Voice
|
|
Sally Silvera
live music maniac
Join date: 17 Feb 2007
Posts: 2,325
|
08-03-2007 08:54
From: Michael Bigwig Ok, once and for all people...jeepers. 3) Knowing that all citizens have the capability to use voice is comforting. As of now, you have to ask whether they use voice, then open (or download) the program, set it up, and blah blah blah...it's so much easier to know we all have the capability, and either see the white dot above someones head, or simply say, "Hello! Can you hear me?" Aside from the oddity of presuming that all 'citizens' have the capability........ You're also missing a point there. If someone is not using voice, they can't see the white dot. And that aside from the fact that seeing the white dot or anything else for that matter is nigh on impossible with the new communications thing anyway. Disclaimer: i'm not anti-voice just never going to use it
|
|
SqueezeOne Pow
World Changer
Join date: 21 Dec 2005
Posts: 1,437
|
08-03-2007 08:55
From: June Oh How does voice effect us? Is it voice users to voice users only, and typing to typing only?
Can typing only users understand the voice users?
Or do we end up being in 2 groups?
Love June If you opt out of voice you can still have it on to hear what people are saying. It's also possible and fairly easy to communicate between the two "social groups" that are being created out of paranoia. I have a couple friends that for whatever reason aren't using voice and am able to communicate with them just fine with me on voice and them on typing It'll be okay, guys. The sky won't fall...it doesn't even really exist!
_____________________
Semper Fly -S1. Pow
"Violence is Art by another means"
Visit Squeeze One Plaza in Osteria. Come for the robots, stay for the view!http://slurl.com/secondlife/Osteria/160.331/203.881
|
|
Chas Connolly
Registered User
Join date: 24 Jan 2007
Posts: 1,433
|
08-03-2007 08:56
From: Michael Bigwig I read ALL posts, and I never skim. That is a fact. That doesn't change human error, or my firm opinion. Don't ASSUME and ACCUSE...you only make an ass out of yourself. How dare you judge me as you act the fool as you are? You sir, are the one that needs to re-work your forum style (starting with all the yelling) How dare I judge him he says and then proceeds to judge me. How odd. Or not. Now I'm going to lie down.
|
|
Tomas Gandini
Just Me!
Join date: 27 Jun 2006
Posts: 384
|
08-03-2007 08:57
From: Michael Bigwig ... lol. You guys crack me up. You are more stubborn than a 99 year old jaded donkey. Looking in mirror are we?
_____________________
 Never underestimate the power of stupid people in large groups
|
|
Michael Bigwig
~VRML Aficionado~
Join date: 5 Dec 2005
Posts: 2,181
|
08-03-2007 08:58
Bah...you guys...  I won't get through to you, clearly. None of my points (no matter how grounded, or valid) seem to jive with anyone. The forums are frequented by mainly those that love to bitch about issues...not embrace them--don't hate on me for making this clear. I love SL, and I love the majority of those I meet and work with on the grid. But boy...I'll tell ya...you guys on the forums love to complain, and never really embrace. Don't accuse me of loving voice because I'm a "techie"..that's just dumb. I'm an artist. *shrugs*
_____________________
~Michael Bigwig __________________________________________________Lead Designer, Glowbox Designs 
|
|
Brenda Connolly
Un United Avatar
Join date: 10 Jan 2007
Posts: 25,000
|
08-03-2007 08:59
From: Michael Bigwig Ok, once and for all people...jeepers. THIRD PARTY SOFTWARE IS NOT A VALID OPTION FOR THE COMMUNITY. How I got there: 1) Third party software soaks up additional RAM (more than internal VOIP). Some may not think this an issue, but when you're running an older rig like I am, I need all the RAM I can get. 2) Third party software has to be downloaded, installed, and set up. This is a hassle to some people, and to others it's down-right confusing. Yes, I understand the majority of people installed SL, and run it...but some people (like my Mother) had trouble getting off Orientation Island...Skype, Vent, or Teamspeak would only confuse them more. And what if someone you know has Skype, but you use Ventrilo? For this to work, we would all need every one of the VOIP applications...that would be straight-up silly. We need an internal setup, with plug and play essentials. The easier to setup, the more people involved. 3) Knowing that all citizens have the capability to use voice is comforting. As of now, you have to ask whether they use voice, then open (or download) the program, set it up, and blah blah blah...it's so much easier to know we all have the capability, and either see the white dot above someones head, or simply say, "Hello! Can you hear me?" Those are just three examples of why third party software should not be relied on. Voice is coming to SL regardless of whether you like it or not...why for the love of Linden would you want to run background apps for voice? Insanity if you ask me.  I agree it should be part of the software, it's sensible. I also think a voice changer should be embedded as well, using the same logic. (Not that I would use it anyway).
