VYC races saturday at 4 PM SL time and next tuesday at 7 pm.
For the historians, here are the race results from tuesday April 25:
official results
1 Oliphant Ming 2 0.75 2 - 0.75 0.75 2 8.25
2 Static Sprocket 9 2 3 0.75 2 - 0.75 17.5
3 Pixeleen Mistral 4 4 - 5 3 3 3 22
4 skippy Spatula 3 3 - 3 5 4 4 22
5 Sifu Luan 6 9 4 2 4 2 - 27
6 Pacifien Massiel 0.75 5 0.75 - 9 9 9 33.5
7 Theodore Polonsky 7 7 7 6 6 9 - 42
8 Tanya Ayoob 9 6 9 9 9 9 - 51
without throwout race:
Oliphant Ming 2 0.75 2 4 0.75 0.75 2 12.25
Static Sprocket 9 2 3 0.75 2 9 0.75 26.5
Pixeleen Mistral 4 4 5 5 3 3 3 27
skippy Spatula 3 3 6 3 5 4 4 28
Sifu Luan 6 9 4 2 4 2 9 36
Pacifien Massiel 0.75 5 0.75 9 9 9 9 42.5
Theodore Polonsky 7 7 7 6 6 9 9 51
Tanya Ayoob 9 6 9 9 9 9 9 60
We had a pair of protests. Static protested me in the first race and after the races were all over, I decided to withdraw from that race rather than contest the issue. This lead to an amusing scenario. Static was sailing Tako with test/non-standard scripts to see how it would perform in race conditions and had asked that his results not be counted for that one race, so he withdrew from the first race as well (as agreed upon before we started). So... both Static and I dropped out of race one and I was protested by a boat that was DSQ'ed before the race had started. But this was in the name of better tako scripts, so it was well worth it.Besides... one race is not really that important.
Race two created more controversy after the event ended with a fairly interesting protest scenario. This time I was not one of the principles... instead I ended up being the protest committee since nobody else was available who I felt comfortable asking to interpret a complex racing rules situation. The problem with small fleet sailing is that you can easily run out of sailors who are not not directly involved in the protest. We really need to recruit more knowledgeable sailors, but that is a different issue.
This was an instructive case of "some positions on the race course are dangerous to be in", and holds many lessons for those interested in learning to use the rules to their advantage, which is something I heartily encourage. Using the rules is specifically allowed. Rule 2 states that
"A boat and her owner shall compete in compliance with recognized
principles of sportsmanship and fair play"
If you read the ISF casebook for interpreting the rules Case 78 states:
"A boat does not break rule 2 by slowing another boat's progress in a race,
provided that this tactic is intended to benefit her own series result,
that the boats are on the same leg and lap of the course, and that in
using it she does not intentionally break a rule."
So studying the rules is to your advantage. Interpreting them makes things interesting for everyone

So... here is the interesting scenario, based on the evidence available to the protest committee (which was somewhat limited since one of the principles did not stay for the entire event and was not present for the hearing).
Boat A and B are both approaching the windward mark on starboard tack, close hauled. It appeared that neither boat will be able to round the mark without tacking onto port then tacking back onto starboard tack. Boat A is ahead and to leeward of boat B which puts boat A outside of B relative to the buoy. Boat A starts turning into the wind and collides with boat B just before boat A is head to wind. Boat B claims that boat A was tacking too close and attempting to tack onto port. Boat B was holding a close hauled course on starboard, then headed up into the wind when it became clear A was not going to clear her but did strike boat A and protested A. Both boats then turned onto onto port tack after the collision. Boat A did not accept the protest during the race, and was not available for the protest hearing after the race.
The protest committee determined that boat A did not hail for room to at the mark, nor did A hail for boat B to head up into the wind. In other words, A did not hail that she was attempting to force B up into the wind, and did not give B sufficient time to respond to being forced up into the wind if that is what she was attempting to do. In light of this, the protest committee found A had fouled B and disqualified A from that race. This was either a case of A tacking too close or attempting to force B to a head to wind course but not allowing B sufficient time to respond. Either way, the protest committee finds that A fouled B. The protest committee found it very likely that A was in fact attempting to tack, since she needed to get over to the port side of the buoy fairly soon to be able to round it properly.
