Chinese woman in Germany earning six figure salary speculating on SL real estate?
|
Deklax Fairplay
Black Sun
Join date: 2 Jul 2004
Posts: 357
|
03-17-2005 12:40
From: Nolan Nash From Anshe perhaps? Well, before looking like a total fool I actually bothered to ask. Thank you come again. Even these forums arn't public domain. If I was to repost a compendium of Nolan Nash quotable quotes outside of this forum I would be banned. BAN PHILLIP!!!! 
_____________________
Better Dead Than Red!
|
Torrid Midnight
Work in progress
Join date: 13 May 2003
Posts: 814
|
03-17-2005 16:13
It would be great to make a 6 figure salary off of SL alone but I wouldn't step on people to get it. I'm not implying that Anshe has, you always hear rumors and never know what's true.
|
Einsman Schlegel
Disenchanted Fool
Join date: 11 Jun 2003
Posts: 1,461
|
03-17-2005 16:15
From: Nolan Nash Ever been in RL?  I am teasing a bit of course... but, it's human nature. Want evidence? Turn on your television. Yes I have, which is why I don't watch TV anymore!  . Only History Channel!
|
Anshe Chung
Business Girl
Join date: 22 Mar 2004
Posts: 1,615
|
03-18-2005 07:00
Yes, Philip's statement is true. Except that "salary" is the wrong term. I did not cash out to buy Porsche car, but I reinvested most of my earning to help SL grow and as such still have it on high risk.
To agree to such figure become disclosed would have been one very bad business decision on my part - if it would have been business decision.
But it wasn't.
It was one decision I made as member of this community because I think it may help people out there to understand that Second Life is more than one game.
So now one girl has exposed herself even more naked on the public altar. Please help me when those who are waiting for their chance will try to sacrifice me.
One good friend shout at you at home when he think you make mistake, but stand up for you in public. This community is still small and I still have hope we could all stick together. "Celebrity", "feted", "inner core" - I think this is all rubbish that nobody wants. We need community, not cult or witch hunt. We are all feted and all of us are the inner core.
You look outside, look at the real world, the world of 6 billion people. What do you see? You see one real world dominated to 99% by one old elite of patent holders, inherited wealth, nth-generation share holders and communist party leaders' grand children. Yes, you see one world full of corruption where it count whom you know or how much money your parents have. Where you invent something and before you turn around one big company stole your idea and sue you with patent infringement. Where the little guy get taxed to death. Where propaganda control your mind. Where only small areas are still dynamic enough to allow newcomer really get to top. Even Bill Gates had rich parents and connections, despite all the mythos spread via the rich people owned media.
Now one girl bought 9,95$ lifetime account and made 100k US$ worth of property in one virtual world. No connections, no prior wealth, no special computer art skills and all 100% within the rules. And if you look carefully she is really just one of many, more known than some others maybe, but still in no way unique.
So if we want to be serious and help Second Life take over or expand the world we need become one team. We need develop our own strength, our own skills, our own brands and our own capital to be prepared for when the real-life elite discovers this space and tries take it over with their patents, copyrights and real-life money. We all share one vision of virtual reality that is based on creativity and opportunity for those who participate, not only for those who own stock of Electronic Arts or Sony.
We don't need content baron vs land baron, SLEx vs Gigas or Ansheism vs Ulrikaism. We should support each other and take pride in each other's achievements because real challenge in the future will be Second Life vs Pepsi Life. It will be the ultimate battle between one real virtual life that allows people to grow like I and others did or the Evercraft golden cage that turns millions into programmed little zombies locked away in guided-entertainment threadmill spaces. Yes, it is one new battle of freedom vs imprisonment, including the freedom to create, have sex or become one US$ millionaire.
_____________________
ANSHECHUNG.COM: Buy land - Sell land - Rent land - Sell sim - Rent store - Earn L$ - Buy L$ - Sell L$ SLEXCHANGE.COM: Come join us on Second Life's most popular website for shopping addicts. Click, buy and smile 
|
Eboni Khan
Misanthrope
Join date: 17 Mar 2004
Posts: 2,133
|
03-18-2005 07:06
From: Anshe Chung Yes, Philip's statement is true. Except that "salary" is the wrong term. I did not cash out to buy Porsche car, but I reinvested most of my earning to help SL grow and as such still have it on high risk.
To agree to such figure become disclosed would have been one very bad business decision on my part - if it would have been business decision.
But it wasn't.
It was one decision I made as member of this community because I think it may help people out there to understand that Second Life is more than one game.
