From: Peggy Paperdoll
Please explain why you spent 2/3 of your post devoted to disputing my use (or non use) of "cleaners"?
Here we go again. It wasn't about you, Peggy, so calm down. I didn't "dispute" you at all. The only thing I was trying to do was exactly what I said, dispel any potential confusion about whether CCleaner does the same thing as DriverCleaner, since drivers were the subject of the thread.
I never said that you were wrong to be using CCleaner, or that you were trying to confuse anyone, or anything of the kind. As I thought I made clear in my post, I've seen plenty of people in the past mistakenly assume that all programs with the word "cleaner" in their names do the same things, and I wanted to throw out a quick FYI to all readers that CCleaner is not a program that cleans up driver files. I can't imagine why you have such a problem with that.
As for why it happened to be "2/3 of the post", all I can say is that my post had two parts to it, and the second part happened to require more words for a thorough explanation than the first did. The first part was mostly a question, after all. The second part was more technical.
I'm not sure why you assign so much weight to the length of a post. Just because something takes longer to explain doesn't mean it's got any extra importance to it. If I were to write a post about how I like the smell of roses, and include in it a summary of the chemical reasons for why roses smell the way they do, chances are the chemistry part would take a lot longer to explain than the enjoyment part. But that doesn't mean I think the chemistry is more important than the enjoyment. Quite the opposite, in fact.
So relax. I wasn't trying to imply that you somehow demanded twice as much attention as poor Ricky who still hasn't gotten his driver to work. That kind of thinking never would have occurred to me. That's simply not how my mind works.
I realize post length is a hot button for you, and that you seem to delight in freaking out when I write anything beyond a certain length in any thread in which you've participated. But please realize, that's your own issue. It's got nothing to do with me. I'm sorry if you can't bring yourself to contain it.
From: Peggy Paperdoll
I put forth my opinions on programs like "driver cleaner"...........my freaking opinions (I didn't mention anyone's name).
I fail to see your point. Yes, you expressed your opinion. Great. What does mentioning anyone's name or not have to do with it?
Yes, I mentioned your name. BECAUSE I WAS RESPONDING TO SOMETHING YOU SAID. Is that a crime?
From: Peggy Paperdoll
I do not use programs that deal with my registry at the driver level. I use programs that I feel comfortable with..........and none of them aggressively delete or modify my registry. That is why I mentioned CCleaner if anyone feels the need to even think registry after an uninstallation.........it only finds the very (hear that? VERY) obvious registry entries that are no longer necessary. I'm quite well aquainted with what CCleaner does.........it's not designed for heavy duty registry clean ups.
Understood. None of that was in dispute.
From: Peggy Paperdoll
And my understanding of what Driver Cleaner does is a little different.........it specifically goes into the registry to find DRIVER registry entries after an uninstallation.
Yes, as I said, it looks for specific things, from a pre-existing list. If it finds them, it removes them. If they're not there, then it does nothing.
Some of the items on the list happen to be registry entries for driver files. If they're present, they're always in the same place, and DriverCleaner will find them in a matter of seconds. If they're not present, DriverCleaner simply won't do anything at all in the registry. It can't delete what's not there. Either way, it won't even look at any other parts of the registry besides the places where the driver related keys should be. So it's powerless to do any harm.
From: Peggy Paperdoll
Drivers, I'm quite sure you know, are a little more serious than DLL's or orphaned entries.
I can't agree with that. Even if a driver is absolute toast, it's not the end of the world. 99% of the time, you can still get into Safe Mode, and remove it. But If the registry is broken, there's a good chance you'll have no choice but to rebuild your system from scratch.
Given the choice of screwing up one or the other, I'd screw up the driver every time. The registry "ain't no joke", as they say. (Of course, I wouldn't screw up either one. I'm just saying.)
From: Peggy Paperdoll
Drivers can make your computer completely unusable if corrupted or damaged.
I'm not sure "comletely unusable" is the right choice of words. As I said, you should be able to get into Safe Mode, no matter what's going on with your drivers. That's what it's for.
But you're certainly right that a bad driver will make normal operation impossible, until it's been properly uninstalled and replaced. That's why DriverCleaner is so important. It's the only way I know of to ensure that drivers are properly uninstalled, so that they can be reinstalled cleanly.