_____________________
Don't you ever try to look behind my eyes. You don't want to know what they have seen.
http://brenda-connolly.blogspot.com
|
|
SqueezeOne Pow
World Changer
Join date: 21 Dec 2005
Posts: 1,437
|
08-03-2007 09:04
From: Brenda Connolly I agree it should be part of the software, it's sensible. I also think a voice changer should be embedded as well, using the same logic. (Not that I would use it anyway). There's all types of free ones out there. If you're just looking to make your voice sound different so no one can recognize you IRL (which is a valid concern) then they'd work for you. Now if you're trying to be another sex convincingly then they don't work so well! I'm debating getting MorphVox Pro for the other features...I wanna be a funky dog robot!
_____________________
Semper Fly -S1. Pow
"Violence is Art by another means"
Visit Squeeze One Plaza in Osteria. Come for the robots, stay for the view!http://slurl.com/secondlife/Osteria/160.331/203.881
|
|
Brenda Connolly
Un United Avatar
Join date: 10 Jan 2007
Posts: 25,000
|
08-03-2007 09:04
From: Michael Bigwig Bah...you guys...  I won't get through to you, clearly. None of my points (no matter how grounded, or valid) seem to jive with anyone. The forums are frequented by mainly those that love to bitch about issues...not embrace them--don't hate on me for making this clear. I love SL, and I love the majority of those I meet and work with on the grid. But boy...I'll tell ya...you guys on the forums love to complain, and never really embrace. Don't accuse me of loving voice because I'm a "techie"..that's just dumb. I'm an artist. *shrugs* Not to troll you, but I seem to always notice a train of thought anong Technophiles, being A. Shock when people don't embrace what they are espousing, and B. An almost insulted stand, that anyone would dare not be as cutting edge as they are. I see it in RL as well. I don't want to hinder advances. But personally, I don't want them forced on me. I will change as my needs dictate, not as someone else decides. If people want to be luddites, let them. It's no harm to you. You can bow to the silicon gods all you wish. The machines will rule the world eventually, don't worry. 
_____________________
Don't you ever try to look behind my eyes. You don't want to know what they have seen.
http://brenda-connolly.blogspot.com
|
|
Maklin Deckard
Disillusioned
Join date: 9 Apr 2005
Posts: 459
|
08-03-2007 09:05
From: Chas Connolly I should be used to the fact that you neither read anyone elses's posts but your own, nor ever admit that non-voicer have concerns other than those to which yopu attribute them, but it is nevertheles getting very annoying.
ITS NOT SO MUCH THAT WE DON'T WANT VOICE TO BE INTRODUCED - VOICE AWAY FOR ALL I CARE - BUT WE DON'T WANT THIS CRAP VIEWER! AND WE WANT TO BE ABLE TO DISABLE IT COMPLETELY!
DID YOU HEAR THAT? I am starting to wonder if Michael is a linden alt, or employed by the company doing voice for them. We say 'we hate the new interface' He says 'voice is critical!' We say 'we hate the interface', he calls us 'voice naysayers'. We say 'we hate the interface' He says 3rd party software is an unworkable solution and text is still there' He either A) cannot read, B) Cannot comprehend what he reads, C) has a stake somehow in voice on SL. Michael, Let me make this perfectly clear....I do not care if folks use voice, use it to your heart's content, people. Yes, as you say, text is still there...however, you completely gloss over the fact that, due to the new interface, they have utterly crippled its usability for no apparent reason! THIS is what I and others are complaining about.
