Welcome to the Second Life Forums Archive

These forums are CLOSED. Please visit the new forums HERE

The Garlic Necklace doesn't really work.

HoneyBear Lilliehook
Owner, The Mall at Cherry
Join date: 18 Jun 2007
Posts: 4,500
02-25-2009 10:21
From: Love Hastings
It occurs to me that Mystitool is far worse than BL. Every time I log in, it contacts something somewhere, and I get a fresh update delivered to me. Never does it ask me if before doing so. Perhaps there's a setting, but if so, it has the wrong default.


Only if you're wearing it, Love.

And update it, then it won't ask you anymore ;)
_____________________
Virtual Freebies now has its own domain!
URL=http://virtualfreebiesblog.com

The Mall at Cherry Park - new vendors, new look!
Ava Cartier
Asshat Extraordinaire
Join date: 17 Mar 2003
Posts: 55
02-25-2009 10:21
I belonged to Bloodlines in the beginning. Damn thing's more trouble than it's worth. I allowed someone to bite me, and then bought everything Bloodlines has to offer, intending to immerse myself in RP. Yeah, well, I have ADD apparently and now couldn't give a toss about BL. So of more concern to me than having my avatar's name on some website, is all this overpriced crap I have sitting in my inventory. But, I digress. I'm not going to procure a garlic strand. What's the point? When people harrass me about anything, vampire or otherwise, if I'm in a crappy mood, I mute 'em. If I'm in a good mood, I mess with 'em until they mute me. So your av's name is on some stupid website. Who cares? I don't think any av is going to steal another av's identity or commit credit fraud. I guess I don't understand the uproar. I've not taken part in months and not ONE person has bothered me. I don't wear the HUD, I don't use any of my BL paraphernalia. No problem.
Love Hastings
#66666
Join date: 21 Aug 2007
Posts: 4,094
02-25-2009 10:24
From: HoneyBear Lilliehook
Only if you're wearing it, Love.


Irrelevant. It still violates the TOS, apparently.

From: someone

And update it, then it won't ask you anymore ;)


Sigh. Have to rez a barrel, start a copy, wait, switch huds, start another copy, wait... I'll get to it... LOL :)
_____________________
Dakota Tebaldi
Voodoo Child
Join date: 6 Feb 2008
Posts: 1,873
02-25-2009 10:25
From: Solar Legion
1. Did I say it was your fault or your problem? No I did not.


Then the limitations of the system they created do not matter to this discussion.

From: Solar Legion
2. Your examples are wholly invalid: as were your expectations. You do NOT need to be wholly removed from their database to no longer be a part of their system: That is a cold, hard fact.


I say I do. The vampire HUD queries the website when it makes a bite request, to find out if biting me is OK. If the website says "no", the bite is disallowed. If the website says "yes", it then also gives that HUD my stats and any restrictions, etc. But whether the website's answer is "no" or "yes, and...", the fact that it is able to send information about me at all proves I'm "in the system" AND still on the website. Maybe I can't see my name by going to the website, but the HUD can see my name by going to the same website, which means pretty obviously I'm still on it.

From: Solar Legion
3. No, by your title and presentation ... the point of the experiment was to see if the necklace does its job: It does so long as the effect is active. Everything from the removal of that effect forward invalidates the experiment.


I cannot help what you infer. I've clarified numerous times already - all you can do is say "Nuh-uh!" over and over; but it was my experiment, I designed it to find out whether the necklace actually removes your data from the Bloodlines system. I found that it does not. You can claim all you want that's not really the reason I designed the experiment...but, well, I'm the one who designed it, so I'm in a slightly better position to make such a statement.

From: Solar Legion
Now then ... instead of complaining about it so much, do whatever you need to do to keep from getting requests and move on.

Your data exists across hundreds, if not THOUSANDS, of outside servers all without your permission anyway. Get over it.


You seem to think I need your permission to complain. I do not; I will continue to whine for as long as I feel justified. Whether YOU feel I'm justified makes no nevermind to me.
_____________________
"...Dakota will grow up to be very scary... but in a HOT and desireable kind of way." - 3Ring Binder

"I really do think it's a pity he didnt "age" himself to 18." - Jig Chippewa

:cool:
HoneyBear Lilliehook
Owner, The Mall at Cherry
Join date: 18 Jun 2007
Posts: 4,500
02-25-2009 10:26
From: Love Hastings
Irrelevant. It still violates the TOS, apparently.



