What can LL do to help small business owners?
|
|
Ciaran Laval
Mostly Harmless
Join date: 11 Mar 2007
Posts: 7,951
|
10-17-2009 16:23
From: Phil Deakins That's because, in the All search, the quotation marks won't return any pages that don't have that exact phrase either on it, or in link text pointing to it. So when you use quotation marks, you need to be aware of that. They are not always the best things to use. For instance, a search for "black leather jacket" won't return pages that contain the phrase, 'black leather jackets', and you would normally want those pages returned. (I think I'm right about that, although the Google system could take account of plurals and singulars. I haven't checked it). Pages that contain things like, "Leather jackets - black, red, green" won't be returned either. Correct Phil, as far as I've seen that's how it works but if you search for "Black Leather Jacket" you will find a Black Leather Jacket. You need to weigh up the pros and cons of using phrases.
|
|
Brenda Connolly
Un United Avatar
Join date: 10 Jan 2007
Posts: 25,000
|
10-17-2009 17:44
From: Mickey Vandeverre ok...I'm going to use one of my own products....it was too hard with black leather jacket, because there were too many....and this product is more obscure, to narrow it down. The product has "lime green retro bedroom" in the title - so used the following keywords....these are the positions they showed up in search:
retro bedroom - 1
bedroom retro - 16, after retro refrigerators and retro pants
+retro +bedroom - 3
+bedroom +retro - 3
There is an item titled "blue retro diary" in the contents on the ad page, not in the main title, and this is how it shows up in search:
blue retro diary - 1
blue diary - 6, after "diary of a black woman gesture set"
retro diary - 4, after an arm diary, a thigh diary, and a bloody diary
+blue +diary - 1
+diary +blue - 1
+diary +retro - 1
You are correct - adding +, makes a huge difference. Not too many people know this. I play with search all day long, and I didn't know this. How the Hell does LL expect to take SL to the masses when you need a degree from MIT just to use the search feature. Jesus.
_____________________
Don't you ever try to look behind my eyes. You don't want to know what they have seen.
http://brenda-connolly.blogspot.com
|
|
Anya Ristow
Vengeance Studio
Join date: 21 Sep 2006
Posts: 1,243
|
10-18-2009 08:29
From: Mickey Vandeverre here it is with Quotation Marks:
"retro bedroom" - 1
"bedroom retro" - None Found - glance back up, and see that it landed at 16...plus there were more after that
"blue retro diary" - 1 - and only 1 - no others
"blue diary" - 1 - no others
"retro diary" - 1 - no others
"diary retro" - None Found If you have to go to that much trouble to find your own stuff for which you already know the keywords used to advertise it, then search is a massive fail. I tried searching for "bedroom furniture", knowing that you sell it and advertise it using those terms, and failed to find you in the first *15* pages of results. At least five of your competitors appear multiple times in those 15 pages. And FWIW it makes no difference if I use quotes or not on these common terms. I get the same results in the first couple pages. It only seems to matter if the terms return far fewer results, anyway. Plusses? Minusses? Nobody but computer nerds even know to try this. And FWIW, plusses don't do anything. It seems to be the default behavior. Nothing I try using the terms "furniture" and "bedroom" finds you, Mickey. You *only* seem to be visible using the far less common combinations that you know to try. My own classifieds get me only a couple (and I mean a couple) hits per week, yet I have dozens of visitors, sometimes every day. It's not search results or classified ads that are getting me visitors. You may be experiencing the same and crediting it to your classifieds.
_____________________
The Vengeance Studio Gadget Store is closed! 
|
|
Anya Ristow
Vengeance Studio
Join date: 21 Sep 2006
Posts: 1,243
|
10-18-2009 08:36
From: Mickey Vandeverre blue diary - 6, after "diary of a black woman gesture set"
+blue +diary - 1
+diary +blue - 1 Comes in at position 3 for me, with or without plusses. In reverse order it appears on the top of page 2, with or without plusses. In quotes, I get only your entry.
_____________________
The Vengeance Studio Gadget Store is closed! 
|
|
Mickey Vandeverre
See you Inworld
Join date: 7 Dec 2006
Posts: 2,542
|
10-18-2009 08:53
From: Anya Ristow If you have to go to that much trouble to find your own stuff for which you already know the keywords used to advertise it, then search is a massive fail.