|
|
Lindal Kidd
Dances With Noobs
Join date: 26 Jun 2007
Posts: 8,371
|
08-03-2007 09:05
From: Michael Bigwig First thing I'd like people to be well aware of: the forum community does not in any way reflect the grid's community. They attitudes are vastly different, the vibe and feel is different...it's not a good reflection of the actual SL experience. Not sure I agree with you, Michael (but when was that ever news?) First, whenever I've mentioned an issue (not just voice, any issue) that's in hot debate here on the forums to someone in-world, most of them are aware of the issue. And many of these people don't even know these forums exist! More than that, the opinions expressed by non-forum-users appear to me (no, I haven't taken a poll, this is just my personal impression) to be divided up in about the same numbers as indicated in these threads. Finally, I noticed that the comments to the blog entry announcing voice on the main viewer were almost uniformly negative. I don't see the huge groundswell of grateful voicers that you seem to be implying.
|
|
Maklin Deckard
Disillusioned
Join date: 9 Apr 2005
Posts: 459
|
08-03-2007 09:07
From: Brenda Connolly Not to troll you, but I seem to always notice a train of thought anong Technophiles, being A. Shock when people don't embrace what they are espousing, and B. An almost insulted stand, that anyone would dare not be as cutting edge as they are. I see it in RL as well. I don't want to hinder advances. But personally, I don't want them forced on me. I will change as my needs dictate, not as someone else decides. If people want to be luddites, let them. It's no harm to you. You can bow to the silicon gods all you wish. The machines will rule the world eventually, don't worry.  AMEN!
|
|
Brenda Connolly
Un United Avatar
Join date: 10 Jan 2007
Posts: 25,000
|
08-03-2007 09:07
From: SqueezeOne Pow There's all types of free ones out there. If you're just looking to make your voice sound different so no one can recognize you IRL (which is a valid concern) then they'd work for you.
Now if you're trying to be another sex convincingly then they don't work so well!
I'm debating getting MorphVox Pro for the other features...I wanna be a funky dog robot! Fine, but just as a third party app is not good enough for voice according to some, I say a 3rd party voice changer is just as impractical. Make it even.
_____________________
Don't you ever try to look behind my eyes. You don't want to know what they have seen.
http://brenda-connolly.blogspot.com
|
|
SqueezeOne Pow
World Changer
Join date: 21 Dec 2005
Posts: 1,437
|
08-03-2007 09:09
From: Lindal Kidd Finally, I noticed that the comments to the blog entry announcing voice on the main viewer were almost uniformly negative.
When have you seen responses to a LL blog that WEREN'T almost uniformly negative?!? From: Lindal Kidd I don't see the huge groundswell of grateful voicers that you seem to be implying. That's because you don't have voice turned on...you can HEAR them now!  The fact that you agree with most of the people in the forum shows that you most likely have similar people surrounding you in SL and probably RL to some extent. Everyone feels like they're in the majority when everyone in their circle agrees with them. I think you might be in a blue state!
_____________________
Semper Fly -S1. Pow
"Violence is Art by another means"
Visit Squeeze One Plaza in Osteria. Come for the robots, stay for the view!http://slurl.com/secondlife/Osteria/160.331/203.881
|
|
Allison Selene
Registered User
Join date: 5 Oct 2006
Posts: 112
|
08-03-2007 09:13
From: Michael Bigwig None of my points (no matter how grounded, or valid) seem to jive with anyone. The forums are frequented by mainly those that love to bitch about issues...not embrace them-- Where is the empathy Michael? I don't care one way or the other about voice, but it seems like the pro-voicers are often quick to dismiss the concerns of the pro-text folks and come off as condescending. Your attitude and statements don't leave any room for working to a resolution. I believe your statement above is a perfect example of why the pro-text folks believe that voice will fragment community. What's happening to SL these days is quickly becoming disappointing.
_____________________
BeateNetworks Your Guide to Success in the Immersive Web http://www.BeateNetworks.com
|
|
SqueezeOne Pow
World Changer
Join date: 21 Dec 2005
Posts: 1,437
|
08-03-2007 09:13
From: Brenda Connolly Fine, but just as a third party app is not good enough for voice according to some, I say a 3rd party voice changer is just as impractical. Make it even. ...except it's kind of a fire and forget deal. You set it up once and then minimize it and that's it. Not as involved as Skype or other chat programs. Also, this is like asking LL to have an in-world photo editor so making clothes will be easier. Use photoshop! Besides, people would just cry about how THAT feature wasn't good enough anyway!
