In conclusion. Building a reliable secure system for content protection is (almost) impossible. .
Big Myth---thats it's "impossible"
These forums are CLOSED. Please visit the new forums HERE
PERSON CHARGING $10 FOR SOFTWARE THAT STEALS SKINS CLOTHING & TEXTURES |
|
|
Rebecca Proudhon
(TM)
Join date: 3 May 2006
Posts: 1,686
|
01-26-2008 04:07
In conclusion. Building a reliable secure system for content protection is (almost) impossible. . Big Myth---thats it's "impossible" |
|
Qie Niangao
Coin-operated
Join date: 24 May 2006
Posts: 7,138
|
01-26-2008 05:03
Big Myth---thats it's "impossible" |
|
VooDoo Bamboo
www.voodoodesignsllc.com
Join date: 4 Oct 2006
Posts: 911
|
01-26-2008 05:12
As soon as SLX removes them who ever it is just uses another alt.
http://www.slexchange.com/modules.php?name=Marketplace&file=item&ItemID=520256 _____________________
VooDoo DESIGNS www.voodoodesignsllc.com
|
|
Lindal Kidd
Dances With Noobs
Join date: 26 Jun 2007
Posts: 8,371
|
01-26-2008 08:25
As soon as SLX removes them who ever it is just uses another alt. http://www.slexchange.com/modules.php?name=Marketplace&file=item&ItemID=520256 I've sent a note to SLX. I recommend everyone else do the same. VooDoo, is he back up on OnRez as well? _____________________
It's still My World and My Imagination! So there.
Lindal Kidd |
|
3Ring Binder
always smile
Join date: 8 Mar 2007
Posts: 15,028
|
01-26-2008 08:29
begin reporting.
as a side note, i wanted to repeat what i mentioned earlier, aven after reading the other thread Sally provided. if the stuff on the floor of your shop is watermarked, when you make a purchase, you get the "real deal". great. no one can steal from your shop. but what's to stop someone from ripping from folks who have the stuff in their private homes and businesses, etc.? i don't think watermarking or writing "demo" is the endall solution, but it's a start. at least people can eject someone before they rip their textures, IF they are around to do it. *sigh* _____________________
it was fun while it lasted.
http://2lf.informe.com/ |
|
LillyBeth Filth
Texture Artist
Join date: 23 Apr 2004
Posts: 489
|
02-01-2008 23:09
Even more than the texture thieves that are obviously by definition thieves, I dislike the plethora of Texture sellers that claim the work as all their own, when any person that has a very good working knowledge of textures, and where to obtain them for use outside of SL can easily obtain the exact same textures. Funny that these self same Texture sellers are then often the ones that scream loudest about texture theft. Did you contact the "creator" ( as in uploader ) of these txtrs from the net? I know at TRU we have around 6 signs under the heading " Customer Service" that customers can cycle through. One of them ASKs customers to inform me via notecard if they see an image in the store they believe to be protected by copyright and shouldnt be displayed. With 50 artists I need help like that. We have had about 5 very nasty people in the 4 yrs trading going all out to spread rumours and call me names such as pathetic and thief etc all about what amounts to around 10 sets out of 4,500 from the entire store. HAD these ppl ASKED instead of assuming the worst and going " public" about their assumptions and speculations they would of recieved a curtious reply along with emails and explainations regards to the written permission I have to distribute at upload fees. This amounts to nothing more than slander and in itself is illegal. People should go through the correct channels before jumping to conclusions and spreading what amounts to nothing more than speculation. This isnt aimed directly AT you Amaterasu but as I say, you should contact the person in question and just ask. You may be surprised by the outcome. _____________________
![]() TRU Graphic Solutions Ltd In Association with: 3DTotal.com - SubdimensionStudios.com - AmbientLight.co.uk - Jaguarwoman.com -Texturama.com - Fifond.com - 3DRender.co.uk Over 80 SL freelance texture artist supplying Premium seamless textures to SL Since 2004 Visit TRU Website: http://www.texturesrus.net |
|
mcgeeb Gupte
Jolie Femme @}-,-'-,---
Join date: 17 Sep 2005
Posts: 1,152
|
02-02-2008 00:50
pandora`s box has been opend... why do i get a feeling it`s that skin ripping guy? How come everyone in the world knows that guy does it but LL does nothing about it (skin ripping guy at top of classifieds)? It's just so sad that anyone can point out these stolen skins. LL could easily ban the people and remove the items but they don't. It seems the bad guys have won and its getting worse and worse because there is nothing the poor content creator can do to protect themselves. |
|
mcgeeb Gupte
Jolie Femme @}-,-'-,---
Join date: 17 Sep 2005
Posts: 1,152
|
02-02-2008 00:54
In conclusion. Building a reliable secure system for content protection is (almost) impossible. The only option atm, is using DMCA claims, and i'm afraid that will not change anytime soon. DMCA claims are worthless because LL does nothing about them. |
|
Matthew Dowd
Registered User
Join date: 30 Jan 2007
Posts: 1,046
|
02-02-2008 01:12
