Welcome to the Second Life Forums Archive

These forums are CLOSED. Please visit the new forums HERE

"LindeX" - Linden Currency Exchange Begins Public Testing

Chris Linden
Program Manager
Join date: 10 Jan 2005
Posts: 149
10-01-2005 12:06
The LindeX market will be closed until further notice, likely a few hours, as we adjust some of the market mechanisms.
Satchmo Prototype
eSheep
Join date: 26 Aug 2004
Posts: 1,323
10-01-2005 12:29
From: Lawrence Linden

Also, we're definitely headed quickly in the web services direction.


Sweet.

A fun baby step would let people access the "Friends Online" info from an api. I could think of a few cool things to do with that.
_____________________

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Electric Sheep Company
Satchmo Blogs: The Daily Graze
Satchmo del.icio.us
Dark Korvin
Player in the RL game
Join date: 13 Jun 2005
Posts: 769
10-01-2005 12:54
From: JIMBO Juergens
I still don't see how its cheaper for the TRADER(as in someone who buys and sells to make a profit on the difference). Paypal fees don't come into play for a trader until they cash in or out. I'm talking about actual trading fees. On gom that fee for a trader would've been 2, 4, or 6 cents per 1k block trade cycle(buy + sell). SL charges over 12 cents per trade cycle. It is better to have higher cash in and out fees and lower spread fees for a trader then vice versa. These cost are too high for traders and kills any sort of trading to be profitable. I would like to see SL have lower trading fees. Maybe charge a monthly fixed fee that gives ppl trader status and gives them lower trading fees. I don't see any problem in doing so.


I agree that a smaller commision for trades and a larger fee for US$ transfers would be more ideal for both those trading and Linden Labs. The volume of trade will always be higher the smaller the commision for the trade is. The more money changes hands, the faster it gets to a stable price, and the more people are willing to both deposit and withdraw money from the system. If Linden Labs got their commision through withdraw and deposit fees, they may possibly make more as more money comes and goes from the market.

The main thing that should cause Linden Labs hassle in the first place is the money withdrawls and depsoits anyway. The commision fee acts like a tax. People will wait longer to sell if they have to overcome the sell fee, and they will wait longer to buy if they have to overcome the buy fee. The lower this disincentive is the better.
Alan Edison
Ty Zvezda
Join date: 28 Jun 2004
Posts: 420
10-01-2005 13:05
From: blaze Spinnaker
You guys missed the analysis.

30 cents fixed cost is WAY cheaper than GOM.

GOM was 30 cents plus 2.9% to transfer from paypal. Ad then on top of that, another 12 cents per 1000 L$ (over 3%) for the seller.

This is just 30 cents to the buyer, and 3.5% to the seller.

Waaaay cheaper.

GOM would have been dead.


surely this added % cost onto the selling price can just be passed on to the buyer? Because without the seller selling L$, buyers cannot buy L$... unless this system will just be working like LL creating L$ as it's needed?

PLUS...
how do we not know that LL bought over GOM? i don't think any company as popular as GOM would give up the majority of the market just to allow for LindX... anshe or ige didn't leave, so wot good reason was there for GOM to go? perhaps there is more tthe story than we r being told?
_____________________
Ty Zvezda
Jillian Callahan
Rotary-winged Neko Girl
Join date: 24 Jun 2004
Posts: 3,766
10-01-2005 13:08
From: Alan Edison
surely this added % cost onto the selling price can just be passed on to the buyer? Because without the seller selling L$, buyers cannot buy L$... unless this system will just be working like LL creating L$ as it's needed?
Well, without buyers buying... :)

From: Alan Edison
PLUS...
how do we not know that LL bought over GOM? i don't think any company as popular as GOM would give up the majority of the market just to allow for LindX... anshe or ige didn't leave, so wot good reason was there for GOM to go? perhaps there is more tthe story than we r being told?
GOM is closed as of tomorrow, OCT 2nd. LindeX has the advantage of convenience. We'll see how it all works out. (I still expect IGE and Anshe to do fine - different market types.)
_____________________
Dnate Mars
Lost
Join date: 27 Jan 2004
Posts: 1,309
10-01-2005 13:23
From: Alan Edison
PLUS...
how do we not know that LL bought over GOM? i don't think any company as popular as GOM would give up the majority of the market just to allow for LindX... anshe or ige didn't leave, so wot good reason was there for GOM to go? perhaps there is more tthe story than we r being told?


