Yes, Landbots screw us once again, so keep cheering them on!
|
Elanthius Flagstaff
Registered User
Join date: 30 Apr 2006
Posts: 1,534
|
05-14-2007 05:11
From: Walker Moore presumably not, but i suppose privately owned estates are too risky for bots to indulge in this kind of fraud. the estate owner could keep the bot's money, and return the land to its original owner - something Linden Lab absolutely will not do. that's why i would expect this con to be far more prevalent on mainland than private estates anyway. Private estate owners don't need to be clever or use bots to perform this sort of scam. They can sell land and then use the built in tools LL gives them to steal it back.
|
Walker Moore
Fоrum Unregular
Join date: 14 May 2006
Posts: 1,458
|
05-14-2007 05:15
From: Elanthius Flagstaff Private estate owners don't need to be clever or use bots to perform this sort of scam. They can sell land and then use the built in tools LL gives them to steal it back. i realise there are ruthless estate owners out there, but there are also continents like Dreamland and the Azures where 'reselling' your own parcel is the norm. I took Coco's question to mean: could this happen if I attempt to buy a parcel on a private estate from the previous parcel 'owner' - who might be a bot, not the estate owner.
_____________________
It's only a forum, no one dies.
|
Strife Onizuka
Moonchild
Join date: 3 Mar 2004
Posts: 5,887
|
05-14-2007 06:13
If there isn't already a bug report on Jira for this, someone should submit one. http://jira.secondlife.com/
_____________________
Truth is a river that is always splitting up into arms that reunite. Islanded between the arms, the inhabitants argue for a lifetime as to which is the main river. - Cyril Connolly
Without the political will to find common ground, the continual friction of tactic and counter tactic, only creates suspicion and hatred and vengeance, and perpetuates the cycle of violence. - James Nachtwey
|
Cocoanut Koala
Coco's Cottages
Join date: 7 Feb 2005
Posts: 7,903
|
05-14-2007 06:21
From: Elanthius Flagstaff Private estate owners don't need to be clever or use bots to perform this sort of scam. They can sell land and then use the built in tools LL gives them to steal it back. That's not what I meant. I meant, on private estates, there is always the final step of going through the island owner. Right? Therefore, this is only a danger on the mainland. And on the mainland, we are chum anyway; that is our purpose there, right? coco
|
Elinah Iredell
Registered User
Join date: 14 Aug 2006
Posts: 269
|
05-14-2007 06:22
From: Sarah Nerd Well for all you land bot supporters... Here is the latest unethical use of landbots. Well most people are aware of how landbot users have been using the bots fast buying ability to take advantage of human and or latency errors. For example someone lists land for sale, lag or error causes the person to miss a number, bot comes and buys in a split second, or someone is trying to sell land to a friend or group land and a bot jumps in and auto buyers faster then the person acually standing on the plot can even move the mouse to click the buy button. But thats old news to most of you. If not see this thread = /327/7a/176533/1.html Well now one bot user is using the bot to bait and switch residents. For example, The land is set for at 4400L. This is a decent deal, people land. The bot uses it's faster than human speed to quickly change the price to 44000L in hopes the person who clicks buy doesnt notice the extra number because the prices look similar on a glance, or else they are lagged to the point that the buy window doesnt update until it's to late and they have paid 44K for 512 meters of land. Bait and switch is an old dirty trick I've seen a few times in the past but ad the bots abilty to change the price faster than any human can change it, and it becomes a more effective dirty unethical method to take advantage of people. So bring on your arguments of how a few bot dealers give back errors, or that this is the new way sl will be and bots are just more effective, But this type of speed and power should not be allowed when it can and obviously IS being used to take advantage of others. Or at least not be allowed for this type of unethical use. This week I've heard of 3 people getting taken with bait and switch, and 1 friend lose half a sim when trying to sell to a friend, on top of all the similar situtions that have been happening last few months. I would make sure I didnt have that much more money in my account than the land cost so If they did that I couldnt pay it anyway... even if I had to temporarily send my money to an alternate av . I dont understand one thing if trying to transfer land to a friend, arent you supposed to make sure to put the friend's name on it so nobody else can buy it? How can lag cause someone to lose their land ? I know it makes me type slow sometimes but wouldnt somebody notice if they put the wrong price ? I think its awful the only things I have read about these bots is they look for ways to take advantage of people in real estate... do they actually have any good uses at all? Elinah
|
Sarah Nerd
I BUY LAND
Join date: 22 Aug 2005
Posts: 796
|
05-14-2007 06:23
From: Suzy Hazlehurst the last two posters failed to notice one thing: the confirmation dialogue will show the wrong amount of money. Because the price is changed by the bot at exactly the 'right' moment, the buyer confirms one money transfer when a different, much higher money transfer takes place. This is not about people not paying attention. This is about people getting conned. Yes this is the point everyone who claims check and double check and has no sympothy misses. And this is one of the exploits thats having faster than human speed can take advantage of. And no matter what the method used, or if someone just misses the added number, scamming people and taking advantage of people like this should never be excused or accepted as the way things are.