Sigh. Have to rez a barrel, start a copy, wait, switch huds, start another copy, wait... I'll get to it... LOL :)


Seriously, doesn't take more than 5 minutes, and that's only if you have it loaded up with landmarks you want to keep.

And you purchased a product, with automatic updates. You won't GET the updates if you don't wear the purchased product. So how is it violating TOS? If you purchased any other product, wouldn't you want the free updates?
_____________________
Virtual Freebies now has its own domain!
URL=http://virtualfreebiesblog.com

The Mall at Cherry Park - new vendors, new look!
Treasure Ballinger
Virtual Ability
Join date: 31 Dec 2007
Posts: 2,745
02-25-2009 10:27
From: Love Hastings
Irrelevant. It still violates the TOS, apparently.



Sigh. Have to rez a barrel, start a copy, wait, switch huds, start another copy, wait... I'll get to it... LOL :)


Right, that. Which I did when I got the one update notice. Which is probably why it doesn't ask me anymore. Which makes me wonder if I need to check out my Jeffries Tube (Novatech) update notices, which could be why it's getting so frantic and panicky, maybe I need to 'do' something to make it happy and stop it from contacting me. Yep, will bet that's it!
Love Hastings
#66666
Join date: 21 Aug 2007
Posts: 4,094
02-25-2009 10:28
From: HoneyBear Lilliehook
Seriously, doesn't take more than 5 minutes, and that's only if you have it loaded up with landmarks you want to keep.


I just upgraded a few weeks ago. LOL.

From: someone

And you purchased a product, with automatic updates. You won't GET the updates if you don't wear the purchased product. So how is it violating TOS? If you purchased any other product, wouldn't you want the free updates?


I'm not complaining about Mystitools, HoneyBear. It's a feature, and I see it as such. My point really has nothing to do with Mystitools specifically - it's just an example.
_____________________
HoneyBear Lilliehook
Owner, The Mall at Cherry
Join date: 18 Jun 2007
Posts: 4,500
02-25-2009 10:30
From: Love Hastings
I just upgraded a few weeks ago. LOL.



I'm not complaining about Mystitools, HoneyBear. It's a feature, and I see it as such. My point really has nothing to do with Mystitools specifically - it's just an example.


I respectfully submit that, in this particular case, it doesn't fall into the same category.

Peace!
_____________________
Virtual Freebies now has its own domain!
URL=http://virtualfreebiesblog.com

The Mall at Cherry Park - new vendors, new look!
Aeryn Lovenkraft
Registered User
Join date: 8 Oct 2007
Posts: 13
Level Headed Post Of The Day
02-25-2009 10:30
From: Desmond Shang
I haven't really cared about it one way or the other, so it hasn't had any power over me.

Vampires, bite me. Whatever...


No surprise that Desmond wins this award again. Or in other words: Ramana Maharshi said, "Rather than cover the earth with leather to walk on, it's easier to make shoes for my feet."
Dakota Tebaldi
Voodoo Child
Join date: 6 Feb 2008
Posts: 1,873
02-25-2009 10:30
From: Love Hastings
Well, it seems to violate the "surreptitious" nature of the communication, according to Dakota's TOS interpretation. Isn't that enough? Why does my having purchased it make any difference to that?


Because the Mystitool documentation TELLS you that it includes an auto-update feature (which makes it not-surreptitious), and you can choose not to use the tool if you don't want any updates. As a matter of fact, you can use Mystitool and receive its updates for a year, and then suddenly arbitrarily decide you no longer want to, and you can detach the Mystitool and never, ever, ever hear from them ever again, nor does Mystitool actually ever collect and store your name in case someday you "might" change your mind.

