Welcome to the Second Life Forums Archive

These forums are CLOSED. Please visit the new forums HERE

pay for event listings?

Tayzia Abattoir
Registered User
Join date: 30 May 2004
Posts: 272
03-10-2006 05:07
From: Jesse Linden
Patrolling the calendar has proven not particularly effective or scalable. A Linden (or resident) police force to dish out punishments for abuse is a time sink when our time is probably better spent elsewhere developing Second Life. As Second Life continues to grow quickly, the calendar abuse will continue to grow requiring more policing etc.

As it stands now, most people who are holding events for fun and not profit are bypassing the calendar entirely and sending group IM's. I suppose the logic here might be if people are going to fill up the calendar with pseudo-events and ads anyways, we might as well create a new money sink. I like Travis' suggestion of charging by the half-hour or simply porting over the classifieds model which has proved successful.



Some people are sending group IMs for events yes, but what about new Citizens that wish to hold quality events and do not have a large friends list or even a group yet.

I hold not for profit events for the Crescent Moon Museum. These events are things such as Ballroom dancing, build contests, reading circles etc. I already have to offer a large "prize" of some sort to get people to come to events so they can experience the artistic possiblilites available in sl. I do not benefit from dwell monies as I dont own the land.

That in itself can be a financial hardship at times, so charging for posting events would perhaps deter me from posting at all. I do have a donation box out generally, but am lucky to get 200-500L donated in 6 months if even that.

If choosing to not charge for not-for-profit posts vs. for-profit-posts, how exactly would that be determined? If its for a grand opening, or a shopping mall etc, yes they will profit. What about a gallery, or a classy jazz club, or a teaching session for newbs on building. Perhaps they will be set up as not-for-profit, but the person whom holds the event will benefit from dwell monies? It would be difficult to try to charge for not-for-profit events vs. profit events.

Policing the postings would be the best avenue to persue. I hardly ever look at the event listings myself because of the garage sales etc that you have to wade thru, get rid of the garage sales and the nonsense event posts. If those people want to sell used prims, let them open a second hand store. Hire Eventpostpolice Linden :) The name is a bit long, but thats ok!

NAY
Lewis Nerd
Nerd by name and nature!
Join date: 9 Oct 2005
Posts: 3,431
03-10-2006 07:08
From: Tayzia Abattoir
Hire Eventpostpolice Linden :) The name is a bit long, but thats ok!


I prefer "Crapfilter Linden" ... it kinda rolls off the tongue easier.

Lewis
_____________________
Second Life Stratics - your new premier resource for all things Second Life. Free to join, sign up today!

Pocket Protector Projects - Rosieri 90,234,84 - building and landscaping services
Zapoteth Zaius
Is back
Join date: 14 Feb 2004
Posts: 5,634
03-10-2006 07:31
From: Lewis Nerd
I prefer "Crapfilter Linden" ... it kinda rolls off the tongue easier.

Lewis


Seconded :)
_____________________
I have the right to remain silent. Anything I say will be misquoted and used against me.
---------------
Zapoteth Designs, Temotu (100,50)
---------------
Candide LeMay
Registered User
Join date: 30 Dec 2004
Posts: 538
03-10-2006 07:56
From: Jesse Linden
Patrolling the calendar has proven not particularly effective or scalable.
When? You mean you've actually patrollled the event calendar already at some point? I haven't noticed. Or is this just one of those thought experiments where you say 'if we try something it will end up like this so better give up now'?

From: Jesse Linden
A Linden (or resident) police force to dish out punishments for abuse is a time sink when our time is probably better spent elsewhere developing Second Life. As Second Life continues to grow quickly, the calendar abuse will continue to grow requiring more policing etc.
Is LL really so clueless to not see that better events = more attractive SL = more (happy) customers = more income for LL? Just tell me what better ways to develop SL do you have in mind? Inviting another high-profile, borderline porn group to join SL to get some exposure on their website? Posting articles how you can earn 5-figures a year in SL in all magazines that care to listen to you? Sucking up to big corporations to do projects here and hope they won't run off to Active Worlds? Creating even more opportunities for unpaid volunteers to do work that LL should be doing?

