Welcome to the Second Life Forums Archive

These forums are CLOSED. Please visit the new forums HERE

Traffic Bots Against the TOS of LL?

MortVent Charron
Can haz cuddles now?
Join date: 21 Sep 2007
Posts: 1,942
09-06-2008 14:23
From: Phil Deakins
Did I say that? I thought it was you who wanted it.

I've no desire to teach my customers the ways of SL, unless they ask me, as one or two do at times. My store isn't an infohub, y'know. It's a furniture store. I want my customers to base their decisions on all the relevant information about my furniture, that's all.

Why don't you take up the challenge that Rene made? Go out and do some research and ask the exact question that he posted. If you don't do it, it means you can't be bothered, and you're interest in this topic is a lot less that you make out.


I see so you want a clientele that is ignorant of anything that might make you lose a sale through open and transparent business operations?

and it gives me something to do to pass the time while compiling.

I guarantee if I had the time and energy to devote I could screw up search bad enough with bots and all the 'tricks' used to game it that it'd be the big pin that gets LL to yelp and fix it.

All I'd need is really one openspace sim, 99 bot accounts (easily done), some website tools, and then spamming the same prim over and over to fill up the search lists with the lot and the items on it.
_____________________
==========================================

Bippity boppity boo! I'm stalking you!

9 out of 10 voices in my head don't like you... the 10th went to get the ammo
Colette Meiji
Registered User
Join date: 25 Mar 2005
Posts: 15,556
09-06-2008 14:25
From: Phil Deakins
Then you make an staggering number of mistakes, Colette, because you've done it ever since I first came across you. Truly amazing. And I've never seen you admit such a mistake - not once - not even in this thread. Would you like to belatedly admit your mistakes in this thread to Bella now?


I didn't twist Bella's words and he made any corrections that were necessary.

Again - like I told Rene ...

Pre-existing bias and assumptions does equal knowledge of someone's motivations.

---------------

Now then since you are going on about apologies ..

are you going to apologize to Pie and Gabi for the apparently INTENTIONAL slights you made toward them?

Gabi's was particularly odious since you used a patronizing language to to get a reaction. Thats the sort of thing that gets people slapped when they aren't separated by the internet.
Rene Erlanger
Scuderia Shapes & Skins G
Join date: 28 Sep 2006
Posts: 2,008
09-06-2008 14:31
From: Pie Psaltery
I'm going to try to rephrase it again and see if I can get any better answer:

If it is accepted that Phil is completely within his rights to use trafficbots to game the search result, then it should be assumed that it is ok for every single merchant on the SL platform to follow suit and also use trafficbots.

If every single merchant used trafficbots to artifically inflate their traffic numbers to optimize their own position in search, not only would search be rendered a completely useless tool, but it would (yes, it would) negatively effect performance and assessablity to the SL platform for everyone.

Therefore, it would be negitive for SL as a platform if everyone used trafficbots.

So why is it ok for Phil?



Because you persistently make the same silly mistake of thinking that "Places Search" is the 'be all and end all' to companies marketing their products in SL

It's simply not true! It's just one marketing tool....and if you are clever at selecting good secondary words, you can still could be very high up on certain "Places Search" listings. From that, one can still draw traffic from Places Search if you spend time optimising your keywords.

Its' because that most businesses have already figured this out, and therefore would never entertain your suggestion in logging on an army of bots. It's pointless and wastes resources and time.

If Places Search were the only means of marketing your product within SL, then it would be a completley different ballgame....yes, it really would be "Bot wars" and eventually SL would come to a grinding halt.
Phil Deakins
Prim Savers = low prims
Join date: 17 Jan 2007
Posts: 9,537
09-06-2008 14:32
From: MortVent Charron
You look at the client side on the bots.

Does a bot:
1 - get polled for position data by the sim as often as a regular avatar in order to update traffic and the maps?
2 - have a network link to the grid's login servers and maintain that link in order to stay connected?
3 - poll to see if anything has changed in their area so the client can be updated?

The answer you know is yes, so they place a load equal to a standard avatar on the servers that handle that.
I wouldn't say the answer is yes to any of them.

#1 Unless you haven't explained what you mean clearly enough, there is no need to poll an av for it's position. The most sensible way to write it is for an av to contact the server when it moves, and for the server to keep a record of its position until it told that the av is moving again. So to #1, I say no.