Like GOM being bought out, but placed under strict NDA? Maybe so this way it looks like GOM is just leaving, but LL really bought them out, and this entire drama is really just a product of LL so they can look like the good guys and getting a new exchange up and running? Maybe Tom and Jamie aren't really real, they are just Philip and Andrew playing a new role, and then they got tired of it, so they desided to produce all this drama?
_____________________
Visit my website: www.dnatemars.com
From: Cristiano Midnight
This forum is weird.
Dark Korvin
Player in the RL game
Join date: 13 Jun 2005
Posts: 769
10-01-2005 13:35
From: Dnate Mars
Like GOM being bought out, but placed under strict NDA? Maybe so this way it looks like GOM is just leaving, but LL really bought them out, and this entire drama is really just a product of LL so they can look like the good guys and getting a new exchange up and running? Maybe Tom and Jamie aren't really real, they are just Philip and Andrew playing a new role, and then they got tired of it, so they desided to produce all this drama?


The conspiracy could even be worse than you think. What if Phillip and Andrew secretly made a pact with the vile Trolls and evil Gnomes all in the name of destroying the Hippos. How do you know that Tom and Jamie are really not good hearted Hippos. This could be the beginning of the ending of everything. The start of a New World Disorder. The time of reckoning. *Throws hands in the air and runs hysterically in circles*
JIMBO Juergens
Registered User
Join date: 10 Jul 2005
Posts: 33
10-01-2005 14:26
From: Dark Korvin
I agree that a smaller commision for trades and a larger fee for US$ transfers would be more ideal for both those trading and Linden Labs. The volume of trade will always be higher the smaller the commision for the trade is.


I don't know if that is necessarily true that smaller spreads and larger fee for USD transfers is ideal for all. It depends on the volume traded by each trader. Larger USD transfer fees with lower spreads is better for larger volume traders, but the opposite is true for low volume traders. SL should really discern between the 2 to maximize trades and revenue. Either setup some sort of tier system like gom or allow ppl to buy large volume trader status which allows smaller spreads. The buying of the status would act like the larger USD transfer fee. Everybody wins, ppl maximize their trades which maximizes SL revenue.
Moonshine Herbst
none
Join date: 19 Jun 2004
Posts: 483
10-01-2005 14:28
...
_____________________

Alexander Yeats
Registered User
Join date: 8 Sep 2005
Posts: 188
10-01-2005 14:34
From: JIMBO Juergens
I don't know if that is necessarily true that smaller spreads and larger fee for USD transfers is ideal for all. It depends on the volume traded by each trader. Larger USD transfer fees with lower spreads is better for larger volume traders, but the opposite is true for low volume traders. SL should really discern between the 2 to maximize trades and revenue. Either setup some sort of tier system like gom or allow ppl to buy large volume trader status which allows smaller spreads. The buying of the status would act like the larger USD transfer fee. Everybody wins, ppl maximize their trades which maximizes SL revenue.


In RL this is done by two different markets, for example NASDAQ = OTC and small penny stocks and NYSE = big blue chips and large volume trades.
Lawrence Linden
Linden Lab Developer
Join date: 25 Jun 2005
Posts: 235
10-01-2005 15:01
From: Chris Linden
The LindeX market will be closed until further notice, likely a few hours, as we adjust some of the market mechanisms.


The market is back up now with changes to the basic buy and sell pages.

