Welcome to the Second Life Forums Archive

These forums are CLOSED. Please visit the new forums HERE

Goodbye Everyone

Alex Fitzsimmons
Resu Deretsiger
Join date: 28 Dec 2004
Posts: 1,605
06-21-2007 14:50
From: Aromadon Enoch
Nice display of ignorance there


Pot, meet kettle?

From: someone
the swastika means just what it always meant.


Well, no. Not really.

From: someone
It can still be found in Indian homes and businesses as a blessing and wish for luck, health and properity.


That may well be, but the symbol's status is nevertheless NOT unchanged, and the simple, unfair-though-it-may-be truth of the matter is that the perception of the majority of the "developed" world overrides, in a worldwide setting such as SL, what some people in India are doing.

From: someone
Gay still means "happy"


Not as a primary meaning, no.

From: someone
Queer still means "odd"


Wrong.

From: someone
and a Fag is still a bundle of sticks


Not here on planet Earth.

From: someone
just because SOME people want to change the meaning of words does not make it so....


The gist of your contention appears to be as follows:

"Words and symbols possess inherent meanings that are unchangeable. Green does not simply refer to a particular physical property because people think it does; instead, a thing with that physical property is inherently entitled to the word 'green' at all times, in all cultures, and in any conceivable reality, irrespective of people and their changing use of language."

If you really believe that and can't divorce yourself from such an absurd, nonsensical idea, I don't know what to tell you, other than I'd avoid tossing about the word "ignorance" if I were you.
_____________________
"Whatever the astronomers finally decide, I think Xena should be considered the enemy planet." - io Kukalcan
Angelique LaFollette
Registered User
Join date: 17 Jun 2004
Posts: 1,595
06-21-2007 15:19
From: Wilhelm Neumann
See its people like you who pull out the wiki and crap that dont take into mind what is real and stuff. Things change over time and the fact of the matter the swastika was adopted by the natzi party and to this day remains a symbol of the party which still exists and means something in this connection and everyone knows it. The background of the symbol etc is totally irrelevant its what it was made into that is.

This happens with words and symbols all the time get used to it as its called evolution and EVERYTHING evolves from what it was to what it is now so that nice definition is fine but that doesn't mean that is what it means to 99.999999% of the population.

I dont see anyone arguing over celebrating christmas as being the birth of christ which it is not its a pagan ritual which evolved over times so remember that next time you pull out the wiki because theer are a million and one things that change over the years and that is one of them

/sigh

I agree, And disagree at the same time. In the Western world the symbol was Not a Common Symbol, and had no meaning to the western culture until the 1920's when it Was introduced, few saw anything wrong with it, it was just another political party logo, It wasn't until Later that it became recognized in the Western Mind as a symbol for Hate, and Evil.
In the Easterm vocabulary, the Swastika Was, Is, and probably always shall be a Symbol Meaning (Ironicly) Peace.

So,, where does that leave us? Simple, Right now the greatest majority of SL players are of North American, and Western European Origin where the Swastika has No Cultural History or signifigance beyond the perversion the Nazi's made of it. Whether Hitler and the party executive were even aware of the Asian meaning is debatable, though I would Guess they were. Their early Efforts for the party were to portray themselves as standing for peaceful reunification of the German peoples so choice of a benign symbol of exotic origin Would make Good PR.
In the end analysis, the Swastika has only one meaning for the Western mind. What a Similar Symbol means to the Eastern Context really Is Irrelevant to us. As for "Reclaiming" the meaning of the symbol, We cannot reclaim what we never had in the first place. Whatever it Might have been, that Image has been stained with far too much Blood, and human degredation to Ever be converted into something Positive in our minds.

As for the OP Quitting SL,, Well she acheived her Aim, and the Offending Materials Were (Rightfully) expunged form SL, so, why does she Quit? because someone makes sport of her Offence. Good call My Dear, you Hand the Forces of ignorance thier Victory on a Platter. You WON. Whatever criticism was levelled at you by some Ignorant S.O.B, YOU WON,,,, Until you Quit. That is when you Snatched defeat from the Jaws of victory.
Far more people agreed with your efforts, and appreciate what you did, But of course they mean Far less in your mind than One cerebral pygmy. If you are expecting applause, or even sympathy for your choice, you aren't going to get it.