Much discussion ensued, as other sailors suggested that A might have been within 2 lengths of the mark and should have been entitled to buoy room. There is a problem with this theory. First, A did not hail asking for room and second, rule 18.2

"If there is reasonable doubt that a boat obtained or broke an overlap in time,
it shall be presumed that she did not"
There is reasonable doubt in the mind of the protest committee that A was within 2 boat lengths of the windward mark, and that an overlap existed, so I presume that she had no right to buoy room.
The moral of the story: approaching the windward mark on starboard you may find it difficult to execute a tack onto port without getting in some difficulty as other boats on starboard converge on the mark and are not interested in letting you pass in front of them. Being stuck inside and needing to tack onto port soon may require you to go BEHIND starboard tack boats, and lose some position. You need to clearly establish overlap and bouy room if you are going to claim it. There are some bad spots that you can get into on the course, and A appeared to have gotten into one of those. Some hailing asking for room or telling the other boat to head up into the wind might have helped A's case, but none of that was in evidence.
A clear awareness of relative position is vital, and I try to keep an eye on where the boats behind me. For instance, Case 15 states:
"In tacking to round a mark, a boat clear ahead must comply with
rule 13; a close hauled boat clear astern is entitled to hold
her course and thereby prevent the other from tacking"
There are scenarios on the race course where you can gain advantage even when behind by holding your course and preventing the boat ahead from going where they want to go, and that is fair and expected behavior, at least in the circles I sailed in in RL. Some interesting ideas for how the real pros use the rules to their advantage may be found here:
http://www.aboutvalencia.com/valencia/amcuprules.asp
see you on the water...
raw results:
Pixeleen withdraws
You: +results
Start Line (2 Way): Race Results:
Start Line (2 Way): 1: Pacifien Massiel - +00:02:26
Start Line (2 Way): 2: Oliphant Ming - +00:02:35
Start Line (2 Way): 3: skippy Spatula - +00:02:40
Start Line (2 Way): 4: Pixeleen Mistral - +00:02:54
Start Line (2 Way): 5: Static Sprocket - +00:02:56
Start Line (2 Way): 6: Sifu Luan - +00:02:58
Start Line (2 Way): 7: Theodore Polonsky - +00:03:21
Start Line (2 Way): Lap Times:
Start Line (2 Way): Theodore Polonsky-- lap 0: +00:00:07
Start Line (2 Way): Pacifien Massiel-- lap 0: +00:00:16
Start Line (2 Way): Pixeleen Mistral-- lap 0: +00:00:19
Start Line (2 Way): Oliphant Ming-- lap 0: +00:00:20
Start Line (2 Way): Static Sprocket-- lap 0: +00:00:22
Start Line (2 Way): skippy Spatula-- lap 0: +00:00:26
Start Line (2 Way): Tanya Ayoob-- lap 0: +00:00:27
Start Line (2 Way): Sifu Luan-- lap 0: +00:00:34
Start Line (2 Way): Pacifien Massiel-- lap 1: +00:02:26
Start Line (2 Way): Oliphant Ming-- lap 1: +00:02:35
Start Line (2 Way): skippy Spatula-- lap 1: +00:02:40
Start Line (2 Way): Pixeleen Mistral-- lap 1: +00:02:54
Start Line (2 Way): Static Sprocket-- lap 1: +00:02:56
