Welcome to the Second Life Forums Archive

These forums are CLOSED. Please visit the new forums HERE

Is Second Life Mature or PG?

Mex Thorn
Mex It Up
Join date: 30 Mar 2004
Posts: 608
02-03-2005 12:14
On Jan. 28th 2005 I got suspended for harassment and language because I called someone a bitch. Im not saying that what I did isn't wrong but if you have to be 18+ to play the game then shouldn't there be a high boundrie between the teen games like There.com and The Sims Online where you cannot get suspended for using adult language. If someone doesn't like cussing and swearing then they should play PG games. Second Life is supposed to be a game for adults and sometime there is conferntation and it should be handled as adults and talked out not suspended like in high school or any other school. We are grown adults and we do play this game bit that doesn't mean that since it is a game we should be treated like children. Second Life can be played to many differant ways but in the end if you have to be 18+ to play then it should ALL be mature not just on some mature rated sims. Why should there be PG sims? We are all adults even 18 year olds that play are mature enough to know what is what and shouldn't have to be hidden in PG sims. I think that it is not fair to us the residents that pay to play the game and pay our land fee's those of us that own land. Its not fair for us to have limited ability to say what we want. In Real Life we have freedom of speach why not have that same freedom in Second Life? Saying we are not allowed to say what we want even in Instant Message which is supposed to be private is like having MOMI from TSO watching over our sholder telling you what is write and whats wrong. Are Lindens our Mommy?
_____________________
-Mex
Mike Zidane
Registered User
Join date: 10 Apr 2004
Posts: 255
02-03-2005 12:18
I dont' mean this as a personal attack. So please don't take it that way. I don't have any problem with you calling anyone a bitch.

But the truth is, you pissed someone off and you got your card pulled.

Is it possible that the person who reported you was being an dumbass, manipulative bitch? Fuckin'-a-right it is possible.

But.... ya know.... that's the way it goes sometimes. See ya when yer time's up.

Edit: I really believe we need to preserve the right to report people and have stuff done about their actions. Sometimes we might end up on the wrong side of that deal. But we have to be able to draw a line somewhere.
_____________________
I'm only faking when I get it right. - CC
Talen Morgan
Amused
Join date: 2 Apr 2004
Posts: 3,097
02-03-2005 12:22
From: Mex Thorn
On Jan. 28th 2005 I got suspended for harassment and language because I called someone a bitch. Im not saying that what I did isn't wrong but if you have to be 18+ to play the game then shouldn't there be a high boundrie between the teen games like There.com and The Sims Online where you cannot get suspended for using adult language. If someone doesn't like cussing and swearing then they should play PG games. Second Life is supposed to be a game for adults and sometime there is conferntation and it should be handled as adults and talked out not suspended like in high school or any other school. We are grown adults and we do play this game bit that doesn't mean that since it is a game we should be treated like children. Second Life can be played to many differant ways but in the end if you have to be 18+ to play then it should ALL be mature not just on some mature rated sims. Why should there be PG sims? We are all adults even 18 year olds that play are mature enough to know what is what and shouldn't have to be hidden in PG sims. I think that it is not fair to us the residents that pay to play the game and pay our land fee's those of us that own land. Its not fair for us to have limited ability to say what we want. In Real Life we have freedom of speach why not have that same freedom in Second Life? Saying we are not allowed to say what we want even in Instant Message which is supposed to be private is like having MOMI from TSO watching over our sholder telling you what is write and whats wrong. Are Lindens our Mommy?



You can't have the same freedoms in SL because SL is privately owned and they make the rules. The fact that you said bitch probably had nothing to do with it it sounds like you got a vacation for harrassment.
David Valentino
Nicely Wicked
Join date: 1 Jan 2004
Posts: 2,941
02-03-2005 12:25
SL is actually XXX. You just have to keep it on the downlow.
_____________________
David Lamoreaux

Owner - Perilous Pleasures and Extreme Erotica Gallery
Stormy Roentgen
Prim Putter Togetherer
Join date: 25 May 2004
Posts: 342
02-03-2005 12:38
As one of the many people you've probably called "bitch" in your SL days, I can say from experience that you handle conflicts in anything but a mature manner. It's funny you should say we should be allowed to handle our conflicts like adults, because that's not at all how you handle them. Calling everyone who pisses you off a "bitch" is by no means a mature way of resolving anything.