So now one girl has exposed herself even more naked on the public altar. Please help me when those who are waiting for their chance will try to sacrifice me.
One good friend shout at you at home when he think you make mistake, but stand up for you in public. This community is still small and I still have hope we could all stick together. "Celebrity", "feted", "inner core" - I think this is all rubbish that nobody wants. We need community, not cult or witch hunt. We are all feted and all of us are the inner core.
You look outside, look at the real world, the world of 6 billion people. What do you see? You see one real world dominated to 99% by one old elite of patent holders, inherited wealth, nth-generation share holders and communist party leaders' grand children. Yes, you see one world full of corruption where it count whom you know or how much money your parents have. Where you invent something and before you turn around one big company stole your idea and sue you with patent infringement. Where the little guy get taxed to death. Where propaganda control your mind. Where only small areas are still dynamic enough to allow newcomer really get to top. Even Bill Gates had rich parents and connections, despite all the mythos spread via the rich people owned media.
Now one girl bought 9,95$ lifetime account and made 100k US$ worth of property in one virtual world. No connections, no prior wealth, no special computer art skills and all 100% within the rules. And if you look carefully she is really just one of many, more known than some others maybe, but still in no way unique.
So if we want to be serious and help Second Life take over or expand the world we need become one team. We need develop our own strength, our own skills, our own brands and our own capital to be prepared for when the real-life elite discovers this space and tries take it over with their patents, copyrights and real-life money. We all share one vision of virtual reality that is based on creativity and opportunity for those who participate, not only for those who own stock of Electronic Arts or Sony.
We don't need content baron vs land baron, SLEx vs Gigas or Ansheism vs Ulrikaism. We should support each other and take pride in each other's achievements because real challenge in the future will be Second Life vs Pepsi Life. It will be the ultimate battle between one real virtual life that allows people to grow like I and others did or the Evercraft golden cage that turns millions into programmed little zombies locked away in guided-entertainment threadmill spaces. Yes, it is one new battle of freedom vs imprisonment, including the freedom to create, have sex and become one US$ millionaire. *Tears Up* Cues... "We are the world, we are the childern, we are the ones to make a brighter day..."
|
John Prototype
Registered User
Join date: 16 Jul 2004
Posts: 84
|
03-18-2005 07:46
From: Torley Torgeson I do think unusual circumstances, unique people are going to get brought up... note the focus of that article on Wilde Cunningham, an extraordinary real-life story unfolding in Second Life... I'm not going to split hairs but there were a few other inaccuracies in that article, as positive as parts of it were. "No dragons to slay" being one of them, the limiting and archaic description of "a video game" being another (which comes with disconcerting juxtaposition to Wilde's experiences -- more than a "game"  . (And my gosh, I've never heard Asperger's referred to as "extreme geek syndrome" before -- and I've even Googled for that! 0 hits.) Perhaps Anshe just wasn't brought up by name, but recollected anecdotally...  It's been used quite a bit, actually. http://www.wired.com/wired/archive/9.12/aspergers_pr.htmlhttp://www.time.com/time/covers/1101020506/scaspergers.htmlPersonally, I don't like the term that much, because I think it's somewhat pejorative and an oversimplification. But I mentioned it to the reporter because it sometimes is an easy way for people to kind of "grok" the basics of Asperger's very quickly, and it has been used before in popular press. He also misquoted me..I didn't say "these people learn to socialize the way *regular* people learn to play the piano"...I used the term "people without Asperger's Syndrome" Grrr...I hate the term "regular people"....nobody is "regular"...we're all uniquely different. And he forgot to put the blog URLs in there for Brigadoon and Live2Give to help people wanting more information. I had asked him explicitly to do this. O well. Anyway, such is the game you play when talking to reporters. Never quite know what they're going to print.
|
John Prototype
Registered User
Join date: 16 Jul 2004
Posts: 84
|
03-18-2005 07:49
From: Anshe Chung Yes, Philip's statement is true. Except that "salary" is the wrong term. I did not cash out to buy Porsche car, but I reinvested most of my earning to help SL grow and as such still have it on high risk.
To agree to such figure become disclosed would have been one very bad business decision on my part - if it would have been business decision.
But it wasn't.
It was one decision I made as member of this community because I think it may help people out there to understand that Second Life is more than one game.
So now one girl has exposed herself even more naked on the public altar. Please help me when those who are waiting for their chance will try to sacrifice me.
One good friend shout at you at home when he think you make mistake, but stand up for you in public. This community is still small and I still have hope we could all stick together. "Celebrity", "feted", "inner core" - I think this is all rubbish that nobody wants. We need community, not cult or witch hunt. We are all feted and all of us are the inner core.