I tried searching for "bedroom furniture", knowing that you sell it and advertise it using those terms, and failed to find you in the first *15* pages of results. At least five of your competitors appear multiple times in those 15 pages.
And FWIW it makes no difference if I use quotes or not on these common terms. I get the same results in the first couple pages. It only seems to matter if the terms return far fewer results, anyway.
Plusses? Minusses? Nobody but computer nerds even know to try this. And FWIW, plusses don't do anything. It seems to be the default behavior.
Nothing I try using the terms "furniture" and "bedroom" finds you, Mickey. You *only* seem to be visible using the far less common combinations that you know to try.
My own classifieds get me only a couple (and I mean a couple) hits per week, yet I have dozens of visitors, sometimes every day. It's not search results or classified ads that are getting me visitors. You may be experiencing the same and crediting it to your classifieds. But Anya....I know they won't find me if I use bedroom furniture as a keyword. I prefer to use more descriptive combinations. I only have a few bedroom sets listed, so trying to compete in the "bedroom furniture" category is a no go. I don't think that "bedroom furniture" is even a phrase in my ads. If you look on that page where the retro bedroom is....I've used very descriptive titles on each of the products that are included in the package.....and that's where the draw is. People do find those items, by using keywords other than "bedroom", and they come in to the store to buy those separately. I've asked shoppers what kind of keywords they use. And they do use obscure words to find specifically what they want. Same applies to running the classified ads. I can't compete in any furniture category as it is, and probably never will.....I rely on the more descriptive or obscure phrases. If someone wants a retro bedroom, they will come across it. I have the Xstreet landing points different from the Classified Ad landing points....so I can watch on the map. They seem to come equally from both.
|
|
Ciaran Laval
Mostly Harmless
Join date: 11 Mar 2007
Posts: 7,951
|
10-18-2009 12:41
From: Anya Ristow Plusses? Minusses? Nobody but computer nerds even know to try this. And FWIW, plusses don't do anything. It seems to be the default behavior. Inworld they are default behaviour, on Xstreet they are not. The plus is only really useful on Xstreet.
|
|
Phil Deakins
Prim Savers = low prims
Join date: 17 Jan 2007
Posts: 9,537
|
10-18-2009 13:51
From: Ciaran Laval Inworld they are default behaviour Are you sure about that? I haven't checked, but it seems likely to me that you're not quite right. What I think would happen is that the search will only return pages that contain all the + words, and no pages that contain less than all of them. Without the +s, the results would return all the pages that contain all the + words and, if the results set isn't big enough, it would also return pages that contain some of the + words but not all of them. In Google, it doesn't matter, because almost all searches return a big enough results set, but in SL, there often isn't enough matching pages for a big enough results set. It's just academic because the best way is to leave the +s out in SL.
|
|
Ciaran Laval
Mostly Harmless
Join date: 11 Mar 2007
Posts: 7,951
|
10-18-2009 14:16
From: Phil Deakins Are you sure about that? I haven't checked, but it seems likely to me that you're not quite right. What I think would happen is that the search will only return pages that contain all the + words, and no pages that contain less than all of them. Without the +s, the results would return all the pages that contain all the + words and, if the results set isn't big enough, it would also return pages that contain some of the + words but not all of them. In Google, it doesn't matter, because almost all searches return a big enough results set, but in SL, there often isn't enough matching pages for a big enough results set.
It's just academic because the best way is to leave the +s out in SL. The + is automatically added after you hit space inworld, try it out with Phil Deakins, I only get two results.
|
|
Argent Stonecutter
Emergency Mustelid
Join date: 20 Sep 2005
Posts: 20,263
|
10-18-2009 14:25
The level of confusion around this subject even for people who think they understand it really does suggest that the best way for LL to help small (or not so small) business owners *and* consumers would be to simplify this.
They have the google appliance and know-how, why not use that in XSL?
