Welcome to the Second Life Forums Archive

These forums are CLOSED. Please visit the new forums HERE

Adults using ebonics.

Yiffy Yaffle
Purple SpiritWolf Mystic
Join date: 22 Oct 2004
Posts: 2,802
08-30-2006 13:32
I always make sure i type out a full legable sentance when i type anything (even live chat). Sometimes i make a typo, but that's a issue i can't really help. I've never been able to figure out the cause of them.
_____________________
nimrod Yaffle
Cavemen are people too...
Join date: 15 Nov 2004
Posts: 3,146
08-30-2006 13:33
From: Chronic Skronski
That is absolute bullshit. Why would someone want to sound like a complete idiot to save them approximately 1 second per paragraph (as if they would ever write a complete one anyway)? I don't buy this excuse whatsoever.

What if they're dyslexic, or english isn't their first language so they can't spell/type well?
_____________________
"People can cry much easier than they can change."
-James Baldwin
Jonas Pierterson
Dark Harlequin
Join date: 27 Dec 2005
Posts: 3,660
08-30-2006 13:43
Nimrod, the language issue was addressed first post. I'm dyslexic (badly) and try to type right still.

Personally anyone using chatspeak isn't worth my time to even bother listening to.
_____________________
Good freebies here and here

I must protest. I am not a merry man! - Warf, ST: TNG, episode: Qpid

You killed my father. Prepare to die. - Inigo Montoya, The Princess Bride

You killed My father. Your a-- is mine! - Hellboy
Carbon Breed
lol furry
Join date: 23 Jan 2006
Posts: 119
08-30-2006 13:51
From: Chronic Skronski
That is absolute bullshit. Why would someone want to sound like a complete idiot to save them approximately 1 second per paragraph (as if they would ever write a complete one anyway)? I don't buy this excuse whatsoever.


Well, you sorta have to. It's either that or you accept that it's the new socially 'cool' method of communication on the internet - which is the most likely answer. I mean, we have such wonderful foundations of word-butchery in our past already. AOL-speak. Leet-speek, etc. :\

On top of that, believe it or not - if you actually saw some of these people trying to type you might rethink your complaint on the shortcut issue. Hunt-and-peck seems to be more commonplace than it should be. I've seen people who do data-entry for a living do this, even.

This is, of course, all just my opinion - but as long as your actual conversation holds some merit, I could really care less if you take a shortcut here or there. Conversely, I really don't want to have to sit around and wait a minute and a half per fully-structured sentence if you're not fast enough, and/or properly taught to use a keyboard, for a response on a subject I may be itching to have a go at.

Take how you will, but - I prefer conversation, even when textual, to be quick enough as not to forget about what was being talked over, and to contain some intelligence. There are several ways to go about this. I'm not really that picky about it, and personally, I don't see why most others are.

That's just my numerical value of 2 out of 100, anyway. :3
Artemis Cain
Take it or Leave it
Join date: 11 Apr 2005
Posts: 116
08-30-2006 13:57
I mostly feel sorry for the people that use this form of communication.

As far as non-native english speaking residents, you can normally tell by their syntax that they do not use english as their first language. You have to respect that they at least give an effort to communicate in english. You cannot say "You are in America - Speak english!" because while the Linden Lab servers reside in America, a lot of residents that access them do not.

As far as the American users of this form of communication, you only serve to make yourself sound less educated, leave yourself open to mockery, and (In my opinion) completely invalidate anything point that you try to present.

The one thing that grates me more than anything is something like the following:

"your going too the store to?"
That is really irritating to read and makes me pity the composer of the line that much more.

Compare that to this:
"ur going 2 the store 2?"

I would prefer to read the latter.

just my L$22 or L$23

-Artemis
Chronic Skronski
SL Live Musician
Join date: 23 Jun 2006
Posts: 997
08-30-2006 14:00
From: nimrod Yaffle
What if they're dyslexic, or english isn't their first language so they can't spell/type well?

Not the same, this would be excusable. From what I can tell, this thread is about deliberate misspellings and l33t/gangsta speak. Why anyone would deliberately want to sound like an imbicile is beyond me, but I suppose I should ask myself the same question sometimes. ;)
_____________________
A man without religion is like a fish without a bicycle.
Bree Giffen
♥♣♦♠ Furrtune Hunter ♠♦♣♥
Join date: 22 Jun 2006
Posts: 2,715
08-30-2006 14:01
Did you guys know that when a large group of people from different countries come together they talk in English. However... they speak a kind of pidgin english that is actually quite hard to understand for people who speak english as their first language. The people using this modifed english actually understand each other better than a person trying to speak correct english. I think that people who type messages like, "Hay wats up?" are really just chattting in a simplified version of english that is understandable by a more global audience. I think more non-english speakers would be able to figure out "Hay wats up?" more than if I wrote "Hello, what is going on here?"