You look outside, look at the real world, the world of 6 billion people. What do you see? You see one real world dominated to 99% by one old elite of patent holders, inherited wealth, nth-generation share holders and communist party leaders' grand children. Yes, you see one world full of corruption where it count whom you know or how much money your parents have. Where you invent something and before you turn around one big company stole your idea and sue you with patent infringement. Where the little guy get taxed to death. Where propaganda control your mind. Where only small areas are still dynamic enough to allow newcomer really get to top. Even Bill Gates had rich parents and connections, despite all the mythos spread via the rich people owned media.
Now one girl bought 9,95$ lifetime account and made 100k US$ worth of property in one virtual world. No connections, no prior wealth, no special computer art skills and all 100% within the rules. And if you look carefully she is really just one of many, more known than some others maybe, but still in no way unique.
So if we want to be serious and help Second Life take over or expand the world we need become one team. We need develop our own strength, our own skills, our own brands and our own capital to be prepared for when the real-life elite discovers this space and tries take it over with their patents, copyrights and real-life money. We all share one vision of virtual reality that is based on creativity and opportunity for those who participate, not only for those who own stock of Electronic Arts or Sony.
We don't need content baron vs land baron, SLEx vs Gigas or Ansheism vs Ulrikaism. We should support each other and take pride in each other's achievements because real challenge in the future will be Second Life vs Pepsi Life. It will be the ultimate battle between one real virtual life that allows people to grow like I and others did or the Evercraft golden cage that turns millions into programmed little zombies locked away in guided-entertainment threadmill spaces. Yes, it is one new battle of freedom vs imprisonment, including the freedom to create, have sex or become one US$ millionaire. That was really nice, Anshe. Inspirational, actually. Thanks for sharing these very positive feelings and ideas.
|
Buster Peel
Spat the dummy.
Join date: 7 Feb 2005
Posts: 1,242
|
03-18-2005 07:55
From: Anshe Chung We don't need content baron vs land baron, SLEx vs Gigas or Ansheism vs Ulrikaism. We should support each other and take pride in each other's achievements ... This is THE most sensible thing I have EVER seen posted in the forums. <claps> 'Atta girl.
|
Emma Thorn
Voice of Treason
Join date: 26 Mar 2004
Posts: 139
|
03-18-2005 09:05
From: Beryl Greenacre Okay, was anybody besides me thinking of the resemblance between these two (see picture below)? Maybe I'm hallucinating, I dunno.  Oh my god.... all of you are ignoring the real issue here...Philip IS Luke. This is a revelation the likes of which SL has never seen!
_____________________
"When it comes to choosing between two evils, I always prefer the one I haven't tried yet."
|
Ulrika Zugzwang
Magnanimous in Victory
Join date: 10 Jun 2004
Posts: 6,382
|
03-18-2005 09:45
From: Anshe Chung We don't need content baron vs land baron, SLEx vs Gigas or Ansheism vs Ulrikaism. Ulrikaism? Careful woman. You could be creating a monster.  While I appreciate your positivity, it's a feel-good whitewash applied by someone who has taken great advantage of a poorly regulated system. Naturally your Pollyanna call for brotherhood and harmony is self serving, as the current system maintained as is will continue to secure and expand your position as a top earner. Would you be so magnanimous if you were on your way down?  Because LL has failed to reform their land auction system and have no method to redistribute wealth, assets in SL continue to accumulate in the hands of just a few members of the community. I understand that LL runs SL as an unregulated free-trade zone with regressive taxation -- that's their right to run an inequitable system if they so choose. However, is it starting to spill over into RL? Is the LL privacy policy being used as a shield to prevent local RL governments from taxing large sums of income earned in SL? What I would like to see is: - A reform of the land-auction system to sell all land at market value.
- A mechanisms to redistribute wealth and to publish anonymous income distributions.
- SL earnings and income distribution of for-profit entities made public in SL (like it is in RL).
- SL earnings by large income earners made public in RL for purpose of local governmental taxation.
I wonder how das Finanzamt would feel about six figures earned but not reported. Hmm. ~Ulrika~
_____________________
Chik-chik-chika-ahh
|
Eggy Lippmann
Wiktator
Join date: 1 May 2003
Posts: 7,939
|
03-18-2005 09:59
Ulrika, I absolutely adore you. I will remember your "self-serving Pollyanna" expression for the rest of my life. May I be your first and foremost worshipper in the upcoming Ulrikaist religion? 
|
Lecktor Hannibal
YOUR MOM
Join date: 1 Jul 2004
Posts: 6,734
|
03-18-2005 10:08
Wow, I've found an agreement with Hit.... errr Ulrika. Bravo.