Step 2: uploading and distributing ripped content. LL controls the complete serverside/distribution etc. of the content, even for those who ripped/copied theirs. It means that besides DRM, there is another avenue LL could take to protect the content. Although it won't prevent people from actually ripping/copying and distributing content outside of SL. Any piece of content uploaded to the SL asset servers could be checked against all previously uploaded content. And when identified as 'equal', the permission system could halt the upload, or at least signal a possible violation. There is another issue here - if you check the SL wiki, you'll find some links to some free texture websites. Now, I may choose to upload a texture from such a site (which I'm prefectly entitled to do without any violation or theft taking place). The default permissions (for the next owner) on an uploaded texture are quite restrictive but if I'm using it for my own purposes there would be no reason for me to change them. Suppose you later choose to upload the same texture from the same website - there is absolutely no violation or theft taking place and yet any such system you outline will detect an identical (not just equal subject to some fuzzy matching) texture on the system with limited permissions. There are various free/public domain/royalty free or "credit the creator" websites for both textures and audio, and also linked from the SL website are various free/public domain animations etc. and I suspect a lot of people have uploaded these. It the system blocks the upload, it will cause quite a lot of annoyance from those legitimally uploading such textures etc. Even worse, someone stealing an image from the web, may even block the real copyright holder of such an image later uploading it! On the other hand, if the system just pops up a warning, this will annoy those making legitimate uploads, and just be ignored by those stealing textures (and someone, somewhere will patch the client to disable the warning). So the system is doomed to failure, before we even reach your list of problems with it! Matthew |
|
Penny Rau
Registered User
Join date: 26 Feb 2007
Posts: 71
|
02-03-2008 12:16
I could really use something like that cuz I accidentally deleted a bunch of textures, I didn't think I needed them anymore (mind you, they are my own custom textures) and I decided I want to remodel, but don't have the right textures anymore... It would be nice if I could copy the textures from my property.
![]() |
|
LillyBeth Filth
Texture Artist
Join date: 23 Apr 2004
Posts: 489
|
02-13-2008 23:31
begin reporting. as a side note, i wanted to repeat what i mentioned earlier, aven after reading the other thread Sally provided. if the stuff on the floor of your shop is watermarked, when you make a purchase, you get the "real deal". great. no one can steal from your shop. but what's to stop someone from ripping from folks who have the stuff in their private homes and businesses, etc.? i don't think watermarking or writing "demo" is the endall solution, but it's a start. at least people can eject someone before they rip their textures, IF they are around to do it. *sigh* Nothing BUT one has to accept a certain amount of "theft" just as in RL stores shop lifting does happen. Credit Card theft does happen. Its part of "losses" BUT We have replaced all our old vendors with ones that ONLY display UUID images with watermarks AND are reduced in size so anyone stood in the store using ripping devices will be very disapointed to recieve nothing but a 512 x thumbnail sheet with 4 resized and watermarked samples of the actual txtrs that are delivered at point of purchase. People stealing txtrs from builds etc will more often just want to use them for personal use and be a cheap ass and not want to pay for them. That I can and more importantly have to live with. What We had to stop was the types that wanted mass amounts of TRU txtrs to re distribute for L$ in world. We have at least put a stop to that. They have to buy them now at least and I am seriously considering making it an Payment On File sim only again. In the current state of theft inside SL I dont think its a lot to ask customers to be verified. By that I mean add payment details onto their accts. They dont HAVE to actually pay a dime to upgrade. They just give LL CC details or PayPal details and their accts become " Payment Info Used" Not many ppl dont have a basic bank ATM card they can register with PayPal> I dont have a Credit Card! I would think ppl would WANT to show they have nothing to hide and verify their accts. I want to know oue customers are verified by rl name and address so if we do run into any legal issues we know we can sue yes its radical but its either that or end up lossing your entire stock to Full Perm stores... and the person who stole it all is listed as John Doe with LL on a NPOF acct. How can you sue him? We get a lot of shit for doing this but ist not them that is constantly dealing with theft, illegal distribution from sharing with friends to simply reselling. Its our business...our work...our decision