Feedback on Ad Farm post
|
Dytska Vieria
+/- .00004™
Join date: 13 Dec 2006
Posts: 768
|
09-08-2008 11:54
From: ROBO Marx First off I dont waste my time cratering plots and I rarely level them off after people raise their property around it.(hmmm) If you wanted to buy the piece to run a sucessful advertising network, I would suspect that you would pay that much or more considering the future profit potential. Otherwise just leave it there until an advertiser does buy it.
****Better get a license first!
ROBO Actually, Robo, I noted in a 'memo to self' that at the same time you cratered that parcel, you also put up ban lines! I was so amazed as you had been such a good neighbor up until that time.
_____________________
+/- 0.00004
|
Carl Metropolitan
Registered User
Join date: 7 Jul 2005
Posts: 1,031
|
09-08-2008 11:54
From: Florencio Paulino Hey Carl, that was very interesting. Were you able to dig up any more on this? Its interesting to read everybody's opinions on what LL should and shouldn't do...but ultimately we have to see what LL takes away from it all and ends up doing. Do you know where we could get any more "official" info on this? These are NOT Linden Lab's proposed requirements. They are my suggestions for licensing requirements. I'm sorry if my initial post was not clear.
|
Joshua Philgarlic
SLinside.com
Join date: 29 Jan 2007
Posts: 143
|
09-08-2008 11:56
From: ROBO Marx First off I dont waste my time cratering plots and I rarely level them off after people raise their property around it.(hmmm) If you wanted to buy the piece to run a sucessful advertising network, I would suspect that you would pay that much or more considering the future profit potential. Otherwise just leave it there until an advertiser does buy it. It's a hole without any doubt: 
|
Sindy Tsure
Will script for shoes
Join date: 18 Sep 2006
Posts: 4,103
|
09-08-2008 11:59
Is it me or is Joshua nekkid in that picture?
|
ROBO Marx
Registered User
Join date: 26 Apr 2006
Posts: 54
|
Hey TL howd it feel when LL devalued all your Estates $600. Same thing here!
09-08-2008 11:59
From: Talarus Luan I'm sorry, but running empty auction websites and morally bankrupt virtual real estate and casino scam operations don't qualify as "businesses". No, the word "golddigger" comes to mind, actually. RL companies have already come.. and gone. People don't want their adspam any more than they want yours. Oh, I am sure that there is some starry-eyed sucker business out there who can be sold a worthless bill of goods like that, but you're going to be waiting a LONG time to find them. I am afraid the concept is too pathetic for laughter. More just slowly shake my head and walk away. It's not even in the same ballpark as someone decrying a virtual world. At least people WANT a virtual world. What was denied was that it could be done in a useful and sustainable way. I'm afraid no one is going to see SL as an advertising venue worthy of the money put into the SuperBowl. Just isn't going to happen. Hell, if it was going to, it would have already. Yeah, that's the problem Robo. You see people as "chumps" to line your pockets with "change". As far as the ads increasing business, I didn't see any statistics in what he said, just "sales went up", but by what percentage, compared to classifieds, affiliate network ads, Search, SLX ads, etc. Hardly a scientific analysis of their effectiveness. If I sell 100 products a month, put up 10 microparcel ads, and sales go up to 102 products a month, that's hardly above a statistical noise level. Plenty of others who realize that SL is a perfect playground for golddiggers? Probably. You get joked on in blogs because your attitude and actions betray your true intentions and motivations, which ARE truly pathetic. I have no idea what Praetor Janus, Desmond Shang, Bart Heart, or Anshe Chung makes on their estate businesses, but I will bet my fangs that it is a HELL of a lot more than you ever have. At least their businesses are REAL businesses. You can make the same money off of destroying other people's property values, view, and land, harassing them to the point of buying your overpriced plots? You mean that CRIME REALLY DOES PAY??? Wow! Who'da thunk it? Robo, the adfarmer business model is OVER. DONE. FINITE. Stick a fork in it and focus on doing something constructive with your life for a change. Or don't. I really don't care one way or another. However, we're not going to let LL continue to allow you to ruin SL for the rest of us no matter how much you kick, scream, whine, complain, or try to sell yourself as "legitimate". You and the rest of the parasites out there. If that means you will end up permabanned someday, hey, no scales off my back. Oh please. In the height of your day, before the February policy, you had one of your SLBayAuction towers on EVERY 16 in sight. In my sim alone, you had more than 10 of the damn things. Don't even TRY to whitewash your past. Read: "I'm looking for any loophole I think I can get away with to keep business as usual."  