Welcome to the Second Life Forums Archive

These forums are CLOSED. Please visit the new forums HERE

Could SL ever make you go this far?

Aleister Montgomery
Minding the gap
Join date: 30 Apr 2006
Posts: 846
07-15-2007 20:54
From: Brenda Archer
When members of the community of abuse survivors try to speak up, there is always a chorus of people willing to blame and demonize the victims.

Our society still thinks children are property. I'll never forget the day I saw someone abusing a child on the bus and gave her a concerned angry look - only to find every other person on the bus turned toward me with a look as if to say, "Say anything about this and you're toast."

Most people think there is no abuse, only discipline, and all discipline is justified to them, no matter how permanently injurious it is to the child. They don't seem to be able to make a connection in their minds between the future damaged adult and the present child, who has no rights to them.


Amen to that. It's time that we apply the same human rights to children that we grant to adults.

But it's not only physical "discipline" (=abuse). We should also do something about people who mess with the gullible minds of children and turn them into delusional, superstitious and religious copies of themselves.
It's quite hard to deconvert from a delusional world-view that has been imprinted and indoctrinated into one's mind from an early age. Some never manage to think rational again and live their whole lives with a damaged self-perception ("I'm a sinful worm, only my invisible 'soul' matters";) and the dangerous notion that their physical lives are unimportant because they're in for something better afterwards.

People with the paranoid belief that there's an invisible devil out to get their soul, with unwitting servants in human shape, and a guy with a long white beard who keeps a checklist on their behaviour and might punish them for following their natural urges – those people were just as messed up during their childhood as a person who suffers from the consequences of physical abuse. Being raised in a paranoid state of mind is something that can never be completely repaired.
_____________________
Gentlemen, you can't fight in here! This is the War Room.
Broken Xeno
~Fething Alt~
Join date: 9 Mar 2007
Posts: 632
07-15-2007 21:28
I'm not going to get into a huge arguement about whether or not internet/gaming addictions are diseases, though I will say for a long time my family thought I was. But I am perfectly fine with leaving games for lengthy periods of time, which I have, including SL.

What those two parents did was horrific, and an addiction isn't justified. They had to feed themselves, to keep playing. They couldn't take the extra time needed to feed their kids? Yeah, no. They probably have other mental and social problems outside of just being addicted to video games.
_____________________
Ace Albion
Registered User
Join date: 21 Oct 2005
Posts: 866
07-16-2007 03:51
One of the things I like about SL, is how easy it is to step away from. I might spend hours in-world on a weekend, building or chatting, but there isn't any pressure to stay there. I don't like to be forced to sit at the computer the way some people feel they are with their gaming guilds expecting them to be there for the rest of the group to do whatever.

I like to "AFK" for coffee, or even just keep half an eye on SL while doing other things. It doesn't need my full attention, and that's something that differentiates it particularly from all those competitive games.
_____________________
Ace's Spaces! at Deco (147, 148, 24)
ace.5pointstudio.com
Deira Llanfair
Deira to rhyme with Myra
Join date: 16 Oct 2006
Posts: 2,315
07-16-2007 05:04
From: Susie Boffin
The internet, online games etc etc do not cause child neglect. The last I heard the parents of the children cause it.



Absolutely! Internet gaming - in this case, a contributory cause of child neglect or an extreme form of self centredness? SL, MMORGs, Intenet etc, can be "addictive" - but this is a pseudo sort of addiction and nothing like that resulting from drug or alcohol dependency. Some people are more vulnerable to addictive behaviour traits for all sorts of reasons - but the most vulnerable of all are the infants who needed their parents care and protection.
_____________________
Deira :)
Must create animations for head-desk and palm-face!.
AWM Mars
Scarey Dude :¬)
Join date: 10 Apr 2004
Posts: 3,398
07-16-2007 05:04
Its the relevant part about escapism thats a diseases in human beings. Many things in life give us these if we 'choose' to take them, or are deemed required to maintain some form of hope/achievement.
So often with Internet related 'offences', it has become the new escape, the new way to ingnore failings in rl, the pressures, the dreams we always wanted. When they fail us, they are perhaps monumental enough, when added to rl failures or under achievements, that people are tipped over the edge.
Neglect of RL... well to different degrees, we all neglect something/someone to be on the internet playing out these fantasies.

Perhaps RL social intercourse has been swapped to using a keyboard or microphone? Shopping online swapped for actually interacting with other people?

This was never more exposed than in a recent sl related movie I watched, whereby a couple, married in both RL and SL, were actually playing out their real lives within sl for over 14 hours everyday, they went to parties, had sex, laid on the beach, dressed up a home and virtually every amenity of their desire, yet played not 3 feet from eachother in the same room. When they were shown as a RL couple, they seemed somewhat disfunctional and almost uneasy they actually had to speak verbally to eachother without using their keyboards or avatars.