Way to drop the ball, really. Sheesh, and you call yourself 'Community Development Manager'. What community exactly do you care about?
_____________________
"If Mel Gibson and other cyberspace writers are right, one day the entire internet will be like Second Life." -- geldonyetich
Tayzia Abattoir
Registered User
Join date: 30 May 2004
Posts: 272
03-10-2006 09:04
I vote Yay for Crapfilter Linden! :)
Lewis Nerd
Nerd by name and nature!
Join date: 9 Oct 2005
Posts: 3,431
03-10-2006 12:05
Having just had a painful look through the listings again, I think "NOTALLCAPS Linden" and "Spellcheck Linden" are seriously required to work alongside Crapfilter Linden if we're ever going to make the Events Calendar useful again.

Lewis
_____________________
Second Life Stratics - your new premier resource for all things Second Life. Free to join, sign up today!

Pocket Protector Projects - Rosieri 90,234,84 - building and landscaping services
Lewis Nerd
Nerd by name and nature!
Join date: 9 Oct 2005
Posts: 3,431
03-10-2006 12:08
From: Candide LeMay
Creating even more opportunities for unpaid volunteers to do work that LL should be doing?


I'm not convinced that's a bad idea actually, because it would allow concerned residents to get involved with helping to shape the world for the better.

I have no hesitation in volunteering myself for further service (on top of my role as a Greeter) to benefit the game - and, so far, nobody has actually said the calendar *doesn't* need work, only the discussion about 'leave yard sales alone'.

Lewis
_____________________
Second Life Stratics - your new premier resource for all things Second Life. Free to join, sign up today!

Pocket Protector Projects - Rosieri 90,234,84 - building and landscaping services
Hugsy Penguin
Sky Junkie
Join date: 20 Jun 2005
Posts: 851
03-10-2006 14:27
Didn't read through the whole thread so this may have already been mentioned.

Travis mentioned charging L$25 per half hour with a $L50 minimum to discourage the all day/every day "events". Others suggested charging for events would cause people to not have legitimate events.

First thought that came to mind is to have a middle ground. Give people 1 or 2 hours free per day, but charge after that.

This way, people can still have their legitimate events for free or cheap, but the all day/every day folks would have to pay alot.

One bad thing is that this would be abused by alts and friends.

HP
Elde Eponym
Registered User
Join date: 14 Feb 2006
Posts: 159
03-10-2006 16:28
From: Hugsy Penguin
Travis mentioned charging L$25 per half hour with a $L50 minimum to discourage the all day/every day "events". Others suggested charging for events would cause people to not have legitimate events.

Pfft. $L50 won't even slow down the abuse - these are the same people that are handing out many times that an hour to campers and spendings tens of thousands a week on Classifieds.
Kaklick Martin
Singer/Songwriter
Join date: 3 Oct 2005
Posts: 175
03-10-2006 16:31
Well, no one's really commented on anything I said, but I'll tie in w/ the "Crapfilter Linden" bit to say, if they provided a decent filter in the client we can all be our own crapfilter - and its much more likely less people would get all bent out of shape.

Please LL, before you muck around with yet another bad policy experiment, consider implementing the real fix to to problem that will make everyone happy. Let us all decide what we don't care to see for ourselves by giving us the proper toolset.
Jesse Linden
Administrator
Join date: 4 Apr 2005
Posts: 285
03-10-2006 16:48
Thanks for all the feedback, keep it coming...checking in w/our development team now to find out what's possible among these suggestions.
Torley Linden
Enlightenment!
Join date: 15 Sep 2004
Posts: 16,530
03-10-2006 16:53
From: Lewis Nerd
Having just had a painful look through the listings again, I think "NOTALLCAPS Linden" and "Spellcheck Linden" are seriously required to work alongside Crapfilter Linden if we're ever going to make the Events Calendar useful again.