Disclaimer: I am not the person involved in his current issues. I have dealt with him months before now.
Forseti Svarog
ESC
Join date: 2 Nov 2004
Posts: 1,730
02-03-2005 12:42
I think it makes sense to have PG and mature sims. No one is forced to buy land in PG areas -- PG sims are in essence lightly-zoned communities that you can choose to visit or not. To get suspended for the word "bitch" does seem like a bit much, but Mike's post is right on target I think.

You should be able to say "bitch" as often as you want in private IMs and no one should bother you... as long as the person on the other end is fine with the conversation. If you repeatedly IM someone calling them a bitch, then that would be hassling and one would expect an abuse report.

(Note: I am not saying this is what you did -- I am just walking through the hypotheticals).

There is a distinction between PG/Mature, which defines what is publically said/shown, and the actual treatment of someone, which can lead to an abuse report.
Forseti Svarog
ESC
Join date: 2 Nov 2004
Posts: 1,730
02-03-2005 12:44
From: Stormy Roentgen
We should be allowed to handle our conflicts like adults, because that's not at all how you handle them.


Total tangent from your point Stormy, but I always laugh at the "behave like an adult" line. Of course when we say it, we all mean "behave like an **idealized** adult", but really most adults act like normal human beings... i.e. asses half the time. ;)
Mex Thorn
Mex It Up
Join date: 30 Mar 2004
Posts: 608
02-03-2005 12:44
So since SL is privately owned and we the residents are the ones taht keep it going we should have to life by the rules that are set for us when there is a limit on age to play. Then why not let teenagers play? They will pay just as much as adults to play a game. It's all about money slap Lindens in the face with a couple millions see how much you will get away with. But yes I did do something wrong but its not like I used the F word or something more offencive. Bitch is not even concidered a sware word cause its meaning is a female dog and I was really describing someone a female as acting like a female dog and I got punished for it. So if someone is acting like something and you call it careful it will be offencive cause of the way SL is setup to make RL look like a freedom while Second Life is made it look fancy on one side but dirty on the other.
_____________________
-Mex
Mex Thorn
Mex It Up
Join date: 30 Mar 2004
Posts: 608
02-03-2005 12:52
From: Stormy Roentgen
As one of the many people you've probably called "bitch" in your SL days, I can say from experience that you handle conflicts in anything but a mature manner. It's funny you should say we should be allowed to handle our conflicts like adults, because that's not at all how you handle them. Calling everyone who pisses you off a "bitch" is by no means a mature way of resolving anything.

Disclaimer: I am not the person involved in his current issues. I have dealt with him months before now.

Stormy you must have me confuesed with someone else I have never had a conflict with you before. Unless you were being retarded and deserved a neg rate for starting something. I NEVER have conflicts with anyone unless there is something to provoke it. For example in this event it happened cause someone was running her mouth talking a whole lot of nonsence cause she was upset we broke up 3 months ago and wont let go of the past in which she was acting like a female dog in other words a "bitch."
_____________________
-Mex
Stormy Roentgen
Prim Putter Togetherer
Join date: 25 May 2004
Posts: 342
02-03-2005 12:54
From: Forseti Svarog
Total tangent from your point Stormy, but I always laugh at the "behave like an adult" line. Of course when we say it, we all mean "behave like an **idealized** adult", but really most adults act like normal human beings... i.e. asses half the time. ;)