|
Elanthius Flagstaff
Registered User
Join date: 30 Apr 2006
Posts: 1,534
|
05-14-2007 06:25
From: Cocoanut Koala I meant, on private estates, there is always the final step of going through the island owner. Right?
OK, firstly that only works if the estate owner is not operating the scam. Secondly, let's say the renter sets his parcel for sale for L$1 and flips it to L$500,000 while you buy it. How do you propose the estate owner would solve this problem? You still lost 500k but you own the land. Fact is the risk of this happening is twice as high with private land since there are two people who can rip you off. One of whom is totally immune to accusations of theft since he ultimately owns the land.
|
Cocoanut Koala
Coco's Cottages
Join date: 7 Feb 2005
Posts: 7,903
|
05-14-2007 06:30
From: Elanthius Flagstaff OK, firstly that only works if the estate owner is not operating the scam. Secondly, let's say the renter sets his parcel for sale for L$1 and flips it to L$500,000 while you buy it. How do you propose the estate owner would solve this problem? You still lost 500k but you own the land. Fact is the risk of this happening is twice as high with private land since there are two people who can rip you off. One of whom is totally immune to accusations of theft since he ultimately owns the land. FORGET the scenario with the island owner ripping you off. I'm not asking about that. I'm saying, if the island owner is above board, IS there any way of someone else ripping you off? Because I believe it has to go through the island owner before it is final. Therefore, the island owner could make it right. Right? coco
|
Elanthius Flagstaff
Registered User
Join date: 30 Apr 2006
Posts: 1,534
|
05-14-2007 06:36
From: Cocoanut Koala FORGET the scenario with the island owner ripping you off. I'm not asking about that. I'm saying, if the island owner is above board, IS there any way of someone else ripping you off? Because I believe it has to go through the island owner before it is final. Therefore, the island owner could make it right. Right? coco No, not at all. You own a sim. I own a parcel on that sim. I set a parcel for sale very cheaply. Someone else comes and buys that parcel but as they do so I change the price to L$1,000,000. That person then pays a million lindens for a small piece of land. I have a million lindens the person has the land. How are you going to get the money off of me and give it to the buyer?
|
Elinah Iredell
Registered User
Join date: 14 Aug 2006
Posts: 269
|
05-14-2007 06:38
From: Cocoanut Koala FORGET the scenario with the island owner ripping you off.
I'm not asking about that.
I'm saying, if the island owner is above board, IS there any way of someone else ripping you off?
Because I believe it has to go through the island owner before it is final.