Sorry it does seem like I'm defending the retards but you really have to take into account that Second Life can reach a much more global audience and that the guy standing next to you in SL just might be from the other side of the world.
_____________________
Samia Perun
Registered User
Join date: 7 Sep 2005
Posts: 111
08-30-2006 14:04
I can tolerate it when people dont have English as a first language, or they are Dyslexic. Thats fair enough and at least they are -trying-.

Its when people who blatently can use full words write in stupid txtpsk or 1337 that really gets on my nerves. There is every key of the English language on the keyboard, I dont understand why people cant use them!
Chronic Skronski
SL Live Musician
Join date: 23 Jun 2006
Posts: 997
08-30-2006 14:07
From: Carbon Breed
This is, of course, all just my opinion - but as long as your actual conversation holds some merit, I could really care less if you take a shortcut here or there.

Oh, absolutely! I don't mind seeing things like "ppl" instead of "people" from time to time in an intelligent conversation, but when the person goes out of their way to misspell and abbreviate, chances are that the conversation is not going to be that intriguing to begin with. Yes, abbreviations are going to creep into conversations. I'll do it myself sometimes. But when the conversation consists of abbreviations and totally intentional misspellings, then it gets to be more like the problem I think the OP was getting at.
_____________________
A man without religion is like a fish without a bicycle.
Coyote Momiji
Pintsized Plutonium
Join date: 13 Aug 2006
Posts: 715
08-30-2006 14:07
I will occasionally type in 1337 to be funny. But I really, really detest the use of txtspk.

It took me a long time to get to the typing speed I am now (somewhere around scaryWPM), but I made the effort so I could keep up in text conversations.

If someone butchers my native language, I really don't have a lot of time for them.
_____________________
Slick - Intimate & Fetish Apparel
http://slurl.com/secondlife/William/97/176/23
Chronic Skronski
SL Live Musician
Join date: 23 Jun 2006
Posts: 997
08-30-2006 14:20
From: Bree Giffen
Did you guys know that when a large group of people from different countries come together they talk in English. However... they speak a kind of pidgin english that is actually quite hard to understand for people who speak english as their first language. The people using this modifed english actually understand each other better than a person trying to speak correct english. I think that people who type messages like, "Hay wats up?" are really just chattting in a simplified version of english that is understandable by a more global audience. I think more non-english speakers would be able to figure out "Hay wats up?" more than if I wrote "Hello, what is going on here?"

Sorry it does seem like I'm defending the retards but you really have to take into account that Second Life can reach a much more global audience and that the guy standing next to you in SL just might be from the other side of the world.

Many people who speak English as a second language are more literate than those educated in North America who know only English. There is no reason that "Hay wats up?" would be more easy to understand than "Hey, what's up?" and I see it for the most part being used between people who speak English as their first language. You do have very valid points, Bree, but I don't think that is what the OP was getting at.
_____________________
A man without religion is like a fish without a bicycle.
Madame Maracas
Not who you think I am...
Join date: 7 Jun 2004
Posts: 1,953
Why even bother with grammar & such?
08-30-2006 14:50
Most of the time, I make it a point of fully typing out most words and phrases, but I'll drop an acronym, or lol type thingie, etc. in there as well. I find that basically the point of annoyance is reached when I find that deciphering the jargon that is being presented is more tedious and time-consuming to "translate" than a more straight-forward typing out of whatever the speaker meant to say. That's when I generally start to get irritated.

733t speak and gangsta and any other verbal "dialect" for lack of a better term tend to have their purposes. In a homogeneous group, use of jargon or lingo does speed communication, as everyone in the conversation is familiar with the terms and codes, so in that instance it has a purpose that is reasonable and useful.

In a mixed background group, the use of these terms (from whichever lingo bucket you care to pull from) can be seen as a mini-power play. By controlling information, one expresses power. Forcing others in the conversation to ask for translation and/or assistance tips the table, socially.