#2 Yes but, as far as I know, that doesn't mean data between the two unless it is necessary; e.g. the av moves, another av comes into range, etc. If you are only talking about the server end, then I don't see any load in keeping a link open. It just stays open until it is closed.

#3 Definite no, imo as a programmer. No polling is necessary. What is necessary is for events to be dealt with; e.g. something has changed. And that would be done regardless of whether or not any avs are around.
_____________________
Prim Savers - almost 1000 items of superbly crafted, top quality, very low prim furniture, and all at amazingly low prices.

http://slurl.com/secondlife/Seymour/213/120/251/
Colette Meiji
Registered User
Join date: 25 Mar 2005
Posts: 15,556
09-06-2008 14:34
From: Rene Erlanger
Because you persistently make the same silly mistake of thinking that "Places Search" is the 'be all and end all' to companies marketing their products in SL


When did Pie say that?

When did anyone other than you say that?

Interesting about the whole "twisting" accusations. Isn't it?
Phil Deakins
Prim Savers = low prims
Join date: 17 Jan 2007
Posts: 9,537
09-06-2008 14:38
From: MortVent Charron
I see so you want a clientele that is ignorant of anything that might make you lose a sale through open and transparent business operations?
No, not at all. That's a fallacy, Mort. It's called "argument form fallacy" - look it up ;)

I don't mind in the slightest if my customers know all about it. I've told some of them, as you know. If you didn't invent things, it would be a much better discussion.
_____________________
Prim Savers - almost 1000 items of superbly crafted, top quality, very low prim furniture, and all at amazingly low prices.

http://slurl.com/secondlife/Seymour/213/120/251/
MortVent Charron
Can haz cuddles now?
Join date: 21 Sep 2007
Posts: 1,942
09-06-2008 14:41
From: Phil Deakins
No, not at all. That's a fallacy, Mort. It's called "argument form fallacy" - look it up ;)

I don't mind in the slightest if my customers know all about it. I've told some of them, as you know. If you didn't things up, it would be a much better discussion.


You claim to have told some. There is no evidence other than your word.

There is evidence in a refusal to educate and illuminate new visitors and such of your practices with a sign that anyone can pop in to verify as being there.
_____________________
==========================================

Bippity boppity boo! I'm stalking you!

9 out of 10 voices in my head don't like you... the 10th went to get the ammo
Colette Meiji
Registered User
Join date: 25 Mar 2005
Posts: 15,556
09-06-2008 14:45
From: Phil Deakins
No, not at all. That's a fallacy, Mort. It's called "argument form fallacy" - look it up ;)

I don't mind in the slightest if my customers know all about it. I've told some of them, as you know. If you didn't things up, it would be a much better discussion.


I dont see why Mort's argument is an example of Argument from Fallacy.

Maybe you should enlighten us. I did look it up.

As someone who makes plenty of fallacious arguments yourself, maybe you have some additional insights.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Argument_from_fallacy
Rene Erlanger
Scuderia Shapes & Skins G
Join date: 28 Sep 2006
Posts: 2,008
09-06-2008 14:46
From: Colette Meiji
I didn't say that was gaming. I said that was Ugly.



I didn't call the keywords gaming. I said they were ugly.

Like Ciaran I would like the parcel name to be allowed to be a nice clean name and use the body of Text to convey keywords and the rest.

It would be nice if instead of the parcel name adding extra weight it either used the Parcel description or even another field for tags.

Although it would be good if the keywords at least matched what that parcel contained.
-------------

And for those watching along at home - even though Rene misinterpreted me - I did not accuse her of twisting things.


If you must know...All Search does pick land description text as well prim description text that are set for sale..as well as Land name. When's the last time you logged into SL?

One last thing.......-----> Rene' =male.......and Renee' = female.
Phil Deakins
Prim Savers = low prims
Join date: 17 Jan 2007
Posts: 9,537
09-06-2008 14:48
From: Pie
If it is accepted that Phil is completely within his rights to use trafficbots to game the search result, then it should be assumed that it is ok for every single merchant on the SL platform to follow suit and also use trafficbots.

If every single merchant used trafficbots to artifically inflate their traffic numbers to optimize their own position in search, not only would search be rendered a completely useless tool, but it would (yes, it would) negatively effect performance and assessablity to the SL platform for everyone.

Therefore, it would be negitive for SL as a platform if everyone used trafficbots.