If that "neighbor" (and I use that term loosely, as someone who has a microplot, especially one that is grossly overpriced, is NOT my "neighbor"  has that plot there in a strategically awkward place for my home or business, and it serves no other purpose for being there, then that plot should be removed by the Lindens. Neighbors don't look to extort and harass one another. It is one thing to have a REAL plot, one which has a home or business on it, one which has a REAL purpose, and price it to sell at some ridiculous price. It is a COMPLETLY different thing for someone to have a microplot, which serves no purpose other than obstruct people (via banlines and being cut out of a rectangular plot, esp as a donut hole), harass people (via exceptionally spammy adtowers), or otherwise extort people. As an Estate Manager, I would never allow such a travesty to begin with. You misuse the land (or abuse your neighbors) like that, I would repossess your land and either give it, or sell it at market value to the neighbors to reclaim and warning you to NEVER do it again. If you did it again, you'd be banned from the estate in perpetuity. As I pointed out above, when it comes to land with a REAL purpose, I don't care what they set their price at. However, some microplot which SPECIFICALLY has been cut and placed strategically to harass, extort, or obstruct the neighbors needs to go away, and the people who make them need to go away, too. You’ll understand what s going on here soon TL. Keep running those estates at $25 a month profit each, while LL devalues them to nothing. You know you can buy a whole region on open simulator for $89.(including 1st month tier) What will people do when they can tp from VW to VW. Certainly not pay $1000 for a private SL estate! SL will flourish and you estate owners will be probably be crushed , all while working for almost free now! That’s a great business model, do all LL work for less money. The connection of virtual worlds will basically make SL ML the hub. Their main objective will be to build registered users, so that there advertising value increases. *****Take note when most websites are bought its due to traffic not due to how great they claim to be. Why you ask? Because all those users equal future advertising revenue. No wonder I have you muted! Robo
|
Carl Metropolitan
Registered User
Join date: 7 Jul 2005
Posts: 1,031
|
09-08-2008 12:00
From: ROBO Marx 1 Ad per sim per company or avatar, that simple. Do you really think we are that stupid?
|
Talarus Luan
Ancient Archaean Dragon
Join date: 18 Mar 2006
Posts: 4,831
|
09-08-2008 12:03
From: Dora Gustafson There are two ways to change the behavior of the crowd, one is by punishing unwanted behavior and the other is by rewarding desired behavior. The problem is that we are talking about behavior here. There is no mechanical or technical way to measure "good" behavior against "bad" behavior, at least that can't be gamed horribly. I mean, look at the traffic statistic for an example. Generally, good behavior rewards itself, where bad behavior is rewarded through practice by others, unwitting or not. If you help an old lady across the street, there's no one there to pay you for doing that. The reward is knowing you did a good deed, and the smile and thanks you get from the old lady. If instead you trip her up or knock her down in your hurried attempt to get across the street, where's the automatic punishment? Someone has to chase you down and beat your sorry face in, or arrest you for assault or whatever. No matter what, it is a lot of effort to actually reward or punish for behavior.
|
Proxima Saenz
Registered User
Join date: 22 Jun 2008
Posts: 107
|
09-08-2008 12:05
I have a solution.. Why not change the SL vieuwe a little. So when you MUTE an object, it becomes invissible?? Like Alpha Textures..??
So if ads annoy you, you just mute them.. and you dont see them anymore!
