reasonable precautions to limit the view and otherwise keep people out of the private areas. Which is why it would be nice if Blondin were to come up with a "yea" or "nay" on the whole "residence above the shop" issue.
|
Alexander Harbrough
Registered User
Join date: 22 Feb 2009
Posts: 601
|
04-06-2009 07:32
From: Ceera Murakami As for damage areas, The LL-owned combat sims, Jessie and Rausch, have no "safe zones", to my knowledge. We used to see lots of complaints from people doing a TP to either sim and getting shot/killed/TP'ed home before the sim had even fully rezzed for them. And I have lost track of how many times I have tried to TP to a store I wasn't familiar with, or was flying across an open expanse of land, and suddenly noticed the damage-enabled indicator popping up on my screen. (At which point I immediately TP home, and mark that location mentally as one never to return to.)
They should change that. Even for those who wish to participate safe zones are important for precisely that reason. What is the point of the sim if you cannot even get into it safely?
|
Ceera Murakami
Texture Artist / Builder
Join date: 9 Sep 2005
Posts: 7,750
|
04-06-2009 07:33
/352/11/314444/47.html#post2381628Blondin: Please read and respond to my post (link above) regarding instances where a Non-adult business is on a parcel that also includes a private residence with sex-themed content. If the business has its space in part of the same structure as the home, and the business has NOTHING to do with use of the adult content that is there for the residents use, would that business be allowed to advertize its location? Or would that cause the sim to have to flag as Adult? Assume for simplicity's sake that if the same site was advertising the use of the sexual facilities there, it would get flagged as an "Adult public venue". But in this case, the sex is NOT for the public. The sex areas are part of the residence, and locked behind security-orb controlled areas.
_____________________
Sorry, LL won't let me tell you where I sell my textures and where I offer my services as a sim builder. Ask me in-world.
|