Lewis


One of the things I've noticed is, if everyone else is screaming and you whisper, you'll stand out. :)

Thanx each & everyone for the feedback thus far!
_____________________
Tayzia Abattoir
Registered User
Join date: 30 May 2004
Posts: 272
03-10-2006 17:17
From: Kaklick Martin
Well, no one's really commented on anything I said, but I'll tie in w/ the "Crapfilter Linden" bit to say, if they provided a decent filter in the client we can all be our own crapfilter - and its much more likely less people would get all bent out of shape.

Please LL, before you muck around with yet another bad policy experiment, consider implementing the real fix to to problem that will make everyone happy. Let us all decide what we don't care to see for ourselves by giving us the proper toolset.



I agree totally Kaklick, I think perhaps if they set it up like the new products forum, clicking on it takes you to four or five other catagories. If people click on events, maybe a screen could pop up with 8 or so catagories that can be clicked on instead of a large listing of mixed events. Do away with the current filters. Catagories could be such as;

Games (*ingo events and all others)
Clubs (all music and dance club events)
Malls/Stores
Yard Sales
Community Enrichment (Museums, Galleries, Build contests, show and tells, newb classes, etc)
Recreation (races, fishing events, boxing etc)
Casinos

I know that these may already be some of the filters, but I think especially for noobs, it would help just to go directly to a filter screen. Then people could click on the ones they choose from here. Linden policing will be needed to make sure events are listed in the correct catagory. Perhaps they would need to be listed 24 hours in advance or whatever so the can be looked at to be sure they are in the correct catagory. I think the way it is set up now, you can almost put any catagory you wish and get a way with it? Hope this makes sense, Im typing while my brother is ranting in my ear on the phone. :)
Jonas Pierterson
Dark Harlequin
Join date: 27 Dec 2005
Posts: 3,660
03-10-2006 18:52
Myabe some of us consider games and some clubs community enrichment?

After all slingo removes stress and can introduce people to different sides of SL.. if that isn't enrichment nothing is.

The other question rises of if theres gaming and a mall.. which is it?
_____________________
Good freebies here and here

I must protest. I am not a merry man! - Warf, ST: TNG, episode: Qpid

You killed my father. Prepare to die. - Inigo Montoya, The Princess Bride

You killed My father. Your a-- is mine! - Hellboy
Elde Eponym
Registered User
Join date: 14 Feb 2006
Posts: 159
03-10-2006 21:28
From: Tayzia Abattoir
I agree totally Kaklick, I think perhaps if they set it up like the new products forum, clicking on it takes you to four or five other catagories. If people click on events, maybe a screen could pop up with 8 or so catagories that can be clicked on instead of a large listing of mixed events.


And what prevents them from spammning multiple categories they way they do in the Classified?
Lewis Nerd
Nerd by name and nature!
Join date: 9 Oct 2005
Posts: 3,431
03-10-2006 23:02
From: Jonas Pierterson
The other question rises of if theres gaming and a mall.. which is it?


Seriously laggy?

Lewis
_____________________
Second Life Stratics - your new premier resource for all things Second Life. Free to join, sign up today!

Pocket Protector Projects - Rosieri 90,234,84 - building and landscaping services
Tayzia Abattoir
Registered User
Join date: 30 May 2004
Posts: 272
03-11-2006 04:56
From: Elde Eponym
And what prevents them from spammning multiple categories they way they do in the Classified?



Like I said, Linden Policing of the posts.
Elde Eponym
Registered User
Join date: 14 Feb 2006
Posts: 159
03-11-2006 09:10
From: Tayzia Abattoir
Like I said, Linden Policing of the posts.
I missed that part - Apologies.
The Sojourner
Registered User
Join date: 18 Aug 2004
Posts: 66
03-11-2006 09:21
Zonax writes: Here's some food for thought, an IMAGINED post:

Quote:
Dear Forum Users,

The current system of SecondLife forum moderation is neither working or scalable. We don't have the people or time to moderate the forums, so we will start to charge 50 cents per post effective from tomorrow, in hopes of reducing unwanted postings and advertisements.