Therefore, the island owner could make it right. Right?
coco I guess the estate owner needs to be made aware of the scam quickly to make sure he/she doesnt sign off on the deal without realizing it was a scam and the person didnt agree to pay that much. Here is another question what about some of the ridiculous prices I came across as a newbie when I was looking for land? A newbie doesnt know better than to pay it sometimes and what about scam artists selling land they dont own to unsuspecting newbies? Elinah
|
Amity Slade
Registered User
Join date: 14 Feb 2007
Posts: 2,183
|
05-14-2007 06:40
Bait-and-switch is illegal in California (and I think in every state in the United States). Using Second Life to violate the law is supposedly a violation of the Terms of Service. Victims of bait-and-switch should start reporting Linden Labs to the California Department of Consumer Affairs. Submit a copy of the Second Life Terms of Service; a screen shot of the land advertised price; a screen shot of the land actual price; and a brief but clear explanation of how the money exchange works. When a few of those pile up, I bet there will be an investigation into Linden Labs' business practices. It would be nice if Linden Labs acted on these issues proactively, rather than waiting until they are threated with litigation. But that's their choice. Keeps the lawyers in business. Here a link to a fact sheet from the California Department of Consumer Affairs, summarizing illegal practices and what victims can do: http://www.dca.ca.gov/legal/advfact.htm
|
Walker Moore
Fоrum Unregular
Join date: 14 May 2006
Posts: 1,458
|
05-14-2007 06:44
From: Elanthius Flagstaff No, not at all. You own a sim. I own a parcel on that sim. I set a parcel for sale very cheaply. Someone else comes and buys that parcel but as they do so I change the price to L$1,000,000. That person then pays a million lindens for a small piece of land. I have a million lindens the person has the land. Doh, yes. WTF was I talking about up there? Estate owner could hardly confiscate land after bot has sold it, and estate owner doesn't get the money to hand back to a screwed buyer anyway. Sheesh. Somebody bring me some clever pills pls. 
_____________________
It's only a forum, no one dies.
|
Elanthius Flagstaff
Registered User
Join date: 30 Apr 2006
Posts: 1,534
|
05-14-2007 06:45
From: Elinah Iredell I guess the estate owner needs to be made aware of the scam quickly to make sure he/she doesnt sign off on the deal without realizing it was a scam and the person didnt agree to pay that much. To be honest, it's all kinda a moo point because no-one is seriously going to try this on estate parcels in the near future because the market isn't active enough. Nonetheless, the estate owner is not involved AT ALL in parcel sales of the land he owns.
|
Ike Fairweather
Off Tha Chain
Join date: 1 Feb 2007
Posts: 387
|
05-14-2007 07:43
From: Sarah Nerd Well for all you land bot supporters... Here is the latest unethical use of landbots. Well most people are aware of how landbot users have been using the bots fast buying ability to take advantage of human and or latency errors. For example someone lists land for sale, lag or error causes the person to miss a number, bot comes and buys in a split second, or someone is trying to sell land to a friend or group land and a bot jumps in and auto buyers faster then the person acually standing on the plot can even move the mouse to click the buy button. But thats old news to most of you. If not see this thread = /327/7a/176533/1.html Well now one bot user is using the bot to bait and switch residents. For example, The land is set for at 4400L. This is a decent deal, people land. The bot uses it's faster than human speed to quickly change the price to 44000L in hopes the person who clicks buy doesnt notice the extra number because the prices look similar on a glance, or else they are lagged to the point that the buy window doesnt update until it's to late and they have paid 44K for 512 meters of land. Bait and switch is an old dirty trick I've seen a few times in the past but ad the bots abilty to change the price faster than any human can change it, and it becomes a more effective dirty unethical method to take advantage of people. So bring on your arguments of how a few bot dealers give back errors, or that this is the new way sl will be and bots are just more effective, But this type of speed and power should not be allowed when it can and obviously IS being used to take advantage of others. Or at least not be allowed for this type of unethical use. This week I've heard of 3 people getting taken with bait and switch, and 1 friend lose half a sim when trying to sell to a friend, on top of all the similar situtions that have been happening last few months. The moral to the story is to pay attention to what you are doing. When I sold my land on strata, I tried to sell it as one big lot, but it didn't sell quick enough, so I subdivided it into 7 (512 Lots). the last 512 was actually 2 strips, but sold as one. Well, I sold that price well under the normal 512 because you couldn't build anything on it. Immediately, 5 people showed up (you were there, so you know who they are). But the landbot snatched it up as soon as I hit sell. Well, with the mass attendance that showed, one of the land reseller just hit "buy" before he paid attention to what he was buying just to beat everyone else. So, instead of him buying the $5450L strip lot that the landbot snatched up, he bought the $7000L 512 lot (this was the going rate at the time). Well, that reseller said he made a mistake and bought the wrong lot and couldn't make any money on it and that he would give me 100L to return his money for my inconvenience. Well, I told him, he does know "All Sales are Final". He said yes. But since he was polite about the entire situation, I agreed to give him his money back. he put the land back up for sale at 100L cheaper and I bought it back. So, again, whenever selling or buying land, do like you would when dealing with money/contracts in real life. Pay attention and check to make sure everything is correct before to confirm the deal.