Angel.
Elinah Iredell
Registered User
Join date: 14 Aug 2006
Posts: 269
06-21-2007 15:21
From: Francesca Alva
Today was the final straw. A request by someone for help with removing a Nazi display from near his parcel was met with ridicule and finally locked by Strife Onizuka - not because it was off-topic but because it broke Forum rules on displaying Nazi symbols. Did she even bother to read the thread? I really don't know because she hasn't replied to the PM I sent her. She has referred it to Linden Review - well good - perhaps they will point out to her that her reason for closing it was nonsense, given the thread content. She could simply have removed the picture.

Another forum member used the locked thread for a bit of grandstanding. His opening post on a subject that has been done to death contained inaccuracies - note I say inaccuracies, not an opinion with which I disagree - in fact I did agree with much of what he posted. I clearly offended him by pointing out 1) that the thread to which he referred had not been locked because it had gone off-topic. I strongly suspect he knew that anyway; 2) that he had attributed a quotation to the wrong person. Although he replied to every other person that posted, he ignored me.

Petty (of me) you may think, but I have to confess that ever since I was attacked by someone in the Forum a few months ago, I've held back from posting anything serious. I am sick, housebound and in constant pain in RL - I don't need more grief in the virtual world.

I have just logged on to find that my post telling everyone that the Nazi items had been removed in world had evoked the ire of one of our great libertarians. Someone should tell him that the price of eternal freedom is eternal vigilance.

I am a Jew. I am offended by the glorification of the Nazi regime and I told him so. I see he has responded, but I have not read his post nor that of the person who told him he had struck "Forum Gold" with his dig at me. She has also responded. Call me a coward but I really can't cope with any more cruelty or any cheap shots - and there is a great deal of both in these forums. There is a great deal of fun and wisdom too, and I shall miss that, and I shall miss so many of you, but I'm going. This isn't like Sinatra's retirement - I shan't creep back in a couple of weeks. I looked to see if there were some way to unsubscribe, but regrettably not.

Doubtless this post will provoke a great deal of mirth and mockery - and it will run and run and go way off-topic, but somehow I don't think Strife will be closing it any time soon. Except of course I used the word Nazi - hmm good job I'm going before I'm banned.

Let me leave you with this posting, made earlier today (not by me, I hasten to add). I'm sure the poster thinks of himself as tolerant. I agree - if tolerant means "I'm all right Jack so the world can screw itself".



I understand how you feel ... but take a breather and I personally invite you to come back if you want :).. when I was a newbie I saw a guy in a fav newbie hangout in a nazi outfit doing nazi salute... I was pissed and confronted him and I never went back there again ( I was told by a friend he was being banned everywhere all over sl so I felt better ) and I saw a nazi flag in the middle of the air once it seemed to be the opening to an invisible club or something.. I filed an abuse report...for me, its not about the ability to reanact the past the way we reanact the civil war or others wars , its the idea the nazi ideals of hatred and genocide that should not be allowed ... if the kkk in their white sheets wanted to start a group here in sl should we allow that too? Hate groups have no place in sl period.

Elinah
Mortus Allen
Registered User
Join date: 28 Apr 2007
Posts: 528
06-21-2007 16:07
Thanks Aromadon Enoch. My only intolerance is ignorance. As long as people choose to remain ignorant, hence stupid, there will be misunderstandings. Those of us that choose not to be ignorant will turn out hate towards those that would use symbols and words for ill and shrug off the symbols as getting up set over them are a waist of time and energy.
Har Fairweather
Registered User
Join date: 24 Jan 2007
Posts: 2,320
06-21-2007 16:23
Interesting thing about the swastika.