Well I suppose my point is, from my own experience dealing with Mex, it's not a surprise he's been suspended for harrassment. Harrassment is how he handles things. I doubt he was suspended simply for saying the word "bitch." If that were the case we'd likely be missing 1/2 the SL population atleast.
Jaynessa Jackson
Second Life Resident
Join date: 1 Nov 2004
Posts: 42
This is funny
02-03-2005 12:56
i find this entire complaint just plain funny. you knew the rules when you started playing the game. i am sure that was not your first complaint...and i can hedge a winning bet that it won't be your last. the bottom line is, there are rules in everything that you do....if you want to play, you follow them and play happily ever after...you break them then you can play vicariously through the forums as you wait your sentence out. if the rules of the game bother you that much...cancel you subscription...but don't whine after you finally get what you basically asked for...and for record "bitch" is a curse word when used in the context that you used it in...don't believe me...walk up to a woman and call her a bitch and see if you don't get "bitch-slapped"
Mex Thorn
Mex It Up
Join date: 30 Mar 2004
Posts: 608
02-03-2005 13:06
From: Stormy Roentgen
Well I suppose my point is, from my own experience dealing with Mex, it's not a surprise he's been suspended for harrassment. Harrassment is how he handles things. I doubt he was suspended simply for saying the word "bitch." If that were the case we'd likely be missing 1/2 the SL population atleast.

Stomry you don't know me so don't say anything about me if can barely pronounce my name or know what it means. So I would really apreciate it if you wouldn't talk your stuff about me in forums when you dont even know me. And NO you have never dealt with me I don't even know who you are. If we had a conflict im sure I would remember it conflits don't get forgotten so easily.
_____________________
-Mex
Kayin Zugzwang
A Superior Grouch
Join date: 7 Jun 2004
Posts: 269
02-03-2005 13:08
Personally, in any place where I have had administrative power I have always believed no one should ever be punished for insulting someone else during an argument. When someone calls you a bitch in real life they don't get arrested(save maybe 1 out of 100,000 times). It's niave to think human beings can all get along in a big happy family.

Now, where I usually draw the line is harassment. If someone on an IRC channel or Forum offends someone my general suggestion is to ignore/block said user. This is a little trickier on forums -- since posts can't be "blocked".. but in SL you have the mute option.

NOW, if somone feels its their duty to constantly find ways to remind people about his or her bitchitude then I have a problem, interject/ban/do whatever. Frankly the whole abuse report system is bullshit. Someone can be harassing you/pushgunning you and when you pushgun em back -- BAMF, BANNED. Now you didn't report em. Why? You wanted to be somewhat "cool" about it.

Now, I don't have an easy answer for situations like that. The Linden's are probably busy enough with abuse reports... But foul langauge/insults? Pfft. Mute the bastard and be done with it.
Shiryu Musashi
Veteran Designer
Join date: 19 Nov 2004
Posts: 1,045
02-03-2005 13:09
You didn't simply use adult language (the fact you purposely try to shift the balance of the issue on the freedom of using adult language is the first proof or your guilt), you insulted someone, and yes, this is part of what is called harrassment, the fact that it's "adult language" is completely secodary.
Maybe next time you will learn to cope with conflict in a mature way (and no, this doesn't mean using mature rated language), so you won't get suspended.

PS: It would be nice if you wrote your post in a decently readable font.
_____________________
Kathmandu Gilman
Fearful Symmetry Baby!
Join date: 21 May 2004
Posts: 1,418
02-03-2005 13:19
Not to take sides or anything but "bitch" is allowable under the rules of "PG". It can, in some uses of the word it can be used in "G" ratinngs. In case you haven't watched TV in the last 10 years, "bitch" is as prevelent as "hell" and "damn" and in reality, all it means is female dog.

On the other hand, it doesn't matter what sim you are in, any sort of verbal attack can be grounds for an abuse report. Doesn't have to be vulgar in the least.
Lo Jacobs
Awesome Possum
Join date: 28 May 2004
Posts: 2,734
02-03-2005 13:23
From: Kathmandu Gilman
On the other hand, it doesn't matter what sim you are in, any sort of verbal attack can be grounds for an abuse report. Doesn't have to be vulgar in the least.


Sure but being suspended for saying "You are an insignificant speck of interstellar dust" would be hysterical.
_____________________
http://churchofluxe.com/Luster :o
Chip Midnight
ate my baby!
Join date: 1 May 2003
Posts: 10,231
02-03-2005 13:28
I agree with Shiryu. The word "bitch" wasn't the issue. On a sidenote: use of the word "retarded" isn't helping your argument about adult behavior any :p
_____________________

My other hobby:
www.live365.com/stations/chip_midnight
Torley Linden
Enlightenment!
Join date: 15 Sep 2004
Posts: 16,530
02-03-2005 13:34
From: Lo Jacobs
Sure but being suspended for saying "You are an insignificant speck of interstellar dust" would be hysterical.