|
ForestMist Skjellerup
Sculptor
Join date: 6 Dec 2006
Posts: 57
|
05-14-2007 07:43
From: Suzy Hazlehurst the last two posters failed to notice one thing: the confirmation dialogue will show the wrong amount of money. Because the price is changed by the bot at exactly the 'right' moment, the buyer confirms one money transfer when a different, much higher money transfer takes place. This is not about people not paying attention. This is about people getting conned. It's fraud. Another computer exploit for the purpose of fraud. Illegal in any country. The modern computer age does give us a crash course on this side of human nature.  -Fo, who works as an ISP sys admin in RL.
|
Raymond Figtree
Gone, avi, gone
Join date: 17 May 2006
Posts: 6,256
|
05-14-2007 08:05
From: Cocoanut Koala So . . . this can happen only on the mainland?
coco Bots don't mess with estates because they can't read the covenants.
_____________________
Read or listen to some Eckhart Tolle. You won't regret it.
|
bilbo99 Emu
Garrett's No.1 fan
Join date: 27 Oct 2006
Posts: 3,468
|
05-14-2007 08:13
From: Ike Fairweather But the landbot snatched it up as soon as I hit sell. Well, with the mass attendance that showed, one of the land reseller just hit "buy" before he paid attention to what he was buying just to beat everyone else. So, instead of him buying the $5450L strip lot that the landbot snatched up, he bought the $7000L 512 lot (this was the going rate at the time).
Well, that reseller said he made a mistake and bought the wrong lot and couldn't make any money on it and that he would give me 100L to return his money for my inconvenience. Well, I told him, he does know "All Sales are Final". He said yes.
But since he was polite about the entire situation, I agreed to give him his money back. he put the land back up for sale at 100L cheaper and I bought it back. I don't think I'm reading this right. So you sold the land for 5450L$ and bought it back for 6900L$? And the landbot made 1550L$? nice work if you can get it!
|
Ike Fairweather
Off Tha Chain
Join date: 1 Feb 2007
Posts: 387
|
05-14-2007 08:24
From: bilbo99 Emu I don't think I'm reading this right. So you sold the land for 5450L$ and bought it back for 6900L$?
And the landbot made 1550L$? nice work if you can get it! No, I sold (7) 512 lots. (6) lots were $7000L (1) lot was $5450L (336 sq m and 176 sq m), but showed up as 512. Not enough range to build anything on it. the bot bought the $5450L strip. The land reseller bought a $7000L lot thinking it was the $5450L just to beat everyone else. So, he sold the $7000L lot back to me for $6900L. So, I got a free 100L (which wasn't the point). then all 6 lots sold a few days later. The $5450L strips are now those 16 sq m ads.
|
ForestMist Skjellerup
Sculptor
Join date: 6 Dec 2006
Posts: 57
|
05-14-2007 08:50
From: Amity Slade Bait-and-switch is illegal in California (and I think in every state in the United States). Using Second Life to violate the law is supposedly a violation of the Terms of Service. Victims of bait-and-switch should start reporting Linden Labs to the California Department of Consumer Affairs. Submit a copy of the Second Life Terms of Service; a screen shot of the land advertised price; a screen shot of the land actual price; and a brief but clear explanation of how the money exchange works. When a few of those pile up, I bet there will be an investigation into Linden Labs' business practices. It would be nice if Linden Labs acted on these issues proactively, rather than waiting until they are threated with litigation. But that's their choice. Keeps the lawyers in business... I think LL will address this egregious exploit as quickly as they can. This kind of programming problem does take longer than an hour or two to fix though. The normal channel in the computer security world for those who find exploits, is to immediately inform the vendor (LL), and then after a reasonable time to fix it (not long in this case, I'd say), report it publicly to hacker watchdog sites, such as Bugtraq at securityfocus.org. I'm glad Sarah reported it, and hope someone has taken Strife's advice to report it directly to LL ASAP. -Fo
|
Meade Paravane
Hedgehog
Join date: 21 Nov 2006
Posts: 4,845
|
05-14-2007 08:56
From: ForestMist Skjellerup I'm glad Sarah reported it, and hope someone has taken Strife's advice to report it directly to LL ASAP. Looks like Elanthius added MISC-204.