People who do not want to be a part of Bloodlines' system do not have the option of removing themselves from it; they only have an option which helps them pretend they have been removed.
_____________________
"...Dakota will grow up to be very scary... but in a HOT and desireable kind of way." - 3Ring Binder

"I really do think it's a pity he didnt "age" himself to 18." - Jig Chippewa

:cool:
Love Hastings
#66666
Join date: 21 Aug 2007
Posts: 4,094
02-25-2009 10:31
I should add, free updates can be done a number of ways. Through a group notice, being made available at a store (click a prim type of affair), or even having an "upgrade" button on the device itself. What Mystitools does is automatically connects to some other system every time I log in, without my consent. If I were paranoid, I'd say that whomever has access to that information knows my SL schedule now, probably better than I do. But I'm not. ;)
_____________________
Solar Legion
Darkness from Light
Join date: 9 Dec 2006
Posts: 434
02-25-2009 10:32
From: Dakota Tebaldi
Then the limitations of the system they created do not matter to this discussion.



I say I do. The vampire HUD queries the website when it makes a bite request, to find out if biting me is OK. If the website says "no", the bite is disallowed. If the website says "yes", it then also gives that HUD my stats and any restrictions, etc. But whether the website's answer is "no" or "yes, and...", the fact that it is able to send information about me at all proves I'm "in the system" AND still on the website. Maybe I can't see my name by going to the website, but the HUD can see my name by going to the same website, which means pretty obviously I'm still on it.



I cannot help what you infer. I've clarified numerous times already - all you can do is say "Nuh-uh!" over and over; but it was my experiment, I designed it to find out whether the necklace actually removes your data from the Bloodlines system. I found that it does not. You can claim all you want that's not really the reason I designed the experiment...but, well, I'm the one who designed it, so I'm in a slightly better position to make such a statement.



You seem to think I need your permission to complain. I do not; I will continue to whine for as long as I feel justified. Whether YOU feel I'm justified makes no nevermind to me.


I will be blunt here Dakota: You and everyone else complaining is, to me, the exact same thing as suing say .... McDonald's after spilling boiling hot coffee on yourself and using the 'logic' that you were not TOLD ON THE CUP that the contents would be hot.

The way the system works IS relevant Dakota: Removal of all statistics is currently not possible as long as such a function can be abused. In addition it MUST store SOMETHING to know to tell the HUD "No."

You want to complain? Do so to the proper person and in the proper manner.

All you have done is stir the pot with information that anyone who had thought it all out would have known by now.

That is NOT a proper complaint ... nor is it a real form OF complaining.
_____________________
Obscurum est Eternus
Love Hastings
#66666
Join date: 21 Aug 2007
Posts: 4,094
02-25-2009 10:34
From: Dakota Tebaldi
As a matter of fact, you can use Mystitool and receive its updates for a year, and then suddenly arbitrarily decide you no longer want to, and you can detach the Mystitool and never, ever, ever hear from them ever again, ...


But I want to use mystitool. OK, we're back to my original point. If you don't want your SL avatar's name in the BL database, then delete your SL account. You can opt out of SL just as easily as I can opt out of Mystitools. Not the same, you say? Is to me.

From: someone
... nor does Mystitool actually ever collect and store your name in case someday you "might" change your mind..


How do you know that?
_____________________
Argent Stonecutter
Emergency Mustelid
Join date: 20 Sep 2005
Posts: 20,263
02-25-2009 10:37
From: Love Hastings
Well, it seems to violate the "surreptitious" nature of the communication, according to Dakota's TOS interpretation. Isn't that enough? Why does my having purchased it make any difference to that?
The concept of a "business relationship" is pretty common in law and trade. If you buy something from someone, you have a business relationship with them.
_____________________
Argent Stonecutter - http://globalcausalityviolation.blogspot.com/

"And now I'm going to show you something really cool."

Skyhook Station - http://xrl.us/skyhook23
Coonspiracy Store - http://xrl.us/coonstore
Love Hastings
#66666
Join date: 21 Aug 2007
Posts: 4,094
02-25-2009 10:38
From: Argent Stonecutter
The concept of a "business relationship" is pretty common in law and trade. If you buy something from someone, you have a business relationship with them.


And the TOS references this relationship as an exception?