They want to add social networking tools? How about starting in XSL, let businesspeople set up their own portals for their products, the way Yahoo Shopping does?
|
|
Ciaran Laval
Mostly Harmless
Join date: 11 Mar 2007
Posts: 7,951
|
10-18-2009 14:33
From: Argent Stonecutter The level of confusion around this subject even for people who think they understand it really does suggest that the best way for LL to help small (or not so small) business owners *and* consumers would be to simplify this.
They have the google appliance and know-how, why not use that in XSL? Having different search functionality for XStreet and inworld certainly doesn't help with consistency, the fact that neither have easy to find tips for advanced search functionality is a tad sloppy in my opinion. From: Argent Stonecutter They want to add social networking tools? How about starting in XSL, let businesspeople set up their own portals for their products, the way Yahoo Shopping does? Not wanting to give them ideas but they could probably charge extra for giving people portals or ebay style store fronts.
|
|
Phil Deakins
Prim Savers = low prims
Join date: 17 Jan 2007
Posts: 9,537
|
10-18-2009 15:12
From: Ciaran Laval The + is automatically added after you hit space inworld, try it out with Phil Deakins, I only get two results. No need for me to check - I believe you 
|
|
Jojogirl Bailey
jojo's Folly owner
Join date: 20 Jun 2007
Posts: 1,094
|
10-18-2009 18:37
mickey i completely agree....trying to compete in the larger catagories is futile unless you are willing to pay for your own island and name it something like "furniture" or you are willing to pay huge amounts of money for a classified. i also use specific words and people find me just fine. for example...i sell blankets but also call them comforters, quilts and bedcovers since those are words someone might use when searching. when i do a search for blankets, what i generally get in the results are a TON of listings for the paradise blankets, beach blankets and picnic blankets, but only my store has actual blankets in all the pages i review. the same thing works for me for curtains, blinds, drapes, etc.
as for helping small biz owners...i dont feel this is a responsibility of LL. they provide this platform and i believe those of us who have successful biz's in sl should help each other. i dont look at sl as something with an exhaustive manual to be referred to for answers. I look as SL as tools to be used to create. part of that creation on the part of residents is creating the marketing channels and methods that we all use. there is no end to the possibilities as we have all seen with things like camping, then lucky chairs, then midnight mania all coming into being. the same is true for other forms of marketing...we have gone from top rated places to all search to enhanced access to xlstreet. i expect things to change and develop and for all of us in world to keep brainstorming and then creating new ways to market.
for me its the journey and not the destination...so to speak
_____________________
Director of Marketing - Etopia Island Corporation Marketing and Business Consultant Jojo's Folly - Owner
|
|
Marcel Flatley
Sampireun Design
Join date: 29 Jul 2007
Posts: 2,032
|
10-19-2009 01:48
XStreet Storefronts will be coming, I remember something about that. Will take time though, and since no time-frame was given yet, it could take much time  As a relatively small business owner, I am not asking LL for any help. Why would I? If I want to be more successful, I have to work for it. The only help I might ask for, is more consumers. More people to sell my stuff to. For the rest, LL should not do anything more then providing the platform. Of course it is hard to start up, harder then 5 years ago. Then again, I am the proof it still can be done. When I started my first business, the market for low prim furniture was well served. Yet I managed to succeed, to a level I made profits. One of my biggest competitors (hi Phil!) even helped me a lot regarding search visibility. When I started my second business, the market for plants was well served. And again I succeeded. Now I run 3 businesses, at this moment I rent a homestead plus I own half a mainland sim, and still can cash out. Even though I started in a market where the big guys already were there. And I am sure that if I want to, I can make a living from SL. Running a business in SL is not about making good products. Compare it with owning a mall or a club: slapping down the building and a few rent boxes doesn't do the job. Even when you make the best stuff in the whole of SL, if no one knows, you won't sell a thing. Running a business is a trade on its own. Of course you DO need to make good products, but that does not make you a good business owner.
|
|
Jojogirl Bailey
jojo's Folly owner
Join date: 20 Jun 2007
Posts: 1,094
|
10-19-2009 13:36
well said marcel...and i agree about phil...he has been gracious enough to help me make a thriving low prim biz as well.
_____________________
Director of Marketing - Etopia Island Corporation Marketing and Business Consultant Jojo's Folly - Owner
|