The thought I have in mind, often is, based upon an experience in college (not band camp, no flute, sorry) when I worked in the Media Center (yes I'm a geek). I noticed that a number of foreign exchange students came in and watched movies, and in speaking with them casually, I learned it wasn't particularly for class, but to help them with their English. One fellow, from mainland China (and this was 1983 - 86 I don't recall when this happened more distinctly), was having a very tough time of it.

He was told to watch British films, not ones in standard American English, and he couldn't bridge the accent gap between what he heard in from folks right there with him, and the actors in the movies, it was too different for him to understand. I set him up with a list of films in standard, not heavily accented American English, and he did much better.

How does that relate to typed text in SL? Well folks that are non-native speakers of English have often learned what I call "book English", which doesn't include a ton of slang or lingo. They've not mastered the shortcuts of native speakers, much less the idiosyncrasies of US (as the predominance of the SL population is in the US) English. So I figure it's easier for them to join in and participate if they can actually follow the conversation.

As far as age = better English, I've made that error before. I can't say that if I meet someone that seems to be allergic to full words and sentences, that I won't guess they're under, say 24 or so, but I'll wait and see if they really are or not. I've met 50 year old (well they said they were and as we all know, shrug, we DON'T know for sure) language butcherers and 19 year olds that are quite eloquent.

Lead by example I say.

Maybe they've not learned proper English or even a semblance of it. It's just possible that SL might save them from a morass of linguistic offal.

A girl can dream. ;)
_____________________
RadioRadio - http://radioradiosl.com

M 6 Hobbes Abattoir
T 7 Sezmra Svorag
W 4 Brian Mason
W 6 Moira Stern
W 8 Nala Galatea
Th 6 Chet Neurocam
F 6 Vertigo Paris
F 9 Madame Maracas
S 5 Madame Maracas
S 8 TriNala
Su 6 Trinity Serpentine

http://madamemaracas.wordpress.com - Madame Maracas Blaaagh

Plurk - http://www.plurk.com/user/MadameMaracas
Scenic Everidge
Registered User
Join date: 4 Aug 2006
Posts: 5
08-30-2006 14:50
From: Richie Waves
Though I agree overuse of it can be annoying, I find the tone of the OP a hell of a lot more annoying than any AOL speak I encounter...

by the way... the logic in "stupidity is spreading to adults" is retarded..


I'm in complete agreement. For anyone to protest online/cell/shorthand and actually confuse it with AAVE is in it's own way quite amusing. I would think one would at least be able to accurately identify the language they are so frustrated with. The tone of the OP was indignant ignorance. I guess if the OP is receiving such a large volume of abbreviated text in communications with friends on SL, it's more indicative of the company kept than anything else. If you don't like how your friends are abbreviating, don't waste time telling a bunch of other people on a thread where your friends may likely never get the hint--but rather just tell them you don't like it. I mean, is reading words and abbreviations like "OP" and "Wb" such a big deal in the grand scheme of things? If so, then perhaps talking online isn't the best use of time because for the most part, that is exactly how people speak. It's just a time saver...and it's not friggen Ebonics. Get a dictionary! As someone else noted, this is one place where people venture from all walks of life and all regions of the world. Txt speak and acronyms are pretty universal and make communicating that much easier. It's just not a big deal.
Scenic Everidge
Registered User
Join date: 4 Aug 2006
Posts: 5
08-30-2006 14:54
From: Chronic Skronski
Not the same, this would be excusable. From what I can tell, this thread is about deliberate misspellings and l33t/gangsta speak. Why anyone would deliberately want to sound like an imbicile is beyond me, but I suppose I should ask myself the same question sometimes. ;)

What exactly is "gangsta" speak and why do you find it so annoying? Again, if your friends online are all speaking this way, it may be a red flag about the company you keep. Just don't confuse Ebonics with a lingo or "speak", it's a venacular as any other and every bit as legitimate as any other. But to sound like an imbilcile doesn't require any misspellings, lingo or use of any other venacular...as has clearly been demonstrated.
Jaycatt Nico
Musical Cat
Join date: 1 Jun 2005
Posts: 169
08-30-2006 14:57
If only text adventures were still around. That's how I learned to type :D

It doesn't matter that I never used the words much outside of the game: just having to hunt for "shillelagh" in order to drop it or attack with it got me to remember where the keys were when looking for more popular words.

I ended up with my own method of touch-typing that doesn't really use the pinky finger. Six years later, when I attempted to learn to touch-type in a classroom, I just couldn't do it.