Thank you for you cooperation!




How would you like THAT?
Because it's similar to what's being proposed for the event listings.

======================

This hit a bell because who do you think would have the monies to post the long events if it was by the hour, or the business listings.... the person who is making money off their events.... the people you are trying to drop from the listings.

Move the yard sales etc to the Miscellaneous page or the commercial page.

Tayzia had some good categories and I sent in mine a while ago. Maybe the idea of seeing the filter page first and making it automatic instead of hitting search would be a good way to deal with it. Filter then listings instead of the other way around. And, maybe have others scan the various lists for outliers. Like someone who does arts and culture scanning those (I found some listings in the Arts and Culture from around Dec or Jan in the PG only listings for "Adult" movies.... like, huh?).

I would be willing to help.

but NAY on the fee for posting.

As it is written now in the rules of posts, half of my building and competition events arent even postable because they run all day.

---
Why not have an all day page or a more than 3-hours-in-a-day page/filter?
Each land owner gets to post ONCE on it.
They can list sub events or events on different parts of their land.. but only ONCE.

For me, that would be preferrable to seeing the multiple listings and would be a lot easier than wading through all the times to find something I am looking for. It would also eliminate duplication, skinny down the events postings, and make the whole thing more readable.
Barbarra Blair
Short Person
Join date: 18 Apr 2004
Posts: 588
03-11-2006 10:12
The Events postings are a service to the players. I would not like for people to have to pay for me to find out about their events; and as someone said above, the events listing abusers are the deep pockets players anyway.

We really need that "all day" or "non-stop" events category. Tringo is an event, but we don't need to see a non-stop tringo game listed every three hours.

Commercial events (sales and so on) need to be limited to the commercial category.

The events calendar will continue to be a mess until it gets a human (Linden) monitor.
_____________________
--Obvious Lady
Ms Kitty
SL Explorer/Shopaholic
Join date: 26 Dec 2004
Posts: 24
My thoughts exactly:)
03-11-2006 11:04
From: Cocoanut Cookie
1.The best solution would be to add tools so people can exclude certain words.

The events calendar is one of the best things SL has going for it. I've said so since I joined, and I absolutely cannot fathom why anyone would want to restrict it so much. People want to be able to find lots of things to do, and at all hours. The more, the better.

2. The worst solution is to have residents policing the thing.

We've already seen that many residents want to define what is an event for everyone else, and I mean, they really, really, REALLY want to define it for everyone else.

Just because some residents have the idea that yard sales, Slingo, best T&A contests and the like aren't really events doesn't mean there aren't BUNCHES of people out there who want them and want to be able to find them.

Including me. Yard sales are one of the few fun, wholesome things there are for me to do in SL, and I think it is absolutely perverted that there is a movement afoot to get rid of them. I resent it. If somebody doesn't like yard sales, then just the heck don't GO to them - stop trying to make it hard for me to find them!

4. As for paying for events, I don't think it is a good idea to nickle and dime people to death, plus we already have classifieds. But at this point, I don't really have an opinion on it one way or the other.

Except I do think that making it where you have to pay more to be at the top of the list is a bad idea.

And I think charging people who are holding yard sales or grand openings more - or making them be the only ones who have to pay - would be unconscionably worse.

To sum up:

We already have categories.

I really don't think someone's pain and suffering from actually having to skim the words "yard sale" should trump my rights to find them, go to them, and have fun at them.

Make the search tools better. But don't expect that to stop the complaining, because making categories didn't.

I think the language already in place - that the event have a start and end point, and a host present - is the perfect definition of an event.

Within that, all events should be treated exactly the same.

God knows, I don't want some residents deciding what I should see as events and what I shouldn't. Please do not give them that power.