Frankly I find your fear of it to be extremely puzzling. On the one hand, you know how disastrous bad driver installations can be. But on the other hand, you refuse to use the best possible tool to make sure your drivers will always be in perfect working order. How do you possibly reconcile that? It doesn't make a whole lot of sense.
From: Peggy Paperdoll
I happen to not want some third party program designed by some whiz kid digging into my registry and assuming something should be deleted.
First, it doesn't "dig". It looks for specific things only in specific locations. If you've got an nVidia driver on your system, you'll have certain nVidia keys in a certain place in the registry. If you've got an ATI driver, you'll have certain ATI keys in a certain place in the registry. If you've got a Creative driver, you'll have certain Creative keys in a certain place in the registry. The program knows where those keys have to be. It's not random at all. It only looks at what's on its list, nothing else.
If you want to be concerned about "digging", you've got a lot more to worry about with ANY general purpose registry cleaner, including CCleaner, than you could ever have with Driver Cleaner. It's not unheard of for registry cleaners to assume a key is orphaned when it's not, especially if your hard drive is heavily fragmented, and then you end up having to reinstall programs, or sometimes even reinstall the whole OS. It doesn't happen often, of course, but it does happen.
Heck, I had a registry cleaner kill my Acrobat installation once. It was a nightmare to fix. Eventually I got it to work by rolling back the computer to an earlier restore point, uninstalling the entire Adobe suite, and then reinstalling it. It didn't shake my faith in registry cleaners. On the whole, they do a lot more good than harm. But it did demonstrate quite clearly that they're not infallible. Had it been a Microsoft key instead of an Adobe key that got killed, I would have had to rebuild the whole hard drive. That really would have sucked.
DriverCleaner simply can't do that sort of thing. The worst thing it could possibly do is uninstall a driver unintentionally, due to the user selecting the wrong one when running it. For example you could inadvertently uninstall your Creative sound card driver because it's right next to ATI on the list, and you clicked on the wrong one. If something like that happens, you simply reinstall the driver, and there's no problem. It's not going to break the computer in any way, or interfere with any other programs, or anything like that. It's completely benign.
Second, regarding the "whiz kid" thing, who exactly do you think invented CCleaner? It wasn't handed down from God, I can assure you.
From: Peggy Paperdoll
I'll deal with a program not starting up because a program like CCleaner saw it as an orphaned entry...........I can get my computer booted to restore the last (or any) backup copy of my registry should that happen. If a program makes my computer unbootable because a similar miss reading of an entry.........quite a different story. I do not use. I do not like, and I'd never recommend a program that deletes anything in my registry dealing with drivers. You can do it all you want..........I will not endorse it.
Your decision, your loss. That's all I can really say.
From: Peggy Paperdoll
And, to be honest, it irks me when you so highly taut the program.
Peggy, why are you so obsessed with what I write? If my posts "irk" you, simply don't read them. I'm not going to stop recommending things I know work well, just because you feel the need to stalk me like this.
Really, this is starting to get disturbing. Please tell me I'm not going to walk into my kitchen tonight and find a rabbit boiling on the stove.
Come on, give it a rest already, will you?
From: Peggy Paperdoll
Just because you happen to think it's the greatest thing since the wheel does not make it a fact.
Let me get this straight. What you're saying is that when you spout your assumptions about something you've never used, that's OK because it's your opinion. But when I share my experiences with a program I actually HAVE used, that's not OK because my opinion isn't fact. So you have the right to opine, and I don't. Wow.
From: Peggy Paperdoll
Every (I repeat, EVERY program has a potential to fail or have a bug).
Sure. What's your point?
A couple weeks ago, an airplane fell on my neighbors. A few days ago, a large asteroid almost hit the Earth. A few months ago my brother in law almost died of an E-coli infection, after swimming in a pool that hadn't been treated properly. Crazy things happen all the time. But I don't sit around my house expecting every last thing to fail.
If you're so concerned about such things, why are you so comfortable with CCleaner? It's got a whole lot more potential to kill your system if it malfunctions than most other programs do, including DriverCleaner. Chances are it won't, of course. As I said, it is a good program. But it could.