Cheers,
Lawrence
blaze Spinnaker
1/2 Serious
Join date: 12 Aug 2004
Posts: 5,898
10-01-2005 15:03
Lindex should kill the fee on people who buy with USD in their account.

All the 30 cents does is punishes them and keeps them from providing important liquidity to the market.

Hell, LL will make MORE money by getting rid of that 30 cents because they'll have more 3.5% fees they get to charge.
crucial Armitage
Clothing Designer
Join date: 30 Aug 2004
Posts: 838
10-01-2005 15:04
From: Lawrence Linden
The market is back up now with changes to the basic buy and sell pages.

Cheers,
Lawrence


can we use lindenX is it up for real or is this still testing ?
Gabrielle Assia
Mostly Ignorant
Join date: 22 Jun 2005
Posts: 262
10-01-2005 15:11
From: Lawrence Linden
The market is back up now with changes to the basic buy and sell pages.

Cheers,
Lawrence


Why am I having to give my login/password EVERY time I start
to do a buy or sell order? Am I not already logged in??
(very annoying)
Lawrence Linden
Linden Lab Developer
Join date: 25 Jun 2005
Posts: 235
10-01-2005 15:23
From: crucial Armitage
can we use lindenX is it up for real or is this still testing ?


Yes, please use it for real... it's really operating.

Think of it as an open beta.... we're actively monitoring everything to watch for problems and tuning things as we go. Thus far there've been no reported instances of loss of L$ or US$, nor did we encounter any such problems during our internal testing. If there is a problem with LindeX that results in a loss of L$ or US$ we'll do everything we can to make things right for the effected parties.

Cheers,
Lawrence
Lawrence Linden
Linden Lab Developer
Join date: 25 Jun 2005
Posts: 235
10-01-2005 15:28
From: Gabrielle Assia
Why am I having to give my login/password EVERY time I start
to do a buy or sell order? Am I not already logged in??
(very annoying)


You have to relogin in to complete a buy/sell/cancel. This is intended to help protect so that someone walking by an open browser on your system can't just wander into the currency exchange and start trading. However, I do agree that it's annoying, it certainly bothered me quite a bit when I was doing a lot of trades to test the market.

This is one of the exchange features I most want feedback about. Does anyone feel this feature is worthwhile? If so, should we add it to the other pages with the account settings page, and the land auction pages?

Cheers,
Lawrence
Simple Chaos
Registered User
Join date: 13 Nov 2003
Posts: 84
10-01-2005 15:32
From: Lawrence Linden
... to complete a buy/sell/cancel.


There is a cancel option? I didn't see it. Or is that only if someone has sell orders placed. I wanted to place some sell orders but was worried that if other folks subsequently placed "cheaper" orders for sale below mine, I would be left hanging for a while, so I'm hesitant to place any ATM.
Dark Korvin
Player in the RL game
Join date: 13 Jun 2005
Posts: 769
10-01-2005 15:33
From: JIMBO Juergens
I don't know if that is necessarily true that smaller spreads and larger fee for USD transfers is ideal for all. It depends on the volume traded by each trader. Larger USD transfer fees with lower spreads is better for larger volume traders, but the opposite is true for low volume traders. SL should really discern between the 2 to maximize trades and revenue. Either setup some sort of tier system like gom or allow ppl to buy large volume trader status which allows smaller spreads. The buying of the status would act like the larger USD transfer fee. Everybody wins, ppl maximize their trades which maximizes SL revenue.


I agree that teirs would help bring liquidity to the market as well. They also have the added bonus of encouraging people to trade more. You are correct that there needs to be a balance with the fees. I don't think commissions should be abolished, but the current commission seems high to me, ecspecially on the buy side. Wasn't one of the points of this this market in the first place to make impulse buying easier to happen. People buying $L250 on impulse are certainly not helped by a US$.30 fee. A fee this large seems to work against the objective of encouraging impulse buys.
Gabrielle Assia
Mostly Ignorant
Join date: 22 Jun 2005
Posts: 262
10-01-2005 15:36
From: Lawrence Linden
You have to relogin in to complete a buy/sell/cancel. This is intended to help protect so that someone walking by an open browser on your system can't just wander into the currency exchange and start trading. However, I do agree that it's annoying, it certainly bothered me quite a bit when I was doing a lot of trades to test the market.