So why is it ok for Phil?
It's a fact that I am completely within my rights to use traffic bots to manipulate the search results. I don't think that can be sensibly argued against. So, yes it can be assumed that so is everyone else. If everyone did it, it most likely have a significantly negative impact on the SL system, as it would be a hell of a lot of bots. If anything like that started to happen then you can bet your boots that LL would act quickly. Until it starts to build up to unmanagable proportions, it's just argument for the sake of argument.
_____________________
Prim Savers - almost 1000 items of superbly crafted, top quality, very low prim furniture, and all at amazingly low prices.

http://slurl.com/secondlife/Seymour/213/120/251/
MortVent Charron
Can haz cuddles now?
Join date: 21 Sep 2007
Posts: 1,942
09-06-2008 14:50
From: Phil Deakins
It's a fact that I am completely within my rights to use traffic bots to manipulate the search results. I don't think that can be sensibly argued against. So, yes it can be assumed that so is everyone else. If everyone did it, it most likely have a significantly negative impact on the SL system, as it would be a hell of a lot of bots. If anything like that started to happen then you can bet your boots that LL would act quickly. Until it starts to build up to unmanagable proportions, it's just argument for the sake of argument.


So in order to get it fixed we need to contact some sim owners and put bot farms on their open areas till LL takes notice?

Can do if need be.

I know a few sim owners with openspace sims they can set to 100 person limits and let us have a bot farm on them.
_____________________
==========================================

Bippity boppity boo! I'm stalking you!

9 out of 10 voices in my head don't like you... the 10th went to get the ammo
Phil Deakins
Prim Savers = low prims
Join date: 17 Jan 2007
Posts: 9,537
09-06-2008 14:51
From: MortVent Charron
You claim to have told some. There is no evidence other than your word.

There is evidence in a refusal to educate and illuminate new visitors and such of your practices with a sign that anyone can pop in to verify as being there.
Alright, feel free to assume that I lied about it, Mort. I hadn't realised that you'd need chat logs (which could be faked anyway) - silly me.
_____________________
Prim Savers - almost 1000 items of superbly crafted, top quality, very low prim furniture, and all at amazingly low prices.

http://slurl.com/secondlife/Seymour/213/120/251/
Colette Meiji
Registered User
Join date: 25 Mar 2005
Posts: 15,556
09-06-2008 14:53
From: Rene Erlanger
If you must know...All Search does pick land description text as well prim description text that are set for sale..as well as Land name. When's the last time you logged into SL?

One last thing.......-----> Rene' =male.......and Renee' = female.


2 hours ago.

-------------

There is some weighting given to Parcel Names now for the All search. Thats why so many parcel names also include text that describes what that place is.

Not in the description field but in the name.

For example

Sue's Bait Shop as a name

will get preference over

Sue's

If you are searching for "bait"

Even if in the description field both included "bait" as a keyword.

Its all in the optimization thread sticky of Cristalle's .. and thats why so many parcel names are now ugly.



---------------------
Sorry about the her thing - I had no idea about the Rene / Renee difference
Phil Deakins
Prim Savers = low prims
Join date: 17 Jan 2007
Posts: 9,537
09-06-2008 14:54
From: MortVent Charron
So in order to get it fixed we need to contact some sim owners and put bot farms on their open areas till LL takes notice?

Can do if need be.

I know a few sim owners with openspace sims they can set to 100 person limits and let us have a bot farm on them.
Go for it. If you can get traffic removed, I and many others will applaud you.
_____________________
Prim Savers - almost 1000 items of superbly crafted, top quality, very low prim furniture, and all at amazingly low prices.

http://slurl.com/secondlife/Seymour/213/120/251/
Rene Erlanger
Scuderia Shapes & Skins G
Join date: 28 Sep 2006
Posts: 2,008
09-06-2008 14:54
From: MortVent Charron
Actually it's basic math, not an assumption.



Its a very stupid assumption as the present SL grid could not log in 50000 av's and 500000 bots. It's all hypothetical mumbo jumbo.....it's like grasping at the final straws!
Colette Meiji
Registered User
Join date: 25 Mar 2005
Posts: 15,556
09-06-2008 14:56
From: Rene Erlanger
Its a very stupid assumption as the present SL grid could not log in 50000 av's and 500000 bots. It's all hypothetical mumbo jumbo.....it's like grasping at the final straws!


I never claimed it was anything other than hypothetical.

Its not mumbo jumbo though

Its just an extrapolation.

Phil basically just admitted if all business owners did what he does the problem would force LL to step in.

