Welcome to the Second Life Forums Archive

These forums are CLOSED. Please visit the new forums HERE

Get Rid of No Tranfer Option

Mirra Hathor
Reality Deviant
Join date: 4 Jul 2004
Posts: 160
05-14-2005 01:20
From: Kilmarac Drago
(snip) however, I dont understand how no transfer protects developer rights.

I can sell my used car, I can sell my used software, I can sell anything I buy to someone else. It doesnt hurt the people who made them. Im not trying to argue, I honestly would like to understand your point of view.


To use your example- when you sell a rl car, you cannot go out to your driveway & rez another copy & drive off or put a new for sale sign on the copy, can you? (Chevrolet etc would be out of business in about 10 minutes) You can't give the same single sweater to 6 different people, can you? (ditto Tommy Hillfiger) When setting permissions, an item can be no copy OR no transfer NOT both. Modify is completely independent of the other 2.

Selling items with open permissions will likely eventually land the item in a freebie box somewhere or, worse, resold by a greedy someone who bought a single copy & now has a cash cow if the item is good. Obviously, this undermines any compensation for the original artist. For the hours & love most of us put into creating lovely & well-detailed items, the profit-margin is narrow enough already.

A fair solution is for sellers to clearly state the permissions on an item in their shop or vendor. If its no transfer & you want to gift it out, contact the creator & ask him/her to lay one on your friend & let you pay for it. Most of us are happy enough to make the sale that we don't mind doing this small customer service for you. :)

In summary, I will sell it to you either copyable or transferrable, not both. Sorry, Hun.
Cocoa Bean
The Mad Hatter of SL
Join date: 7 May 2005
Posts: 12
For a reason...
05-14-2005 05:34
That's there for a reason though. Often times we want to make multiple copies of items in our inventory to put into multiple folders so that we can drop the folder right onto our avitars, and have it dress us completely, without having to go from folder to folder. Doing this copyable option would be a hazard to designers, if we all decided to just make unlimited copies and sell all their wares as our own. This is why no transfer is great, we give them the ability ( the buyer ) to have all the copies they want for all their folders without giving them the ability to sell it all out from under us as their own!

:)
Dragon Steele
Artist/conservationist
Join date: 3 Jan 2005
Posts: 183
05-15-2005 10:05
From: Kris Ritter
Absolutely positively categorically NO to this suggestion.

Even so called friends who I have given custom objects to have passed them on. Hell, in one case, I found one selling them.

And I sure as hell know I can't trust the rest.


Agreed. ;)
_____________________
Boycot the spam farms and the ads on them. Ban the spamers from your land. Look for the clocktower network for a blacklist to put on you land that is grid wide.
1 2