Welcome to the Second Life Forums Archive

These forums are CLOSED. Please visit the new forums HERE

Merge Redundant Proposals - Increase Votes

DoteDote Edison
Thinks Too Much
Join date: 6 Jun 2004
Posts: 790
04-19-2005 22:08
I spent an hour or so during downtime at work scanning all of the Feature Proposals. In doing so, I realized that many proposals were redundant, costing a few votes here and there. Here's the list (about 26 redundants):

Prop #'s--------new total--------description-----------------------------------old votes

14/216...............482..........Extra Tattoo Layers......................................466/16
49/202...............298..........Curved/Rounded Prim Edges........................296/2
140/206/237......234..........Voice Chatting.............................................221/11/2
22/133/180........177..........Allow Partner Land Permissions...................155/2/20
98/165...............120..........Create/Edit Animations In-World..................118/2
65/103.................63..........Bring Back Free Dragging..............................56/7
36/37...................69..........Allow More Keys For Control Mapping...........15/54
11/68...................65..........Full Bright Textures Without Emitting Light...53/12
152/189...............31..........Script Limits - Like Prim Limits.......................23/8
153/218...............24..........Increase the Stipend/Allowance...................21/3
79/162.................21..........Text On Prims..............................................19/2
34/203.................26..........Allow Joystick/Alternate Control Inputs........17/9
77/139.................17..........Shared Whiteboards....................................15/2
217/231/245........17..........Change Last Name to Partner's Name.........13/2/2
146/159...............14..........On/Off Option For Object Info.......................2/12
62/63...................14..........Flash/Java/Internet Media On Prims.............11/3
179/184...............13..........Improve Border Crossing Problems..............2/11
131/261.................9..........Outer Space Sims/Regions...........................8/1
59/259...................8..........Fix Texture Warping On Manipulated Prims..6/2
138/149.................6..........Boolean Operations On Prims.......................5/1
116/117/118..........3..........Separate Facial Hair Editor...........................1/1/1
Jeffrey Gomez
Cubed™
Join date: 11 Jun 2004
Posts: 3,522
04-19-2005 22:49
Just to chime in, 62 and 63 are both my own, and the rift between the two was intentional, as they expressed what I felt to be a large difference in scope.

However, I have seen other proposals along the same lines that should be combined with my own (or vice versa).
_____________________
---
Nekokami Dragonfly
猫神
Join date: 29 Aug 2004
Posts: 638
04-20-2005 14:23
I'm responsible for two of these myself (202 andd 203). The original proposals had no detail and no links to forum boards to discuss detail further. I thought it was risky to leave them there as they were. If by some miracle they floated to the top and were implemented, there was no telling how the Lindens might have interpreted them.

On the hotline, one of the Lindens (Robin, I think) said overlapping proposals would be combined and duplicates removed. That was supposed to happen Monday. Then again, the GDC contestants were supposed to be announced Tuesday, and that just happened this afternoon. (My team didn't get picked. Wah! :( )

What I'm worried about is how the descriptions will be handled, i.e. if the descriptions will all be combined into one proposal, or the most complete description will be used, or only the earliest one, or what. I'd like to see all the text and forum links retained, if proposals are combined -- and some seemingly similar proposals were deliberately made separate, as Jeffrey pointed out.

neko