We're not talking laws here. We're talking about terms of service to a private corporations services.
_____________________
Argent Stonecutter
Emergency Mustelid
Join date: 20 Sep 2005
Posts: 20,263
02-25-2009 10:41
From: Solar Legion
I will be blunt here Dakota: You and everyone else complaining is, to me, the exact same thing as suing say .... McDonald's after spilling boiling hot coffee on yourself and using the 'logic' that you were not TOLD ON THE CUP that the contents would be hot.
Actually, if you look into the circumstances of the McDonalds spilled coffee lawsuit, McDonalds set themselves up the bomb big-time, with years of settling lawsuits and acknowledging that their coffee was hotter than people would reasonably expect. Why they decided to play hardball with one old lady with third degree burns all over her thighs and belly (yes, really) I don't know, but they really did deserve to go down.

Personally I think Dakota is going a bit off the rails, here, but Bloodlines are setting themselves up the bomb by running what's effectively a combat system that involves people not wearing a combat HUD.
_____________________
Argent Stonecutter - http://globalcausalityviolation.blogspot.com/

"And now I'm going to show you something really cool."

Skyhook Station - http://xrl.us/skyhook23
Coonspiracy Store - http://xrl.us/coonstore
Argent Stonecutter
Emergency Mustelid
Join date: 20 Sep 2005
Posts: 20,263
02-25-2009 10:42
From: Love Hastings
And the TOS references this relationship as an exception?
I don't care, I'm simply pointing out that the concept of a "business relationship" is not coming out of thin air.
_____________________
Argent Stonecutter - http://globalcausalityviolation.blogspot.com/

"And now I'm going to show you something really cool."

Skyhook Station - http://xrl.us/skyhook23
Coonspiracy Store - http://xrl.us/coonstore
Dakota Tebaldi
Voodoo Child
Join date: 6 Feb 2008
Posts: 1,873
02-25-2009 10:45
From: Solar Legion
I will be blunt here Dakota: You and everyone else complaining is, to me, the exact same thing as suing say .... McDonald's after spilling boiling hot coffee on yourself and using the 'logic' that you were not TOLD ON THE CUP that the contents would be hot.


No, it is not. Said person knows they have a cup of coffee - they've actually purchased it, so they have reason to believe there's a cup with something hot in it that could burn them if they spilled it on themselves. I didn't buy a cup of coffee. I didn't buy anything at all. In fact, I specifically said I didn't WANT any coffee.

A closer analogy would be McDonald's having a "samples" stand on a street corner, thrusting a bag out at me as I walked by saying "Here, have a free sandwich!" without telling me there's an uncovered cup of steaming hot coffee in the bag where I can't see it, which then burns me as it spills when I jostle the bag. Your counter that "well the system doesn't work that way" would be like McDonald's saying "well sorry, but our policy is that all free sandwich samples must come with an unlidded cup of fresh coffee in the bag. That's the way it's always been, and you should've known." Except that there was no sign anywhere stating that policy.

From: Solar Legion
The way the system works IS relevant Dakota: Removal of all statistics is currently not possible as long as such a function can be abused. In addition it MUST store SOMETHING to know to tell the HUD "No."


That's their fault; they should have to fix it. I shouldn't have to put up with it.

From: Solar Legion
You want to complain? Do so to the proper person and in the proper manner.


This is absolutely a reasonable suggestion and I agree with it fully. Unfortunatley, the "proper person" has proven arrogant and cavalier towards people with this particular concern. That changes the equation and makes this now the "proper manner", so far as I'm concerned. The Bloodlines creators bought this reaction with their attitude, plain and simple.
_____________________
"...Dakota will grow up to be very scary... but in a HOT and desireable kind of way." - 3Ring Binder

"I really do think it's a pity he didnt "age" himself to 18." - Jig Chippewa

:cool:
LittleMe Jewell
...........
Join date: 8 Oct 2007
Posts: 11,319
02-25-2009 10:50
I got the necklace and wore it quite a while back -- I even posted a thread about the necklace that has been necro'd a few times.

However, just 2 days ago, I had some guy ask to bite me. When I got mad, he said he could tell me where to get a necklace. After I told him I had already done that, he said that apparently I need to do it again for some reason.