Practice makes perfect... Since the mouse and the GUI, maybe we've just had less practice than before.
Raindrop Drinkwater
Globally Creative
Join date: 28 Jun 2006
Posts: 240
08-30-2006 15:02
From: Bree Giffen
Did you guys know that when a large group of people from different countries come together they talk in English. However... they speak a kind of pidgin english that is actually quite hard to understand for people who speak english as their first language. The people using this modifed english actually understand each other better than a person trying to speak correct english. I think that people who type messages like, "Hay wats up?" are really just chattting in a simplified version of english that is understandable by a more global audience. I think more non-english speakers would be able to figure out "Hay wats up?" more than if I wrote "Hello, what is going on here?"


*Waves from the other side of the world.*
I partly disagree :D I find it much easier to understand a well-written, grammatically correct post/chat over a leetspeak one, because that's the English I learned. But yes, I use and understand the pidgin you're talking about, mainly with Spanish people. I've noticed we tend to use our respective grammar structures and colloquialisms and translate them directly into English. It is a simplified version of English, but it doesn't compare to leetspeak or, worse, gangsta-speak at all. (Leetspeak, most of the time, I can make out the meaning of. Gangsta-speak? Forget it.)

In short: leetspeak makes it harder to understand for anyone who doesn't know that particular way of talking. Pidgin, on the other hand, is useful to bridge the gap between those who share a similar grammar, but not the same vocabulary.
Chronic Skronski
SL Live Musician
Join date: 23 Jun 2006
Posts: 997
08-30-2006 15:04
From: Scenic Everidge
What exactly is "gangsta" speak and why do you find it so annoying? Again, if your friends online are all speaking this way, it may be a red flag about the company you keep. Just don't confuse Ebonics with a lingo or "speak", it's a venacular as any other and every bit as legitimate as any other. But to sound like an imbilcile doesn't require any misspellings, lingo or use of any other venacular...as has clearly been demonstrated.

I am not confusing ebonics with l33tsp33k, the OP was. They are definitely not the same. None of my friends online "sp33k like dis yo", as I tend to choose friends who can carry on an intelligent conversation. There is no need to get testy with me, we're having a civil discussion here.
_____________________
A man without religion is like a fish without a bicycle.
Otaku Farrell
Member
Join date: 1 Jul 2006
Posts: 51
08-30-2006 16:08
From: Jesse Malthus
Personaly, I don't mind 'u', etc, as long as the person is making sense and not just being plain STUPID.
I try my hardest to type as quickly and accuratly as possible, but sometimes it just doesn't work.
(Oh, BTW, I'm doing a research paper on teh Interwubs and Language, does anyone I refrence this thread/your post?)


Go for it, include my (fake) name. :D
Angelique LaFollette
Registered User
Join date: 17 Jun 2004
Posts: 1,595
08-30-2006 19:04
From: Samia Perun
I can tolerate it when people dont have English as a first language, or they are Dyslexic. Thats fair enough and at least they are -trying-.

Its when people who blatently can use full words write in stupid txtpsk or 1337 that really gets on my nerves. There is every key of the English language on the keyboard, I dont understand why people cant use them!


Thank you for your tolerance, I actually fall into both catagories that you mention. Having said that, I have spent years learning to express myself Clearly in English and i am also very tolerant of people for whom English is a second language.

At all costs i avoid the dialect called Ebonics, I also only occasionally use internet speak (Afk, BRB, Rofl. That is about as far as i go with that lot.). I have to say though that some of you seem to have confused the two. Internet abbreviations are NOT Ebonics. Ebonics is the name given to the manner of speech of inner city African Americans (Primarily, but not excluding whites and Hispanics from the same environment).
Most of the problem with either form of communication is that there are a great many people who have difficulty deciphering the meaning of Phrases rendered in either dialect. I have no such problem Myself. I have my own opinions about Ebonics, but i won't discuss those here because they are not germain to the discussion. None of us here posting speaks English perfectly, Nor do we type it so.
People point out that i Cap in odd places (Usually when they find they cannot argue with the content of my posts, they attack the Form) But when i have explained my reasons for doing so They find it reasonable, AND one thing is for certain, you always know when it's ME posting. Lol.
I Digress.
In any case, None of us speak, or type Perfect English and we frequently have to wade through a sea of Misspellings, poor grammar, and disasterous punctuation all perpetrated by those for whom English is the Primary language, so i Don't see the perticular reason for controversy over either Ebonics or Internet speak when used on the net. I take care to Read and Understand what people are saying so the delay in translating Any of the above isn't a hinderance to my Understanding.
If i can do it,(And remember i'm both dyslexic, and not a native English speaker) then why can't the rest of you?