It has been adopted by a number of cultures as a symbol of peace or good fortune, the Hindus, the ancient Greeks, and certain American Indians (I am aware of the Navajo in particular) - but always in a form the opposite of the Nazi swastika. If you look at the swastikas of these other cultures, you will see, if you will allow yourself a little poetic license, they resemble a stylized pinwheel spinning clockwise. That is the widely recognized "good" symbol. The Nazi swastika, however, resembles a pinwheel spinning counterclockwise - "backward" - and that version was widely regarded pretty much everywhere as very bad luck - long before Hitler's grandfather was conceived, let alone Hitler. Carl Jung, the psychologist, had quite a bit to say about all this - that some symbols are inherent in the human unconscious and would appear spontaneously when the situation was right.

In high school, I occasionally noted a wise-guy kid or two making swastikas just to get a rise out of the administration - and they were almost always, spontaneously, the clockwise, "good" kind, though neither they nor the administration realized it. If it is a spontaneous symbol, the "normal" human creation of it is the "clockwise," "good kind...

And whatever else you might say, the Nazi "counterclockwise" pinwheel was certainly very bad luck for them...

Interesting.
Chris Norse
Loud Arrogant Redneck
Join date: 1 Oct 2006
Posts: 5,735
06-21-2007 16:24
From: Elinah Iredell
I understand how you feel ... but take a breather and I personally invite you to come back if you want :).. when I was a newbie I saw a guy in a fav newbie hangout in a nazi outfit doing nazi salute... I was pissed and confronted him and I never went back there again ( I was told by a friend he was being banned everywhere all over sl so I felt better ) and I saw a nazi flag in the middle of the air once it seemed to be the opening to an invisible club or something.. I filed an abuse report...for me, its not about the ability to reanact the past the way we reanact the civil war or others wars , its the idea the nazi ideals of hatred and genocide that should not be allowed ... if the kkk in their white sheets wanted to start a group here in sl should we allow that too? Hate groups have no place in sl period.

Elinah


But then who defines hate groups? The best way to combat bad ideas is with good ideas. If I hear someone advocating censorship, my first thought is that they have no argument that can beat what they want to censor. But then I will debate anything with anyone, I may "lose" but I will never back down.
_____________________
I'm going to pick a fight
William Wallace, Braveheart

“Rules are mostly made to be broken and are too often for the lazy to hide behind”
Douglas MacArthur

FULL
Chris Norse
Loud Arrogant Redneck
Join date: 1 Oct 2006
Posts: 5,735
06-21-2007 16:26
From: Colette Meiji
Theres a difference between preferential treatment and compassion, though.


Yes, compassion is voluntarily given, preferential treatment is most often imposed by force.
_____________________
I'm going to pick a fight
William Wallace, Braveheart

“Rules are mostly made to be broken and are too often for the lazy to hide behind”
Douglas MacArthur

FULL
SqueezeOne Pow
World Changer
Join date: 21 Dec 2005
Posts: 1,437
06-21-2007 16:30
From: Chris Norse
Yes, compassion is voluntarily given, preferential treatment is most often imposed by force.


...or by guilt.
_____________________
Semper Fly
-S1. Pow

"Violence is Art by another means"

Visit Squeeze One Plaza in Osteria. Come for the robots, stay for the view!http://slurl.com/secondlife/Osteria/160.331/203.881
Chris Norse
Loud Arrogant Redneck
Join date: 1 Oct 2006
Posts: 5,735
06-21-2007 16:32
Francesca, my argument was not with you as a person, but with the policies you wish to impose upon us.

Yes, I am a "great" libertarian. The best way to remain vigilant against a threat is to be able to see the threat. You wish to drive the hate underground to fester and rot the body from within. I want to keep the infection exposed to the cleansing light of the truth.

As far as being homebound and in constant pain, well I know what you are speaking of, I am homebound and in constant pain as well. It still gives me no claim to any moral superiority.

I do hate to see you go under these circumstances, because losing a source of thoughts diminishes us all.