This is one of the exchange features I most want feedback about. Does anyone feel this feature is worthwhile? If so, should we add it to the other pages with the account settings page, and the land auction pages?

Cheers,
Lawrence


Yes.. this is terrible as it is right now.
I make/change several orders close together usually.

I think having AT LEAST 5 min idle time before log out would be good.
GOM had a decent idle-time logout set up. Maybe you should ask if
anyone got burned from that?
Jillian Callahan
Rotary-winged Neko Girl
Join date: 24 Jun 2004
Posts: 3,766
10-01-2005 15:42
From: Lawrence Linden
You have to relogin in to complete a buy/sell/cancel. This is intended to help protect so that someone walking by an open browser on your system can't just wander into the currency exchange and start trading. However, I do agree that it's annoying, it certainly bothered me quite a bit when I was doing a lot of trades to test the market.

This is one of the exchange features I most want feedback about. Does anyone feel this feature is worthwhile? If so, should we add it to the other pages with the account settings page, and the land auction pages?

Cheers,
Lawrence
I vote to keep it. It's only a small burden for most, and I'm a big fan of security in front of anything even vaguely monitary.
_____________________
Gabrielle Assia
Mostly Ignorant
Join date: 22 Jun 2005
Posts: 262
10-01-2005 15:50
From: Jillian Callahan
I vote to keep it. It's only a small burden for most, and I'm a big fan of security in front of anything even vaguely monitary.


Why don't you just use the "logout" button then, after
you are done with your trade?

That way you get your security, and those that wish to
stay logged in for several trades can do that too.
Dark Korvin
Player in the RL game
Join date: 13 Jun 2005
Posts: 769
10-01-2005 15:51
From: Simple Chaos
There is a cancel option? I didn't see it. Or is that only if someone has sell orders placed. I wanted to place some sell orders but was worried that if other folks subsequently placed "cheaper" orders for sale below mine, I would be left hanging for a while, so I'm hesitant to place any ATM.


In the currency section on the left side of the window there is an option named 'transaction history'. I believe that is where the cancel button is.
Aaron Levy
Medicated Lately?
Join date: 3 Jun 2004
Posts: 2,147
10-01-2005 15:55
A few oddities with the buy Lindens... enter 50,000 L$, then tab down and back up, the numbers jump up and down and finally stabalize at 49,995 @ (at this time) $194.93. I know it has to do with rounding, but if I wanted to buy 50,000 L$, I can't cause it keeps rounding it down.

If I enter 50,001, it rounds it UP to 50,003. Weird.
Aaron Levy
Medicated Lately?
Join date: 3 Jun 2004
Posts: 2,147
10-01-2005 15:58
Overall its confusing. There needs to be market info ON the pages where you are buying and selling, not off on some separate page. I don't like the format -- it actually too simplified. Also, buyers should not have a fee. Period. The sellers are the ones profiting, it should come from their pockets. (and I'm a seller and buyer)

And why didn't you just stick with the widely-accepted $L1,000 = $X.XXUSD, instead of this really weird L$/US$1.00? I know what it means, but it's really, well, not unintuitive.

Maybe the more I use it, I don't know.

At first glance, though, I'd say it falls really really short.
Jillian Callahan
Rotary-winged Neko Girl
Join date: 24 Jun 2004
Posts: 3,766
10-01-2005 16:04
From: Gabrielle Assia
Why don't you just use the "logout" button then, after you are done with your trade?

That way you get your security, and those that wish to stay logged in for several trades can do that too.
Because I wasn't thinking about me.
_____________________
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 ... 16