Pissed me off.
_____________________
♥♥♥
-Lil

Why do you sit there looking like an envelope without any address on it?
~Mark Twain~

Optimism is denial, so face the facts and move on.
♥♥♥
Lil's Yard Sale / Inventory Cleanout: http://slurl.com/secondlife/Triggerfish/52/27/22
.
http://www.flickr.com/photos/littleme_jewell
Dakota Tebaldi
Voodoo Child
Join date: 6 Feb 2008
Posts: 1,873
02-25-2009 10:51
From: Love Hastings
But I want to use mystitool. OK, we're back to my original point. If you don't want your SL avatar's name in the BL database, then delete your SL account. You can opt out of SL just as easily as I can opt out of Mystitools. Not the same, you say? Is to me.


Funny. You can "opt out" of Mystitools without having to delete your SL account. Yet that makes them all the same?


From: Love Hastings
How do you know that?


There's no reason to suspect Mystitools keeps such a database. If there were, that would be different.

I'm not dissatisfied because I THINK that Bloodlines MIGHT, possibly, theoretically, conceivably retain my information in an external database despite my wishes; I'm dissatisfied because such has been empirically proven to be true. That's why the notion that my name "could be" in a thousand other databases without my permission doesn't bother me: I KNOW for certain it's in the Bloodlines database, therefore there is something specific to express dissatisfaction with.
_____________________
"...Dakota will grow up to be very scary... but in a HOT and desireable kind of way." - 3Ring Binder

"I really do think it's a pity he didnt "age" himself to 18." - Jig Chippewa

:cool:
Yumi Murakami
DoIt!AttachTheEarOfACat!
Join date: 27 Sep 2005
Posts: 6,860
02-25-2009 10:54
From: Dakota Tebaldi

There's no reason to suspect Mystitools keeps such a database. If there were, that would be different.


Most auto-updaters, in fact, do not use a database.
Love Hastings
#66666
Join date: 21 Aug 2007
Posts: 4,094
02-25-2009 10:56
From: Dakota Tebaldi
Funny. You can "opt out" of Mystitools without having to delete your SL account. Yet that makes them all the same?


Well, BL is a product of how SL is designed and built, and the policies which LL enforces. It even conforms to "your world, your imagination" as far as the creator of BL is concerned (see that Yumi?). Your issue with BL is really an issue with LL. If you don't like it, you can always opt out.

Oh, and why is it the same to me? I couldn't stand being SL without my wonderful Mystitools! :p
_____________________
Dakota Tebaldi
Voodoo Child
Join date: 6 Feb 2008
Posts: 1,873
02-25-2009 10:58
From: Yumi Murakami
Most auto-updaters, in fact, do not use a database.


Indeed, they shouldn't have to. An object can be scripted to ping a website or another object without HAVING to identify the wearer at all; because the results are sent back to the script, not the avatar wearing it, and the script can say the results in chat - even with llOwnerSay, the avatar's identifying information never goes beyond script itself.
_____________________
"...Dakota will grow up to be very scary... but in a HOT and desireable kind of way." - 3Ring Binder

"I really do think it's a pity he didnt "age" himself to 18." - Jig Chippewa

:cool:
Love Hastings
#66666
Join date: 21 Aug 2007
Posts: 4,094
02-25-2009 10:58
From: Dakota Tebaldi

I'm not dissatisfied because I THINK that Bloodlines MIGHT, possibly, theoretically, conceivably retain my information in an external database despite my wishes; I'm dissatisfied because such has been empirically proven to be true. That's why the notion that my name "could be" in a thousand other databases without my permission doesn't bother me: I KNOW for certain it's in the Bloodlines database, therefore there is something specific to express dissatisfaction with.


I wish there was a version of that picture of the sad girl and "information" somehow represented with the caption, "not yours" to illustrate my point. :D
_____________________
Yumi Murakami
DoIt!AttachTheEarOfACat!
Join date: 27 Sep 2005
Posts: 6,860
02-25-2009 10:59
From: Love Hastings
Well, BL is a product of how SL is designed and built, and the policies which LL enforces. It even conforms to "your world, your imagination" as far as the creator of BL is concerned (see that Yumi?). Your issue with BL is really an issue with LL. If you don't like it, you can always opt out.


"Your world, your imagination" isn't a policy statement, and as a marketing statement it's meant to apply to everyone, not just to the creator of BL.

And saying "you can leave SL to opt out" is pretty ridiculous. That'd be like a company hassling you day and night with marketing messages and saying that, well, you can always opt out - by killing yourself.
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 ... 12