_____________________
YOUR MOM says, 'Come visit us at SC MKII http://secondcitizen.net ' From: Khamon Fate Oh, Lecktor, you're terrible. Bikers have more fun than people !
|
Jake Reitveld
Emperor of Second Life
Join date: 9 Mar 2005
Posts: 2,690
|
hmmm
03-18-2005 10:29
Well I suppose for me the fact that I can never buy land without competeing against anshe in market dimishes the game for me, because land is not accessible, also the malls and clubs are tied to the land, so ownership of the land gives you ownership of the retail. There really is no game here other than make money and spend it, so virtual merit and skill and ability has very little to do with it.
If it were the real world, Anshe would probably have been exposed to several lawsuits for unfair business practicies and collusion in auctions, not to mention the private and public anti-trust suits. I don't mean to accuse anshe of not playing by the SL rules, just that people have done so. Anshe Cheung is a virtual lesson is why the sherman anti-trust act was passed. Frankly a part of me thinks I should figure out how to open up an SL law practice, with people putting real dollars on the table I could make money.
Now I don't have anything in for anshe cheung. I applaud the hard work she puts into this. I appreciate real-estate specutaltion as a way of making money..i do it IRL to pad my own retirement (and I didn't buy a porsche either). We as a community enable her, and create her..if we wanted to, we could simply, as a community of 20000, simple release all our land and start sharing goods for free. Not likely, since most of us are here to carve out a piece of our own virtual pie. (except me I come for the sex, and just need an enclosed space to do it inso my account is not pulled lol). So really, all this bitching about Anshe this or Anshe that..remember that $100000 is our money..we gave it to her. All she did was figure out a way to ask nicely. Give her a break. Besides, Anshe sets a bar we all choose to compete against in some way.
Now what distresses me about this land speculation is that SL is a game. And when people feel that they cannot play the game, becuase there is no way to compete with someone who has already made a mint, and drives the land costs up to $100US an acre as a matter of course, they get frustrated, and feel like the should go back to WoW where all this spending US$ for In game money is forbidden, and you actually get to kill stuff.... SL ha some beautiful animations and the avatars are awesome, but thats mosty it, eyecandy..and our own small private emotional dramas. For the stanpoint of being a player in the game..i'd like to see all new land released at a stable market price, and land values be dictated by how the land is improved. Making player in game contributiuons, and not player UD$ resources the defining factor.
Of course I would comment Anshe that it is very easy to say we all should just get along when you are the richest person around and have a good amount of cashe to invest back into the business. But some people just want to get more sims or have a bit of land bigger than the basic, and you come into auctions and price it beyond thier reach, as a matter of pure business. Don't blame them for resenting you? Surely you didn;t think you could get rich off of us and not garner some hatred? Congrats on your hard work though. US$100K is impressive.
|
Deklax Fairplay
Black Sun
Join date: 2 Jul 2004
Posts: 357
|
03-18-2005 11:30
From: Jake Reitveld If it were the real world, Anshe would probably have been exposed to several lawsuits for unfair business practicies and collusion in auctions, not to mention the private and public anti-trust suits. What specific violation of laws are you refering to here Jake? Seems to me like you must have a lot of information to base these claims on before you came and smeared them all over anshe. From: Jake Reitveld I don't mean to accuse anshe of not playing by the SL rules, just that people have done so. Actually, your doing exactly that by calling her out publicly. I wasnt aware the Lindens were so stupid they would let her slip past all this time cheating the system; what rules exactly has she broken? From: Jake Reitveld Anshe Cheung is a virtual lesson is why the sherman anti-trust act was passed. Frankly a part of me thinks I should figure out how to open up an SL law practice, with people putting real dollars on the table I could make money. I doubt there is any logical way you could prove or even suggest Anshe acts as a trust, but if you want to try go right ahead. The barriers for entry into this market are remarkably low and there are abosultely no restrictions on anyone else accessing every bit of land that is released. Where is the monopoly in that? From: Jake Reitveld For the stanpoint of being a player in the game..i'd like to see all new land released at a stable market price, and land values be dictated by how the land is improved. Making player in game contributiuons, and not player UD$ resources the defining factor. How would the land be 'improved'? Would everyone have the ability to