This is a cheaper solution for LL and for all the residents of SL.
|
Shimada Yoshikawa
Registered User
Join date: 9 Mar 2007
Posts: 76
|
Enforcement will be hard
09-08-2008 12:05
There are so many ways this can be "loopholed" by ad farmers that it's probably going to take some trial and error, as well as adjustments to the rules to get it right.
I would be more than willing to help LL find a solution to this problem that benefits everyone. I'm offering my consulting services for free if it will help beautify the mainland and stop microparcel extortion once and for all.
Just as states and towns have local ordinances, I'm sure something similar could be worked out in SL. Limiting billboard height and distance from protected Linden land (road or water) is one way. One uniform, Linden approved ad banner is another way (it could easily be issued with the license and be made in several sizes). Create "Advertising zones" in sims that have more than 50% business owned parcels, and ban advertising in "Residential Areas" where commercial activity is below 25%. Everything that falls in the middle can be handled on a case by case basis.
Advertising works, but it has to be done in a responsible way, just like RL. I don't keep stats on my sales increases after using billboards, but it was roughly a 5000 to 10,000$L difference per week from using a half dozen roadside billboards. I have met some Ad Network owners who actually keep stats on the sales using scripted banners. I'll see if I can get one to come join the discussion. I think their feedback would be helpful.
|
Kara Spengler
Pink Cat
Join date: 11 Jun 2007
Posts: 1,227
|
09-08-2008 12:06
From: Proxima Saenz We are not in your Spelling contest!!
Lu^H^HProxima- It is a valid technique for determining who is who is a conversation (and pretty important when a debate may or may not include alts). Looking at word usages and errors is almost akin to biometric analysis for the purpose of assigning probabilities of who wrote something.
|
Frame Go
Registered User
Join date: 29 Oct 2006
Posts: 1
|
It may end...
09-08-2008 12:11
.. as long as fools click on ad's (same like spam mails) and money (more or less *g*) can be made by this: so long this ugly annoying things will continue to exist. Independend which kind of reality (SL or RL).
The easiest and fastest way to get rid of this ads is: DO NOT TOUCH THEM!
Everybody can support by passing this "information" on to other ppl (i.e. newbies).
|
Kara Spengler
Pink Cat
Join date: 11 Jun 2007
Posts: 1,227
|
09-08-2008 12:15
From: ROBO Marx Its the model I stick too in SL that has helped to propel my business, how’s your business doing here? I guess you didn’t advertise. Actually robo, I do not advertise and my 'business model' is doing pretty well thank you. When I build something in SL I freely give it away (and with full privs). Since you do not create at all I am guessing that is a completely foreign idea to you. I believe strongly in Karma. If people appreciate the creation that is payment in itself. If they say so, even better. If they offer me ideas/advice for improving it, even better. If I ever do get into the business of selling my content I know I would be starting from a point of already having generated good will before I opened the doors on the store.
|
Talarus Luan
Ancient Archaean Dragon
Join date: 18 Mar 2006
Posts: 4,831
|
09-08-2008 12:16
From: ROBO Marx Thumbs down Hey TL howd it feel when LL devalued all your Estates $600. Same thing here! Personally, I loved it. Made buying new regions and expanding so much cheaper.  The only people worried about "devaluation" from prices going down are those who were only looking to make a buck by flipping regions. The rest of us, who USE our regions to conduct business were not bothered in the least. We loved it. From: someone You’ll understand what s going on here soon TL. Keep running those estates at $25 a month profit each, while LL devalues them to nothing. We make a LOT more than $25/mo, I am happy to say.  From: someone You know you can buy a whole region on open simulator for $89.(including 1st month tier) So? OS sims aren't competitive against full sims. I would never run events or any kind of scripted business in an OS sim. They are FAR too laggy and variable for me to trust. I realize that some folks don't agree, but experience is the best teacher. From: someone What will people do when they can tp from VW to VW. Certainly not pay $1000 for a private SL estate! SL will flourish and you estate owners will be probably be crushed , all while working for almost free now! That’s a great business model, do all LL work for less money. The connection of virtual worlds will basically make SL ML the hub. Their main objective will be to build registered users, so that there advertising value increases. Why, we'll have a presence in those Virtual Worlds, too, of course.  As long as the SL estate pays its bills and makes money, we'll have it. When it ceases to do so, we'll move on. No smart businessperson sticks around where there is no money to be made. From: someone *****Take note when most websites are bought its due to traffic not due to how great they claim to be. Why you ask? Because all those users equal future advertising revenue. So, when is slbayauctions going up for sale? That is a sure winner!  From: someone No wonder I have you muted! I'm crushed, truly. 