Start Line (2 Way): Sifu Luan-- lap 1: +00:02:58
Start Line (2 Way): Theodore Polonsky-- lap 1: +00:03:21
skippy Spatula: lower
DSQ Sifu
You: +results
Start Line (2 Way): Race Results:
Start Line (2 Way): 1: Oliphant Ming - +00:02:50
Start Line (2 Way): 2: Sifu Luan - +00:02:56
Start Line (2 Way): 3: Static Sprocket - +00:03:01
Start Line (2 Way): 4: skippy Spatula - +00:03:03
Start Line (2 Way): 5: Pixeleen Mistral - +00:03:13
Start Line (2 Way): 6: Pacifien Massiel - +00:03:15
Start Line (2 Way): 7: Tanya Ayoob - +00:05:06
Start Line (2 Way): 8: Theodore Polonsky - +00:06:10
Start Line (2 Way): Lap Times:
Start Line (2 Way): Theodore Polonsky-- lap 0: +00:00:01
Start Line (2 Way): Sifu Luan-- lap 0: +00:00:03
Start Line (2 Way): skippy Spatula-- lap 0: +00:00:04
Start Line (2 Way): Pixeleen Mistral-- lap 0: +00:00:04
Start Line (2 Way): Oliphant Ming-- lap 0: +00:00:05
Start Line (2 Way): Static Sprocket-- lap 0: +00:00:09
Start Line (2 Way): Pacifien Massiel-- lap 0: +00:00:18
Start Line (2 Way): Tanya Ayoob-- lap 0: +00:00:22
Start Line (2 Way): Oliphant Ming-- lap 1: +00:02:50
Start Line (2 Way): Sifu Luan-- lap 1: +00:02:56
Start Line (2 Way): Static Sprocket-- lap 1: +00:03:01
Start Line (2 Way): skippy Spatula-- lap 1: +00:03:03
Start Line (2 Way): Pixeleen Mistral-- lap 1: +00:03:13
Start Line (2 Way): Pacifien Massiel-- lap 1: +00:03:15
Start Line (2 Way): Tanya Ayoob-- lap 1: +00:05:06
Start Line (2 Way): Theodore Polonsky-- lap 1: +00:06:10
You: +results
Start Line (2 Way): Race Results:
Start Line (2 Way): 1: Pacifien Massiel - +00:02:28
Start Line (2 Way): 2: Oliphant Ming - +00:02:37
Start Line (2 Way): 3: Static Sprocket - +00:02:39
Start Line (2 Way): 4: Sifu Luan - +00:02:44
Start Line (2 Way): 5: Pixeleen Mistral - +00:02:52
Start Line (2 Way): 6: skippy Spatula - +00:03:01
Start Line (2 Way): 7: Theodore Polonsky - +00:03:22
Start Line (2 Way): Lap Times:
Start Line (2 Way): Pacifien Massiel-- lap 0: +00:00:06
Start Line (2 Way): Theodore Polonsky-- lap 0: +00:00:06
Start Line (2 Way): Sifu Luan-- lap 0: +00:00:09
Start Line (2 Way): Oliphant Ming-- lap 0: +00:00:11
Start Line (2 Way): Pixeleen Mistral-- lap 0: +00:00:13
Start Line (2 Way): Static Sprocket-- lap 0: +00:00:17
Start Line (2 Way): skippy Spatula-- lap 0: +00:00:29
Start Line (2 Way): Pacifien Massiel-- lap 1: +00:02:28
Start Line (2 Way): Oliphant Ming-- lap 1: +00:02:37
Start Line (2 Way): Static Sprocket-- lap 1: +00:02:39
Start Line (2 Way): Sifu Luan-- lap 1: +00:02:44
Start Line (2 Way): Pixeleen Mistral-- lap 1: +00:02:52
Start Line (2 Way): skippy Spatula-- lap 1: +00:03:01
Start Line (2 Way): Theodore Polonsky-- lap 1: +00:03:22
You: +results
Start Line (2 Way): Race Results:
Start Line (2 Way): 1: Static Sprocket - +00:02:43
Start Line (2 Way): 2: Sifu Luan - +00:02:43
Start Line (2 Way): 3: skippy Spatula - +00:02:57
Start Line (2 Way): 4: Oliphant Ming - +00:02:58
Start Line (2 Way): 5: Pixeleen Mistral - +00:02:59
Start Line (2 Way): 6: Theodore Polonsky - +00:03:15
Start Line (2 Way): Lap Times:
Start Line (2 Way): Theodore Polonsky-- lap 0: +00:00:00
Start Line (2 Way): Oliphant Ming-- lap 0: +00:00:03
