From: Rhynalae Eldrich
Hmmm. And I suppose you have the corner on the market
I think it's interesting how you put something like market and social behaviour into one sentence. Its about people... not about business and also not about any corner.
From: someone
of being introverted and can speak so broadly for everyone concerned?
"Well, that might work for some people. But I think others do need the "forced" experience of being assigned a group, so everyone feels they are in the same boat and that they all have "permission" to talk to each other.
(Social introverts really need a context where they feel comfortable speaking to complete strangers. Otherwise they usually end up waiting for someone to talk to them first... which could be a long time in coming.)"
I speak insofar broadly that the most basic promiss of SL is freedom. And any *forced* experience beyond the absolut basics to get used to the sl client and its behaviour and posibilities is a break of this promiss.
And even if this experience of being group social had been offered during creation of ones account... would you have accepted it? There was (at least for me) the offer of having a greeter... but do there exist working offers beyond that for new residents? And would you have accepted those... or how can people who need that be recognized by a software for an account signup... and be forced to choose that? Any answers that are not guesswork?
I don't know what you expect from the foundation of the sl world. To sort out ones own personal social behaviour that already exists for the person in rl? I have high doubts that this will work.
From: someone
I thought I was clear that I was talking simply about how to meet people with this "group" idea, and NOT how people actually had to spend their time when in-world.
There are already lots of groups of similar interest. Easy to join the ones of topic specific interest. Unfortunately not every group really works...
I am in a german furry group and it is my best group experience so far. I consciously decided against the mainstream german group around the Dreamland community "Die Insel" as I believe that minorities are far more interesting and tollerant than others.
From: someone
No one will be telling you what to do. No one is "ignorant" or "crappy" enough to force you to be social with people you don't care for. (That WOULD be "ignorant" and "crappy."
The quote I reacted to was different. You said something about a forced social experience... for some people. Who are these? Do they already have to know themselves that they want to be forced? And to what? Joining a group of people who are also new. Does this really help new people in a way to go on the freebie hunt and sort out 90 percent junk from the junkyard or what?
I was in a big group with regular traffic (but no personal meetings)... and I left it disappointed. The traffic gave no real benefit to me even if I was interested in the topic. Other topic bound groups might be more useful.
So my group experience is mixed. And a new resident group has to organize them also in a way to make it work.
From: someone
I was envisioning simply a list of people who came in-world when you did -- a group that you would at least feel "permission" to interact with, and a group you happen to have something in common with at that time, since you're new.
I am not sure if this feeling of "permission" works for a longer time.
This seems to me like psychological trickery... and as most psychological stuff isn't really proven... I have my doubts.
I think that all residents have in general a lot of *social* permissions. And if one thinks not to have them... well... it's only in the persons head.
From: someone
Pretty simply, pretty basic, maybe pretty useless to you, but you would be surprised at how many people need that "feeling of permission" in order to do what amounts to feeling like you're "intruding" into someone else's space.
I just can repeat myself. This permission thing exists only in the head of the people who are pertained by it. The basic concept of sl is plenty of freedom and lots of anonymity. And that includes these permissions to state whatever one wants, anytime, everywhere including stuff like "Impeach Bush"... one has to deal with the reaction of the others (e.g. the group).
And it is speculative if a group of new residents is really better with that... as they have all sorts of backgrounds, already learned knowledge of creation and building elsewhere, plenty of other online gaming experience or more time to spent in-world to experience more and develop faster...
But I have seen a group of shy people and a group especially founded to overcome this as well. You see that these are specific offers to help overcome this...
My point is: Preserve the freedom of new people and provide offers for better overall integration and development paths for them, especially those who come here curious but don't want to commit right from the start.
And no... this shouldn't be a business or a market in the first kind.