Good luck and have a happy life.
_____________________
I'm going to pick a fight
William Wallace, Braveheart

“Rules are mostly made to be broken and are too often for the lazy to hide behind”
Douglas MacArthur

FULL
dzogchen Moody
need Smell feature
Join date: 3 Jan 2007
Posts: 159
06-21-2007 17:01
From: Mortus Allen
Thanks Aromadon Enoch. My only intolerance is ignorance. As long as people choose to remain ignorant, hence stupid, there will be misunderstandings. Those of us that choose not to be ignorant will turn out hate towards those that would use symbols and words for ill and shrug off the symbols as getting up set over them are a waist of time and energy.


people don't "choose" to be or to remain ignorant.
people do "choose" thinking highly of themselves as individuals.

and misunderstandings happen wherever there is more than one human involved.
Wilhelm Neumann
Runs with Crayons
Join date: 20 Apr 2006
Posts: 2,204
06-21-2007 17:02
I"m also pretty sure that the swastikas painted on my grandmothers gravestones while they were tumbled were put there by natzi groups and the one painted on my door one summer. I have never seen anyone paint one anywheer but on a jews property in my home town if its for other reasons its usually kept in its place as a little medalion or a decoration inside a house never flaunted in the way we see in SL. Once you start throwing around symbols and sticking up giant billboards I will not believe that you are putting it there as a sign of peace etc it looks like an attempt at grandstanding to me and in your face method of flaunting something which bring me back to realizing its probably someone just saying its the "nice kind" especially if its black on a red background.

Anyone willing to prove this wrong is free to build a themed budhist temple and encorporate the "swastika" the good kind into their build meanwhile if i see a big huge swastika in my backyard where it should not be I will be reporting it for what it is. The natzi parties official emblem and also trash..
Har Fairweather
Registered User
Join date: 24 Jan 2007
Posts: 2,320
06-21-2007 17:08
Agree, Wilhelm, I think it is pretty clear what the intention was behind the swastikas on your grandmother's headstone and your property.

Best revenge, continue to isolate and diminish the sick fucks.
Dnali Anabuki
Still Crazy
Join date: 17 Oct 2006
Posts: 1,633
06-21-2007 17:10
Francesca, I am really sorry to see you go. In the long run it is always good to stand on your principles so whatever good you lose here, you will find elsewhere.

For good or for ill, people speak their mind here and though it gets very uncomfortable, I think its important to stand your ground even if you feel in a minority in the forum. Otherwise eventually only one side of things ever gets expressed.

Best wishes for your health
Chris Norse
Loud Arrogant Redneck
Join date: 1 Oct 2006
Posts: 5,735
06-21-2007 17:11
From: Wilhelm Neumann
I"m also pretty sure that the swastikas painted on my grandmothers gravestones while they were tumbled were put there by natzi groups and the one painted on my door one summer. I have never seen anyone paint one anywheer but on a jews property in my home town if its for other reasons its usually kept in its place as a little medalion or a decoration inside a house never flaunted in the way we see in SL. Once you start throwing around symbols and sticking up giant billboards I will not believe that you are putting it there as a sign of peace etc it looks like an attempt at grandstanding to me and in your face method of flaunting something which bring me back to realizing its probably someone just saying its the "nice kind" especially if its black on a red background.

Anyone willing to prove this wrong is free to build a themed budhist temple and encorporate the "swastika" the good kind into their build meanwhile if i see a big huge swastika in my backyard where it should not be I will be reporting it for what it is. The natzi parties official emblem and also trash..


The people who vandalized your Grandmother's gravestone and your door should be charged with a crime, destruction of private property.
_____________________
I'm going to pick a fight
William Wallace, Braveheart

“Rules are mostly made to be broken and are too often for the lazy to hide behind”
Douglas MacArthur

FULL
Xylo Quisling
Registered User
Join date: 1 Feb 2007
Posts: 146
06-21-2007 17:16
I'm passionately in favour of free speech. I would like to remind you guys, though, that none of the countries with free speech allow everything to be said or otherwise expressed that people feel like. Among the things that you can get punished for, at least in my country, are hate speech, antisemitism, and certainly the placing of swastika's on one's porch. And rightly so.