_____________________
Semper Fly -S1. Pow
"Violence is Art by another means"
Visit Squeeze One Plaza in Osteria. Come for the robots, stay for the view!http://slurl.com/secondlife/Osteria/160.331/203.881
|
|
Michael Bigwig
~VRML Aficionado~
Join date: 5 Dec 2005
Posts: 2,181
|
08-03-2007 09:14
From: Maklin Deckard I am starting to wonder if Michael is a linden alt, or employed by the company doing voice for them. We say 'we hate the new interface' He says 'voice is critical!' We say 'we hate the interface', he calls us 'voice naysayers'. We say 'we hate the interface' He says 3rd party software is an unworkable solution and text is still there'
He either A) cannot read, B) Cannot comprehend what he reads, C) has a stake somehow in voice on SL.
Michael, Let me make this perfectly clear....I do not care if folks use voice, use it to your heart's content, people. Yes, as you say, text is still there...however, you completely gloss over the fact that, due to the new interface, they have utterly crippled its usability for no apparent reason! THIS is what I and others are complaining about. By you saying, "it has utterly cripple its usability for no apparent reason." Isn't that just as much opinion as my opinions? The community on the forum does not reflect the community on the grid...my opinion of course. I am not a hater. I am a believer. I am a thinker. I am an artist--if you guys want to twist everything I say as negative and adversary...well, that's your problem, not mine. I am here to tell you what I believe, and you can react how you see fit. I'm not a troll, nor am I a Linden in disguise. 
_____________________
~Michael Bigwig __________________________________________________Lead Designer, Glowbox Designs 
|
|
Maklin Deckard
Disillusioned
Join date: 9 Apr 2005
Posts: 459
|
08-03-2007 09:16
From: Michael Bigwig Bah...you guys...  I won't get through to you, clearly. None of my points (no matter how grounded, or valid) seem to jive with anyone. The forums are frequented by mainly those that love to bitch about issues...not embrace them--don't hate on me for making this clear. I love SL, and I love the majority of those I meet and work with on the grid. But boy...I'll tell ya...you guys on the forums love to complain, and never really embrace. Don't accuse me of loving voice because I'm a "techie"..that's just dumb. I'm an artist. *shrugs* No, you're not going to 'get through to me' that the steaming pile of s**t they shoveled onto us last night in the form of the new communicator panel is in any way to my benefit. It has hampered my ABILITY to communicate in text (perhaps the reason it exists? To force text folks to voice and force 'reluctant' sim admins to pay for voice?). Add voice - stupid idea, but I can opt-out. Other than communit split, doesn't affect me. New communicator -- massive downgrade to my ability to effectively communicate, not acceptable.
|
|
Kitty Barnett
Registered User
Join date: 10 May 2006
Posts: 5,586
|
08-03-2007 09:17
From: Michael Bigwig Why are people so worried about being judged or segregated because of their voice choice? You answered your own question: From: someone I think something is drastically wrong if you fear voice this badly. Don't want to use voice = something is wrong with you = judging
|
|
Chas Connolly
Registered User
Join date: 24 Jan 2007
Posts: 1,433
|
08-03-2007 09:18
From: Michael Bigwig By you saying, "it has utterly cripple its usability for no apparent reason." Isn't that just as much opinion as my opinions?  ROFL. No, Michael this is a fact. The interface is useless for anyone not using voice. I notice you didn't say you were a listener. Quite telling that.
|
|
Michael Bigwig
~VRML Aficionado~
Join date: 5 Dec 2005
Posts: 2,181
|
08-03-2007 09:18
From: Maklin Deckard No, you're not going to 'get through to me' that the steaming pile of s**t they shoveled onto us last night in the form of the new communicator panel is in any way to my benefit. It has hampered my ABILITY to communicate in text (perhaps the reason it exists? To force text folks to voice and force 'reluctant' sim admins to pay for voice?).