And I don't think that should be any of Linden business, either, as long as the guidelines already in place are followed. Don't try to social engineer me away from my yard sales, or some other person away from his T&A contests, or somebody else away from their Tringo.

coco


I couldn't have said it better - go girl!!!

Charging for events 'will not' solve the problem but as I mentioned in another post I believe the events should be restructured.....allow one event posting per person per day - cannot use alts or other group members to post for same type of event. If system stays as it is resmods are not going to help because so many are previously biased against certain things (i.e. yard sales). We do not need more rules/regulation just simple concise rules and if people break them they get one warning....if they break them again they are banned from posting events altogether. Simple as that!

My two cents

Kitty
_____________________
>^.^< Ms Kitty >^.^<
Proprietress of Dark Kitty Emporium and Yard Sale Dark Kitty 72,11,23; Dark Kitty Prefab Homes 223,60,101
Ms Kitty
SL Explorer/Shopaholic
Join date: 26 Dec 2004
Posts: 24
03-11-2006 11:18
From: Tayzia Abattoir
I If people click on events, maybe a screen could pop up with 8 or so catagories that can be clicked on instead of a large listing of mixed events. Do away with the current filters. Catagories could be such as;

Games (*ingo events and all others)
Clubs (all music and dance club events)
Malls/Stores
Yard Sales
Community Enrichment (Museums, Galleries, Build contests, show and tells, newb classes, etc)
Recreation (races, fishing events, boxing etc)
Casinos



I second this:)
_____________________
>^.^< Ms Kitty >^.^<
Proprietress of Dark Kitty Emporium and Yard Sale Dark Kitty 72,11,23; Dark Kitty Prefab Homes 223,60,101
Keiki Lemieux
I make HUDDLES
Join date: 8 Jul 2005
Posts: 1,490
03-11-2006 12:17
YAY!

1 free per day is not a bad idea or maybe 1 free per week or something if we think that will be abused.

Someone else said it, but I agree: When some form of advertisement is free it will be abused. A small nominal fee per event or per hour would be great in my opinion. The $25L per half hour would be fine. I think people would be surprised how many non-events might get elminated that way, and if it doesn't, an added money sink wouldn't be bad for the economy.

I don't like the idea of bidding for time slots like the classifieds. That would be bad. I hate that idea.

Worst idea: letting residents police the events calendar. That's really bad. Put a little report button somewhere so that any resident can bring attention to a problem event poster, maybe. But don't give residents the power to moderate that. Bad idea. Really bad.
_____________________
imakehuddles.com/wordpress/
vivi Odets
Flibbertigibbet
Join date: 4 Sep 2005
Posts: 698
03-11-2006 12:33
hmmmmm...

Why should folks who host ligitimate events be penalized for the actions of those who post "illegitimate" events?

Why should we be limited to the number of events we post/host per day? (to efficiently run our "business" we have managers who post for the actual event hosts -- this allows us to make sure the event gets posted and is literate -- and, since we limit the number of people in our land owning group, it allows for internal security. It would be helpful if there were some fields in the event post form to account for this [i.e. event posted by and event hosted by])

Why should we pay $L for following the rules? (Oh, sure, 25L an hour or 50L an event may not sound significant, but multiply it by several events a day x 7 days a week and it adds up!)

Either police the events listings, using the rules and guidelines at your disposal or let it go. Don't punish those of us who follow the rules.

Sheesh.
Travis Lambert
White dog, red collar
Join date: 3 Jun 2004
Posts: 2,819
03-11-2006 13:41
What if......

There was a $25 charge per half hour to post an event, with a $50 minimum.

And...

The proceeds from those event charges would, instead of becoming a money sink - be used to fund social events beyond those that are funded via the Educational grants?

Cleanup the calendar *and* bring back event support for social events in a limited fashion. Its like doublemint gum :D
_____________________
------------------
The Shelter

The Shelter is a non-profit recreation center for new residents, and supporters of new residents. Our goal is to provide a positive & supportive social environment for those looking for one in our overwhelming world.
1 2 3 4 5 6