|
Drongle McMahon
Older than he looks
Join date: 22 Jun 2007
Posts: 494
|
09-08-2008 12:22
From: Proxima Saenz I have a solution.. Why not change the SL vieuwe a little. So when you MUTE an object, it becomes invissible?? Like Alpha Textures..?? So if ads annoy you, you just mute them.. and you dont see them anymore! This is a cheaper solution for LL and for all the residents of SL. And you can actually vote for it ... http://jira.secondlife.com/browse/VWR-1017
|
Talarus Luan
Ancient Archaean Dragon
Join date: 18 Mar 2006
Posts: 4,831
|
09-08-2008 12:25
From: Shimada Yoshikawa Advertising works, but it has to be done in a responsible way, just like RL. I don't keep stats on my sales increases after using billboards, but it was roughly a 5000 to 10,000$L difference per week from using a half dozen roadside billboards. I have met some Ad Network owners who actually keep stats on the sales using scripted banners. I'll see if I can get one to come join the discussion. I think their feedback would be helpful. What percentage increase is that, and how does it compare against all other forms of advertising you use? I think you will find that, while it *may* increase your sales somewhat, it won't compare favorably to other forms of non-intrusive advertisement, and is definitely not worth it being seen as harassing and intrusive by the neighbors. Personally, I don't buy anything from such advertising, and advise friends and neighbors also to avoid patronizing such businesses who use that model. I realize that you do seem to care about others, and if Rem sticks up for you, that's a feather in your cap. However, I don't condone that advertising model in any way, shape, or form, and would fight against it being anywhere near my home or place of business, regardless of whom it was. Now, if you want to *pay* me to put advertisements in my mall or stores, that's fine, we can work out a deal. But subsuming eyeballs that *I* and my neighbors worked hard to attract just won't be tolerated, let alone appreciated.
|
Messamo House
Registered User
Join date: 23 May 2008
Posts: 1
|
Ha ha, oh wow.
09-08-2008 12:31
Well, 'tis about time something was done about this Ad Farming business. The mainland region where my land is currently at has a few huge spinning cubes with random German advertised porn on it. It's rather annoying having friends over and then having that in the background.
Anyway, as for how big I think they should be, 16 by 16 meters at most, buhaha! Or we could just get rid of all this needless advertising. Then again those people do bring money to Second Life and the Lindens need their cash eh? Oh well.
Just kidding about the snarky remarks by the way.
|
Drongle McMahon
Older than he looks
Join date: 22 Jun 2007
Posts: 494
|
09-08-2008 12:35
From: ROBO Marx I’m focusing on the day LL gets this thing moving and RL companies are begging for a presence. Maybe it will never happen, but all I have invested are lindens and some of my time..... Thanks for explaining your motivations. However, one thing escapes me. If that is your purpose, what was the point of surrounding so many microplots with banlines that were bound to annoy people? (no knitting jokes please!). From: ROBO Marx If you neighbor listed their house for 1 million and you think its only worth $350,000, what would you do? Probably laugh at him with all the other neighbors. Until he sold it, then you would sell yours for $1,000,000 too. In present circumstances? More likely to laugh at him when he sold it for $250,000, then suffer him laughing at me selling mine for $150,000.