So could Windows itself, for that matter.
Should anyone stop using it because it MIGHT one day malfunction out of the blue? Of course not. It's got a good track record of not doing bad things. So does DriverCleaner. Again, why you're so afraid of DriverCleaner, I really don't get. Sorry, but it makes zero sense.
From: Peggy Paperdoll
You know as well as I know, most people don't know what damage can be done with one little miss cue in the driver files.........yet you seem to enthusiatistically recommend a program that automatically "fixes" driver issues (or I should say, potential driver issues) after an uninstallation.
How can I put this in the simplest possible terms? The reason I recommend DriverCleaner is precisely BECAUSE of the potential damage you mentioned. The most common "miss cue", as you put it. is when leftover remnants of older drivers interfere with the successful installation of newer ones. In order to prevent that, you've got two options. One is to go through by hand, and remove every file and every registry entry by hand. But as you point out, most people wouldn't have the first clue how to do that, and the procedure is far from error-proof, even for those who do. It's a big risk to do that sort of thing by hand. So the other option is to use DriverCleaner, which automates the same exact process, so that people don't have to know how, and so that human error can't happen.
Why that doesn't make sense to you, I can't imagine.
From: Peggy Paperdoll
And then feel it's necessary to spend 2/3 or a rather long post devoted to telling people that what I said was foolish or misinformed in some way.
That's not what I said at all, Peggy. This obsession of yours is getting really pathetic. Please let it go.
From: Peggy Paperdoll
My method works,
Your method works for doing the things that CCleaner does. But driver cleanup is not one of those things. You want to talk general PC maintenance, great. Your method for that is not a bad one. But if you want to talk drivers, which is what this thread is about, your "method" is irrelevant.
From: Peggy Paperdoll
my method is safe
Well, it's "safe" until one of those dreaded malfunctions you mentioned earlier happens, right?
But yes, if I were a leftover driver file, looking to cause a malfunction with a newer driver, and I saw you running CCleaner, I'd feel pretty darned safe that you weren't gonna do anything to stop me.
From: Peggy Paperdoll
my method is recommended by most driver developers.
Sorry, but I can't help but laugh at that statement. Exactly how many driver developers have you talked to to arrive at that conclusion?
Want to know who first turned me on to DriverCleaner? I'll give you a hint. His job title rhymed with "shmoftware shmengineer", and he worked for a company that rhymened with "shminvidia".
From: Peggy Paperdoll
A simple uninstallation is safe. Yeah it could cause problems if something is left over in the driver files..........but it's very unlikely your system will become unusable. Your method and recommended way is riskier because if your program messes up it's very likely the user is in for a formating of the drive to "fix" it.
The chances that something could go wrong are so remote, they're not worth talking about. Honestly, I don't know where you get this stuff. Do you just make it up? Look, you've got a better chance of getting struck by lightning tomorrow than of having DriverCleaner damage your system in any way. Again, the only power it has is to delete a specific list of files, and a specific list of registry entries. It has no other function whatsoever. Your display of paranoia towards it is laughable at best, and certifiable at worst.
From: Peggy Paperdoll
Finding and fixing a driver unistallation problem is easier (you can still boot your system)...........just reinstall and uninstall once again.
No, if the problem is a bad uninstallation, then simply trying to uninstall again the same way won't fix it. Windows is almost never able to remove the offending files on its own. Add/Remove programs is nowhere near smart enough to handle it properly (despite years of complaints to Microsoft and requests for improvements). Again, the solutions are locate the problem files and keys by hand and delete them by hand without making any mistakes, or let DriverCleaner do its job. That's it.
From: Peggy Paperdoll
Do you have stock in the company that developes or distributes Driver Cleaner?
No. Do you have any in CCleaner?
ETA: Ricky, I'm sorry that this garbage has derailed your thread. I debated not responding to that last post, so as not to feed the troll, but in the end I decided it was better not to leave the questions hanging. There was a lot of misinformation in there, and I wanted to dispel the myths as best I could. I'm not sure if that was the right decision or not.
I'm still hoping we can find a solution to your problem. Please keep us informed of your progress.

I was sincere when I asked for more information on your friends' problems with DriverCleaner. I'd really like to hear what happened.