Help needed with odd problem

I'm trying to create an object that will hand out a notecard. I have one object that does this already. If I rezz it from Inventory, it works fine.

If I create a new object, add the same script and a notecard to it, and then try it, nothing is given. It does, however, display the float text. In chat, I see a message that I'm declining the notecard, yet the other object works fine.

What causes me to accept Inventory from an object and where/how do I control that?

Thanks!

See Kelly's post below...

Try renaming the new object you create (in the second case), and then seeing if the script works.