Add voice - stupid idea, but I can opt-out. Other than communit split, doesn't affect me. New communicator -- massive downgrade to my ability to effectively communicate, not acceptable. Give it time. Perhaps all of your voices will be heard, and SL will become a fluid, efficient environment for you. But remember what I said earlier: you can't please every body all the time.
_____________________
~Michael Bigwig __________________________________________________Lead Designer, Glowbox Designs 
|
|
Michael Bigwig
~VRML Aficionado~
Join date: 5 Dec 2005
Posts: 2,181
|
08-03-2007 09:19
From: Chas Connolly ROFL. No, Michael this is a fact. The interface is useless for anyone not using voice. I notice you didn't say you were a listener. Quite telling that. No!!!! ARghhhh! I don't agree with you...even if it were little ol' me...it still would turn your fact to fiction...or opinion rather. Not everyone agrees with the voice dislike...can't you guys see that? SHeesh.
_____________________
~Michael Bigwig __________________________________________________Lead Designer, Glowbox Designs 
|
|
Maklin Deckard
Disillusioned
Join date: 9 Apr 2005
Posts: 459
|
08-03-2007 09:19
From: Michael Bigwig By you saying, "it has utterly cripple its usability for no apparent reason." Isn't that just as much opinion as my opinions? The community on the forum does not reflect the community on the grid...my opinion of course. I am not a hater. I am a believer. I am a thinker. I am an artist--if you guys want to twist everything I say as negative and adversary...well, that's your problem, not mine. I am here to tell you what I believe, and you can react how you see fit. I'm not a troll, nor am I a Linden in disguise.  Add egotist to that list, truth in advertising. 
|
|
SqueezeOne Pow
World Changer
Join date: 21 Dec 2005
Posts: 1,437
|
08-03-2007 09:21
From: Allison Selene Where is the empathy Michael? I don't care one way or the other about voice, but it seems like the pro-voicers are often quick to dismiss the concerns of the pro-text folks and come off as condescending. Why does Mike there have to be the only empathetic one? I get accused of the same thing when I express my opinions on voice...and I've never said "everyone should like voice"! The status quo glee club (maybe anti-glee club since they're always complaining about something!) likes to accuse those that disagree with them of being insensitive to the weak and all that. Funny how they do it in the most insensitive and apathetic ways! I'm not neccessarily saying you do that, but the "in" crowd on the forum certainly does. From: Allison Selene I believe your statement above is a perfect example of why the pro-text folks believe that voice will fragment community. I believe his statement above is him getting frustrated with how people react to change on these forums. This whole "voice will fragment the community" crock is being manufactured by the very people that are afraid of being "discriminated against". It's like calling me a "racist cracker" because you're worried I'll discriminate against you for being another race before I have a chance to do ANYTHING! This tired "fragmented community" argument was started before voice was even in the Beta Grid.
_____________________
Semper Fly -S1. Pow
"Violence is Art by another means"
Visit Squeeze One Plaza in Osteria. Come for the robots, stay for the view!http://slurl.com/secondlife/Osteria/160.331/203.881
|
|
Maklin Deckard
Disillusioned
Join date: 9 Apr 2005
Posts: 459
|
08-03-2007 09:22
From: Michael Bigwig Give it time. Perhaps all of your voices will be heard, and SL will become a fluid, efficient environment for you.
But remember what I said earlier: you can't please every body all the time. Give it time? Must be a new user.  The ONLY way the lindens back down is if the community uproar here and in other forums is big enough and sustained enough. Otherwise, they blow off the community every time. You take the lindens at face value as reasonable. I have experience otherwise.....
|
|
Michael Bigwig
~VRML Aficionado~
Join date: 5 Dec 2005
Posts: 2,181
|
08-03-2007 09:22
From: Kitty Barnett You answered your own question  on't want to use voice = something is wrong with you = judging No sweetie... I meant, there is something wrong if you fear it THAT much. Not if you just "don't want to use it." There is a difference...one I was hoping wouldn't fly over your head. I'm not discriminating anyone for not using voice. And I'm not judging you if you don't want to use it...what I AM saying is...there is something wrong if you fear voice so much that you have to slander it to its death.
_____________________
~Michael Bigwig __________________________________________________Lead Designer, Glowbox Designs 
|