From: Phil Deakins
If everyone did it, it most likely have a significantly negative impact on the SL system, as it would be a hell of a lot of bots. If anything like that started to happen then you can bet your boots that LL would act quickly. .
Rene Erlanger
Scuderia Shapes & Skins G
Join date: 28 Sep 2006
Posts: 2,008
09-06-2008 15:12
From: MortVent Charron
So we should ask for volunteers that own private open sims... so we can fill them with bots to boost traffic to them till LL takes notice.


The typical trait of the vocal minority trying to impose their will on the rest of us.
Do the Bots really effect your daily SL life? Do you have a home right next to a Bot farm and therefore restricts your access at times? Do you have agenda against person on this forum? I said in a previous post you come as being very vindictive.....nothing has changed on that score.
Colette Meiji
Registered User
Join date: 25 Mar 2005
Posts: 15,556
09-06-2008 15:18
From: Rene Erlanger
The typical trait of the vocal minority trying to impose their will on the rest of us.
Do the Bots really effect your daily SL life? Do you have a home right next to a Bot farm and therefore restricts your access at times? Do you have agenda against person on this forum? I said in a previous post you come as being very vindictive.....nothing has changed on that score.


Now how does that follow?

This "Silent Majority" you go on about isn't Pro-bot either, You have been making a point they do not care. That means they are neither Pro-Bot nor Anti-Bot.

Thus its not imposing on that Majority - since the pro-bot and the anti-bot would BOTH be minorities.








----------------
------------------
It still cracks me up about the Nixonesque "Silent Majority" bit, his other line was "I am not a crook" ROFL.
MortVent Charron
Can haz cuddles now?
Join date: 21 Sep 2007
Posts: 1,942
09-06-2008 15:36
From: Rene Erlanger
The typical trait of the vocal minority trying to impose their will on the rest of us.
Do the Bots really effect your daily SL life? Do you have a home right next to a Bot farm and therefore restricts your access at times? Do you have agenda against person on this forum? I said in a previous post you come as being very vindictive.....nothing has changed on that score.

And to be honest you and phil are also a vocal minority trying to impose your will on the masses that are ignorant of the issue (so they have no opinion on it yet... education may and likely would change that)

You assume vindictive, when I'm even less aggressive than you and phil.

I state means of demonstrating use of the same tools claimed to be okay for one person, and get told that it would be an AR offense or wrong for me to do so...

It's goose and gander time, it's wrong for someone to deliberately set up a location to game search for education of the masses that don't know about how searches are being manipulated.... but okay to manipulate search in order to put lindens in someone's pocket.
_____________________
==========================================

Bippity boppity boo! I'm stalking you!

9 out of 10 voices in my head don't like you... the 10th went to get the ammo
Colette Meiji
Registered User
Join date: 25 Mar 2005
Posts: 15,556
09-06-2008 15:38
You know .. it could also be viewed that a minority (the traffic gamers) imposed their will on everyone already.

The anti-botters are the ones who aren't happy about it.

Since the system Originally wasn't meant to be gamed.
Phil Deakins
Prim Savers = low prims
Join date: 17 Jan 2007
Posts: 9,537
09-06-2008 15:51
From: MortVent Charron
And to be honest you and phil are also a vocal minority trying to impose your will on the masses that are ignorant of the issue
Huh? What does Rene do to impose his will on the masses that are ignorant of the issue? I can understand you saying it about me, because I use traffic bots plain and simple, but Rene?

Before you employ your argument from fallacy technique to that, I should point out that it's not an admission that I try to impose my will etc. I don't. I just tend to my little corner of SL, and leave others to tend to theirs. When challenged about what I do in my little corner, I respond and that's all. You on the other hand, along with a few cohorts, want to tend to *all* of SL - impose your will on all of it.
_____________________
Prim Savers - almost 1000 items of superbly crafted, top quality, very low prim furniture, and all at amazingly low prices.

http://slurl.com/secondlife/Seymour/213/120/251/
Gabriele Graves
Always and Forever, FULL
Join date: 23 Apr 2007
Posts: 6,205
09-06-2008 15:51
From: Rene Erlanger
Come on Gabriele....now its not even about the existance of bots but it's numbers. Where is the line drawn?