improve land equally? If so why would anyone ever buy land for more than the 'stable market price' (which really isnt a market at all) and just improve whatever land they ended up with? At that point Linden Lab might as well charge a $100 membership fee and give the land out for free. Usually a building can't and won't be considered 'improvement' by a majority of land buyers who have their own ideas about construction, so that would leave fairly little to be done until terraforming is finally allowed to us peons. Terraforming itself would be another devisive topic im sure, because you can only terraform as much land as you buy. What if someone else buys 8/10ths of a sim and you try to 'improve' your 2/10ths down in a crater left by their friendly land moving techniques? From: Jake Reitveld Of course I would comment Anshe that it is very easy to say we all should just get along when you are the richest person around and have a good amount of cashe to invest back into the business. But some people just want to get more sims or have a bit of land bigger than the basic, and you come into auctions and price it beyond thier reach, as a matter of pure business. Don't blame them for resenting you? Surely you didn;t think you could get rich off of us and not garner some hatred? Congrats on your hard work though. US$100K is impressive. I would submit to you that its not as easy as you might believe for Anshe to speak out on these (or any) topics. I mean look at this thread - which had over 50 posts about her before she even probably knew it existed. No matter what she has to say someone will jump out of the woodwork and hate her for it and even your veiled 'comments' were harsh and judgemental. I think its ridiculous that just because someone is not able to compete due to skill or knowledge they would try to cast doubt and suspicion on those that are. I know for a fact its more than possible to compete with her and profit as much; considering her amazing tier fees and scale of business. If you feel your being priced out of the market blame the linden's who carefully monitor and run the system. We don't exist in a virtual vacuum here. Anshe has always been a stand-up business girl as long as I've known her and she didn't cheat me once that I know of. P.S. As for wealth distribution - HAHAHA. Yeah right.  Ive been saying for a long time I would like to see some sort of better group code that allowed for proper income distribution, but your other ideas (ulrika) just don't make sense in a community that actually wants to grow and succeed.
_____________________
Better Dead Than Red!
|
Jake Reitveld
Emperor of Second Life
Join date: 9 Mar 2005
Posts: 2,690
|
oh for someone who could read.
03-18-2005 11:42
Hmm I never did accuse Anshe of breaking any rules. I simply said others have and IRL it is likely she would be sued, whether or not there is any merit to the accusations is beyond the point of my thread..which really is that we allow anshe to exist by sustianing it. Its a natural phenomenon of the game. And yes..Anshe does behave like a trust, even when the threshold for market entry is low.
A good definition of what I mean by a trust (for which there a number of definitions) is thus: Any combination of establishments in the same line of business for securing the same ends by holding the individula interests of each subservient to a common authority for the common interests of all. Anshe is in the line of work of real-estate development. She buys the land, rents and sells the land owns the clubs on the land and owns the malls on the land, and improves the land and rents residences. This behavior is like a trust..very similar to a vertical monopoly. Whether it is breaking the rules of SL, was not my concern. It simply is an accurate reflection of her power in the market place. Look what they put poor Martha Stewart in Jail for. The Sherman act is very braod reaching.
The observations of people trying to buy land based on what a new user can reasonbbly make in game suggest that in order to reasonably participate in this market, one must commit real world dollars to play. This is fine, but it makes a frustrating game. I was not comment on my own skill at either land speculation or at manufacturing, just pointing out that games like this invide new people who cannot compete against you uber L337's for all the ph@ loo7. A game should accommodate the unskilled player as well as the hard core speculator, and provide enjoyment to both.
my own enjoyment of SL has nothing to do with owning propery or getting rich, so In truth I could care less what Anshe does. However, these forums provide a lively discussion and allow me to bait people like you to come out with hearts on theri sleeves and guns blazing. I find it funny. And fun.
As far as my suggestions on improving the game, they were just musings. But if it makes you feel superior to take them apart..then have at them. Since you seem to have decided that my post was somehow an attach on anshe, and didn't bother to post anything other than a knee jerk defense of her. I'll give you all due consideration.