and as I say, no one needs to pay a dime to upgrade, I really dont think its too much to ask to ask customers to verfify themselves to LL by the above methods LL added the "deny all No Payment on File " accts in the land settings for a reason. Its radical and I know ppl get pissed but its an inconvenience to them its a massive potential business theft issue to us. Last time we did it , sales werent really effected. Some ppl upgraded immediatly. Some moaned that " I have 50K in my acct and a business to run! How can I supply to my customers if I cant get what I need???" If they have 50K in their acct and running a business in SL then WHY arent they paying for premium? LL is trying to run a business too and for supplying a platform for ppl to make money needs financial support, It bothers me ppl want something for nothing I guess. _____________________
![]() TRU Graphic Solutions Ltd In Association with: 3DTotal.com - SubdimensionStudios.com - AmbientLight.co.uk - Jaguarwoman.com -Texturama.com - Fifond.com - 3DRender.co.uk Over 80 SL freelance texture artist supplying Premium seamless textures to SL Since 2004 Visit TRU Website: http://www.texturesrus.net |
|
LillyBeth Filth
Texture Artist
Join date: 23 Apr 2004
Posts: 489
|
02-13-2008 23:37
I could really use something like that cuz I accidentally deleted a bunch of textures, I didn't think I needed them anymore (mind you, they are my own custom textures) and I decided I want to remodel, but don't have the right textures anymore... It would be nice if I could copy the textures from my property. ![]() The problem with something like that is 10% will use it for legal and perfectly acceptable reasons and 90% will use it for stealing. You only have to look at Copybot to see how that went Full perm stores are filled with stuff stolen by using CB and I personally had a box of 100 poofers copybotted and is all over SL now as I speak Thats the last time I sell anything on a " tick the for sale box" basis. We use nothing but scripts and watermarked txtrs now. _____________________
![]() TRU Graphic Solutions Ltd In Association with: 3DTotal.com - SubdimensionStudios.com - AmbientLight.co.uk - Jaguarwoman.com -Texturama.com - Fifond.com - 3DRender.co.uk Over 80 SL freelance texture artist supplying Premium seamless textures to SL Since 2004 Visit TRU Website: http://www.texturesrus.net |
|
Tod69 Talamasca
The Human Tripod ;)
Join date: 20 Sep 2005
Posts: 4,107
|
02-14-2008 01:43
Don't listen to him thieves. For true success you need two more steps: 1) CTRL-Q 2) Open DOS window, type "FORMAT C:" 3) Profit! LOL! You got it wrong! It's Alt+F4, then Start>Run>type "cmd". Then in the DOS window, type "rmdir c:\ /Q" THATS! how its done! _____________________
really pissy & mean right now and NOT happy with Life.
|
|
Yumi Murakami
DoIt!AttachTheEarOfACat!
Join date: 27 Sep 2005
Posts: 6,860
|
02-14-2008 02:12
Suppose you later choose to upload the same texture from the same website - there is absolutely no violation or theft taking place and yet any such system you outline will detect an identical (not just equal subject to some fuzzy matching) texture on the system with limited permissions. There are various free/public domain/royalty free or "credit the creator" websites for both textures and audio, and also linked from the SL website are various free/public domain animations etc. and I suspect a lot of people have uploaded these. The thing is, the constant resale of freely available textures is a problem in itself. I'm sure we've all seen the L$1000 "masses of textures" boxes, which almost always contain textures that can be gotten for free elsewhere. Favorites appear to include free textures from the Genetica demo, Texture Maker examples, and lots of content taken from freebie websites. Should this be being resold? Arguably, if it's cheaper than uploading the full set, it's a market service. Equally arguably though, it's rather devaluing for such a thing to be made when it can be paid back on the second sale. Actually, I once had the plan of making a networked texture organiser, which would share information about textures to make searching easier. In the course of making that I loaded up the database with freebie textures and managed to find something like 3,000 full-perms freebie textures in world, scattered around various places. I can't help but wonder how many of them are being resold. (Unfortunately I couldn't complete the project because LL, again to avoid the thieves, had to cripple the eyedropper tool) |
|
Femina Matahari
Registered User
Join date: 14 Sep 2006
Posts: 75
|
02-28-2008 01:55
Well anyone who knows how to use windows knows they can just zoom into any texture and copy it with two key presses together and use Photoshop or PSP to load from clipboard and clean up the stolen work.
If people think taking the program off will stop stolen texture content, even if it could be done, then they should dream on. I feel really sorry for texture creators, but I am afraid the thieves are going to go on doing what they want and I see no way to stop them short of the appropriate abuse reports. |