Which is not to say that I have a detailed opinion right now on what SL should and should not allow. These are difficult matters. But total, unlimited free speech is not allowed in any of our democracies.
Wilhelm Neumann
Runs with Crayons
Join date: 20 Apr 2006
Posts: 2,204
06-21-2007 17:17
From: Chris Norse
The people who vandalized your Grandmother's gravestone and your door should be charged with a crime, destruction of private property.



well they had to catch them first and yes of course they were reported. They were when caught charged with a lot more then that though as one year we had a rampage of neo natzi's when I was in my 20's they beat a couple of people to death too among other things.

Anyhow i strongly disbelieve its a sign of peace when people errect ugly spinning things etc when they know people hate that stuff seems the opposite to me. Peaceful people who are trying to be "zen" using such symbols are usually pretty unintrussive of their ideas and dont go around plopping them on linden land and other stuff it means something and there are a lot of griefer groups out there who have made poofers that poof little hitlers and swastikas depending on the poofer they are using at the time. So I highly doubt these are peacful people minding their own business bulding their little builds and making ornate symbols for peace out of pixels and prims
Maggie McArdle
FIOS hates puppies
Join date: 8 May 2006
Posts: 2,855
06-21-2007 17:20
From: Alex Fitzsimmons
Irrelevant and misleading.

The meaning of symbols, not unlike the meaning of words, changes with time. A symbol, like a word, is nothing but what people think it is -- the word "green" only corresponds to a particular physical property because people think it does. There's nothing inherent in the word itself that makes it so.
At one time, the swastika symbolized well-being. It no longer does. It now symbolizes Nazism.


not so, just because one group appropiates a symbol to use, wether negativley(nazism), or positively(i was taught the original use of the swastika was in healing rites in some native american cultures, namely the Navajos), does not take away the original intent of that symbol.
once You take back the symbol, and use it and educate yourself in what it really means, can it be "cleansed" of its hateful misuse.
_____________________
There's, uh, probably a lot of things you didn't know about lindens. Another, another interesting, uh, lindenism, uh, there are only three jobs available to a linden. The first is making shoes at night while, you know, while the old cobbler sleeps.You can bake cookies in a tree. But the third job, some call it, uh, "the show" or "the big dance," it's the profession that every linden aspires to.
Pirate Cotton
DarkLifer
Join date: 26 Sep 2003
Posts: 538
06-21-2007 17:21
There's nothing I hate worse than retards arguing over the swastika as a good luck symbol. It usually goes hand in hand with being young and thinking you're smarter than everyone else. Instantly it makes you look like a sad dork who needs to try and prove something.

Look at the Nazi flag.
Look at the swastika as used by Hindus.

They are QUITE different.

I can't see the offending material, but if it is related to the Nazi flag, then there is only one meaning for the image, as Hindus don't use it in that mix of colors, background and orientation.

LL is right to try and keep the swastika out of SL. In many countries the display of the device is illegal and LL could end up putting their users at risk by leaving it up, let alone face problems with governments overseas. With the kiddy porn and age play issues I think they have enough on their plate without stirring the feelings of the majority of Europeans on the matter.
Rusty Satyr
Meadow Mythfit
Join date: 19 Feb 2004
Posts: 610
06-21-2007 17:24
From: Francesca Alva
Today was the final straw. A request by someone for help with removing a Nazi display from near his parcel was met with ridicule and finally locked by Strife Onizuka - not because it was off-topic but because it broke Forum rules on displaying Nazi symbols. Did she even bother to read the thread? I really don't know because she hasn't replied to the PM I sent her. She has referred it to Linden Review - well good - perhaps they will point out to her that her reason for closing it was nonsense, given the thread content. She could simply have removed the picture.

Another forum member used the locked thread for a bit of grandstanding. His opening post on a subject that has been done to death contained inaccuracies - note I say inaccuracies, not an opinion with which I disagree - in fact I did agree with much of what he posted. I clearly offended him by pointing out 1) that the thread to which he referred had not been locked because it had gone off-topic. I strongly suspect he knew that anyway; 2) that he had attributed a quotation to the wrong person. Although he replied to every other person that posted, he ignored me.