Angel
Cherry Czervik
Came To Her Senses
Join date: 18 Feb 2006
Posts: 3,680
08-30-2006 19:40
From: Siobhan Taylor
Would you have preferred Latin, or British?


No such language as British - but points for the Chaucer :)

Also the thing about modern English being a dumbed down form of Anglo-Saxon - not really. I doubt the lexicon of the times had as much to cope with. I am prepared to revise this when someone finds an ancient scroll which shows how to set up a satellite dish on a longboat or something.

Sorry, but I am admitting that if someone approaches me and says 'wots up' as their greeting I am not expecting a meeting of the minds. I'm a sucker for brains ... talk to me the right way and I am a little purring kitten :) Doesn't have to be in perfect English either, a lot of my friends don't have English as their first language but I know the intention behind what is said is not 'wots up'.
Cherry Czervik
Came To Her Senses
Join date: 18 Feb 2006
Posts: 3,680
08-30-2006 19:48
From: Chronic Skronski
Oh, absolutely! I don't mind seeing things like "ppl" instead of "people" from time to time in an intelligent conversation, but when the person goes out of their way to misspell and abbreviate, chances are that the conversation is not going to be that intriguing to begin with. Yes, abbreviations are going to creep into conversations. I'll do it myself sometimes. But when the conversation consists of abbreviations and totally intentional misspellings, then it gets to be more like the problem I think the OP was getting at.


Also ... never underestimate the power of a cordless keyboard with dodgy batteries when coupled with massive lag and a fairly fast typist who is used to being able to correct mistakes and then carry on typing and hitting the return. Some of the things I have sent out into the world recently have been bearly readable - good job my friends can see when I am typing on MSN instead of SL on a bad day ... or else they would think I alys wut seointe WTF THE LG :/ cntt p

(Yes I know you can't understand that ... but that is what has come out when under heavy lag recently - usually leaving me mashing the keyboard with my fists in frustration - and probably typing far more sense that way :D)
Otaku Farrell
Member
Join date: 1 Jul 2006
Posts: 51
08-30-2006 20:02
From: Scenic Everidge
I'm in complete agreement. For anyone to protest online/cell/shorthand and actually confuse it with AAVE is in it's own way quite amusing. I would think one would at least be able to accurately identify the language they are so frustrated with. The tone of the OP was indignant ignorance. I guess if the OP is receiving such a large volume of abbreviated text in communications with friends on SL, it's more indicative of the company kept than anything else. If you don't like how your friends are abbreviating, don't waste time telling a bunch of other people on a thread where your friends may likely never get the hint--but rather just tell them you don't like it. I mean, is reading words and abbreviations like "OP" and "Wb" such a big deal in the grand scheme of things? If so, then perhaps talking online isn't the best use of time because for the most part, that is exactly how people speak. It's just a time saver...and it's not friggen Ebonics. Get a dictionary! As someone else noted, this is one place where people venture from all walks of life and all regions of the world. Txt speak and acronyms are pretty universal and make communicating that much easier. It's just not a big deal.


The people I talk with are intelligent, SL is just filled with stupid people, and you can't ignore stupid for long.
Bree Giffen
♥♣♦♠ Furrtune Hunter ♠♦♣♥
Join date: 22 Jun 2006
Posts: 2,715
08-30-2006 20:07
I guess there is a difference between leetspeak and pidgin english. If the OP was ranting about leetspeak then I'd have to agree with him. It is annoying and I think less of a person who chats that way but I wouldn't treat them any differently.
_____________________
Otaku Farrell
Member
Join date: 1 Jul 2006
Posts: 51
08-30-2006 20:11
From: Bree Giffen
I guess there is a difference between leetspeak and pidgin english. If the OP was ranting about leetspeak then I'd have to agree with him. It is annoying and I think less of a person who chats that way but I wouldn't treat them any differently.


Mostly 'gangsta'. 1337speak isn't so much of a problem for me, I basically learned to type from playing Half-Life,DOOM etc..Hehe. :)
Cottonteil Muromachi
Abominable
Join date: 2 Mar 2005
Posts: 1,071
08-30-2006 23:08
I can't stand the sight of serif fonts! AARGH, they're so irritating.
1 2 3