|
Ciaran Laval
Mostly Harmless
Join date: 11 Mar 2007
Posts: 7,951
|
09-08-2008 12:36
From: Talarus Luan Personally, I loved it. Made buying new regions and expanding so much cheaper.  The only people worried about "devaluation" from prices going down are those who were only looking to make a buck by flipping regions. The rest of us, who USE our regions to conduct business were not bothered in the least. We loved it. Speak for yourself, I hated it and I've never engaged in flipping regions and I'm sure as hell not alone in that  I thought they handled it very very badly. As for the ad farmers as that's the topic here, if they'd designed their own decent network advertising system we wouldn't even need to be having this discussion. Luminous green eyesores are not going to attract inworld business to pay for adverts.
|
Talarus Luan
Ancient Archaean Dragon
Join date: 18 Mar 2006
Posts: 4,831
|
09-08-2008 12:48
From: Ciaran Laval Speak for yourself, I hated it and I've never engaged in flipping regions and I'm sure as hell not alone in that  I thought they handled it very very badly. *shrug* Well, I am not alone in thinking it was a good move, and I am glad they gave us the full discount all at once. LL land isn't really "property". It's a service. It has no intrinsic value outside of what you do with it. If LL gets rid of the $1000 setup fee tomorrow, I know plenty of people who are 100% good with it, INCLUDING current region owners. Most places that do the exact same thing (webserver rentals) already either have low or no setup fees. It is not inconceivable that LL will eventually go to that model themselves. In short, if you are buying regions to speculate on the value of the region by itself, you're setting yourself up for loss. That's not a wise business model and why I consider anyone who has problems with the up-front price going down only focused on the short-term gain aspects of region buying/selling (aka "flipping"  , since that business model lives or dies on the margins of the sale. No one else who uses their regions should really be too worried about it.
|
Shimada Yoshikawa
Registered User
Join date: 9 Mar 2007
Posts: 76
|
09-08-2008 12:49
From: Talarus Luan What percentage increase is that, and how does it compare against all other forms of advertising you use? I told you I don't keep stats. I spend over 8000$L a week using the Linden Classifieds with some success. 6 ad lots cost me less than 5000$L (some are 32sqm) and I own them, so no weekly charge. That 5000$ was recouped the first day and it's all profit after that. From: Talarus Luan I think you will find that, while it *may* increase your sales somewhat, it won't compare favorably to other forms of non-intrusive advertisement, and is definitely not worth it being seen as harassing and intrusive by the neighbors. No offense, but I think I'm a better judge of what is working for my business than you are. And as I explained in my earlier posts, I work WITH my neighbors and I am always willing to move or rebuild my ads so they don't devalue anyone else's property. From: Talarus Luan Personally, I don't buy anything from such advertising, and advise friends and neighbors also to avoid patronizing such businesses who use that model. I realize that you do seem to care about others, and if Rem sticks up for you, that's a feather in your cap. However, I don't condone that advertising model in any way, shape, or form, and would fight against it being anywhere near my home or place of business, regardless of whom it was. Well, fortunately not everyone is like you. Question for you. How do you advertise in SL and how is it working for you? Because I have found from experience. No advertising = No business. From: Talarus Luan Now, if you want to *pay* me to put advertisements in my mall or stores, that's fine, we can work out a deal. But subsuming eyeballs that *I* and my neighbors worked hard to attract just won't be tolerated, let alone appreciated. Why would I want to pay you to advertise in your mall? Lol I have plenty of my own malls I can advertise in. The IDEA is to get more people INTO your mall by advertising all over the place.
|
Dytska Vieria
+/- .00004™
Join date: 13 Dec 2006
Posts: 768
|
09-08-2008 12:59
From: Joshua Philgarlic It's a hole without any doubt:  It is now a hole with a complimentary toilet, since Robo needs to go... 