Petty (of me) you may think, but I have to confess that ever since I was attacked by someone in the Forum a few months ago, I've held back from posting anything serious. I am sick, housebound and in constant pain in RL - I don't need more grief in the virtual world.

I have just logged on to find that my post telling everyone that the Nazi items had been removed in world had evoked the ire of one of our great libertarians. Someone should tell him that the price of eternal freedom is eternal vigilance.

I am a Jew. I am offended by the glorification of the Nazi regime and I told him so. I see he has responded, but I have not read his post nor that of the person who told him he had struck "Forum Gold" with his dig at me. She has also responded. Call me a coward but I really can't cope with any more cruelty or any cheap shots - and there is a great deal of both in these forums. There is a great deal of fun and wisdom too, and I shall miss that, and I shall miss so many of you, but I'm going. This isn't like Sinatra's retirement - I shan't creep back in a couple of weeks. I looked to see if there were some way to unsubscribe, but regrettably not.

Doubtless this post will provoke a great deal of mirth and mockery - and it will run and run and go way off-topic, but somehow I don't think Strife will be closing it any time soon. Except of course I used the word Nazi - hmm good job I'm going before I'm banned.

Let me leave you with this posting, made earlier today (not by me, I hasten to add). I'm sure the poster thinks of himself as tolerant. I agree - if tolerant means "I'm all right Jack so the world can screw itself".


I think you singlehandedly filled the SL official forums "Drama" quotient for the day.
... regardless of whether I agree with all, any or none of your post.

Thanks for sharing I guess...


afterthough: Keep in mind that a lot of the people posting nazi paraphenalia aren't doing it because they 'believe' in white supremacy and that rubbish... it's because they're GRIEFERS trying to annoy people. Like cruel children throwing rocks at leashed dogs hoping to get the dog to charge them enraged, and harming itself when it attempts to leap past the end of it's chain.

Sure nazi idealism is intolerable... but WE control how we react when some assinine griefer waves 'taboo' images around. Lose your temper... lose your composure.... and you've basically given them the only victory they're ever going to have.

Censorship empowers symbols by treating them "Special". Let the racist idiots wear their nazi crap and spit on them for being stupid enough to declare their ignorant closed-mindedness so publically.
Xylo Quisling
Registered User
Join date: 1 Feb 2007
Posts: 146
06-21-2007 17:35
The above poster seems, as many, unnecessarily unkind. I suppose that's not exactly spectacular - all over the internet the hostile way seems to be favoured by a large percentage of posters. It's pointless wishing it weren't so, of course.
Chris Norse
Loud Arrogant Redneck
Join date: 1 Oct 2006
Posts: 5,735
06-21-2007 17:36
From: Wilhelm Neumann
well they had to catch them first and yes of course they were reported. They were when caught charged with a lot more then that though as one year we had a rampage of neo natzi's when I was in my 20's they beat a couple of people to death too among other things.

Anyhow i strongly disbelieve its a sign of peace when people errect ugly spinning things etc when they know people hate that stuff seems the opposite to me. Peaceful people who are trying to be "zen" using such symbols are usually pretty unintrussive of their ideas and dont go around plopping them on linden land and other stuff it means something and there are a lot of griefer groups out there who have made poofers that poof little hitlers and swastikas depending on the poofer they are using at the time. So I highly doubt these are peacful people minding their own business bulding their little builds and making ornate symbols for peace out of pixels and prims


Would it have somehow been better if the people had been beat to death over the money in their pockets? All crime is hateful.
_____________________
I'm going to pick a fight
William Wallace, Braveheart

“Rules are mostly made to be broken and are too often for the lazy to hide behind”
Douglas MacArthur

FULL
Wilhelm Neumann
Runs with Crayons
Join date: 20 Apr 2006
Posts: 2,204
06-21-2007 18:07
From: Chris Norse
Would it have somehow been better if the people had been beat to death over the money in their pockets? All crime is hateful.


err i thought we were talking about swastikas and what connotation please dont try to put words in people's mouths you said they should have been charged and I said they were when they were caught i'm not sure how you derived from what i said that other crime is not hateful?
Peggy Paperdoll
A Brat
Join date: 15 Apr 2006
Posts: 4,383
06-21-2007 18:10
From: Chris Norse
Would it have somehow been better if the people had been beat to death over the money in their pockets? All crime is hateful.