An improvement by the way, Is a valuable addition made to property or an amelioration in its condition, amounting to more than mere repairs or replacement of waste, costing in labor or capital, and intended to enhance its value, beuaty or utility or to adapt it to new or further purposes. My suggestion is that raw land be valued according to the uses and structures on it and around it. This is, of course a pipe dream, as land use management is a major RL governement fuction and would never be readily duplicated in a game.
|
Deklax Fairplay
Black Sun
Join date: 2 Jul 2004
Posts: 357
|
03-18-2005 11:51
From: Jake Reitveld The observations of people trying to buy land based on what a new user can reasonbbly make in game suggest that in order to reasonably participate in this market, one must commit real world dollars to play. This is fine, but it makes a frustrating game. I think your confusing Anshe with Linden Lab. That is by design of the game - not her. Many people seem to hold her accountable to this, and i don't really see why. She is not actually a part of LL and gets no vote in their decision making processes. From: Jake Reitveld As far as my suggestions on improving the game, they were just musings. But if it makes you feel superior to take them apart..then have at them. Actually, it does in a way. I like you. Stick around. From: Jake Reitveld Since you seem to have decided that my post was somehow an attack on anshe, and didn't bother to post anything other than a knee jerk defense of her. I'll give you all due consideration. That is certainly generous of you. It seems like you've made up your mind but to me its important to be honest when it comes to criminal accusations. I think your 'case' is treading on very thin ice, and likely to sink under the immense weight of its load of hearsay bullshit.
_____________________
Better Dead Than Red!
|
Cristiano Midnight
Evil Snapshot Baron
Join date: 17 May 2003
Posts: 8,616
|
03-18-2005 11:54
From: Eggy Lippmann Ulrika, I absolutely adore you. I will remember your "self-serving Pollyanna" expression for the rest of my life. May I be your first and foremost worshipper in the upcoming Ulrikaist religion?  Sorry Eggy I am first in line in the Ulrika worship department. Great post, Ulrika. Anshe's current kinder, gentler Anshe campaign is certainly something to see, kind of like the commercials Philip Morris puts out now. I figured when the "Why are you so mean" ims started, it could only be followed by a PR masterpiece like that post. Bravo, Anshe. PS - I am particularly amazed at the ability to have mastered phrases like "nth-generation" but to still be challenged by the word "a". It provides just the right balance of sophistication, while still maintaining the "one business girl with 9.95 account" image. It is brilliant.
_____________________
Cristiano ANOmations - huge selection of high quality, low priced animations all $100L or less. ~SLUniverse.com~ SL's oldest and largest community site, featuring Snapzilla image sharing, forums, and much more. 
|
Jake Reitveld
Emperor of Second Life
Join date: 9 Mar 2005
Posts: 2,690
|
hearsay.
03-18-2005 12:13
Um you still havent read what I said. I have not accused anshe of anything. Others have and in the real world, she would probably have been sued. With or without merit.
Here's your sign....
Also Hearsay is an out of court statement offered to show the truth of the matter stated. Since I never inteneded to suggest that anshe was in fact conducting herself ciminally, It can't be heresay. I would think you have carefully read every other post accusing Anshe of bad business dealings and I would not have to reiterate them here.
Here's your other sign...
And finally I'm not in the least confusing linden labs with anshe, I'm describing a condition of the game, not who authored the condition. But it eludes you, apparently that I nowhere make an accusation, just refrerence what has been said.
|
Oz Spade
ReadsNoPostLongerThanHand
Join date: 23 Sep 2003
Posts: 2,708
|
03-18-2005 12:15
From: Beryl Greenacre Okay, was anybody besides me thinking of the resemblance between these two (see picture below)? Maybe I'm hallucinating, I dunno.  Mark Hamill rocks. Maybe Philip is the long-lost THIRD twin child of Anakin's?
_____________________
"Don't anticipate outcome," the man said. "Await the unfolding of events. Remain in the moment." - Konrad
|
Deklax Fairplay
Black Sun
Join date: 2 Jul 2004
Posts: 357
|
03-18-2005 12:24
From: Jake Reitveld Hmm I never did accuse Anshe of breaking any rules. I simply said others have and IRL it is likely she would be sued, whether or not there is any merit to the accusations is beyond the point of my thread..which really is that we allow anshe to exist by sustianing it. Its a natural phenomenon of the game. And yes..Anshe does behave like a trust, even when the threshold for market entry is low. So would you say its alright for me to say things like 'I heard from other people Jake Reitveld is a polygamist that doesn't believe in a minimum age for consensual sex'? Im not in any way claiming its true, but just in case since i heard from someone I have the right to say so? From: Jake Reitveld A good definition of what I mean by a trust (for which there a number of definitions) is thus: Any combination of establishments in the same line of business for securing the same ends by holding the individula interests of each subservient to a common authority for the common interests of all. Anshe is in the line of work of real-estate development. She buys the land, rents and sells the land owns the clubs on the land and owns the malls on the land, and improves the land and rents residences. This behavior is like a trust..very similar to a vertical monopoly. Whether it is breaking the rules of SL, was not my concern. It simply is an accurate reflection of her power in the market place. Look what they put poor Martha Stewart in Jail for. The Sherman act is very braod reaching. I dont see how its accurate at all to call a business in the midst of hundreds of others a monopoly. If your going to redefine the word trust entirely then yes I believe