The young couple in question on the posters link, were perhaps not too far from the couple I mentioned above, and as they had 2 children 11 months apart, indicates that the only part of the escapsim that is common between cases like this, was that the internet was involved. I remember video games, playstations, gameboys all being cited as 'diversities' to taking part in real life.

With the advent of VR coming closer everyday, and certainly on the minds/agendas of every 'futurist', will there come a time, when we see the same story, but the couple were immersed in a VR suits and their brains plugged into a super computer, where they slept, ate, had sex, shopped and even brought up a virtual family? At least RL children, perhaps won't become victims?
_____________________
*** Politeness is priceless when received, cost nothing to own or give, yet many cannot afford -

Why do you only see typo's AFTER you have clicked submit? **
http://www.wba-advertising.com
http://www.nex-core-mm.com
http://www.eml-entertainments.com
http://www.v-innovate.com
Brenda Connolly
Un United Avatar
Join date: 10 Jan 2007
Posts: 25,000
07-16-2007 05:07
From: Angelique LaFollette
~At a Tupperware party, one woman Stabbed another to death in an Ongoing dispute over resealable containers.


I've been trying for years to warn people about the evils of Tupperware, but no one would listen. Perhaps they will listen now.
_____________________
Don't you ever try to look behind my eyes. You don't want to know what they have seen.

http://brenda-connolly.blogspot.com
Pie Psaltery
runs w/scissors
Join date: 13 Jan 2004
Posts: 987
07-16-2007 06:46
Its so much easier to place the blame for your own actions upon external influences:

"I would never neglect my children... SL/EverQuest/WoW made me do it"

"I would never be that big of a jerk... I was drunk"

"I didn't mean to kill that woman... but she was trying to buy the last Fresh-As-Can-Be container set"

People of weak minds have been shrugging the blame for thier own actions since the beginning of time. It's not MMORPG's or alcohol or Tupperware that's to blame.

The things that makes me weep for humanity most is simply the more unsavoury aspects of basic Human Nature.
_____________________
Suzy Hazlehurst
Offensive Broad
Join date: 14 Oct 2006
Posts: 323
07-16-2007 08:04
Nothing and nobody has the power to 'make' anybody go that far. Only the persons themselves have any power to get this wrapped up in whatever they are doing, to the point of starving their own children.

Had it not been SL, it would have been some other excuse.
_____________________
No children, elderly or animals were harmed during the creation of my second life.
Caete Chevalier
TOC Resident Neko
Join date: 8 Jan 2007
Posts: 118
07-16-2007 09:53
From: Suzy Hazlehurst
Nothing and nobody has the power to 'make' anybody go that far. Only the persons themselves have any power to get this wrapped up in whatever they are doing, to the point of starving their own children.

Had it not been SL, it would have been some other excuse.


Exactly!

The mindset of most of the world now is "it's not MY fault" and "someone else is to blame".

So few accept responsibilities for their own actions now days. Makes me sad to see fingers pointed at everyone BUT the one responsible.

When I was a guide for SOE, most of the responses I got when investigating griefers was "it wasn't me, my little brother was on my account". Damn scary how many people have little brothers who only get on a specific password/id secured program to cause grief, lol.

It is sad that some go so far into the addiction that others end up suffering. Yes, it will always happen as people are all different. Just a shame when help is ignored, or worse.
_____________________
CAeTe Chevalier

Future Crazy Cat Lady
Brenda Archer
Registered User
Join date: 28 Apr 2005
Posts: 557
07-17-2007 00:49
From: Aleister Montgomery
Amen to that. It's time that we apply the same human rights to children that we grant to adults.

But it's not only physical "discipline" (=abuse). We should also do something about people who mess with the gullible minds of children and turn them into delusional, superstitious and religious copies of themselves.
It's quite hard to deconvert from a delusional world-view that has been imprinted and indoctrinated into one's mind from an early age. Some never manage to think rational again and live their whole lives with a damaged self-perception ("I'm a sinful worm, only my invisible 'soul' matters";) and the dangerous notion that their physical lives are unimportant because they're in for something better afterwards.

People with the paranoid belief that there's an invisible devil out to get their soul, with unwitting servants in human shape, and a guy with a long white beard who keeps a checklist on their behaviour and might punish them for following their natural urges – those people were just as messed up during their childhood as a person who suffers from the consequences of physical abuse. Being raised in a paranoid state of mind is something that can never be completely repaired.


I fully agree. I also think there is a tendency for all kinds of abuse to be worse in families of this kind. When you have to appear righteous, it's impossible to ask for help or report any problems. The paranoid state of mind is paired with authoritarian attitudes that deny human worth, and justify selfishness in anyone with a little power over someone else.