I visited a shop last week on a private SIM....a well known fashion house actually. The sim was filled with green dots throughout the 3/4 shops located on that sim. The majority of these dots were actually Bot Models. They were modelling the products (some for skins, some for clothes, some for hair) on rotating stands.
Now i don't know about you, but as potential customer and in terms of clarity...it's easier to make a decision about a product viewing it on a 3D model than on a 2D photograph.
As a customer i think it helps my decision process........but we also know that all the bots present have the same effect as being cluttered together ina 700 m skybox. So in this instance it has 2 functionalities. You cannot accept one form and not the other.
So thats the dilemna. Maybe more businesses will adopt this approach who knows.......and i'm sure for most of the public this would be acceptable as it enhances their shopping experience.
Sheesh Rene, of course its about the numbers. It has always been about the numbers. The big fat traffic number. How is what I wrote that hard to understand? If you are running enough bots to elevate you to the top of traffic for your type of business then the intent of you having bots is evident even if wearing clothes and signing Waltzing Matilda! If it does not then you are probably genuiningly trying to present some clothing. Nobody needs more than a couple of bots for that andI am saying I could live with that. What amazes me is that you in you obviously pro-bot stance despite protestations are actually picking me to bits for that instead of being happy for that small concession. Go figure...
_____________________

Trout Rating: I'm giving you an 8.2 on the Troutchter Earth-Movement Slut Scale. You are an amazing, enchanting woman, and, when the situation calls for it, a slut of the very best sort. Congratulations and shame on you!
Gabriele Graves
Always and Forever, FULL
Join date: 23 Apr 2007
Posts: 6,205
09-06-2008 15:52
From: Rene Erlanger
You really talk in riddles and to be honest not very convincingly :(

If you really want proof to the assumptions i have made.....i offer you this challenge.

You do a 24 hour research into shopping habits of people. Select a dozen well established business location that use Bots......TP overthere and observe the customers that are milling around looking at products. If you want to take it one stage further for clarity sake...approach potential customers and ask them this 1 single question.
" Would you still be happying purchasing a product from here knowing that this particular shop uses Traffic bots to enhance their position in Places Search"

If you can't find the appropiate locations, i can send you a dozen Landmarks for you to view. Hopefully at the end of this exercise you might have a valid opinion!
Nope sorry, I am not into proving or disproving others people's supposed "facts" on this forum. If you are not happy with just presenting your opinions as just that and nothing more then you go gather some facts yourself and come back.
BTW I am not talking in riddles, if you cannot understand what is written then ask for clarification, and I will happily explain further.
_____________________

Trout Rating: I'm giving you an 8.2 on the Troutchter Earth-Movement Slut Scale. You are an amazing, enchanting woman, and, when the situation calls for it, a slut of the very best sort. Congratulations and shame on you!
MortVent Charron
Can haz cuddles now?
Join date: 21 Sep 2007
Posts: 1,942
09-06-2008 15:55
From: Phil Deakins
Huh? What does Rene do to impose his will on the masses that are ignorant of the issue? I can understand you saying it about me, because I use traffic bots plain and simple, but Rene?

Before you employ your argument from fallacy technique to that, I should point out that it's not an admission that I try to impose my will etc. I don't. I just tend to my little corner of SL, and leave others to tend to theirs. When challenged about what I do in my little corner, I respond and that's all. You on the other hand, along with a few cohorts, want to tend to *all* of SL - impose your will on all of it.


Actually you do impose your will or try to by coming here and speaking out against the other minority.

And you impose your will in world through the use of the bots to manipulate search to show what you want it to show.
_____________________
==========================================

Bippity boppity boo! I'm stalking you!

9 out of 10 voices in my head don't like you... the 10th went to get the ammo
Rene Erlanger
Scuderia Shapes & Skins G
Join date: 28 Sep 2006
Posts: 2,008
09-06-2008 15:59
From: MortVent Charron
Oh when you point out assumptions on someone's part it's okay. When others do it's insult worthy?

You assume they are aware there are dots up in the sky, when they can very well be unaware of the bot box.

And since they are unaware of the bots, then their shopping there might change if they knew the bots were there. After all they may be unaware the bots are there, and many are unaware that bots can be used to alter the traffic stats in order to manipulate search.

I know a couple that had to be told why people were offering to buy their picks now, as well as explain the current use of camping/bots.

The silent majority is quite commonly unaware of the issues that the vocal minority had problems with.



Yes, I agree...many of the silent majority are totally unaware and equally there are ones that do know, but really could not care less in the grand scheme of things.
1 ... 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 ... 66