Start Line (2 Way): Sifu Luan-- lap 0: +00:00:05
Start Line (2 Way): Static Sprocket-- lap 0: +00:00:08
Start Line (2 Way): skippy Spatula-- lap 0: +00:00:11
Start Line (2 Way): Pixeleen Mistral-- lap 0: +00:00:17
Start Line (2 Way): Pacifien Massiel-- lap 0: +00:00:17
Start Line (2 Way): Static Sprocket-- lap 1: +00:02:43
Start Line (2 Way): Sifu Luan-- lap 1: +00:02:43
Start Line (2 Way): skippy Spatula-- lap 1: +00:02:57
Start Line (2 Way): Oliphant Ming-- lap 1: +00:02:58
Start Line (2 Way): Pixeleen Mistral-- lap 1: +00:02:59
Start Line (2 Way): Theodore Polonsky-- lap 1: +00:03:15
You: +results
Start Line (2 Way): Race Results:
Start Line (2 Way): 1: Oliphant Ming - +00:03:00
Start Line (2 Way): 2: Static Sprocket - +00:03:01
Start Line (2 Way): 3: Pixeleen Mistral - +00:03:04
Start Line (2 Way): 4: Sifu Luan - +00:03:09
Start Line (2 Way): 5: skippy Spatula - +00:03:22
Start Line (2 Way): 6: Theodore Polonsky - +00:03:33
Start Line (2 Way): Lap Times:
Start Line (2 Way): Pixeleen Mistral-- lap 0: +00:00:00
Start Line (2 Way): Static Sprocket-- lap 0: +00:00:03
Start Line (2 Way): Oliphant Ming-- lap 0: +00:00:06
Start Line (2 Way): Pacifien Massiel-- lap 0: +00:00:17
Start Line (2 Way): Sifu Luan-- lap 0: +00:00:22
Start Line (2 Way): skippy Spatula-- lap 0: +00:00:24
Start Line (2 Way): Theodore Polonsky-- lap 0: +00:00:56
Start Line (2 Way): Oliphant Ming-- lap 1: +00:03:00
Start Line (2 Way): Static Sprocket-- lap 1: +00:03:01
Start Line (2 Way): Pixeleen Mistral-- lap 1: +00:03:04
Start Line (2 Way): Sifu Luan-- lap 1: +00:03:09
Start Line (2 Way): skippy Spatula-- lap 1: +00:03:22
Start Line (2 Way): Theodore Polonsky-- lap 1: +00:03:33
You: +results
Start Line (2 Way): Race Results:
Start Line (2 Way): 1: Oliphant Ming - +00:09:38
Start Line (2 Way): 2: Sifu Luan - +00:09:59
Start Line (2 Way): 3: Pixeleen Mistral - +00:10:05
Start Line (2 Way): 4: skippy Spatula - +00:10:12
Start Line (2 Way): Lap Times:
Start Line (2 Way): Static Sprocket-- lap 0: +00:00:01
Start Line (2 Way): Oliphant Ming-- lap 0: +00:00:02
Start Line (2 Way): Sifu Luan-- lap 0: +00:00:06
Start Line (2 Way): skippy Spatula-- lap 0: +00:00:08
Start Line (2 Way): Pixeleen Mistral-- lap 0: +00:00:09
Start Line (2 Way): Theodore Polonsky-- lap 0: +00:00:22
Start Line (2 Way): Oliphant Ming-- lap 1: +00:09:38
Start Line (2 Way): Sifu Luan-- lap 1: +00:09:59
Start Line (2 Way): Pixeleen Mistral-- lap 1: +00:10:05
Start Line (2 Way): skippy Spatula-- lap 1: +00:10:12
You: +results
Start Line (2 Way): Race Results:
Start Line (2 Way): 1: Static Sprocket - +00:15:07
Start Line (2 Way): 2: Oliphant Ming - +00:15:55
Start Line (2 Way): 3: Pixeleen Mistral - +00:16:01
Start Line (2 Way): 4: skippy Spatula - +00:17:06
Start Line (2 Way): Lap Times:
Start Line (2 Way): Pixeleen Mistral-- lap 0: +00:00:03
Start Line (2 Way): Static Sprocket-- lap 0: +00:00:04
Start Line (2 Way): Oliphant Ming-- lap 0: +00:00:09
Start Line (2 Way): skippy Spatula-- lap 0: +00:00:11
Start Line (2 Way): Static Sprocket-- lap 1: +00:15:07
Start Line (2 Way): Oliphant Ming-- lap 1: +00:15:55
Start Line (2 Way): Pixeleen Mistral-- lap 1: +00:16:01
Start Line (2 Way): skippy Spatula-- lap 1: +00:17:06