you might be right, but a more common definition would be "A combination of firms or corporations for the purpose of reducing competition and controlling prices throughout a business or an industry." (dictionary.com) She in no way is the sole owner of any of the levels of establishments you mentioned and on every level she has compitition from people that in many cases are more established and have been there longer than she has. I just don't see how the word 'monopoly' applies. Also, Martha Stewart was arrested for lying and obstructing justice (for a crime that didn't exist). Maybe you could further explain. From: Jake Reitveld I was not comment on my own skill at either land speculation or at manufacturing, just pointing out that games like this invide new people who cannot compete against you uber L337's for all the ph@ loo7. A game should accommodate the unskilled player as well as the hard core speculator, and provide enjoyment to both. Again, why blame a single player for problems you have with the entire game? From: Jake Reitveld An improvement by the way, Is a valuable addition made to property or an amelioration in its condition, amounting to more than mere repairs or replacement of waste, costing in labor or capital, and intended to enhance its value, beuaty or utility or to adapt it to new or further purposes. My suggestion is that raw land be valued according to the uses and structures on it and around it. This is, of course a pipe dream, as land use management is a major RL governement fuction and would never be readily duplicated in a game. This is a virtual world with no repairs or waste in need of replacement. Your operating under real world guidelines for virtual property and im not sure how well they really work together. I'd be interested in a more fully detailed and developed plan on the flat-land-price plan but I just dont see how that could work or why the Lindens would want it. Remember as land prices go up they profit more per m2 that they release, so its in their benifit for at least minor fluctuations. Location and Lag are much more important in SL than the prims sitting on top of it in many cases so people often are forced to pick up and move to a better location. Buildings can be constructed and moved easily and there is no permanence to anything as people churn through the system.
_____________________
Better Dead Than Red!
|
Jake Reitveld
Emperor of Second Life
Join date: 9 Mar 2005
Posts: 2,690
|
03-18-2005 12:47
well I did offer a common definitions of the word trust, just a legal one: See mallinckrodt chemical works v. the state of missouri, 238 US 41.
Again you characterize my commments as accustations or allegations. If somone says I am a philandering paedophile, and you report it, that does not mean you are calling me a philandering peadophile. If I say that other would probably have sued Anseh for unfair business practices, it does not mean that I am saying she conducts her self unfairly. I went to great length to make this clear. And it seems to elude you.
A monoply can be both horizontal or vertical..I never said Anshe has a horizontal monopoly, but lets look at a legal definition of a monoply: A monoply consists in the ownership of or control of so large a part of the market-supply or output of a given commodity as to stifle competition, restrict freedom of commerce and give the monoplist control over prices. State v. Eastern Coal, 29 RI 254 (is a state case, but a useful espression of the definition of the term). Anshe, I think, certainly has this status. She may not have broken any rules getting here, but she is there. My point has awlays been she is what she is through hard work and in fact, its our money she has, so why complain about her? If you don't like it don't play the game.
Finally, virtual or real an improvement is an improvement. Land with a nightclub is more valuable and more able to make money than raw land. Same thing with land with a mall. In theory land with a house is more valuable..but since houses are so easy to make, and so indivisual..that may not be so. But I think land with a small house with a good view, is more appealing than land with my neighboors 512 Square meter monoboxes on four sides.
|
Deklax Fairplay
Black Sun
Join date: 2 Jul 2004
Posts: 357
|
03-18-2005 12:52
From: Jake Reitveld A monoply can be both horizontal or vertical..I never said Anshe has a horizontal monopoly, but lets look at a legal definition of a monoply: A monoply consists in the ownership of or control of so large a part of the market-supply or output of a given commodity as to stifle competition, restrict freedom of commerce and give the monoplist control over prices. State v. Eastern Coal, 29 RI 254 (is a state case, but a useful espression of the definition of the term). Anshe, I think, certainly has this status. Except for the fact that she doesn't have control over the prices, restrict commerce or stifle competition your almost on to something. Well, except for the fact everyone has equal access to the entire supply output as well. I think she certainly doesn't have such a status and its really as simple as that. I doubt we will convince each other. Id be interested to see the context your first 'legal definition' took place in, as i don't think you took all the pertinent information. Reading through the 1910 case, i notice you carefully omitted all references to "with the intent to limit or fix the price or lessen the production and sale of any article of commerce, use or consumption, or to prevent, restrict or diminish the manufacture or output"., etc that was mentioned throughout that document. Selective quotation is your friend, huh? Just because you own two companies that work for a common good does not necessarily mean you fall under the Anti-Trust legislation. From: Jake Reitveld My point has awlays been she is what she is through hard work and in fact, its our money she has, so why complain about her? If you don't like it don't play the game. Very well said. I was in need of some debate and you've held up much better than the majority of beta-trolls around here. Time for me to go. 