Alien invasion?

Ratings creep may just very well strike again.

Heck, I'm reminded of that scene in Poltergeist where the dude's face melts off. And THAT was PG?! That's an example. I bet posting screencaps of that wouldn't go over well -- nor do I recommend it. Seriously.
_____________________
Ursula Madison
Chewbacca is my co-pilot
Join date: 31 Jul 2004
Posts: 713
02-03-2005 13:35
From: Chip Midnight
I agree with Shiryu. The word "bitch" wasn't the issue. On a sidenote: use of the word "retarded" isn't helping your argument about adult behavior any :p

That eyestrain-inducing font he's using isn't helping any, either.
_____________________
"Huh... did everything just taste purple for a second?" -- Philip J. Fry
Aimee Weber
The one on the right
Join date: 30 Jan 2004
Posts: 4,286
02-03-2005 13:42
From: Mex Thorn
So since SL is privately owned and we the residents are the ones taht keep it going we should have to life by the rules that are set for us when there is a limit on age to play. Then why not let teenagers play? They will pay just as much as adults to play a game. It's all about money slap Lindens in the face with a couple millions see how much you will get away with. But yes I did do something wrong but its not like I used the F word or something more offencive. Bitch is not even concidered a sware word cause its meaning is a female dog and I was really describing someone a female as acting like a female dog and I got punished for it. So if someone is acting like something and you call it careful it will be offencive cause of the way SL is setup to make RL look like a freedom while Second Life is made it look fancy on one side but dirty on the other.


Aimee has a headache :(

Mex, if you are going to be all badass calling some chickie a bitch, why don't you stay in badass mode and take the punishment like a man. Show us all that nothing bothers you.

But if you are going to cry and appeal to us when you get punished for something you admitted was wrong, maybe you should be working on a personae that can earn our sympathy. A kinder, gentler personae. One that doesn't call people "bitch".
_____________________
Lo Jacobs
Awesome Possum
Join date: 28 May 2004
Posts: 2,734
02-03-2005 13:43
From: Torley Torgeson
Heck, I'm reminded of that scene in Poltergeist where the dude's face melts off.


Ewww face melting. Made me think of Robocop, I think it was, when the guy falls into acid or something and then melts. Or like, The Rock, where some guy gets hit by a poison bomb and HIS face melts.
_____________________
http://churchofluxe.com/Luster :o
Siobhan Taylor
Nemesis
Join date: 13 Aug 2003
Posts: 5,476
02-03-2005 13:46
From: Kathmandu Gilman
Not to take sides or anything but "bitch" is allowable under the rules of "PG".
Not in SL. I know of people who've had groups deleted because they had the word 'bitch' in the title. Personally, it wouldn't offend me, but it obviously offends the Lindens, and it's their world.
I can't comment on Mex's situation. He's always been nice to me when we've met... but then I was buying stuff :)
_____________________
http://siobhantaylor.wordpress.com/
Pete Fats
Geek
Join date: 18 Apr 2003
Posts: 648
02-03-2005 13:48
I'd suspend you for using tiny red fonts....but that's just me.
_____________________
Torley Linden
Enlightenment!
Join date: 15 Sep 2004
Posts: 16,530
02-03-2005 13:50
From: Lo Jacobs
Ewww face melting. Made me think of Robocop, I think it was, when the guy falls into acid or something and then melts. Or like, The Rock, where some guy gets hit by a poison bomb and HIS face melts.


EWWW EWWW EWWW!

Those are on my list of "melting" scenes, right next to the Wicked Witch in the Wizard o' Oz... yeah, in Robocop, it was that crim who got dumped into the radioactive waste and then howled out, "HELLLP ME!!!" and in The Rock, it was VX nerve gas.
_____________________
Shiryu Musashi
Veteran Designer
Join date: 19 Nov 2004
Posts: 1,045
02-03-2005 13:50
From: Pete Fats
but that's just me.


... and me :D
_____________________
1 2 3 4 5