_____________________
Tired of shouting clubs and lucky chairs? Vote for llParcelSay!!! - Go here: http://jira.secondlife.com/browse/SVC-1224- If you see "if you were logged in.." on the left, click it and log in - Click the "Vote for it" link on the left
|
Amity Slade
Registered User
Join date: 14 Feb 2007
Posts: 2,183
|
05-14-2007 08:57
From: ForestMist Skjellerup I think LL will address this egregious exploit as quickly as they can. This kind of programming problem does take longer than an hour or two to fix though.
I don't share your optimism, but I hope you're right. it seems to me that there is great potential for Second Life in many ways, including business, but in the brief while I've been on Second Life, Linden Labs hasn't really showed a great commitment to, or ability to, develop it to its potential. That is a shame.
|
Dnali Anabuki
Still Crazy
Join date: 17 Oct 2006
Posts: 1,633
|
05-14-2007 09:06
So does this mean the bots are now competing with each other? And the tactics getting dirtier by the minute to keep the ill gotten gains coming in. Racing to the bottom. So one bot owner now sees that this is happening and wants protection so their bots can keep working but the speedier/less honest bots can't. Because what is going to happen because of this scam is that eventually LL will regulate all the bots and I would imagine all bot owners are dreading that day. Sell to a reputable person who deals in land. And don't be fooled by bot runners who hide behind facades of being good SL Citizens.
Is any SL press doing investigative journalism on this? Or are they all easy/peasy fashion rags.
We need to keep pressuring LL about this as it is going to erode their future sure as donuts taste great and go to my hips. We are not hearing from all the people this has happened to and it creates a feel of SL being a place of fraud where the average person is at the mercy of the greedy and dishonest.
Shafted Life?
|
Meade Paravane
Hedgehog
Join date: 21 Nov 2006
Posts: 4,845
|
05-14-2007 09:10
From: Dnali Anabuki We need to keep pressuring LL about this as it is going to erode their future sure as donuts taste great and go to my hips. Vote for the JIRA issue. The more votes it gets, the more attention at LL it gets.
_____________________
Tired of shouting clubs and lucky chairs? Vote for llParcelSay!!! - Go here: http://jira.secondlife.com/browse/SVC-1224- If you see "if you were logged in.." on the left, click it and log in - Click the "Vote for it" link on the left
|
Ylikone Obscure
Amatuer Troll
Join date: 24 Jan 2007
Posts: 335
|
05-14-2007 09:11
This bait-and-switch thing probably won't affect too many people (except landbarons that deal with property exchanges all day)... just for the fact that when the price suddenly jumps tenfold, how many people are going to have that many extra lindens in their current balance to be able to complete the sale. Isn't it dangerous to keep a high linden balance in-world at the best of times?
|
Ralph Doctorow
Registered User
Join date: 16 Oct 2005
Posts: 560
|
This is an Exploit Bug
05-14-2007 09:14
I just confirmed this and bug reported it.
1) AV "Seller" sets a piece of land for sale for L$100 2) AV "Buyer" selects buy land - the purchase price is shown as L$100 3) "Seller" changes the price to L$110 4) "Buyer" clicks Purchase on the purchase menu that still shows L$100
The result is "Buyer" pays "Seller" L$110 without ever seeing that as the price.
IMHO this is a clear SL bug which LL should immediately do something about and should compensate people who lost money because of it. They should probably also consider banning people who exploited it, although it may be tough to prove intent.
|