_____________________
Better Dead Than Red!
|
Jake Reitveld
Emperor of Second Life
Join date: 9 Mar 2005
Posts: 2,690
|
03-18-2005 13:38
Clever. Yes I selectively quoted the 1910 languague (some times older law establishes the definitions). So you can look up a case. Impressive. Why do you have such a fixation on me accusing anshe of anything. Thoughn the debate is killing time wonderfully for me. Have you participated in a land auction? I did.
Anshe can come in and afford to bid 2.2 cents a square meter, or what ever her, I would think, automatic bid level is. This means that in any alnd acution she plays in, the price will never ben below US$100 an acre or so. She then Sells it back at 4 times value or so. I don;t know If Anshe bids on every parcel..but I have to imagine she does.. I would. Thus she sets a celing that cuts out the casual gamer from acquiring land relatively cheaply, and thus creates a rental market for her properties (and mine..so i am glad). Now she sets up a mall on land she has bought using her considerable leverage and a nightclub..she then is free to charage what she wants for vendors, and people will pay as those paying inflated costs for land cannot comepte with thier own malls. Now she goes in and decised she actually will hold the land in trust to preserve zoning, and takes our money in place of us paying to lindens, we then pay her price for land and live on her sim, shopping at her mall, hanging out in her club. Anshe could up her standard bid and drive the market cost higher and higher. her competition will always have to out bid her. Thus the people who can afford to fight Anshe are the land barons themselves.
Now you may say what you mean about other businesses being competitive. And I'm sure micorsoft said that there were hundreds of available comepting operating systems. Anshe is a player large enough to dominate the market. Large enough to set the price, and in fact does set a price. My point was that this market dominance could in fact, expose her to private or maybe public anti-trust suits in real life.. (after all Standard Oil was not the only oil company). My thought was that if the SEC went afer miss martha based on her alleged insider trading (yeah thats not what she went to jail for true, but i have always been talking about what it takes to get you to the courthouse, not put you in the jail) then they certainly would be gunning, right or wrong for a player in a market as dominant as anshe.
My issue with your whole arguement is that you seem to predicate all your comments on me accusing anshe of wrongdoing, when all I said was that people will, can and do, question her ethics and that she is the dominant force in SL real estate, and has priced the smaller people out of business by virtue of her economic muscle. She may in fact have done this legitimately, it does not matter. She has worked hard and been sucessful with our consent, what ever she has done..we have given her our money. We enabled her so what complain about what she does?
Sorry missed your edit..have a good one..and likewise..it was interesting and though provoking.
|
blaze Spinnaker
1/2 Serious
Join date: 12 Aug 2004
Posts: 5,898
|
03-18-2005 15:05
From: someone . She then Sells it back at 4 times value or so
She marks it up 20%. Thats 1.2 times the value. And she has absolutely 0 pricing control. Only LL has pricing control. If the price of the land goes over a certain point, LL releases more land. And if it drops below a certain point, LL releases less land. Please do your research before wading into these conversations with your mis-information. Someone might take you seriously.
_____________________
Taken from The last paragraph on pg. 16 of Cory Ondrejka's paper " Changing Realities: User Creation, Communication, and Innovation in Digital Worlds : " User-created content takes the idea of leveraging player opinions a step further by allowing them to effectively prototype new ideas and features. Developers can then measure which new concepts most improve the products and incorporate them into the game in future patches."
|
blaze Spinnaker
1/2 Serious
Join date: 12 Aug 2004
Posts: 5,898
|
03-18-2005 15:08
The only one with pricing control is SL is LindenLabs.
If the price ever went above a certain point, LL just releases more land. Which is exactly what they do. Similarly, when the price falls below a certain they release less land. Which is also exactly what they do.
Again - do your research before you wade into a conversation like this.
_____________________
Taken from The last paragraph on pg. 16 of Cory Ondrejka's paper " Changing Realities: User Creation, Communication, and Innovation in Digital Worlds : " User-created content takes the idea of leveraging player opinions a step further by allowing them to effectively prototype new ideas and features. Developers can then measure which new concepts most improve the products and incorporate them into the game in future patches."
|