To acknowledge human rights, you have to start by acknowledging that any human can have rights, but who can believe that a human has value, if they are so superstitious that they think humans are born evil?
_____________________
Angelique LaFollette
Registered User
Join date: 17 Jun 2004
Posts: 1,595
07-17-2007 14:34
From: Aleister Montgomery
I agree with everything you said, except for the part about alcoholism. Unlike obsessive behaviour and purely mental addictions to online games, gambling etc., alcoholism is a purely physical dependance which is simply caused by regular ingestion of alcohol.

I don't say that some alcoholics don't start out as an addictive personality who look for something to escape reality. But it can also hit an alcohol consumer without any psychological risk factors. Someone who merely drinks 2 bottles of beer each day. Or a glass of bourbon every evening.
The body gets used to the toxic substance over time and can't operate without the neurotoxin anymore. But in addition to the alcohol dependendance, the body also develops an alcohol tolerance and soon craves higher amounts.

Once someone reached that state, their psychological predisposition doesn't matter. They're physically addicted. Withdrawal of the neurotoxin will lead to (been there) a physical illness: fever-like symptoms like sweating and chill, stomach cramps, headaches, nausea, blurred vision, dizziness, sometimes circulatory breakdown, collapse, even cardiac arrest. Of course, the severity of the withdrawal symptoms depends on the amount of alcohol the body got used to.

This is nothing like the "withdrawal symptoms" of a game addict or an obsessive-compulsive person who desperetaly tries to withstand the urge to wash their hands for the 100th time. It's a physical malfunction that can have deadly consequences if it isn't treated with substitute drugs.
You can turn every living organism into an alcohol addict. Give a cat or dog a bowl of beer each day, and they will develop the same physical alcohol dependance.

As a former alcohol addict, I somehow understand that governments make the attempt to protect their citizens from highly addictive substances. Alas, they get it wrong and ban completely harmless drugs like cannabis, while alcohol is too established in our society and therefore tolerated.
Don't get me wrong, I'm a libertarian and totally against the prohibition of anything, toxic and addictive or not. If someone wants to ingest drain pipe cleaner, that's their decision. But there need to be warning labels on drain pipe cleaner and alcoholic drinks, plus sufficient education about the effects of drain pipe cleaner or alcohol on the human body.

I would agree with Some of what you say, and yet, The Withdrawl from Alchohol, like that from heroin, or Cigarettes Has a definate time frame, the Physical/Chemical dependance is broken after a term of Convelescence, HOWEVER, the psychological dependancy on Alchohol is among the strongest known, As any recovering Alchoholic will tell you, the Alchoholic Never gets over the desire, The Psychological Compulsion is with them for life. Whether this is an After effect of dependancy is debatable, But That is the End result, the BEGINNING is the same, the need, or the desire to ESCAPE What is it that says One person will Settle for a Galss of Wine Each day with Dinner, while the Other will eventually be Drinking Mouthwash, and Aftershave? There IS a Certain Psychological Disposition that drives the abuse. Some Compulsions Can be controlled, Some are more difficult, if not impossible to rein in. and whether one is Born with a Bit of bad Wiring, or whether Life has Damaged them in some Way the Compulsions exist.
It IS Possible that there will be recorded, a case of net addiction So severe that the Person Suffering it will need to eschew Ownership of Digital tech entirely in order to lead a Normal Life, if indeed in the early days of the 21st century in North America a life without any Digital toys can be Classified as normal.
How severe the compulsion is rests to a certain extent With the individual.
Have you Ever Seen an obsessive compulsive Trying to resist their compulsion? they Can become Physicaly Ill from doing so, the mental stress can be that severe. Do you ever become Mildly agitated or uneasy if you can't talk to friends on the net, or text message them, or do you Feel naked without your cell phone?
Whatever the compulsion, there IS something Chemical going on in your Cranium, Adrenaline, Endorphins, whatever, you DO form a Biochemical dependancy on things, and there Is Withdrawl. it just happens that the Toxic reaction of alchohol, heroin, Cocaine or Nicotine is more severe because the changes they wreak in your biochemistry are more radical than those of the chemicals produced by your own body. There is a Chemical Root there, but Psychology, and perhaps biochemical susceptability play a Big role in whether one becomes addicted, or How severe an addiction one faces, But it ends up being the same thing in the end.

Angel.

Angel.
Showdog Tiger
Registered User
Join date: 30 Nov 2005
Posts: 404
Puzzled by Fate
07-17-2007 15:20
Dearly Darlings,

Maneo and I could never have children so we have often borrowed others progeny to fill our parenting needs.

My dogs AND cats get a bath once a week, get their toenails does 4 times a week, get their teeth brushed daily...If I can find the time to get all this done and still be here in SL there is NO excuse of abuse. I hope you all have a lovely afternoon...I'm getting ready to watch TV with the floppy earred ones as Maneo is flying Home from NOLA. He hates to share the TV couch...but the wee ones deserve it!

Ever Yours,

Mrs. Showdog Tiger
_____________________
Dogdom Doge
1 2