Assinine statement.........totally off topic. The Neo Nazi's mentioned that you are relating to killed because of religious beliefs (assuming, of course the event happened.....but there's no reason to disbelieve it either). You really need to read the whole statement....not cherry pick for you own purposes. It was not because of "money in their pockets" as you so moronically posted.

Some people argue to "impress" others of their wisdom.......wisdom that is seldom there. You are guilty of that, my friend. You said you "may lose" an argument but "won't back down".........that is a very clear sign of a "loser".

Take that for what's it's worth.
Chris Norse
Loud Arrogant Redneck
Join date: 1 Oct 2006
Posts: 5,735
06-21-2007 18:24
From: Peggy Paperdoll
Assinine statement.........totally off topic. The Neo Nazi's mentioned that you are relating to killed because of religious beliefs (assuming, of course the event happened.....but there's no reason to disbelieve it either). You really need to read the whole statement....not cherry pick for you own purposes. It was not because of "money in their pockets" as you so moronically posted.

Some people argue to "impress" others of their wisdom.......wisdom that is seldom there. You are guilty of that, my friend. You said you "may lose" an argument but "won't back down".........that is a very clear sign of a "loser".

Take that for what's it's worth.


He is the one that brought up that two people had been beat to death. I agree that is a horrible crime. But if it was because of their religion, race or the cash in their pocket, it is all equally bad. I make no distinction as to why the people were killed. You seem to be saying that being murdered for your religion is worse than if the thug did it for economic reasons. We will have to agree to disagree.


Peggy why resort to personal insults?
_____________________
I'm going to pick a fight
William Wallace, Braveheart

“Rules are mostly made to be broken and are too often for the lazy to hide behind”
Douglas MacArthur

FULL
Wilhelm Neumann
Runs with Crayons
Join date: 20 Apr 2006
Posts: 2,204
06-21-2007 18:44
From: Chris Norse
He is the one that brought up that two people had been beat to death. I agree that is a horrible crime. But if it was because of their religion, race or the cash in their pocket, it is all equally bad. I make no distinction as to why the people were killed. You seem to be saying that being murdered for your religion is worse than if the thug did it for economic reasons. We will have to agree to disagree.


Peggy why resort to personal insults?


last post on this as this thread is spinning out of control but how you suddenly change a topic as to the connotation of freedom of speech and what a swastika is to whether or not getting robbed and beated for it is "hateful" escapes me this is how threads spin out of control.

For you its an argument for me i was replying to your statement as a part of a conversation and i'm actualy not here to debate what crime is worse which is why im' gone I'm not comparing one nasty thing to another I'm talking about the what was above. I replied to you because you seem genuinely interested and not to argue over what is worse hateful crimes or crimes of hate.. that's an entirely different topic and not a part of this thread even.

So if you want to start to try to start an argument over what's worse it wont be with me. Im sorry i replied now to your interest in what happened I simply said it in passing as a conclusion to what happened as they caused a lot of damage and it was a mess in an otherwise quite city. If you want to start extrapolating on what I think of other issues by all means do but from what i read in your response your wrong on how or what i think and can try to twist it toyour own means if you wish however you will be wrong.

I'm not a huge debator and had this thread had a more appropriate subject line I would not be here at all but since I started to read it and thought I would say something as usual I regret that I did because i see how people try to twist words towards whatever point they are trying to prove which I truly am not interested in I came and posted in this thread because people are basically saying that the symbols that were removed were not placed for the purpose that most people would see that they are. So again i redirect this to what peaceful loving zen type person using the symbol which as has been pointed out looks completely different would plop down huge billboards with certain colours etc and call that peace because obviously its not

Anyhow have fun it never occured to me I was being drawn into an argument by takling about this in this thread so i withdraw and leave you to argue about what is worse and leave it at that.
1 2 3 4