_____________________
+/- 0.00004
|
Talarus Luan
Ancient Archaean Dragon
Join date: 18 Mar 2006
Posts: 4,831
|
09-08-2008 13:05
From: Shimada Yoshikawa I told you I don't keep stats. I spend over 8000$L a week using the Linden Classifieds with some success. 6 ad lots cost me less than 5000$L (some are 32sqm) and I own them, so no weekly charge. That 5000$ was recouped the first day and it's all profit after that.
No offense, but I think I'm a better judge of what is working for my business than you are. And as I explained in my earlier posts, I work WITH my neighbors and I am always willing to move or rebuild my ads so they don't devalue anyone else's property. If you don't keep stats, how can you be a better judge of what is working for your business? OK, I suppose that you can go with your gut, but that's hardly a support for intrusive outdoor advertising models. I already acknowledged that you seem to care about what others think concerning your ads (or at least I thought you did; my apologies if that was misread). From: someone Well, fortunately not everyone is like you. Question for you. How do you advertise in SL and how is it working for you? Because I have found from experience. No advertising = No business. No, but there still are a lot of people like me.  Presently, I am not advertising. However, I will be using classifieds, Search, affiliate networks, forums, probably SLX banner ads, etc. I will NOT be spamming other people's places without their consent and support, though. That much I can tell you. From: someone Why would I want to pay you to advertise in your mall? Lol I have plenty of my own malls I can advertise in. The IDEA is to get more people INTO your mall by advertising all over the place. You missed the point entirely. I wasn't making you an offer, I was making a conceptual analogy. If you come to my sim, buy an adfarm plot next to my home or mall, and put up your ads, that's basically "stealing" attention from me and my neighbors, and we won't appreciate it. That's the concept I am trying to drive home: that the intrusive outdoor advertising model is parasitic in nature. The natural counter to that is that you offer to support us to support you. ..and yes, I plan to advertise all over the place. JUST NOT in people's backyards and frontyards with what amounts to visual spam. That's why we have fought so hard and so long for this policy. It's time for that model to be strictly regulated if not outright killed.
|
Proxima Saenz
Registered User
Join date: 22 Jun 2008
Posts: 107
|
09-08-2008 13:12
Interesting. They are talking about Parcel muting. Which would be a great great solution!
|
Ciaran Laval
Mostly Harmless
Join date: 11 Mar 2007
Posts: 7,951
|
09-08-2008 13:13
From: Talarus Luan *shrug* Well, I am not alone in thinking it was a good move, and I am glad they gave us the full discount all at once. LL land isn't really "property". It's a service. It has no intrinsic value outside of what you do with it. If LL gets rid of the $1000 setup fee tomorrow, I know plenty of people who are 100% good with it, INCLUDING current region owners. Most places that do the exact same thing (webserver rentals) already either have low or no setup fees. It is not inconceivable that LL will eventually go to that model themselves. In short, if you are buying regions to speculate on the value of the region by itself, you're setting yourself up for loss. That's not a wise business model and why I consider anyone who has problems with the up-front price going down only focused on the short-term gain aspects of region buying/selling (aka "flipping"  , since that business model lives or dies on the margins of the sale. No one else who uses their regions should really be too worried about it. Not sure about your thinking here at all. First of all if they dropped the prices completely tomorrow anyone who has just purchased an island is going to be bloody furious. The same as those who had islands on order when the price drop was announced were none too impressed when LL said they'd have to pay the old rate, they changed their mind on that decision but it was an example of how poorly thought out the decision was. Then there's the issue of value, which actually ties in with this thread. The island is an asset, it's not going to be worth x forever, but to see it devalued so much made a lot of people question the policy. One of the biggest complains about Ad Farmers is devaluation, if land has no intrinsic value then that argument is null and void, but plenty of people who complain about ad farms complain because it devalues mainland. Those who complain about extortion are also complaining about land values.
|
Proxima Saenz
Registered User
Join date: 22 Jun 2008
Posts: 107
|
09-08-2008 13:20
Money money money.. Its all about money lol. If you buy mainland you are aware that there is a RISK that it drops in value because of adfarmers.. that is a risk you take.
|